Edited: On average, what's normal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter constantconvert
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This thread is depressing. When you are doing all the right things for all the right reasons and it still doesn’t pay off, it just feels like :banghead:

Not saying I do anything for the purpose of bribery, because that is NOT the case, by any means. But how much do you have to do out of love for a spouse before they feel inspired to return the love back to you in a way that is important to you (and the marriage as a whole)?

True love, what I would consider agape love, is hard, but I am getting better. Sometimes I need to know when to stop reading threads like this one because it just does nothing but get me down.
 
oh…Good Lord above…we’re now fighting on CAF about sex in marriage :banghead:

I left CAF for 2 months and I’m not sure if it were wise to come back 😃
 
oh…Good Lord above…we’re now fighting on CAF about sex in marriage :banghead:

I left CAF for 2 months and I’m not sure if it were wise to come back 😃
You know how CAF goes…wait a few more weeks and the discussion might possibly drift to Marian veneration and (excuse my language) ladies in trousers. 😉
 
First, someone said 14-15. Now 20?!

I need to go to confession right now because the envy is gonna kill me… LOL
Ha!

I have to say that my husband and I were looking forward to getting it on that often before we got married. We thought we’d enjoy it very frequently before we were sleeping together, but once we started we realized that we quickly realized that our “ideal” is not actually going at it twice a day.

Also, to quote Zapp Branigan – The spirit is willing, but the flesh is spongy and bruised.
 
This is getting a tad defensive. 5 minute quickies are not the “norm” for us but they are fun and I assure you my wife enjoys them and most of the time initiates them. 2 Hour marathons are fun too. It just depends. My point was that it is common for us to have frequent relations and we find creative ways to make that happen. I’m sorry if I came across as crude or abnormal. I probably should have skipped over this thread anyway. But here we are. I understand that some women need to be warmed up and there are definitely times when we make sure that we spend appropriate time (when we have it) But you need to understand that some women dont take as long as others. We arent talking about 0-60 in 4 seconds, we are talking about little hints and teases as we are frantically loading the kids in the car.
here is an example.:o
Friday night we were at a store and my wife found a purple dress shirt that she wanted me to wear. Knowing that I was going to lose this battle and hating purple I said, If I wear a purple shirt and tie to Mass tomorrow do I get to pick you out something? That was the deal. Later that night my wife had to visit a relative in the hospital after the kids were down. When she came home she laughed because I was dressed to the nines with the shirt. Nough said. normal, fun, healthy.
Those little “hints and teases” are exactly what I’m talking about when I say that a wise husband begins his love-making at the beginning of the day. I used the example of notes, flowers, and gifts, but it can be whatever works for the couple.

I know one couple where every morning, without fail, the husband brings his wife a cup of coffee while she is still in bed. For me, this would be yucko, but it sure works for this couple, and for the wife, his kind act every morning helps to “get her ready.” (They are now elderly.)

For those of you who don’t need anything from your husbands other than an invitation to “make love,” that’s fine and dandy. But for me, making love is more than just a physical act that’s fun and feels goo, and it’s more than just a wifely “duty” or “obligation” or “debt.”

For sex to work between the two of us, I need to connect not only physically, but emotionally and spiritually, with the man that I love and I’m married to, and I know that my husband feels the same way. If we don’t have this “connection,” then it’s just sex–a animal coupling.

The emotional and spiritual “connection” is made easier for me when my husband does kind things to me and for me outside of the bedroom. Of course, it goes without saying that I do the same for him. Again, for those of you who are fine without these kind acts, more power to you.

I would venture the suggestion that as you get older, you might find that you do need more time to “get interested.” When you are young, your body is more easily “ready,” and God, in His wisdom, made us women that way so that we can make babies! But as you get older, the hormones won’t be there anymore, and you need all the help you can get from those silly old flowers, notes, jokes, or whatever. You’ll realize then what I’m talking about–it’s not a “bribe,” but a part of foreplay.
 
This thread is depressing. When you are doing all the right things for all the right reasons and it still doesn’t pay off, it just feels like :banghead:

Not saying I do anything for the purpose of bribery, because that is NOT the case, by any means. But how much do you have to do out of love for a spouse before they feel inspired to return the love back to you in a way that is important to you (and the marriage as a whole)?

True love, what I would consider agape love, is hard, but I am getting better. Sometimes I need to know when to stop reading threads like this one because it just does nothing but get me down.
Yeah I know what you mean. Sometimes it can be hard to read about these kind of threads hehe.
 
This thread is depressing. When you are doing all the right things for all the right reasons and it still doesn’t pay off, it just feels like :banghead:

Not saying I do anything for the purpose of bribery, because that is NOT the case, by any means. But how much do you have to do out of love for a spouse before they feel inspired to return the love back to you in a way that is important to you (and the marriage as a whole)?

True love, what I would consider agape love, is hard, but I am getting better. Sometimes I need to know when to stop reading threads like this one because it just does nothing but get me down.
 
I’m A-OK with the poll question since it seems to be out of genuine curiosity, but the play by play here is a bit… odd. I’m not saying it’s wrong and I certainly understand that the anonymity of the Internet comes into play, but I still find it somewhat strange. But whatever.

And before you get all “what a fuddy-duddy” on me, I just hit the threshold of “late 20s.”
 
you try to go back to the dumpster of your life and pick up little shards of the golden treasure that you once possessed. You find a speck here and there, way at the bottom of the dumpster, but you can never even imagine what that gift would have looked like, had you not ruined it and given it away to those who didn’t care.

I do not believe I am alone in what I have done. Many Catholics have done the same as I did. The difference is that I woke up and realized what I did. And I will regret it for the rest of my life.
As much as I appreciate someone understanding the gravity of the gift and responsibility of sexuality, I have to take issue with you here. You’re incorrect to say you have ruined it. There is no reason to continue to confess ancient sins even if they haunt your present, unless of course they are causing sins in the here and now.

It’s a trap by the enemy and trust me I well know about falling into that trap of thinking that God cannot truly forgive me or I’m not worthy of my spouse because of X, Y, Z and what have you. It’s nonsense.

You are 100% completely and totally forgiven when you go to confession. It’s gone. Over. And if you’re still worried, go earn a plenary indulgence and your temporal punishment is eradicated as well. The propensity for sin isn’t washed away as easily and again, I well know that. Being a virgin when you get married doesn’t mean you don’t have faults when it comes to this area in life and I know from personal experience.

Pride is what keeps you attached to past sins that are forgiven. Wipe it away from your mind. God has already done so in His.
 
I think that past experiences do haunt you even after Confession…not because you are not forgiven, but because they obscure your view of sexuality forever after.

it’s not that someone can’t get passed those experiences, i think many people certainly do…but it takes time and a lot of love and reassurance from a supportive spouse.

Finding an average for sex would be darn near impossible…there are so many factors.

How about this question: When you do have sex, how satisfied (fulfilled) are you?

You know, quality rather than quantity. I have heard that Catholic NFP couples that waited until marriage to have sex rate their quality among the highest in the country. I believe it!
 
As much as I appreciate someone understanding the gravity of the gift and responsibility of sexuality, I have to take issue with you here. You’re incorrect to say you have ruined it. There is no reason to continue to confess ancient sins even if they haunt your present, unless of course they are causing sins in the here and now.

It’s a trap by the enemy and trust me I well know about falling into that trap of thinking that God cannot truly forgive me or I’m not worthy of my spouse because of X, Y, Z and what have you. It’s nonsense.

You are 100% completely and totally forgiven when you go to confession. It’s gone. Over. And if you’re still worried, go earn a plenary indulgence and your temporal punishment is eradicated as well. The propensity for sin isn’t washed away as easily and again, I well know that. Being a virgin when you get married doesn’t mean you don’t have faults when it comes to this area in life and I know from personal experience.

Pride is what keeps you attached to past sins that are forgiven. Wipe it away from your mind. God has already done so in His.
Thank you for your perspective. Of course I cannot agree with you, not from where I stand. I know I am forgiven. However, the consequences, the temporal consequences as it were, are still present. With my husband, I do not believe that he can ever respect me because I never had self-respect enough to stay pure. I am not saying other men could not overcome that bad start and come to respect their wives. But from where we started, and where we are now, I track backward to the way we began and that is where I believe the problems began. In having sex without commitment, I sent a message to him that I would accept that. I am a person with high ethical and moral standards, and have lived my life in an upright way, so why would my husband not respect me as a person? When I go back and consider things, that’s where I settle.

I could be wrong. My husband’s father is a narcissist and my husband also has some narcissistic traits. So it’s possible that what I am interpreting as a lack of respect due to the way we started out, is simply a lack of consideration due to the narcissistic traits. The jury is still out and over time, I’ll learn more.

Thanks again for the (name removed by moderator)ut.

Added: NFPKate gets it: *I think that past experiences do haunt you even after Confession…not because you are not forgiven, but because they obscure your view of sexuality forever after.

it’s not that someone can’t get past those experiences, i think many people certainly do…**but it takes time and a lot of love and reassurance from a supportive spouse. ***

Exactly.
 
I think that this is one of those things that many (not all) women just “don’t get” about men. So many of us could have sex every day, or every other day at the very least.
I second this – and I’m not even married!

I don’t think most women fully understand what it’s like to be a guy in terms of sex drive. It is a real and urgent need. It causes us physical and mental anguish. The nearest equivalent for a woman of denying a man sex, I suppose, would be a man expecting a woman to go months without most kinds of social interaction with her husband, even chitchat and friendly hugging. If that sounds like Hell for women, well, that’s what sexlessness is like for men.
I see nothing “horrible” about expecting a man to act like a gentleman and continue to “woo” his wife even after they have been married for many years.

No, I don’t NEED love notes, lunch dates, and gifts, and I don’t make my husband earn sex. But I certainly enjoy love notes, lunch dates, and gifts. Don’t you?

And please don’t feel sorry for my husband. I read him the post from the person who said that five minute quickies are great and that sex is easy to schedule, and my husband was appalled. His first comment was, “Obviously a man wrote that.”

Please keep in mind that my husband and I have been married 33 years this June, and we dated (chastely) for 6 years before we got married. Both of our daughters have stated in public that they hope to have a marriage as good as their parents’ marriage.

We have been privileged over the years to know many other couples who have been married for decades until death, and it was from one of these dear older couples (the husband just died last year, RIP) that we received the advice about a husband “stoking the fires” throughout the day. You’re certainly free to reject the advice if you disagree, but it’s my opinion that it is usually a wise idea to pay attention to marriage advice from couples who have been happily married for many decades.

If I implied in my post that marital sex is all about bribes and withholding and rewarding, then I did a bad job of writing.

To me, the idea of making love just because “we made the committment” sounds like a “duty” rather than a joy. Marriage is not a life-time membership in a local lodge, with required “meetings.” And even the most determined couple finds that as the decades pass, the “commitment” seems further and further away, but the kindnesses like notes, lunches, etc. are very helpful to keeping a marriage young and fresh and exciting.
For what it’s worth I don’t see anything offensive in your original comment, which simply said that sex is part of a continuing dynamic between couples for which women are not solely responsible. Which, to me, seems so obviously true there’s no reason for it to be controversial.

What’s key here is that many marriages treat sex and non-sexual attention and affection as negotiable. Neither are. Marital duties are duties even if the rights attached to them are left unjustly unfulfilled. A woman has a duty to satisfy her husband even if she feels neglected and unloved. And a man has a duty to love and care for his wife even if she neglects him sexually. Of course, each of these things belong to one another. It’s hard a for man to be loving and attentive when his wife is neglecting him sexually. And it’s hard for a woman to have sex with her husband when he is not particularly loving or attentive. I suspect it’s very easy to get into cycles in which a man resents his wife for not being sexual enough and retaliates by withholding affection, or vice-versa. And the neglected partner responds by cutting back on his or her end, and the cycle worsens. Probably many marriages are destroyed this way, because they’re not meant to be run on the basis of justice (“I’m giving you what you’re owed”) but on the basis of love (“I’m giving you this because I want what’s best for you”).
 
As much as I appreciate someone understanding the gravity of the gift and responsibility of sexuality, I have to take issue with you here. You’re incorrect to say you have ruined it. There is no reason to continue to confess ancient sins even if they haunt your present, unless of course they are causing sins in the here and now.

It’s a trap by the enemy and trust me I well know about falling into that trap of thinking that God cannot truly forgive me or I’m not worthy of my spouse because of X, Y, Z and what have you. It’s nonsense.

You are 100% completely and totally forgiven when you go to confession. It’s gone. Over. And if you’re still worried, go earn a plenary indulgence and your temporal punishment is eradicated as well. The propensity for sin isn’t washed away as easily and again, I well know that. Being a virgin when you get married doesn’t mean you don’t have faults when it comes to this area in life and I know from personal experience.

Pride is what keeps you attached to past sins that are forgiven. Wipe it away from your mind. God has already done so in His.
Aren’t you required, though, to confess any sins forgotten and unconfessed from a previous confession? If TRJ was baptized in youth I’d think she’d be obligated to continue confessing sins as she remembers them, even though they were absolved by a previous confession.
 
This thread is depressing. When you are doing all the right things for all the right reasons and it still doesn’t pay off, it just feels like :banghead:

Sometimes I need to know when to stop reading threads like this one because it just does nothing but get me down.
oh…Good Lord above…we’re now fighting on CAF about sex in marriage :banghead:

I left CAF for 2 months and I’m not sure if it were wise to come back 😃
Eeek! Sorry! I feel bad about starting this thread if it’s making people feel bad. My husband and I have very different drives, and I was just wondering how it was with other people. I was going to start a subsequent thread on trying to give your husband more sex, but have quickly changed my mind 😃
 
Eeek! Sorry! I feel bad about starting this thread if it’s making people feel bad. My husband and I have very different drives, and I was just wondering how it was with other people. I was going to start a subsequent thread on trying to give your husband more sex, but have quickly changed my mind 😃
That could be a very helpful thread for many people…don’t hesitate to start it.
 
I second this – and I’m not even married!

I don’t think most women fully understand what it’s like to be a guy in terms of sex drive. It is a real and urgent need. It causes us physical and mental anguish. The nearest equivalent for a woman of denying a man sex, I suppose, would be a man expecting a woman to go months without most kinds of social interaction with her husband, even chitchat and friendly hugging. If that sounds like Hell for women, well, that’s what sexlessness is like for men.

For what it’s worth I don’t see anything offensive in your original comment, which simply said that sex is part of a continuing dynamic between couples for which women are not solely responsible. Which, to me, seems so obviously true there’s no reason for it to be controversial.

What’s key here is that many marriages treat sex and non-sexual attention and affection as negotiable. Neither are. Marital duties are duties even if the rights attached to them are left unjustly unfulfilled. A woman has a duty to satisfy her husband even if she feels neglected and unloved. And a man has a duty to love and care for his wife even if she neglects him sexually. Of course, each of these things belong to one another. It’s hard a for man to be loving and attentive when his wife is neglecting him sexually. And it’s hard for a woman to have sex with her husband when he is not particularly loving or attentive. I suspect it’s very easy to get into cycles in which a man resents his wife for not being sexual enough and retaliates by withholding affection, or vice-versa. And the neglected partner responds by cutting back on his or her end, and the cycle worsens. Probably many marriages are destroyed this way, because they’re not meant to be run on the basis of justice (“I’m giving you what you’re owed”) but on the basis of love (“I’m giving you this because I want what’s best for you”).
I think you’ve nailed it.

I think that often, women especially get into the habit of saying “no.” I think this often starts right after a baby arrives. The wife is tired, sore, and she feels more like a mommy than a wifey. If she goes back to work after six weeks of maternity leave, she’s even more exhausted.

So she says “No,” and the husband goes along with with it for a while because he too is tired and stressed because of the new baby and all the extra work and problems.

But then the wife continues to say “no” even after the sleeping is going better, and a routine (even a chaotic one) is established. It’s just a habit.

Calliso mentioned this in their post when he/she asked, “Is it that some people just donlt have time…or is the I donlt have time just an excuse?” I think that’s another good “nailed it” comment. Yes, “lack of time” can be just an excuse, or, as I call it, a “habit.”

Sometimes, though, time really is an issue and it’s not just an excuse. E.g., if one of the spouses is working long hours and isn’t home, there’s not a lot that either spouse can do about it other than quitting the job, and frankly, in this economy, I wouldn’t be too quick to quit any job. Of course if I had to choose between the job and the marriage, it would be to lose the job. But OTOH, a lot of marriages fail when there isn’t enough money coming in to lift the couple out of debt and poverty. A lot of issues to consider–it’s not just a simple dilemma.

Something else that can take away time is a difficult baby or child. Of course we love our difficult-to-care-for babies, but let’s be honest–if you have a child with special needs or a child who is sick a lot, or just a cranky baby who can’t seem to adjust to life outside of a womb and of course, NEVER sleeps!–it takes a LOT of time to care for that baby. So this is a case where “there’s no time for sex” ISN’T just an excuse, but a legitimate issue.

I think that if a couple truly doesn’t seem to have the time for love-making, they need to take a serious look at what is happening in their lives, and try to make some changes to allow for more time.

Like I said, it’s possible that a job that demands too much time may have to go, but boy oh boy, that’s a very tough decision to make, and I think a couple should seek the wisdom of an older couple before cavalierly deciding to quit a good job.

When it comes to the difficult child, a couple could hire a mature sitter to give them a few hours away from the crying and fussing. That’s really hard for some mothers, but I think they should give it serious thought, because they were wives before they were mothers, and they will be wives long after the baby has grown up and left home. The best thing a mother can do for her children is to love their daddy!
 
Aren’t you required, though, to confess any sins forgotten and unconfessed from a previous confession? If TRJ was baptized in youth I’d think she’d be obligated to continue confessing sins as she remembers them, even though they were absolved by a previous confession.
No. If that was true then absolution wouldn’t be absolution. You are totally and completely absolved of everything, every time, provided that there is no deception and you really are sorry for your sins.

So there’s no such thing as “intentionally forgetting.” God knows what you know, so it’s not like you can trick Him.

If it makes you feel better to confess a truly forgotten sin, mortal or venial, by all means do it. But it’s gone.
 
I know I am forgiven. However, the consequences, the temporal consequences as it were, are still present. With my husband, I do not believe that he can ever respect me because I never had self-respect enough to stay pure. I am not saying other men could not overcome that bad start and come to respect their wives. But from where we started, and where we are now, I track backward to the way we began and that is where I believe the problems began. In having sex without commitment, I sent a message to him that I would accept that. I am a person with high ethical and moral standards, and have lived my life in an upright way, so why would my husband not respect me as a person? When I go back and consider things, that’s where I settle.
Why would my wife love me when I have so many failings? Why should she trust me with her innermost self when I had problems aplenty with something that affects so many, many adolescent and young adult males these days? (You can fill in the blanks here) But she did, even after I told her… and we were not even engaged yet! Grab an indulgence and your temporal effect is washed away forever. The impact of learned behavior won’t dissipate but…
I could be wrong. My husband’s father is a narcissist and my husband also has some narcissistic traits. So it’s possible that what I am interpreting as a lack of respect due to the way we started out, is simply a lack of consideration due to the narcissistic traits. The jury is still out and over time, I’ll learn more.
As the owner of such traits, I can tell you that it’s quite possible that it’s really about those problems and not about you. I love my wife and children beyond measure but that doesn’t keep me from being an incredibly selfish person at times. Heck I’ve made my wife cry because of it and I had no idea I was even doing anything wrong. It takes a big-time emotional slap to get people like us to really think about how our behavior affects other people, even people we love.
 
I second this – and I’m not even married!

I don’t think most women fully understand what it’s like to be a guy in terms of sex drive. It is a real and urgent need. It causes us physical and mental anguish. The nearest equivalent for a woman of denying a man sex, I suppose, would be a man expecting a woman to go months without most kinds of social interaction with her husband, even chitchat and friendly hugging. If that sounds like Hell for women, well, that’s what sexlessness is like for men.

For what it’s worth I don’t see anything offensive in your original comment, which simply said that sex is part of a continuing dynamic between couples for which women are not solely responsible. Which, to me, seems so obviously true there’s no reason for it to be controversial.

What’s key here is that many marriages treat sex and non-sexual attention and affection as negotiable. Neither are. Marital duties are duties even if the rights attached to them are left unjustly unfulfilled. A woman has a duty to satisfy her husband even if she feels neglected and unloved. And a man has a duty to love and care for his wife even if she neglects him sexually. Of course, each of these things belong to one another. It’s hard a for man to be loving and attentive when his wife is neglecting him sexually. And it’s hard for a woman to have sex with her husband when he is not particularly loving or attentive.** I suspect it’s very easy to get into cycles in which a man resents his wife for not being sexual enough and retaliates by withholding affection, or vice-versa. And the neglected partner responds by cutting back on his or her end, and the cycle worsens. Probably many marriages are destroyed this way, because they’re not meant to be run on the basis of justice (“I’m giving you what you’re owed”) but on the basis of love (“I’m giving you this because I want what’s best for you”)**.
You just described the last 2 years of my life. 😦 We were working on our issues in counseling but had to stop because of my husband’s extensive travel schedule. I’m back to wondering if we’re going to make it going forward…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top