'Draw Muhammad' contest planned in Phoenix

  • Thread starter Thread starter Seamus_L
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We had a similarly ridiculous incident in a Texas. When a new mosque opened up in West Houston(they were a client of mine) their farmer neighbor started holding pig races during their services. They just ignored him
And this was an adult? :rolleyes:
 
And this was an adult? :rolleyes:
It was a feud over property, not something staged to incite violence, and it ended close to 10 years ago with a handshake between neighbors. Katy used to be a small farming town but has been getting swallowed up into the greater Houston area for some time. There were bound to be some disputes on land usage. I’m not really sure that what happened is worthy of national attention.
 
So far from what I’ve learned online, there will be a peaceful counterprotest opposing the anti-Islamic group outside the mosque, as well as an extreme left wing group that espouses violence also planning to attend.
 
To have free speech we have to allow it and protect it. We do not have to believe what is said or pass it on as worthy expression of knowledge. We may not agree with it - and we do not HAVE to - that is what is important.
 
It was a feud over property, not something staged to incite violence, and it ended close to 10 years ago with a handshake between neighbors. Katy used to be a small farming town but has been getting swallowed up into the greater Houston area for some time. There were bound to be some disputes on land usage. I’m not really sure that what happened is worthy of national attention.
The land in question(about two blocks from my house) was encompassed on all sides by stores and subdivisions. Mocking other peoples faith is not a good way to solve land use disputes.
 
I have no problem with free speech, peaceful protests and the likes, but when anyone starts saying that violence is the answer, then there is a problem. I know the organizer has telling people he expects trouble, so “bring your guns”. I have no problems with the 2nd amendment, but when you are instigating something, leave your guns at home, or better yet, just stay home. I don’t know what the law is in this state, but in my state, for a CCW permit holder to use their weapon for self-defense, they can not have instigated the event.

Let’s all remember what it says in John 15:17 “This I command you: love one another”.
 
Maybe. But I’m a big fan of supporting the rights of others to express that which offends me most.
Then should I, as a lawful gun owner with no criminal record, be allowed to exercise my 2nd Amendment rights and walk down the street carrying an AR-15 rifle?
 
When people describe protests like this as childish, idiotic, provacative, serving no purpose, etc, I certainly will not disagree with them, but when they advocate banning such demonstrations because serious trouble could arise, then I have to say, learn to live with it. We Catholics along with others have had our churches picketed before, without people getting harmed, and I do not think Islam is entitled to some special category status, because some people feel they are more likely to be provoked by such activities.
So are you okay with soccer ultras being arrested, banned, and brutalized by police and UEFA autocrats or does freedom of speech not apply their?
 
I have no problem with free speech, peaceful protests and the likes, but when anyone starts saying that violence is the answer, then there is a problem. I know the organizer has telling people he expects trouble, so “bring your guns”. I have no problems with the 2nd amendment, but when you are instigating something, leave your guns at home, or better yet, just stay home. I don’t know what the law is in this state, but in my state, for a CCW permit holder to use their weapon for self-defense, they can not have instigated the event.

Let’s all remember what it says in John 15:17 “This I command you: love one another”.
Arizona has an open carry law. Could some intervening laws apply per a meeting place? Possibly.
 
Mine too.

Seeing how it is only a “Draw Mohamed” contest, we don’t know if we are speaking of snide jabs. This is not a cartoon contest.
If the organiser of this event is calling for guns to be brought I would hope there are grounds under the law of the US state he lives in to halt the event.
No grounds exist in Arizona apparently, someone please correct me if I am wrong.

It seems to offend some to marry outside of that faith, are we suppose to obey that law too?
 
We don’t know if they are all Catholics going to this, if not, perhaps the words of the Holy Father would not be heeded. As a Catholic, I would not draw a mocking picture of the Prophet but only to follow what the Pope said and not to appease Sharia Law. If you are suggesting a poster understands following Sharia Law, so be it. But I don’t think the rest of us must follow this.

If we follow this law, what else are we going to follow? That honor killings are proper as well?

Let alone, ISIS objects to this as if they are some sort of standard of morality.
 
I don’t know the faith of the organizers of this event but I can’t help wondering if they were Catholic, what their reaction would be if the KKK were burning crosses in front of their churches.
 
I don’t know the faith of the organizers of this event but I can’t help wondering if they were Catholic, what their reaction would be if the KKK were burning crosses in front of their churches.
If it is protected speech, they couldn’t do anything about it except in the example you cite, I don’t believe that is protected free speech.
 
No they didn’t unless somehow we need to have our own Sharia Law.

Do not marry outside of Islam, we can call that stupid too.
Showing respect for other peoples religion is not adhering to Sharia law. free speech allows one to do stupid things as it allows me to call stupid things stupid.
 
First thing, don’t draw pictures of the Prophet, next, why not follow other precepts of the religion.

Are we to object if others draw a picture of Jesus Christ? I won’t.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top