Early data show $15 minimum hurting Seattle's poor

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maxirad
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, now maybe the ultra-socialists will find the economic truth. It’s like saying, “Let’s bring people out of poverty by doubling the cost to hire them!” 🤷
 
Minimum wage jobs are not meant to RAISE A FAMILY. They are meant to be for high school kids and those working during college.
You want $15 an hour? Go to trade school and become an electrician or plumber.

You pay more in taxes the more you earn per hour…plus the cost of food is more. If McDonald’s paid $15 an hour, no more $ menu…and robots would be taking orders. Or kiosks.
 
Minimum wage jobs are not meant to RAISE A FAMILY. They are meant to be for high school kids and those working during college.
You want $15 an hour? Go to trade school and become an electrician or plumber.

You pay more in taxes the more you earn per hour…plus the cost of food is more. If McDonald’s paid $15 an hour, no more $ menu…and robots would be taking orders. Or kiosks.
Could be just a matter of perspective.

Some might say that business owners, corporations, and yes, even consumers are the victims of greed rather than victims of the poor.

Proverbs 21:13
He who closes his ear to the cry of the poor will himself cry out and not be heard.

Maybe its just a Franciscan thing.

Pax et bonum!
 
Minimum wage jobs are not meant to RAISE A FAMILY. They are meant to be for high school kids and those working during college.
You want $15 an hour? Go to trade school and become an electrician or plumber.

You pay more in taxes the more you earn per hour…plus the cost of food is more. If McDonald’s paid $15 an hour, no more $ menu…and robots would be taking orders. Or kiosks.
Something somewhere along the line must be broken if adults with families are unable to get anything other than minimum wage jobs.

Of course simply raising the minimum wage well-intentioned isn’t going to solve anything at all (and quite possibly make it worse), but I suppose it’s a nominal bit of tokenist law at least nearly acknowledging the employment morass which consumer and employer greed, and political inadequacy, has led the western world…
 
Minimum wage jobs are not meant to RAISE A FAMILY. They are meant to be for high school kids and those working during college.
You want $15 an hour? Go to trade school and become an electrician or plumber.

You pay more in taxes the more you earn per hour…plus the cost of food is more. If McDonald’s paid $15 an hour, no more $ menu…and robots would be taking orders. Or kiosks.
I think you may be illustrating a larger problem. Not that long ago, the way to learn how to become an electrician or a plumber was to learn on the job. You’d start as an apprentice, then work your way up to journeyman, and then, maybe, a master. Now, we expect people to take on thousands of dollars in student loan debt in order to learn in an environment that they’re, likely, ill-suited for anyway Realistically speaking, people who’s goal is to be a plumber, are probably not appropriate for a college environment.
 
Minimum wage jobs are not meant to RAISE A FAMILY. They are meant to be for high school kids and those working during college.
You want $15 an hour? Go to trade school and become an electrician or plumber.
I always get a laugh when I hear people say this…while it is true this is the way it used to be and is still accurate to some extent today, for the most part, these jobs are now being done by older folks. I know this first hand with my job, the low level cashier jobs at the convenience store/ gas station which pay minimum wage are normally staffed by people in their early 30s and up.

A large majority of the younger people that do apply with us are disqualified by either the drug test or background check, the BG check especially, so much so that my company is considering lowering their hiring standards a bit, just because its causing such a staffing problem.

Times change, its not the 70s and 80s anymore, when teenagers would happily work these part time jobs for low pay.

The real problem with this is companies whining and crying about having to pay out more in labor, they want as close to slave labor as they can get. They complain that its killing them, but a look at their profit margins over the years tells a different story imo.
 
I think you may be illustrating a larger problem. Not that long ago, the way to learn how to become an electrician or a plumber was to learn on the job. You’d start as an apprentice, then work your way up to journeyman, and then, maybe, a master. Now, we expect people to take on thousands of dollars in student loan debt in order to learn in an environment that they’re, likely, ill-suited for anyway Realistically speaking, people who’s goal is to be a plumber, are probably not appropriate for a college environment.
I agree with you. Somewhere along the line, learning a trade became something to be looked down upon, rather than a solid (and possibly lucrative) career.
 
The minimum wage advocates are always pikers. Why not raise the minimum wage to $30, $50, or $100 an hour. If there economic theory is correct, and it isn’t, that should make everyone rich.
I think you may be illustrating a larger problem. Not that long ago, the way to learn how to become an electrician or a plumber was to learn on the job. You’d start as an apprentice, then work your way up to journeyman, and then, maybe, a master. Now, we expect people to take on thousands of dollars in student loan debt in order to learn in an environment that they’re, likely, ill-suited for anyway Realistically speaking, people who’s goal is to be a plumber, are probably not appropriate for a college environment.
The education racket has definitely hurt the economy. Like anything subsidized by the state we get more of it then we want or need. Another problem for low wage jobs is the constant stream of immigrants. This tactic has always been used to lower wages.
 
I agree with you. Somewhere along the line, learning a trade became something to be looked down upon, rather than a solid (and possibly lucrative) career.
Just guessing, but I’m thinking that my plumber makes more than most recent college graduates. Many of them would do well to exit the business world and try for plumbing and electrician jobs. Heck, even tree trimmers make a lot.
 
I agree with you. Somewhere along the line, learning a trade became something to be looked down upon, rather than a solid (and possibly lucrative) career.
Its not the trade, its the class, blue collar versus white collar.

Upper class has always held its nose up high above the blue collar world.
 
I wouldn’t trade my History degree for anything! I studied it because I wanted to, not to get rich…and guess what? Stats say the degree will earn 50K a year…I haven’t made less than 3 times that a year in over a decade…trade school wouldn’t have helped me, financially, more than a university education…but anyone only looking for money, instead of the other blessings God has to offer is likely to be disappointed and bitter.
 
The minimum wage advocates are always pikers. Why not raise the minimum wage to $30, $50, or $100 an hour. If there economic theory is correct, and it isn’t, that should make everyone rich.
I’ve never heard of 100 dollar/hour minimum wage. I looked it up and it is a real thing! I’m appalled. :eek:

forbes.com/sites/carriesheffield/2013/12/10/why-not-raise-the-minimum-wage-to-100-an-hour/#1dfff1ec79bc
**At its core, a minimum wage hike is a temporary, Band-aid fix to a deeper, chronic problem. **And it generates unintended consequences that ripple far beyond that temporary fix, including encouraging teenagers to drop out of school to pursue those tantalizing, higher-wage jobs.
In a rhetorical war where the left employs demagoguery about the lives of low-income workers, the right can show it’s fighting for holistic, empowering approaches to improving quality of life for these folks.
 
I make less than $15 an hour. Given my age and health issues, my current job is pretty much all I can do. It’s kind of hard to get by — long-term financial planning is pretty much pointless, my best option is to croak on the job before I am forced to retire — but it could be a lot worse.

I would oppose a hike in minimum wage to $15 in my province — mainly because I know it would result in massive layoffs, and possible increase in outsourcing. And, given my aforementioned issues, I’d probably be one of the first to receive my pink slip.
 
Its not the trade, its the class, blue collar versus white collar.

Upper class has always held its nose up high above the blue collar world.
It’s not even so much that anymore. Even those from blue collar backgrounds no longer want to took to trades. Everyone sees college (and what are fast becoming useless degrees) as their ticket to something 'better".
 
Not surprising. It was an utterly idiotic idea for Seattle and it would be far worse nationwide.
 
I think you may be illustrating a larger problem. Not that long ago, the way to learn how to become an electrician or a plumber was to learn on the job. You’d start as an apprentice, then work your way up to journeyman, and then, maybe, a master. Now, we expect people to take on thousands of dollars in student loan debt in order to learn in an environment that they’re, likely, ill-suited for anyway Realistically speaking, people who’s goal is to be a plumber, are probably not appropriate for a college environment.
Good trade schools don’t have a college environment. They are quite hands on and allow students to learn the trades in a variety of settings so they can exit the school with some skills.

The thing about apprenticeships, they were low-paying because the company was losing money on the apprentice, but would reap the reward once they had learned the trade to a minimal degree. But now with employees jumping to new jobs all the time, employers were finding themselves training someone and then they’d leave for another company and they never reaped the reward of their investment.
 
Good trade schools don’t have a college environment. They are quite hands on and allow students to learn the trades in a variety of settings so they can exit the school with some skills.

The thing about apprenticeships, they were low-paying because the company was losing money on the apprentice, but would reap the reward once they had learned the trade to a minimal degree. But now with employees jumping to new jobs all the time, employers were finding themselves training someone and then they’d leave for another company and they never reaped the reward of their investment.
While you are right about trade schools, I think apprenticeships pay low wages because the can, because of regulation. It’s not really different than medical interns being worked to the bone during their training because they know they’ll bank $$ when they get their license (regulation)
 
I’ve always thought the “trades will solve everything” mentality missed the mark. I would be confident in saying that if some people pursuing a university degree were to pursue a career in the trades then those people would be better off. If, however, everyone with a “useless” degree were to become a trades-person, I suspect there would just be a whole lot of unemployed tradespeople.

I should also say as someone in their mid 20’s, I know plenty of white-collar oriented people who say they wish they would have taken a career in the trades. It isn’t so much that young people look down on a blue-collar career, it’s the fact that in high school, when they’re making decisions about post-secondary education, it seems as if a university degree is the only choice. Where I’m from (and I’m from a blue-collar mining town), I don’t know that going the trades route was ever mentioned to me. I think its unfair to say that trades positions aren’t being filled because young people are too picky; I honestly think its a case of not knowing any better.

Finally, I know people love to say that minimum wage jobs shouldn’t provide a living wage because such a job was never intended to. I would say that the reality of the situation is that some people don’t have access to any better. Maybe its the local economy, maybe its poor life choices, maybe its any number of reasons. I know guys who work hard, have their lives more-or-less together, regularly look for work, and are stuck doing landscaping because there just isn’t anything better. Like it or not, a minimum wage job may have been designed to support a family but that is precisely what they need to do in far too many cases.
 
Not surprising. It was an utterly idiotic idea for Seattle and it would be far worse nationwide.
Why would it?

wages have been stagnant for a long time, but at the same time, if you look at company profits by year, they are definitely doing good, and raking in the cash, so whats the problem…pretty clear to me, the greedy companies do not want to come up off more of their profits for labor, in essence, they want HUGE profit increases each year, but do not want to pay any more than absolutely necessary.

This is common sense, why do you think so many companies choose to have factories in countries with no minimum wage or no labor laws…they want as much profit as they can get and want to pay as close to nothing for it as possible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top