Earth 'entering new extinction phase' - US study

  • Thread starter Thread starter triumphguy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You could indeed have that impression if you failed to read either of the published papers.
Well let me quote directly from

“Accelerated modern human–induced species losses: Entering the sixth mass extinction”
Gerardo Ceballos1,*, Paul R. Ehrlich2, Anthony D. Barnosky3, Andrés García4, Robert M. Pringle5 and Todd M. Palmer6
the average rate of vertebrate species loss over the last century is up to 114 times higher than the background rate. Under the 2 E/MSY background rate, the number of species that have gone extinct in the last century would have taken, depending on the vertebrate taxon, between 800 and 10,000 years to disappear. These estimates reveal an exceptionally rapid loss of biodiversity over the last few centuries, indicating that a sixth mass extinction is already under way. Averting a dramatic decay of biodiversity and the subsequent loss of ecosystem services is still possible through intensified conservation efforts, but that window of opportunity is rapidly closing.
The evidence is incontrovertible that recent extinction rates are unprecedented in human history and highly unusual in Earth’s history. Our analysis emphasizes that our global society has started to destroy species of other organisms at an accelerating rate, initiating a mass extinction episode unparalleled for 65 million years
Didn’t help much.😦
 
Well let me quote directly from

“Accelerated modern human–induced species losses: Entering the sixth mass extinction”
Gerardo Ceballos1,*, Paul R. Ehrlich2, Anthony D. Barnosky3, Andrés García4, Robert M. Pringle5 and Todd M. Palmer6

Didn’t help much.😦
Sure it did, let me help you out a bit, second paragraph, page one of the same paper:

"However, direct evaluation (of extinction rates) is complicated by uncertainties in estimating the incidence of extinction in historical time and by methodological difficulties in comparing contemporary extinctions with past ones."

In other words, they don’t know previous extinction rates, and are making a subjective judgement in the absence of data. Then they make subjective assumptions to paper over the uncertainties. The paper is rife with uncertainties due to this, to the point of creating reasonable doubt about the paper’s conclusion.
 
Sure it did, let me help you out a bit, second paragraph, page one of the same paper:

"However, direct evaluation (of extinction rates) is complicated by uncertainties in estimating the incidence of extinction in historical time and by methodological difficulties in comparing contemporary extinctions with past ones."

In other words, they don’t know previous extinction rates, and are making a subjective judgement in the absence of data. Then they make subjective assumptions to paper over the uncertainties. The paper is rife with uncertainties due to this, to the point of creating reasonable doubt about the paper’s conclusion.
Well they do say this:
To produce conservative comparisons with modern extinctions, we assumed a background extinction rate of 2 E/MSY as the highest likely baseline average background extinction rate (7); that is, we should expect 2 extinctions per 10,000 vertebrate species per 100 years. That background extinction rate was empirically determined using the exceptionally good fossil records of mammals, combining extinction counts from paleontological databases and published literature on the fossil, subfossil, and historical records (7).*** Using the resulting high background extinction rate provides a stringent test for assessing whether current modern extinction rates indicate that a mass extinction event is under way***. Previous estimates of background extinction rates for other taxa are invariably lower than the mammal-derived estimate of 2 E/MSY used here.
My emphasis.

Correct me if I’m wrong but they are saying they assumed a HIGHER background rate of extinction rather than a lower one.
 
Well they do say this:

My emphasis.

Correct me if I’m wrong but they are saying they assumed a HIGHER background rate of extinction rather than a lower one.
C’mon, they are guessing, it’s all on the imaginary axis, unless they know, which they don’t. If they did know, they would give a number, which they don’t. Instead the use subjective terms, highly conservative, extremely conservative to paper over the shortcoming. These are the result of extinct, extinct in the wild and possible extinct factors being summed. This is not data, it’s a model. This is not a new issue, only the way in which they are obscuring the missing data is sort of new.
 
A timely if extremely scary report, given the Pope’s Encyclical:

bbc.com/news/science-environment-33209548
This is how the climate change militants work… and the media is working with them. They are using a shotgun technique and adding similar “we are all doomed” articles to attempt to add credibility to climate change, which in my opinion is a scam.

You have to ask yourself this question. Why would scientists at NASA fake data to weigh in favor that global warming is real? See this in depth analysis of leaked NASA emails:

lavoisier.com.au/articles/greenhouse-science/climate-change/climategate-emails.pdf
 
I can see why so many people would rather bury their heads in the sand and avoid this topic, or choose to believe this is all some kind of hoax.

Denial - not just a river in Egypt!
It is a hoax. Why did NASA fake global warming data? They were busted some time ago and emails leaked to prove it. (see lavoisier.com.au/articles/greenhouse-science/climate-change/climategate-emails.pdf)

If it truly was real and the world was in imminent danger, why not completely outlaw any use of jets, cars, coal, etc.? Shouldn’t we all stop and live in mud huts?

I don’t get the double standard - climate change alarmists think we will destroy the earth very soon, but we’re supposed to keep jetting around the globe going to climate change summits and such? #doublestandards
 
I guess the scientists are pretty accurate when they state that 400 invertebrate species have gone extinct in the modern era, when formerly that level of extinction would have taken 10,000 years.
Shouldn’t be difficult to verify or disprove.
 
2 quick questions: Evolution, fact or fiction? Geocentrism - worth investigating?
 
Since Ehrlich wrote the “Population Bomb” and has probably done a few other things, I think from a Catholic perspective, his views are a bit of a red flag.
OK. Let me explain where Ehrlich is coming from.

Recall the 1972 Limits to Growth study, a.k.a. the Club of Rome report:



LtG is probably the single most misrepresented study in the history of science, partially because the authors have made some controversial statements, such as “population is the enemy” (and I will get to that in a moment). Nevertheless, as you can see from the above graph, the 40-year period since the study shows that their model has been (so far) very successful in predicting how the human civilization will change in the future.

The real reason LtG was villified is that is makes the following statement: the current economic system must collapse in 2030-2040 due to resource depletion. There is absolutely nothing which should be controversial about this, once you understand the basics: the civilization is running on non-renewable resources (fossil carbon), so one day these will run out, and then all other things equal everything collapses as seen in the graph: by 2100, population drops by 50%, and industrial output per capita drops to medieval levels. Although, recent research suggests that LtG’s model of collapse phase dynamic was too optimistic: it’s a basic fact that Earth can feed at most ca. 1 billion people without fossil fuels or some magical future technological development (which does not seem to be there).

The study authors then realized that the variable which controls resource consumption is population count. Again, this is also very simple: the more people you have, the more resources you need to support them (clothe, feed, etc.). And if population is growing, then resource consumption is accelerating. The logical conclusion is that if you want to avoid the systemic collapse, then the logical thing to do is limit the population growth to zero, thus keeping the resource usage constant:



And this is the context in which the “population is the enemy” remark was made, and this is what Ehrlich’s faction was always advocating: cap the birth rate by whatever means, so we can keep the system going for 300 more years (instead of 60) since 1970.

There’s a catch though: the advise to cap the population made sense if the population would be kept at 1970 levels, at most 1985 levels. Since that level has been passed, then it looks like we are heading for a catastrophic collapse anyway.
 
It is a hoax. Why did NASA fake global warming data? They were busted some time ago and emails leaked to prove it. (see lavoisier.com.au/articles/greenhouse-science/climate-change/climategate-emails.pdf)

If it truly was real and the world was in imminent danger, why not completely outlaw any use of jets, cars, coal, etc.? Shouldn’t we all stop and live in mud huts?

I don’t get the double standard - climate change alarmists think we will destroy the earth very soon, but we’re supposed to keep jetting around the globe going to climate change summits and such? #doublestandards
:tsktsk:

climatecrocks.com/2014/06/25/fox-news-flash-nasa-fakes-temp-data-obama-born-in-kenya-batboy-found-in-cave/
Fox News is reviving accusations that NASA’s peer-reviewed adjustments to temperature data are an attempt to “fak[e]” global warming, a claim that even a climate “skeptic” threw cold water on.
Tony Heller, a birthed who criticizes climate science under the pseudonym “Steven Goddard,” wrote a blog post that claimed “NASA cooled 1934 and warmed 1998, to make 1998 the hottest year in US history instead of 1934.” After the Drudge Report promoted a report of this allegation by the conservative British newspaper The Telegraph, conservative media from Breitbart to The Washington Times claimed the data was “fabricated” or “faked.” On June 24, Fox & Friends picked it up, claiming that “the U.S. has actually been cooling since the 1930s” but scientists had “faked the numbers”.
However, the libertarian magazine Reason noted that even climate “skeptic” blogger Anthony Watts said that Goddard made “major errors in his analysis” and criticized the implication that “numbers are being plucked out of thin air in a nefarious way.”
In fact, the National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) and NASA, which both maintain temperature records that use slightly different methods but show close agreement, have publicly documented the peer-reviewed adjustments they make to raw data. NCDC states that the “most important bias in the U.S. temperature record occurred with the systematic change in observing times from the afternoon, when it is warm, to morning, when it is cooler,” and so it must correct this cool bias as well as other biases that, for example, result from moving temperature stations.
NASA’s data shows that the nation has not been “cooling” since the 1930s, with several years, including 2012, ranking hotter than 1934 in the continental United States, along with a long-term warming trend. And while The Sean Hannity Show claimed that this shows the “Earth has been cooling,” the continental United States makes up less than 2 percent of the Earth’s surface — global surface temperatures have increased significantly.
Independent studies using different methods have consistently found a warming trend. Satellite data confirmthat there is a warming trend in the United States:
That NASA faked global warming data is just some bogus claim by “Steven Goddard”.
 
Shouldn’t be difficult to verify or disprove.
It’s not a matter of “disproving” their theory, they must first “prove” it. They need to revisit their work to quantify the data uncertainties first, see if they can reduce those uncertainties second, and see if the theory is still plausible after one and two. It will be very difficult due to how much they don’t know, but who said it would be easy? If they are reasonably good researchers, this will be cake to them. Where it goes off the rails is when there is an expectation to get an answer “now.”
 
It’s not a matter of “disproving” their theory, they must first “prove” it. They need to revisit their work to quantify the data uncertainties first, see if they can reduce those uncertainties second, and see if the theory is still plausible after one and two. It will be very difficult due to how much they don’t know, but who said it would be easy? If they are reasonably good researchers, this will be cake to them. Where it goes off the rails is when there is an expectation to get an answer “now.”
:confused: But the research has been going on for a long time now,

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_climate_change_science#Scientists_increasingly_predict_warming.2C_1970s
 
So what I heard you say is that because it has been on going for a while, the research must be pointing to, or converging towards a positive AGW signature? I don’t think this is true. I would agree that our knowledge has incrementally become “better” in the sense that our instrumentation methods are improving. That does not mean that the models predictive ability has improved to the point where they “know” what is going to happen in the future. Like the models created to simulate changes in biodiversity, there is a lot of missing data, and hence a lot of uncertainty. They don’t like to show that uncertainty, and do a lot of creative hand waving to take the focus off it so that they don’t frighten policy makers. Again, the expectation to get an answer “now” has polluted, polarized and biased the process towards expecting the “proper” answer, that AGW is a reality, so in kind, the numerous doomsday scenarios must also be true. All of this can be traced back to the models, and the assumptions that the models were constructed from. As I have said before, there are serious issues with the models.
 
Again, the expectation to get an answer “now” …
You’re not understanding me. The answer, I am saying, has been known already for a few decades, so even if there is pressure to know something immediately, the research already has been done.
 
You’re not understanding me. The answer, I am saying, has been known already for a few decades, so even if there is pressure to know something immediately, the research already has been done.
Oh my, that’s a good one. We don’t even really know the dynamic planetary energy budget, have only within the last 10 years made strides towards more reliable ocean temperatures.

If by know you mean that the optical properties of CO2 are known, then yes. As a gas, in isolation, we know those properties fairly well. However that does not mean that we understand how it interacts with the thousands of other atmospheric properties well enough to predict catastrophe. If you drill down to the underlying assumptions, and see the liberal sprinkling of “all things being equal” embedded in those assumptions, then you may see that it is not a done deal.

I understand that you desperately wish to believe in these numerical fantasies, that imagining a world of scientists diligently working to save the planet as in some 1950’s B-sci flim enables you to rest easier, but it does not mean it is so. I have worked in science and engineering for a long time, and have yet to see a “done deal.” The world of science is much more messy than you could imagine.
 
C’mon, they are guessing, it’s all on the imaginary axis, unless they know, which they don’t. If they did know, they would give a number, which they don’t. Instead the use subjective terms, highly conservative, extremely conservative to paper over the shortcoming. These are the result of extinct, extinct in the wild and possible extinct factors being summed. This is not data, it’s a model. This is not a new issue, only the way in which they are obscuring the missing data is sort of new.
Most of physics is “a model” - a mathematical model that gives as close to a real view of the world as possible.
 
So what I heard you say is that because it has been on going for a while, the research must be pointing to, or converging towards a positive AGW signature? I don’t think this is true. I would agree that our knowledge has incrementally become “better” in the sense that our instrumentation methods are improving. That does not mean that the models predictive ability has improved to the point where they “know” what is going to happen in the future. Like the models created to simulate changes in biodiversity, there is a lot of missing data, and hence a lot of uncertainty. They don’t like to show that uncertainty, and do a lot of creative hand waving to take the focus off it so that they don’t frighten policy makers. Again, the expectation to get an answer “now” has polluted, polarized and biased the process towards expecting the “proper” answer, that AGW is a reality, so in kind, the numerous doomsday scenarios must also be true. All of this can be traced back to the models, and the assumptions that the models were constructed from. As I have said before, there are serious issues with the models.
If I’m going 90 miles an hour in a dead end street I don’t know for certain how it’s going to end, but on the balance of probabilities I’d better put the brake on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top