DOJ takes big steps to combat mandatory minimums

  • Thread starter Thread starter SeannyM
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is great news! Mandatory minimums tie judges’ hands, and keep them from assessing each situation based on the circumstances.
I too think this is good news, for the same reasons you post above, but…
Mandatory minimums also have a pretty distinct element of racial and income inequallity.
This I think is quite irrelevant. It isn’t enough to just look at the results (ends) to make any statement about racism being present in the justice system (means). Unless you can demonstrate an actual racist intent by any of the justice system members, the results are incidental. I don’t think we should craft the legal system to achieve some desired racial or income outcome.

Edit: One point, though. I’m not sure how this is implemented right now. Is there a law that states that there are mandatory minimums, and the DOJ is crafting some policy to ignore that law? Or is there some policy that the DOJ is imposing upon judges? And if it is just some policy, why are the judges legally bound to follow it?

These minimums are either a legal requirement or they aren’t. If it is a legal requirement, the DOJ can’t ignore it. And if it isn’t a legal requirement, the DOJ can’t impose it upon the courts. Something doesn’t jive here.

Edit (again): Looks like this policy just discusses what the minimums that the DOJ will accept as part of plea agreements or during sentencing. This doesn’t appear to have anything to do with the sentences that judges may hand down.
 
I too think this is good news, for the same reasons you post above, but…

This I think is quite irrelevant. It isn’t enough to just look at the results (ends) to make any statement about racism being present in the justice system (means). Unless you can demonstrate an actual racist intent by any of the justice system members, the results are incidental. I don’t think we should craft the legal system to achieve some desired racial or income outcome.

Edit: One point, though. I’m not sure how this is implemented right now. Is there a law that states that there are mandatory minimums, and the DOJ is crafting some policy to ignore that law? Or is there some policy that the DOJ is imposing upon judges? And if it is just some policy, why are the judges legally bound to follow it?

These minimums are either a legal requirement or they aren’t. If it is a legal requirement, the DOJ can’t ignore it. And if it isn’t a legal requirement, the DOJ can’t impose it upon the courts. Something doesn’t jive here.

Edit (again): Looks like this policy just discusses what the minimums that the DOJ will accept as part of plea agreements or during sentencing. This doesn’t appear to have anything to do with the sentences that judges may hand down.
I’m not sure how the policy previously worked, I’ll look into it, and ask my lawyer buddies about it. As for the racial element, it is difficult to prove intent of whoever implemented it, but it’s pretty difficult to justify higher minimums for crack cocaine vs powder cocaine. Except, the use of powder cocaine is predominently by white wealthy individuals, while crack is predominently used by racial minorities and those of low-income status.
 
Meanwhile, Rahm Emanuel is trying to get mandatory minimums enforced in Illinois in gun-related crimes.

From the article:

“Under the new policy, federal prosecutors will allow drug offenders without ties to large-scale organizations, gangs or cartels to avoid harsh mandatory minimum sentences by removing the drug quantities that trigger such requirements.”

As I read this, then, one might be in possession of large quantities of drugs, but unless law enforcement canprove that the offender is connected to gangs or cartels, he won’t be subject to the minimums.

Now, who posseses large quantities of drugs who is NOT connected somehow with organized crime? Does Holder really think law enforcement is going to be able to prove gang membership for everybody who is obviously a dealer?

Does Emanuel need to instruct Holder or does Holder need to instruct Emanuel?
 
These minimums are either a legal requirement or they aren’t. If it is a legal requirement, the DOJ can’t ignore it. And if it isn’t a legal requirement, the DOJ can’t impose it upon the courts. Something doesn’t jive here.

Edit (again): Looks like this policy just discusses what the minimums that the DOJ will accept as part of plea agreements or during sentencing. This doesn’t appear to have anything to do with the sentences that judges may hand down.
I don’t think this administration is overly concerned about what’s legal and what isn’t. Where they think they have discretion, they exercise it, even if it’s questionable.

What I think this is really about is the use (abuse perhaps) of “prosecutorial discretion” in filing charges. If, say, a particular defendant has a quantity of drugs that exceeds the requirement for a mandatory minimum, the DOJ will simply charge the defendant for a lesser quantity, at its discretion, or perhaps do a “prosecutorial diversion” into a probationary program in which the judge is not involved.
 
I’m not sure how the policy previously worked, I’ll look into it, and ask my lawyer buddies about it.
Looks like it was just prosecutorial minimums. This change in policy has no effect on judges.
As for the racial element, it is difficult to prove intent of whoever implemented it,
Then there must be some other metric besides outcomes we can use to measure this. Outcome based law is likely to be as much of a failure as outcome based education.
but it’s pretty difficult to justify higher minimums for crack cocaine vs powder cocaine. Except, the use of powder cocaine is predominently by white wealthy individuals, while crack is predominently used by racial minorities and those of low-income status.
And you think this difference in sentencing was racist in intent? When it was the Congressional Black Caucus that pushed for even harsher penalties because of the devastation that crack was having on black communities. The strongly supported the 100-to-1 ratio. So I don’t think racism was part of the decision.

But now, 30 years later, when the results come it, suddenly it is racist?
 
Meanwhile, Rahm Emanuel is trying to get mandatory minimums enforced in Illinois in gun-related crimes.

From the article:

“Under the new policy, federal prosecutors will allow drug offenders without ties to large-scale organizations, gangs or cartels to avoid harsh mandatory minimum sentences by removing the drug quantities that trigger such requirements.”

As I read this, then, one might be in possession of large quantities of drugs, but unless law enforcement canprove that the offender is connected to gangs or cartels, he won’t be subject to the minimums.

Now, who posseses large quantities of drugs who is NOT connected somehow with organized crime? Does Holder really think law enforcement is going to be able to prove gang membership for everybody who is obviously a dealer?

Does Emanuel need to instruct Holder or does Holder need to instruct Emanuel?
The “large quantity” for the trigger, is not so high that it would imply connection with organized crime.

And just to illustrate the difference between the minimums for crack vs powder cocaine, it takes 500g of powder cocaine to trigger the minimums, while it only takes 28g of crack cocaine to trigger. There is no justifyable reason for this.
 
TAnd just to illustrate the difference between the minimums for crack vs powder cocaine, it takes 500g of powder cocaine to trigger the minimums, while it only takes 28g of crack cocaine to trigger. There is no justifyable reason for this.
I agree. It doesn’t make sense.

But that doesn’t make it racist in intent nor racist in implementation.
 
Looks like it was just prosecutorial minimums. This change in policy has no effect on judges.

Then there must be some other metric besides outcomes we can use to measure this. Outcome based law is likely to be as much of a failure as outcome based education.

And you think this difference in sentencing was racist in intent? When it was the Congressional Black Caucus that pushed for even harsher penalties because of the devastation that crack was having on black communities. The strongly supported the 100-to-1 ratio. So I don’t think racism was part of the decision.

But now, 30 years later, when the results come it, suddenly it is racist?
Perhaps racist is the wrong word to use, but it certainly effects racial minorities and the poor disproportionately. Also, it hasn’t done anything to decrease the amount of drug use amongst minorities. I’d say it is definitely race related. Even if these policies were put into effect with the best intentions, they are failing, it’s time for them to go.
 
The “large quantity” for the trigger, is not so high that it would imply connection with organized crime.

And just to illustrate the difference between the minimums for crack vs powder cocaine, it takes 500g of powder cocaine to trigger the minimums, while it only takes 28g of crack cocaine to trigger. There is no justifyable reason for this.
Possibly that’s due to the fact that the two are not identical in their action; the effect of a very small amount of crack being much faster and therefore stronger than an equal amount of powder cocaine.

But I don’t know what the thinking was exactly in setting the ratio, then altering it in 2010. Nor, of course, do you.
 
Perhaps racist is the wrong word to use, but it certainly effects racial minorities and the poor disproportionately.
What do you mean by “disproportionately.” Are you saying that white or rich users of crack cocaine are less likely to be charged or convicted? Or are you saying that as a proportion of the overall population, racial minorities and the poor are charged and convicted of crack cocaine use? If racial minorities and the poor disproportionately use crack cocaine, then it makes sense that they would be more likely to be charged and convicted of crack cocaine use.

It seems to me the problem is the drug use in minority and poor populations, not in the law.
Also, it hasn’t done anything to decrease the amount of drug use amongst minorities. I’d say it is definitely race related. Even if these policies were put into effect with the best intentions, they are failing, it’s time for them to go.
I don’t think anybody denies that it is race related. But it is race related in the same way that diabetes is race related. The black population has a much higher incidence of diabetes than white populations. It is a characteristic of the population. And we should handle drug use the same way we handle diabetes, treatment and education.

Just to be clear, I agree that this 100-to-1 ratio needs to go. It is stupid. If drugs are illegal, and the drugs being trafficked are essentially the same, they should be prosecuted in the same way. That should be the reason the law should be changed. But we shouldn’t be changing the law because we aren’t seeing the racial outcomes we think are “fair” (unless there is some clear racial bias or intent in the law).
 
Possibly that’s due to the fact that the two are not identical in their action; the effect of a very small amount of crack being much faster and therefore stronger than an equal amount of powder cocaine.

But I don’t know what the thinking was exactly in setting the ratio, then altering it in 2010. Nor, of course, do you.
I do know the logic that they said they used. In 1986 when the minimums were originally proposed, they said that it was the opinion of Congress that crack cocaine is more dangerous. This belief has since been disputed by the United States Sentencing Commision and other experts in the toxicology field.
 
Perhaps racist is the wrong word to use, but it certainly effects racial minorities and the poor disproportionately. Also, it hasn’t done anything to decrease the amount of drug use amongst minorities. I’d say it is definitely race related. Even if these policies were put into effect with the best intentions, they are failing, it’s time for them to go.
Would it be safe to conclude it has something to do with the rate one group commits crime?
 
I do know the logic that they said they used. In 1986 when the minimums were originally proposed, they said that it was the opinion of Congress that crack cocaine is more dangerous. This belief has since been disputed by the United States Sentencing Commision and other experts in the toxicology field.
So why would drug dealers continue to sell it knowing they faced harsher sentences? Wouldn’t it be a case of actions have consequences?
 
What do you mean by “disproportionately.” Are you saying that white or rich users of crack cocaine are less likely to be charged or convicted? Or are you saying that as a proportion of the overall population, racial minorities and the poor are charged and convicted of crack cocaine use? If racial minorities and the poor disproportionately use crack cocaine, then it makes sense that they would be more likely to be charged and convicted of crack cocaine use.
I don’t think the disparity is in number of people charged, but instead in severity of sentences. In 2009 79% of those convicted for crack cocaine posession were black, while only 10% were white. During the same time period those convicted of powder cocaine offenses were 17% white, 28% black, and 53% hispanic. So the disproportion is in the amount required to trigger the minimums, which are much lower for crack.
 
Would it be safe to conclude it has something to do with the rate one group commits crime?
Sure, but why the different minimums for different forms of the same substance?

Suppose I were the principle of a highschool, and I decided that if a student was found with a certain amount of tobacco products, there would be no suspension, or detention, but instead they would automatically be expelled. Sounds OK so far, right? But let’s say I then set the minimums number of cigarettes to be automatically expelled as follows:

Marlboro: 2 packs

Newports: 3 cigarettes

Obviously, there would be a huge disparity in how these minimums effect people based on race. It would be wrong. This is in effect the same thing that these mandatory minimum laws do now.
 
Obviously, there would be a huge disparity in how these minimums effect people based on race. It would be wrong. This is in effect the same thing that these mandatory minimum laws do now.
To me, that is no different than saying that high school testing standards are racist because blacks and hispanics are more likely to fail than caucasians. Would you allege that these testing standards were deliberately designed to set blacks and hispanics up for academic failure? I don’t believe the racial argument makes any sense. You’re essentially saying that the law is racist just because blacks choose to break it in greater numbers.
 
To me, that is no different than saying that high school testing standards are racist because blacks and hispanics are more likely to fail than caucasians. Would you allege that these testing standards were deliberately designed to set blacks and hispanics up for academic failure? I don’t believe the racial argument makes any sense. You’re essentially saying that the law is racist just because blacks choose to break it in greater numbers.
I don’t think so. I think the tests apply the same standard to everyone, while the minimums are stricter for two different forms of the same substance. Also, I don’t think racism is necessarily the motivating factor, but the result is a different standard for a form of cocaine that is primarily used by black people.

If you think that a minimum is important as a deterent, and that possesing the drug in large quantities is something that needs to have a minimum established, then why not apply the minimums for the same quantity of the drug for all of it’s forms?
 
I do know the logic that they said they used. In 1986 when the minimums were originally proposed, they said that it was the opinion of Congress that crack cocaine is more dangerous. This belief has since been disputed by the United States Sentencing Commision and other experts in the toxicology field.
Which may be why they reduced the ratio in 2010, which they did.

But I’m not sure you’re framing the dispute correctly. There was an argument as to which is actually the more addictive. It was initially believed crack to be the more addictive, and that has been disputed by respectable people. What is not disputed is that crack cocaine, as normally administered, acts much faster than powder cocaine as normally administered, and hits all at once, bringing more of the potent effect within a narrower time frame. Crack can also be more deadly in that the effect is shorter-lived, and a “binger” is going to get less desired effect with each dose in the binge, thus encouraging greater and greater doses of a toxic substance over a short time frame.

But again, I can’t read the minds of those who reduced the ratio in 2010 to 18:1. And, again, I don’t think you can either.

I do think it’s a huge and unfounded assumption that the ratio was established for racist reasons.
 
Which may be why they reduced the ratio in 2010, which they did.

But I’m not sure you’re framing the dispute correctly. There was an argument as to which is actually the more addictive. It was initially believed crack to be the more addictive, and that has been disputed by respectable people. What is not disputed is that crack cocaine, as normally administered, acts much faster than powder cocaine as normally administered, and hits all at once, bringing more of the potent effect within a narrower time frame. Crack can also be more deadly in that the effect is shorter-lived, and a “binger” is going to get less desired effect with each dose in the binge, thus encouraging greater and greater doses of a toxic substance over a short time frame.

But again, I can’t read the minds of those who reduced the ratio in 2010 to 18:1. And, again, I don’t think you can either.

I do think it’s a huge and unfounded assumption that the ratio was established for racist reasons.
I’m not saying that it was established for racist reasons, just that the effects are disproportionate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top