Either Catholics or Mormons have it right...

  • Thread starter Thread starter SalesianSDB
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you SteveVH, that does help. Sorry to press the point but is it fair to say that even if everyone here at the Catholic forums agreed that there was no Apostolic authority within the Catholic church, that it would change very little?
No. It would change everything because we would not have the assurance that we were receiving the truth given to the Apostles by Christ. In addition, we would have no authority to ordain legitimate priests and bishops and to effect the sacraments, most especially the sacrifice of the Mass. The good news is that we do have authority and can prove this authority by a documented, unbroken line of succession which takes us right back to Peter, and therefore to Jesus Christ himself. We are the only Church on the face of the earth that can prove this. All others must rely only on a claim, LDS included.
 
Posted by Kathleen Gee
To believe in Egyptian scrolls and golden slabs are to believe in symbols and images outside the framework of Judeo Christianity. To justify polygamy and starting a new religion…one would indeed have to create new stories.
These “physical articles” of Joseph Smith that were used for the Book of Mormon were warned against by God in the book of Samuel. They all fall in the category of superstition.
Also the reason ( actually excuse } that the LDS Church use for polygamy is that David and Solomon were polygamists with their myriad of wives and concubines. This is poor reasoning since they do not really know the reason as to why God allowed it under the Law. If the LDS would delve into the history and Chonicles of the Hebrews and the Law of the time, they would find out why it was allowed back then, but was a violation of the law anyway. The LDS should also read the writings of the early rebbes.

PAX DOMINI :signofcross:

Shalom Aleichem
 
Exactly…

In the transmission of Divine Revelation, Christ wants all men to be saved, not just the Mormons, but all people who have lived during the past 2,000 years.

What proof is there that a few Christians were living righteously after the death of the last apostle? This is weak.

Jesus is greater and bigger than allowing a few people here and there to be real Christians for all this period of time to Joseph Smith’s new revelations that supposedly superceded Christ’s.

All that we have and need is in Sacred Scriptures and by the Apostles who knew Jesus.

Why did Moroni the angel have wives? Why didn’t the Apostles teach that?

The Mormon belief is that Jesus went to America to see the Indians on the evening of the Resurrection.

The Sacred Scriptures say Jesus appeared – not to the Indians after His resurrection – but to His Apostles in the evening that Sunday, and that He gave them the power to forgive sin. Why would He leave His apostles and go some place to reveal the fullness of truth when all the events were being culminated in Jerusalem?

Sacred Scripture is authored by God through the Holy Spirit through human writers who were members of of the public gathering of the teaching of men, part of the public gathering of believers…those part of the Jewish assembly to that in the New Testament.

Sacred Tradition fully transmits the Word of God 'entrusted to the Apostles by Christ the Lord and the Holy Spirit. It transmits it to the successors of the apostles so that, enlightened by the Spirit of truth, they may faithfully preserve, expound, and spread it (the Word of God) by their preaching. CC 82.

Hermeneutics is the discipline that the Holy Spirit interpreted past events in the Old Testament and teachings by Christ not yet understood, that were finally revealed after His death and resurrection.

The apostles entrusted the 'Sacred deposit of faith contained in Sacred Scripture and Tradition, to the whole Church. CC84.

Regarding the Magesterium of the Church
CC85: “‘The task of giving an authentic interpretation of the Word of God, whether in its written form or in the form of Tradition, has been entrusted to the living, teaching office of the Church alone. Its authority in this matter is exercised in the name of Jesus Christ.’ This means that the task of interpretation has been entrusted to the bishops in communion with the successor of Peter, the Bishop of Rome.’”

The Magesterium is servant to the Word of God…“It teaches only what has been handed on to it. At the divine command and with the help of the Holy Spirit, it listens to this devotedly, guards it with dedication, and expounds on it faithfully. All that it proposes for belief as being divinely revealed is drawn from this single deposit of faith”. CC86

Christ said to His apostles…“He who hears you, hears me.”

We do not hear Jesus in Joseph Smith.
 
Here are some writing by some prominent Mormon leaders regarding Christianity. I would like to speak about the tone of these writings. I would like your thoughts on it. …I find the same tone in a lot of Joseph Smiths writings. What do you think?

“Since the departure from the true gospel of Christ was to be universal…it would follow that a restoration would be necessary. Such a restoration is the message of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.”—Apostle LeGrand Richards, *A Marvelous Work And A Wonder, *1976, p. 32

Nothing less than a complete apostasy from the Christian religion would warrant the establishment of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.”—History of the Church, vol. 1, p. XL
“We talk about Christianity, but it is a perfect pack of nonsense.…it is as corrupt as hell; and the Devil could not invent a better engine to spread his work than the Christianity of the nineteenth century.”—Apostle John Taylor (who would eventually become 3rd Prophet), 1858,
Journal of Discourses,
vol. 6, p. 167

“What is it that inspires professors of Christianity generally with a hope of salvation? It is that smooth, sophisticated influence of the devil, by which he deceives the whole world.”—Joseph Smith, *History of the Church, *vol. 5, p. 218

“My object in going to inquire of the Lord was to know which of all the sects was right, that I might know which to join.…I was answered that I must join none of them, for they were all wrong; and the Personage who addressed me said that **all their creeds were an abomination **in his sight; that those professors were all corrupt.…”—Joseph Smith—History 1:18-19

“And he said unto me: Behold there are save two churches only; the one is the church of the Lamb of God, and the other is the church of the devil.…”—1 Nephi 14:10, Book of Mormon
“ ‘Will everybody be damned, but Mormons?Yes, and a great portion of them, unless they repent, and work righteousness.”—*Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, *compiled by Joseph Fielding Smith, 1976, p. 119

“There is no salvation outside The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. (Doctrines of Salvation, vol. 2, pp. 1-350.)”—Apostle Bruce R. McConkie, Mormon Doctrine, p. 670

Catholic-RCIA,
I think the tone of those writings is similar to the tone of the Old Testament writings where Jehovah told the house of Israel, in no uncertain terms and sometimes in very descriptive language that could be regarded as offensive, that they were no longer worshiping the true God of Israel and that is why they were being scattered.

The tone can be regarded as offensive if one is not familiar with those Old Testament “calls to repentance”, but if one is familiar with those Old Testament passages, then they will be able to understand the context of the challenges to the “conventional wisdom” of the day and time in which those words were being used.

Bear in mind that “salvation” in the context used by BRM in the last quote, means “exaltation” since that is really what Christ wants for all of humanity, but yet they are allowed to choose what it is they deep-down want.

As far as the “influence of the devil”, then it seems to me that the “original sin” concept and the “pride” concept that are attributed to Adam and Eve, are definitely influenced by Satan since those concepts mean that a person will reject seeking to “be ye therefore perfect” or “become like Christ (which means literally to do that)”.

So there’s my take on what you asked. It really is a difference in approach to what Christ and John taught about what it means to follow Him and become like Him, through being sanctified as a person repents of all their sins and thus becomes more like Him by how they act day by day.
 
Javl----excellent draw on your learning of Judaism…clarifying my point that God does not use any piece of gold…the 10 commandments were made of clay…we were made of clay…and when Moses returned with the tablets, the Law was already broken.

It is this ongoing ‘other’ problem with Mormonism…Jesus heals blindness…Jesus is the Light – no need for glasses that Smith used…The Sun is many times is used as representing Christ, the source of all light…coming from faith in Him.

The Egyptian scrolls that bore secrets??..that Christ and His apostles did not reveal?..that turned out to be instructions in mummyfying…the golden slates??..reflections of the Golden Calf…

On Resurrection Sunday, the Apostles were afraid and waiting on the Lord…Why would the Lord go to America??? All the events of Salvation come from Israel.

How many Jews actually did convert? My Hebrew Catholic friend conjectures so many millions of Jews in Israel…and the Jews who refused Christ, had their numbers, and the vast majority of them had to flee Israel…

Catholicism is indeed the fulfillment of Judaism. But now we await the ingrafting of the Jews. I personally believe that when the Jews finally turn to Jesus, they will ‘fill in all the gaps’…issues…people have of the Catholic Church, mainline Christianity, and all the rest.
 
People who do not think Catholicism is the fulfillment of Judaism do not know the Catholic Mass or how much Sacred Scriptures is integrated into the Church.
 
You have it right, Kathleen. Too bad that too many so-called “Christians” have blinders on that they cannot see the beauty of the truth in the Eucharist and the Mass. Someday, soon I hope.

From all that I’ve read, all my conversations, and all my dialogs with all the LDS, I can only reach one conclusion: the LDS is not only based upon the figment of imagination of one man, but that so many intelligent persons, who seem to have a real love of and for God, are duped into believing the writings and rantings of this man. Their mind seems to be closed to the beautiful truth which stares them in the face through the Sacred and Holy Scriptures of the Bible. Yet, they are either totally blind to the real truth or are so engrossed with this fantasy that they refuse to see it.

We can only pray to God the Holy Spirit to remove the blinders and clear their minds so that they can perceive the whole truth and turn to the true understanding and worship of the One True God. Shalom haMeshiach.

PAX DOMINI :signofcross:

Shalom Aleichem.
 
Catholic-RCIA,
I think the tone of those writings is similar to the tone of the Old Testament writings where Jehovah told the house of Israel, in no uncertain terms and sometimes in very descriptive language that could be regarded as offensive, that they were no longer worshiping the true God of Israel and that is why they were being scattered.

The tone can be regarded as offensive if one is not familiar with those Old Testament “calls to repentance”, but if one is familiar with those Old Testament passages, then they will be able to understand the context of the challenges to the “conventional wisdom” of the day and time in which those words were being used.
Oh poppycock, if any one here said We talk about Mormonism, but it is a perfect pack of nonsense.…it is as corrupt as hell; and the Devil could not invent a better engine to spread his work than Mormonism LDS posters would be up in arms. And then you add to the injury by saying the problem people have is not with the ugly words spoken but with the “fact” that they are unfamiliar with the bible. That if they would just read the bible they would be perfectly happy with the ugly statements about them.
As far as the “influence of the devil”, then it seems to me that the “original sin” concept and the “pride” concept that are attributed to Adam and Eve, are definitely influenced by Satan since those concepts mean that a person will reject seeking to “be ye therefore perfect” or “become like Christ (which means literally to do that)”.
Please explain to me how you are in any minuscule way qualified to tell Catholics what their concepts mean?? Your "explaining here of Original Sin is much like those who say “exaltation means getting your own planet and copulating with your goddess wives to populate them”.
 
Zaff here has a very good point…Parker, it is akin to Muslims telling us the ‘truth’ about Christianity, and I saw that in reference to what Javl illuminated in regards to our reactions to symbols and objects not found in the Bible or concepts or happenings not happening in Sacred Scripture.

I would like to share on the parts of the Mass on what they mean in Fr Jeremy Driscoll’s book, ‘What Happens at Mass’. If you could then understand what is happening, our perspective and vision, then you would better understand our reaction when Mormons claim essentially that Christ stopped being Savior and Redeemer to the world until Joseph Smith and his beliefs came. Holding concepts like that also makes people back up and then ask what kind of God then, do you believe in, if Christ was not allowed through His apostles to have successors, to not be the Good Shepherd to His flock.
 
Catholic-RCIA,
I think the tone of those writings is similar to the tone of the Old Testament writings where Jehovah told the house of Israel, in no uncertain terms and sometimes in very descriptive language that could be regarded as offensive, that they were no longer worshiping the true God of Israel and that is why they were being scattered.

The tone can be regarded as offensive if one is not familiar with those Old Testament “calls to repentance”, but if one is familiar with those Old Testament passages, then they will be able to understand the context of the challenges to the “conventional wisdom” of the day and time in which those words were being used.

Bear in mind that “salvation” in the context used by BRM in the last quote, means “exaltation” since that is really what Christ wants for all of humanity, but yet they are allowed to choose what it is they deep-down want.

As far as the “influence of the devil”, then it seems to me that the “original sin” concept and the “pride” concept that are attributed to Adam and Eve, are definitely influenced by Satan since those concepts mean that a person will reject seeking to “be ye therefore perfect” or “become like Christ (which means literally to do that)”.

So there’s my take on what you asked. It really is a difference in approach to what Christ and John taught about what it means to follow Him and become like Him, through being sanctified as a person repents of all their sins and thus becomes more like Him by how they act day by day.
Ok
Lets take the following Parker. Give me a parallel from the Old Testament
Then explain it. Make the comparison as clear as you possibly can.
In Christ. But most of all what were these false teachers teaching?
Rich

Both Catholics and Protestants are nothing less than the “whore of Babylon” whom the Lord denounces… as having corrupted all the earth by their fornications and wickedness. And any person who shall be so wicked as to receive a holy ordinance of the gospel from the ministers of any of these apostate churches will be sent down to hell with them, unless they repent of the unholy and impious act. If any penitent believer desires to obtain forgiveness of sins through baptism, let him beware of having any thing to do with the churches of apostate Christendom, lest he perish in the awful plagues and judgments, denounced against them. The only persons among all nations, kindreds, tongues, and people who have authority from Jesus Christ to administer any gospel ordinance are those called and authorized among the Latter-day Saints. Before the restoration of the church of Christ to the earth in the year 1830, there have been no people on the earth for many generations possessing authority from God to minister gospel ordinances. We again repeat. Beware of the hypocritical false teachers and imposters of Babylon!
  • Apostle Orson Pratt The Seer, Vol.2, No.4, p.255
St. Polycarp was one of the immediate disciples of the Apostles, in particular St. John the Evangelist. He embraced Christianity very young and was named bishop of Smyrna. He was greatly respected by the faithful, wrote many letters and formed many holy disciples. His epistle to the Philippians - the only one to be preserved - demonstrates his apostolic spirit, his profound humility and meekness, and his great charity.
St. Polycarp fought against heresy. He also taught that Christians must walk in truth, do God’s will, keep all of His commandments, and love whatever He loved. Christians must refrain from all fraud, avarice, detraction, and rash judgment. They must repay evil with forgiveness and mercy. He taught that one must pray all the time, so as not to be led into temptation, fast, persevere and be joyful.
During his episcopate, a violent persecution broke out in Smyrna against the Christians. During this time, though fearless, the bishop retreated to a neighboring village, spending most of his time in prayer.
A boy betrayed the bishop, and horsemen came by night to arrest him. He met his captors at the door, ordered them a supper, and prayed for two hours before he went with them.
He was led directly to the proconsul, who ordered him to blaspheme Christ. St. Polycarp refused and he was to be burned alive.
The executioners would have nailed him to the stake, but he convinced them that it wasn’t necessary. So they simple tied his hands behind his back. At the end of his prayer, the executioners set the fire, but the large flames formed into an arch, gently encircling but not burning his body. Exasperated, officials ordered a spearman to pierce him. Such a quantity of blood flowed from his left side that it put out the fire. The Christians wanted St. Polycarp’s body but the centurion burnt it to ashes.
 
Or Smith’s accusation that we are the abomination…but they never do say what it is that makes us worthy of hell.

They still cannot define the real crux of the apostasy.

Then I hear how Mormons do not believe in hell, there are 3 celestial heavens…but may be there is one just for us…

I saw articles a number of times by those who left Mormonism noting the influence of Masonry.

Anyway, you can go around and around…
 
Christianity was not undermining Judaism. Christianity is the fullfillment and completion of Judaism. Ref: Hebrewcatholics.org.

The Pharisees, along with the Saducees, were more interested in the power they had over the people than adhereing to God’s Law. In their eyes the Christians ( like the Zadoks ) posed a threat to them, therefore they encouraged a form or persecution of Christians. Please read early Church history.

PAX DOMINI :signofcross:

Shalom Aleichem
Likewise, the revelations of the prophet Joeseph Smith do not undermine Catholicism, they are the fulfillment and completion of Catholicism.

I know it is fanciful for me to imagine you want to understand our position but the LDS/Catholic relationship is analogous to the Early Christian/Jewish relationship.
 
No. It would change everything because we would not have the assurance that we were receiving the truth given to the Apostles by Christ. In addition, we would have no authority to ordain legitimate priests and bishops and to effect the sacraments, most especially the sacrifice of the Mass. The good news is that we do have authority and can prove this authority by a documented, unbroken line of succession which takes us right back to Peter, and therefore to Jesus Christ himself. We are the only Church on the face of the earth that can prove this. All others must rely only on a claim, LDS included.
Now this makes some sense to me and is very similar to the LDS position, the only other church that makes a claim to Apostolic succession. But if that’s true then why do you accept baptism from Protestants who have no such claim but instead claim their authority comes from their study of the Bible? And also, why so you get so annoyed when we say because we’re the only church with the Apostolic succession that other churches should not be accepted?
 
Or Smith’s accusation that we are the abomination…but they never do say what it is that makes us “worthy of damnation”.

They still cannot define the real crux of the apostasy.

Then I hear how Mormons do not believe in hell, there are 3 celestial heavens…but may be there is one just for us…

I saw articles a number of times by those who left Mormonism noting the influence of Masonry.

Anyway, you can go around and around…
Kathleen and Rich (Catholic-RCIA),

Please be aware that the compilation given the title “The Seer” is considered by LDS leaders and members to be doctrinally wrong, so why would I defend any of it? I don’t need to defend it–it is incorrect.

Joseph Smith said he was told “all their creeds are an abomination in His sight”. That is a specific statement about “creeds”–not a statement about people. See Hosea 9:10 for an example of a comparative statement using the word “abominations”.

The word “damnation” as used by Joseph Smith in the quote that had been cited by Rich needs to be understood within context, the context being that anyone who doesn’t receive exaltation through having made and kept all the covenants and ordinances of the gospel has placed themselves (through their choice) in a position of not becoming “like Christ” and thus they don’t gain the faith and the sanctification necessary to lay hold on exaltation.

All the statements I read when a person says in so many words that they reject the idea of “becoming like God” (since Christ is God the Son, to become like Him is to become like God) are in essence saying they reject the faith that would be necessary to do that, so by choice such a person has had their exaltation “stopped” by their own choice. It also means they at some point are doing their own will instead of doing Christ’s will and being led by the Spirit in the process of becoming wholly pure and sanctified through repentance.

This above-noted quality of the teachings, including the idea that teaches that Adam and Eve were embracing pride when they partook of the forbidden fruit and started this process of choosing between good and evil (not because of pride, but to gain “wisdom” by making choices) is the “crux of the apostasy”. It is found in what becomes the motivation of the people following the beliefs. If the target–the goal–is moved then the target is a different target than the one intended by the pure teachings of Christ and the apostles. (Even if it were moved slightly, it would still be a different target–purity is “completely pure”, without any impurity whatsoever.)

So please be aware that the use of the word “damnation” does not mean a person who has chosen against “exaltation” is going to a place of torment–for it doesn’t mean that. It means they have chosen less than what they could have chosen, as far as the “target” for their faith and devotion to God and their repentance. So those other “kingdoms of glory” that you mentioned (terrestrial kingdom and telestial kingdom), Kathleen, do become part of that context.
 
I couldn’t imagine that catholics would wonder one day which of these 2 religions is true, while both are completly different.
If any catholic would have asked this question regarding Catholic and Orthodox church it would have been different, but to put the mormon church beside the Catholic Church is incredible.
Yes, the ‘learned man’ would of known it was either the Catholic Church, the LDS (Brighamite) Church, Church of England, Eastern Orthodox Churches, some Lutheran Churches, Assyrian Church of the East, Oriental Orthodox Church, Old Catholic Church, Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, or Community of Christ, etc.

The ‘learned man’ story is a Mormon feel good fiction.
 
Kathleen and Rich (Catholic-RCIA),

Please be aware that the compilation given the title “The Seer” is considered by LDS leaders and members to be doctrinally wrong, so why would I defend any of it? I don’t need to defend it–it is incorrect.

Joseph Smith said he was told “all their creeds are an abomination in His sight”. That is a specific statement about “creeds”–not a statement about people. See Hosea 9:10 for an example of a comparative statement using the word “abominations”.

The word “damnation” as used by Joseph Smith in the quote that had been cited by Rich needs to be understood within context, the context being that anyone who doesn’t receive exaltation through having made and kept all the covenants and ordinances of the gospel has placed themselves (through their choice) in a position of not becoming “like Christ” and thus they don’t gain the faith and the sanctification necessary to lay hold on exaltation.

Parker, I would say repentance opens the door to allow Christ to grow within me. Repentance is the key to Christ’s Holiness. He is the exalted one. There are no others in this world or in heaven or in the entire Cosmos. I can not become exalted by following the Ten Commandments because I know I cannot follow them. All I can do is try by calling upon the name of Jesus. His power as I am powerless in these matters. Was it not the powerless that Christ was able to heal? Where were the Jews who followed the Ten Commandments as Jesus was walking to our salvation? No, it was the sinners, those who could not follow the commands and new it . They knew something was not right inside of them. It was the sinners who came out of the closet or were caught in sin that wiped the sweat and blood from His face. Those who gave Him drink, those who moved in to help Him carry His Cross. Those who wiped His blood from the stones He walked upon.

Only through my reliance on Jesus is following the commands made possible. He is not only my example, He is the only way. The only door to heaven is the Cross of Jesus. There is no going around it. Only through it.

Adam and Eve said no to Gods will and brought death to the world. They made an unwise choice. They cut the Chord of true Wisdom,… pure Grace, …life.

The perfect example of not making this wrong choice is found only in Jesus who through all of eternity has done the Fathers will in all perfection. Man at his beginning cannot but fail when left to his own accord. This is why God is always needed to give them victory over themselves. A learning curve for Gods Special Creation. Those created for Jesus.

A great example of true perfection is when Jesus was tempted in the desert in a similar way that Eve was tempted. Adam and Eve were like Jesus in the garden before they fell. The difference between them and Jesus is they were created, Jesus has always been. Their very existence was sustained by Him, through Him.

The progression if you want to call it that is really not about progressing at all. It’s about discovering the Grace of God out of free will given, then choosing Him or not. One brings an eternal life within the Holy Trinity; the other brings an eternal life away from God.

When you start at the top in Gods wisdom, in Gods grace, in Gods love and then reject it you go down not up, you go backwards not forward. When you realize this all you can do is ask for help to come back home. You do not come back by following laws and ordinances. You come back because you know you are loved dearly. You know this because you lay it all out, you recognize your sinful nature and in this because you have turned to the light it only gets brighter. No more laws, just Jesus and the laws simply fall into place one by one. Your are no longer checking them off as if they were important as they just run their natural course. You give all praise and Glory to God for the good you choose to do for Him. You know it’s no longer about you as it becomes all about Him. About Jesus. There is no other work on earth that can bring such joy.

Continued
 
If Joseph had followed the Law given Mary would have been stoned to death. He followed love and the law had no hold on them, no power over them.

When we turn to Christ, not ordinances, the father immediately sends His Son to gather those yearning to return to His Grace and to His love. When we have nothing to offer, we have only to receive. Why does all of this happen? Because as created beings we need to learn what happens when we search for Wisdom rather than simply surrendering to it, in it. To God will. Again the perfect example is found in Jesus. And yes we can become like Him. But we will never be Him. He will be our God. We will be His adopted Children. I find a lot of relief in this Parker. It also helps to write it down.

In all humility and love Parker, what are you offering me or others here that we do not already have in Jesus?

Can you list a few things?

P.S.
The hardest part for me this year regarding Christ-mas was a few hours before I went to Christmas. To be present at the birth of Christ. I asked my LDS family face to face if they wanted to go to the Christmas Mass with us. It all went kind of quiet. The fact that they were not there with us struck hard. They have never been. You see on that night Jesus was very much front and center and you want this for those you love, so much so that it can drive you down. Down you go and once again you are reminded who is in control and the peace returns, you get over yourself and just continue to love. To invite.

God Bless
 
…Can you list a few things?

The hardest part for me this year regarding Christ-mas was a few hours before I went to Christmas. To be present at the birth of Christ. I asked my LDS family face to face if they wanted to go to the Christmas Mass with us. It all went kind of quiet. The fact that they were not there with us struck hard. They have never been. You see on that night Jesus was very much front and center and you want this for those you love, so much so that it can drive you down. Down you go and once again you are reminded who is in control and the peace returns, you get over yourself and just continue to love. To invite.

God Bless
Rich,

The only thing I might possibly be able to “offer you” (since other issues involve your own choices and you have reiterated that you have exactly what you want within those choices) would be clarification about why your “LDS family” members may not have felt comfortable “going to Christmas Mass” with you. Bear in mind that anything that happened during that service was not “Jesus front and center”. It was a service in His memory and honor, true, but they could have “Jesus front and center” by reading the Bible and remembering His birth just as sincerely at home with their own children as attending a special service, since Christmas Eve this year nor Christmas Day were on Sunday.
 
If Joseph had followed the Law given Mary would have been stoned to death. He followed love and the law had no hold on them, no power over them.

When we turn to Christ, not ordinances, the father immediately sends His Son to gather those yearning to return to His Grace and to His love. When we have nothing to offer, we have only to receive. Why does all of this happen? Because as created beings we need to learn what happens when we search for Wisdom rather than simply surrendering to it, in it. To God will. Again the perfect example is found in Jesus. And yes we can become like Him. But we will never be Him. He will be our God. We will be His adopted Children. I find a lot of relief in this Parker. It also helps to write it down.

In all humility and love Parker, what are you offering me or others here that we do not already have in Jesus?

Can you list a few things?

P.S.
The hardest part for me this year regarding Christ-mas was a few hours before I went to Christmas. To be present at the birth of Christ. I asked my LDS family face to face if they wanted to go to the Christmas Mass with us. It all went kind of quiet. The fact that they were not there with us struck hard. They have never been. You see on that night Jesus was very much front and center and you want this for those you love, so much so that it can drive you down. Down you go and once again you are reminded who is in control and the peace returns, you get over yourself and just continue to love. To invite.

God Bless
Thank you for this Rich. It is difficult to describe the yearning that burns within us concerning our loved ones and our wish for their happiness in Christ. You have done so quite well and I could not be more empathetic. God bless you.
 
Rich,

The only thing I might possibly be able to “offer you” (since other issues involve your own choices and you have reiterated that you have exactly what you want within those choices) would be clarification about why your “LDS family” members may not have felt comfortable “going to Christmas Mass” with you. Bear in mind that anything that happened during that service was not “Jesus front and center”. It was a service in His memory and honor, true, but they could have “Jesus front and center” by reading the Bible and remembering His birth just as sincerely at home with their own children as attending a special service, since Christmas Eve this year nor Christmas Day were on Sunday.
With all due respect, Parker, if what you say is true then none of us have a need for a “Church”. All we need is a Bible. From the outside, it is difficult for us to imagine why anyone would not want to celebrate the birth of the Savior of the world. In the Catholic Church we do this by actually entering into the most intimate relationship possible with our Lord by listening to his word and receiving his true presence within us in the Eucharist. It is much more than sitting around talking about what a great event this was. It is why families gather, so that they can actually be in each other’s presence, rather than staying home and simply “remembering” each other. We want to actually be with our Lord on his birthday and we believe He wants to also be with us. This was the event for which the entire world had been waiting since Adam and Eve. It is a very big deal and certainly worthy of celebration in the greatest manner of which we are capable. There is no greater manner of celebration than the holy Mass.

God bless you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top