Ecumenical flattery?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Peter_J
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t know if this topic will spark much conversation, but I thought I would give it a try…

Do you think there is such a thing as ecumenical flattery, and if so what example(s) come most to your mind?

For example, I think Catholics (and Orthodox for that matter) tend to flatter protestants by writing “Protestants” with a capital P.
I guess a follow-up question could be: is it offensive to Anglicans to say that they are “catholic and protestant” rather than “Catholic and Protestant”?
 
I guess a follow-up question could be: is it offensive to Anglicans to say that they are “catholic and protestant” rather than “Catholic and Protestant”?
Anglicans (some?, many?) might not like being called protestant at all.

Jon
 
Well, I prefer if people say “the Roman Communion” rather than “the Roman Catholic Church”, since it’s actually made up of 23 different churches (although the largest of those, the Latin Church, contains about 98% of Catholics).

As far as terms like “the Catholic Church”, “the one true church”, “the original church”, and “the church of Christ” … well I guess I don’t mind at all if you want to call us those. 👍 😃
I always use Roman Catholic, or sometimes the Latin Church as referring only to the latin rite. I once dated a Melkite. If any communion would have been able to persuade me to become catholic it would be them. 🙂

I have pondered the the validity of names for the RC church and I have come up with “The papal church” - it’s accurate and void of insult, easily understandable and any protestant would have no qualms using this terminology. Perhaps it will catch on 😉

However in day to day I will quite happily use “catholics” and “Catholic Church” because everyone knows what it means in colloquial language. Same with “Orthodox” and “Calvinist”. Would we refuse to refer to the “Free Democratic Republic of Congo” by it’s official name simply because we don’t believe it’s free? No we wouldn’t
 
As others have said, “Protestant” is a proper noun and in English we capitalize proper nouns. Simple as that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top