ELCA elects first openly-gay bishop

  • Thread starter Thread starter JackieMom
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JackieMom

Guest
ELCA elects first openly-gay and partnered bishop…
What would Martin Luther think?

Article
 
Not sure if the link in post #1 is working but here is one:

jsonline.com/news/usandworld/elca-elects-firs-to-openly-gay-bishop-b9924248z1-209794481.html
Los Angeles —The Evangelical Lutheran Church of America has elected its first openly gay bishop.
In a press release, church officials say the Rev. R. Guy Erwin was selected for a six-year term Friday as bishop of the Southwest California Synod.
The church’s rules changed in 2009 to allow gays and lesbians to be ordained in the nation’s largest Lutheran denomination.
Erwin currently serves as a pastor at Faith Lutheran Church and a professor of Lutheran Confessional Theology at California Lutheran University.
Officials say the “partnered gay man” is also the first Native American to be elected. Erwin is part Osage Indian.
 
ELCA elects first openly-gay and partnered bishop…
What would Martin Luther think?
He probably thinks that now would be a good time for strong traditional Lutherans to swallow their pride and become Catholics, or at least WELS, or have they gone off the deep end too?
 
If HE was the one that decided it was ok then it would be SO for he SAID SO 🙂
If NOT it would be REJECTED.
 
He probably thinks that now would be a good time for strong traditional Lutherans to swallow their pride and become Catholics, or at least WELS, or have they gone off the deep end too?
The divide with ELCA occurred a long time ago, but there is still LCMS and WELS and in fact, CLBA. Though I get a generally favorable impression of the latter, it appears to be a very small congregation and does one want to be a part of an extemely small denomination? Maybe? Maybe they will grow like the proverbial mustard seed.

ELCA sponsored Somalis to come to the US, ELCA is the Church George Tiller was of all things an Usher at when he got killed, now violence is unacceptable and wrong but it still makes one wonder a bit about a Church that would have a late term abortion provider attending.

Abby Johnson who became pro-life from working at a Planned Parenthood clinic says in her book she had problems finding a Church that would accept her when she worked for Planned Parenthood.
 
I tthink this is a sad day for Christianity in America. One of the largest mainline Protestant American denominations has elected a bishop who is living a homosexual life that is in complete contradiction to the Old Testament as well as the Gospels and apparently has the support of Evangelical Lutherans across America.
What is truly a sad commentary is that in 2009 the ELCA approved openly gay members in the clergy which has led to the first election of a bishop who is practicing homosexuality and yet the overwhelming majority of Evangelical Lutherans across America are in full support of this. When the Anglican (Episcopal) church fell into the trap of Moral Relatvism there were many Anglicans who correctly realized that the Anglican Church was going into unchartered territory that it was never supposed to go into. Upon realizing this many of these individuals turned to Pope Benedict XVI to request union with the Holy See. While in the ELCA their is no recognition on the part of Evangelical Lutherans that their is in the process of watering down the gospels. At the mere mention of creating a Lutheran Oridinate for Evangelical Lutherans to be able to join the Catholic Church is looked upon as being offensive and antagonistic.
In contemplating this matter further I realize that this should not be a surprise for any Chruch that would have the abortionist George Tiller and a member or communicant has lost it’s way a long time ago. Martin Luther must be spinning in his grave.
I do believe that our Catholic Church needs to reach out to those Evangelical Lutherans who are uncomfortable with the most recent development of the ECLA. 🤷:banghead:
 
I tthink this is a sad day for Christianity in America. One of the largest mainline Protestant American denominations has elected a bishop who is living a homosexual life that is in complete contradiction to the Old Testament as well as the Gospels and apparently has the support of Evangelical Lutherans across America.
What is truly a sad commentary is that in 2009 the ELCA approved openly gay members in the clergy which has led to the first election of a bishop who is practicing homosexuality and yet the overwhelming majority of Evangelical Lutherans across America are in full support of this. When the Anglican (Episcopal) church fell into the trap of Moral Relatvism there were many Anglicans who correctly realized that the Anglican Church was going into unchartered territory that it was never supposed to go into. Upon realizing this many of these individuals turned to Pope Benedict XVI to request union with the Holy See. While in the ELCA their is no recognition on the part of Evangelical Lutherans that their is in the process of watering down the gospels. At the mere mention of creating a Lutheran Oridinate for Evangelical Lutherans to be able to join the Catholic Church is looked upon as being offensive and antagonistic.
In contemplating this matter further I realize that this should not be a surprise for any Chruch that would have the abortionist George Tiller and a member or communicant has lost it’s way a long time ago. Martin Luther must be spinning in his grave.
I do believe that our Catholic Church needs to reach out to those Evangelical Lutherans who are uncomfortable with the most recent development of the ECLA. 🤷:banghead:
👍
 
I left the ELCA in 1991 when they put out their statement on abortion which was essentially pro-choice.
(also very pro- artificial contraception)
I am currently a member of the WELS, my children were born, baptized and educated in this church-hubby and I have been studying both the Orthodox and Catholic faith I’ve read the Catechism of the Catholic church and I like a lot of what I’ve read -but still have questions-(which are subjects for a another thread)
My Mom and brother left the ELCA also and are members of the Missouri Synod.

ETA Martin Luther would be appalled of course-just read some of Luther’s writings on marriage and family life and very anti contraceptive I may add… I agree with the above poster, I bet he’d tell people to either go to the WELS or Missouri Synod or the Catholic church.
 
He probably thinks that now would be a good time for strong traditional Lutherans to swallow their pride and become Catholics, or at least WELS, or have they gone off the deep end too?
Completely…my church is WELS and it’s hard to see the ELCA as Lutheran with their doctrine. I do know the Missouri Synod is also still very traditional as far as I know.
 
It really alienates the conservatives (i.e morally sane) in the Lutheran Church. It makes them appreciate the Catholic Church a lot more too.

Not a good sign for the ELCA, especially since their base is in the Dakotas and Minnesota. And for MN Lutherans are much more numerous in the conservative areas. When the leadership is staunchly liberal and the laity more reserved and conservative, tensions will arise.

Martin Luther would be disappointed. 😦
 
ELCA elects first openly-gay and partnered bishop…
What would Martin Luther think?

Article
My city has almost as many Lutherans as Catholics. My Missouri Synod Lutheran friends do not consider ELCA members to be real Lutherans. My general impression is that the MSLC knows what it believes and the ELCA does not-anything goes.

Missouri Synod churches here were in near total agreement with our Bishop Rhoades on religious liberty issues. The previous ELCA bishop was a good friend of our Bishop D’Arcy, but they have been very quiet on religious liberty.
 
My city has almost as many Lutherans as Catholics. My Missouri Synod Lutheran friends do not consider ELCA members to be real Lutherans. My general impression is that the MSLC knows what it believes and the ELCA does not-anything goes.

Missouri Synod churches here were in near total agreement with our Bishop Rhoades on religious liberty issues. The previous ELCA bishop was a good friend of our Bishop D’Arcy, but they have been very quiet on religious liberty.

LCMS
, Lutheran Church Missouri Synod.

As for ELCA per a prior post…en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evangelical_Lutheran_Church_in_America , according to this article, they are headquartered in Chicago. The history seems to be that the original Lutheran Church in America splintered and this was worked on in Ohio in 1987.

ELCA simply seems to be quite a bit larger than the next biggest Lutheran denominations. ELCA Lutheran Churches are actually rather easy to find on a widespread basis while if someone was in WELS, you might be able to find one but would need to search. There are of course, search engines on line to do such.

There is a real history with the Lutheran Church and the splits it has suffered over the past several years.

Not meaning to be critical of any other Churches but it seems like the Boy Scouts, I hate seeing it, there has been an agenda as quite a few mainstream protestant churches have changed greatly in the past few decades. One would need to study it but quite a few have.

Speaking of the Boy Scouts, LCMS released this statement: blogs.lcms.org/2013/boy-scouts-of-america-what-the-policy-change-means

As for me, I can’t find fault with their approach so far.

While it looks like WELS has a long time stand against Scouting: wels.net/news-events/forward-in-christ/may-1986/still-against-scouting
Scouting seeks to develop good habits and moral uprightness in boys and girls, but without Christ. A scout must believe in some god, but scouting cannot tolerate belief in Jesus Christ alone as the only basis for a really righteous life. Scouting may teach a boy or a girl how to become a useful, helpful, morally straight citizen; in the process, however, it may also develop in that boy or girl a crusted coat of self-righteousness, which protests, “I need no Savior.” Then “what good is it for a man to gain the whole world, yet forfeit his soul?” The last state of the man will be worse than the first.
“We maintain,” said one-time synod president, John Brenner, “that the scout program still contains elements of religion, that it perverts the teachings of Holy Scriptures; and that, therefore, the Scriptures bid us to avoid it.” President Brenner said that in 1945. We must still say that in 1986. That’s where we still stand.
That was the same problem I always saw with Scouting.
 
I guess that’s their religion so no real concern for me.

Hopefully, they can convert to the true faith.
 

LCMS
, Lutheran Church Missouri Synod.
Thanks for the correction. There are more than enough abbreviations in use here without me adding another by mistake.

Late last year I attended a LCMS funeral for the wife of a friend. They use the same Nicene Creed we do except they replaced “catholic” with “Christian” and included a footnote that the original was “catholic, meaning that they accepted the full gospel.”

Their church may not accept the doctrine of purgatory, but they had no objection if I prayed for one of their deceased members.
 
He probably thinks that now would be a good time for strong traditional Lutherans to swallow their pride and become Catholics, or at least WELS, or have they gone off the deep end too?
I can assure you, the WELS (Wisc Ev. Lutheran Synod) would NEVER allow an unrepentant sinner (homosexuality is STILL a sin in our eyes) to be elevated to such a position as this! He would have been excommunicated long ago (following, of course, the principles of confronting sin that our LORD Jesus laid out in Matt 18). When it comes to moral teachings of life and marriage, we are “hand in hand” with the Catholic Church.
 
I personally don’t care one iota what the heretical protestants do
 
The farther our non Catholic Churches stray from the Truth and Faith the more difficult I think it might be for them to find their way home to the Church; thus it’s important in my opinion to be aware of what is going on and comment upon it.

Mary.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top