Elisha and the Bears

  • Thread starter Thread starter Questioner28
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A couple quick thoughts.
Code:
If you don't regard some Old Testament stories as presenting a false picture of God, then we obviously see things differently. When a god, any god, commands Joshua to murder everyone in Jericho and demands that Saul slaughter every remaining Amalekite, I consider such acts as evil\ and outrageous genocide, totally at odds with the Sermon on the Mount. Those who see it differently, fine. Frankly, I believe in a 'big tent' when it comes to Christianity. 'Think and let think.' That's why I have developed serious reservations about traditional Catholicism. Most Catholics I know aren't all that traditional. In this area, where Catholics are the largest faith community, the legislature has legalized gay marriage, which suggests how little influence the church now has here. 

As for God not making mistakes - well, if he actually gave such orders he certainly made mistakes. But, I believe the authors of those Old Testament books made mistakes and not God. They wanted to boost Hebrew nationalism and justify crimes againt humanity, so they piled them on God. What a sinful thing to do! 

But, as I recall, God even admitted making a mistake if we are to believe scripture entirely. My Bible says that God 'repented' that he had made mankind (Gen. 6:6) so decided to drown everybody but Noah and his family, even all the children and babies in the womb. Now, how can we take a principled stand against abortion but excuse God for drowning everyone is something that puzzles me. I have to conclude that that story is a legend, exaggerated as it was passed from generation to generation. Yes, there must have been a massive flood in that part of the world. There is an ancient Babylonian legend that is similar (Gilgamesh, I believe was the 'Noah' in that version), and I suspect that both legends have a kernel of truth that grew into myth proportions.

 Enough for now. I have to get to pressing chores, even though I do enjoy this sort of dialogue. God bless everybody - yes, even those who appear ready (in my view) to let our God of peace, mercy and love be misrepresented, distorted, and slandered.
Dear Roy, These fanatical views you are being given are NOT the teaching of the Holy Roman Church. The Church is not, and never has been, fundamentalist. Our Holy Father’s approach is much more balanced and sane. You certainly do not have to believe that God commanded genocide in order to be a Catholic.
 
… vile, murderous, perverted, sick act…
Your words, not mine. I take God for how He has chosen to reveal Himself to mankind - not according to my intuition or taste.
Thank God they are not the views of our Holy Father, as can easily be seen by reading his two new books.
Which “two new books”? The New Testament and the Catechism? Critics often point out the supposed “immorality” of the NT - like how Paul didn’t condemn the general practice of slavery in Philemon. You’re still on shaky ground; still undermining God’s word. And I don’t believe for a second that this has anything to do with God, as opposed to modernism.
 
Your words, not mine. I take God for how He has chosen to reveal Himself to mankind - not according to my intuition or taste.

Which “two new books”? The New Testament and the Catechism? Critics often point out the supposed “immorality” of the NT - like how Paul didn’t condemn the general practice of slavery in Philemon. You’re still on shaky ground; still undermining God’s word. And I don’t believe for a second that this has anything to do with God, as opposed to modernism.
Try answering the question. Is there any act which is so evil that God wouldn’t do it, or is anything permissable as long as it fits into your theory?

The two books I refer to by the Holy Father are Jesus of Nazareth I and II. In these and his other writings he shows he is no fundamentalist.

Do you really believe that God has chosen to reveal himself to mankind as a baby-torturer and murderer and as an accessory to rape??!!
 
secondeve
Code:
I'm encouraged when you say that Catholics don't have to believe passages in the old Testament that attribute wholesale genocide to God, because I will never accept that. Bible fundamentalists, Catholics and Protestants both, appear unwilling to face up to the fact that many acts ascribed to God in the Old Testament totally conflict with - for example - the Ten Commandments, the Sermon on the Mount, and I Corinthians 13. 

 God is love is how I learned it. And I will not abandon that belief. Love does not demand the wholesale murder of whole tribes whose land another tribe is seizing. This is the work of a Hitler or a Stalin and not of our God. These horror stories are not of God but of religious fanatics who used God as a scapegoat for their crimes.
 
Is there any vile, murderous, perverted, sick act that you wouldn’t try to justify on “God’s” behalf as long as it fitted in with your fundamentalist dogma? I find your extreme, fanatical views most disturbing. Thank God they are not the views of our Holy Father, as can easily be seen by reading his two new books.
Actually, it is vile, etc to reject the Word of God. As I stated previously, these events are recorded in the Canon of Scripture for a reason. Even if one doesn’t presently understand the writing, Catholics MUST still accept it as the Word of God.
secondeve
Code:
I'm encouraged when you say that Catholics don't have to believe passages in the old Testament that attribute wholesale genocide to God, because I will never accept that. Bible fundamentalists, Catholics and Protestants both, appear unwilling to face up to the fact that many acts ascribed to God in the Old Testament totally conflict with - for example - the Ten Commandments, the Sermon on the Mount, and I Corinthians 13. 

 God is love is how I learned it. And I will not abandon that belief. Love does not demand the wholesale murder of whole tribes whose land another tribe is seizing. This is the work of a Hitler or a Stalin and not of our God. These horror stories are not of God but of religious fanatics who used God as a scapegoat for their crimes.
Catholics must accept all Scripture as true. That truth may be historical, allegorical, metaphysical, etc but the nature of truth doesn’t change.

Do NOT mistake me for a fundamentalist. Fundamentalists favor a literal reading of Scripture. I do not.

I accept the Elisha and the bears story as an allegory of the spiritual destruction that befalls those who heap ridicule on God (there seems no shortage of those these days with the current political climate). Historically, they may have just been too close to the bear’s cubs (like the recent Yellowstone incident).
 
One book that influenced me years ago is entitled “Hebrew Origins” by Theophile Meek. Among many other things, it argued that the whole Exodus story is fiction, that there isn’t an iota of evidence that the Jews were ever slaves in Egypt, that Moses and Joshua did not follow one another but were heroes of different tribes, that their stories were combined to promote unity of these tribes, etc. Fascinating stuff.

Sadly, most people don’t look into the origins of the Old Testament sufficiently to grasp all the complications. To begin with, obviously Moses did not write the first five books of the Bible. One evidence of that is that his death and burial are reported in Deuteronomy. Besides, those who know Hebrew and the ancient manuscripts are well aware that there are different styles of writing involved - apparently from documents sometimes listed as J, E, P, and D.
Most people will continue to believe the unbelievable. So be it. But I resent the way in which God is blamed for so many outrageous atrocities.
 
Roy5, you are strawmanning us. No Catholic in here has actually staked a particular interpretation of any so-called controversial passage, and many of us, I’m sure, would criticize your interpretation of them as ham-handed, Protestant - needless to say, unCatholic. So you are attacking positions that none of us have actually really put forth - for all you know, you could agree with us.

Most of us are trying to get at the fundamentals - at something far more important. Your “Christianity” is a mess. Plain and simple. You have as your guiding rule of faith your individual and limited sensibility. Not once have you actually shown a concern for what the Bible actually is trying to say - no, what mattes is that you think your sensibility is being offended, you’ve made up your mind about that, and so you make the Bible out into a deceptive text that lies to us. These are fundamental structural problems in your “Christianity” that is just unacceptable. We are pointing this out for the benefit of the OP. That is all.
 
Actually, it is vile, etc to reject the Word of God. As I stated previously, these events are recorded in the Canon of Scripture for a reason. Even if one doesn’t presently understand the writing, Catholics MUST still accept it as the Word of God.

Catholics must accept all Scripture as true. That truth may be historical, allegorical, metaphysical, etc but the nature of truth doesn’t change.

Do NOT mistake me for a fundamentalist. Fundamentalists favor a literal reading of Scripture. I do not.

I accept the Elisha and the bears story as an allegory of the spiritual destruction that befalls those who heap ridicule on God (there seems no shortage of those these days with the current political climate). Historically, they may have just been too close to the bear’s cubs (like the recent Yellowstone incident).
I think you are misunderstanding the debate so far. There is no question (in my mind at least) that the Bible is the Word of God and must be accepted as true. The question is “true in what sense”. What I have been arguing strongly against is fundamentalism, the idea that every word is literally true. We must not believe that God is the cruel vengeful child-murdering despot as portrayed in some of the Old Testament books. It is perfectly in line with Church teaching to give these passages a mystical or allegorical interpretation, just as today we would not wish to accept the simple story of Noah’s Ark, but would prefer to see in it a prophetic tale concerning the Ark of Salvation ie the Church. The origins of this simple tale is for the experts to unravel (if they can).

As you seem to accept this I don’t know why you are arguing with me?
 
I think you are misunderstanding the debate so far. There is no question (in my mind at least) that the Bible is the Word of God and must be accepted as true. The question is “true in what sense”. What I have been arguing strongly against is fundamentalism, the idea that every word is literally true. We must not believe that God is the cruel vengeful child-murdering despot as portrayed in some of the Old Testament books. It is perfectly in line with Church teaching to give these passages a mystical or allegorical interpretation, just as today we would not wish to accept the simple story of Noah’s Ark, but would prefer to see in it a prophetic tale concerning the Ark of Salvation ie the Church. The origins of this simple tale is for the experts to unravel (if they can).

As you seem to accept this I don’t know why you are arguing with me?
No, you misunderstand Church teaching. We are not given free reign to allegorize or whatever. We must work within certain parameters like genre and the intent of the author. Is the intent of the author allegory in those “controversial” passages? No. It is history. To contradict that is to contradict the word of God. But see, there is more to it than that, and you and Roy5 are demonstrating a biblical illiteracy if you think “God is the cruel vengeful child-murdering despot as portrayed in some of the Old Testament books.” That is NOT what the books are saying, that is YOUR interpretation of what the books are saying. The Bible was never read or understood in isolation from its oral tradition and other authoritative traditions of interpretation. As long as you miss that, you won’t understand these passages.
 
One book that influenced me years ago is entitled “Hebrew Origins” by Theophile Meek. Among many other things, it argued that the whole Exodus story is fiction, that there isn’t an iota of evidence that the Jews were ever slaves in Egypt, that Moses and Joshua did not follow one another but were heroes of different tribes, that their stories were combined to promote unity of these tribes, etc. Fascinating stuff.

Sadly, most people don’t look into the origins of the Old Testament sufficiently to grasp all the complications. To begin with, obviously Moses did not write the first five books of the Bible. One evidence of that is that his death and burial are reported in Deuteronomy. Besides, those who know Hebrew and the ancient manuscripts are well aware that there are different styles of writing involved - apparently from documents sometimes listed as J, E, P, and D.
Curious. “Theophile Meek” seems to be an obvious pseudonym at first glance but he does have a real biography at the University of Toronto. Then again, look at some of the names people give their children today.

Anyway, his book is over 60 years old and there has been about as much Biblical scholarship since then as there has been in the millennia before. I notice that his theory about the origins of the Hebrews has not not had any meaningful influence on modern scholarship (outside the ramblings of a few militant atheists).
Code:
Most people will continue to believe the unbelievable. So be it. But I resent the way in which God is blamed for so many outrageous atrocities.
I think that placing “blame” on God is really inappropriate. The people who are so destroyed are clearly portrayed as having brought calamity upon themselves, their children, etc. Following through on your line of reasoning, we would have to imprison every police officer who kills a suspect to prevent further violence.
 
Ganging up on someone and calling them names is very sinful. I think those kids got exactly what they deserved!😉
 
I think you are misunderstanding the debate so far. There is no question (in my mind at least) that the Bible is the Word of God and must be accepted as true. The question is “true in what sense”. What I have been arguing strongly against is fundamentalism, the idea that every word is literally true. We must not believe that God is the cruel vengeful child-murdering despot as portrayed in some of the Old Testament books. It is perfectly in line with Church teaching to give these passages a mystical or allegorical interpretation, just as today we would not wish to accept the simple story of Noah’s Ark, but would prefer to see in it a prophetic tale concerning the Ark of Salvation ie the Church. The origins of this simple tale is for the experts to unravel (if they can).

As you seem to accept this I don’t know why you are arguing with me?
Because the alternative forwarded by you and Roy5 is rejection of Scripture. Catholics cannot do this. We can choose how to accept it (even to the point of accepting that there must be some purpose for the passage to be recorded though one can’t see any reason for it right now). We cannot, however, say the passage is not of God, no matter how repugnant it appears to our human minds.

I certainly understand the debate. I am warning against the consequences of rejecting Scripture. It’s dangerously close to rejecting the Author.
 
No, you misunderstand Church teaching. We are not given free reign to allegorize or whatever. We must work within certain parameters like genre and the intent of the author. Is the intent of the author allegory in those “controversial” passages? No. It is history. To contradict that is to contradict the word of God. But see, there is more to it than that, and you and Roy5 are demonstrating a biblical illiteracy if you think “God is the cruel vengeful child-murdering despot as portrayed in some of the Old Testament books.” That is NOT what the books are saying, that is YOUR interpretation of what the books are saying. The Bible was never read or understood in isolation from its oral tradition and other authoritative traditions of interpretation. As long as you miss that, you won’t understand these passages.
It is you who misunderstand. You are confused about the meaning of the word “history”. History in the modern sense did not exist in those days.

To see God as cruel is NOT my interpretation. The books clearly are saying that God ordered the Israelites to rape women, slaughter babies etc. I am sure I don’t need to quote chapter and verse to you; you know the passages I am talking about. God is breaking his own laws.

Since you are claiming to understand what I do not, please answer this question:

Do you believe that God commanded the Israelites to rape women, torture and murder babies, and to make war on the various tribes and steal their land?
 
Because the alternative forwarded by you and Roy5 is rejection of Scripture. Catholics cannot do this. We can choose how to accept it (even to the point of accepting that there must be some purpose for the passage to be recorded though one can’t see any reason for it right now). We cannot, however, say the passage is not of God, no matter how repugnant it appears to our human minds.

I certainly understand the debate. I am warning against the consequences of rejecting Scripture. It’s dangerously close to rejecting the Author.
You seem to be determined to argue even when there is nothing to argue about. I am NOT rejecting Scripture. I am merely stating that I cannot accept in a literal way passages that portray God as a child murderer. I thought you agreed with me on this. I am also taking the advice of some of the Church Fathers and giving an alllegorical interpretation to these passages. I accept ALL Scripture, but it must be read according to the particular passage’s literary genre, and not as a modern history book.
 
To see God as cruel is NOT my interpretation. The books clearly are saying that God ordered the Israelites to rape women, slaughter babies etc. I am sure I don’t need to quote chapter and verse to you; you know the passages I am talking about. God is breaking his own laws.
Yes, it IS your interpretation. That is typical deprecatory language that was in common use in the ancient near east. It is hyperbole. See, you have an IGNORANCE of Scripture, yet you go around scandalizing Catholics with views that are not of the Church. The Catholic thing to do is to proceed very cautiously and slowly, always with the mind that your interpretation may be wrong because you are not an authority on Scripture. That is the Protestant approach - the approach of individuals like Roy5.

You are also not an authority on theology. “God his breaking his own laws.” Give me a break, you have no idea what you are talking about.

Do you know Hebrew? Probably not. Do you know the Catholic scholarship on the issue? Probably not. Have you read the Church’s authoritative documents that are the basis for proper Scriptural interpretation? Probably not. Do you know all of the theological dogmas that interpret the picture of God in the Bible for us? Probably not. Do you know how the ancient Jews and the ancient Christians interpreted those passages? Probably not. All these things and more you probably do not have a very good grasp on, so it is frustrating to see people like you and Roy5 totally miss the boat.
Do you believe that God commanded the Israelites to rape women, torture and murder babies, and to make war on the various tribes and steal their land?
See above.
 
Yes, it IS your interpretation. That is typical deprecatory language that was in common use in the ancient near east. It is hyperbole. See, you have an IGNORANCE of Scripture, yet you go around scandalizing Catholics with views that are not of the Church. The Catholic thing to do is to proceed very cautiously and slowly, always with the mind that your interpretation may be wrong because you are not an authority on Scripture. That is the Protestant approach - the approach of individuals like Roy5.

You are also not an authority on theology. “God his breaking his own laws.” Give me a break, you have no idea what you are talking about.

Do you know Hebrew? Probably not. Do you know the Catholic scholarship on the issue? Probably not. Have you read the Church’s authoritative documents that are the basis for proper Scriptural interpretation? Probably not. Do you know all of the theological dogmas that interpret the picture of God in the Bible for us? Probably not. Do you know how the ancient Jews and the ancient Christians interpreted those passages? Probably not. All these things and more you probably do not have a very good grasp on, so it is frustrating to see people like you and Roy5 totally miss the boat.

See above.
Perhaps if, instead of pontificating and trying to impress us all with your knowledge of Hebrew, you were to answer my simple question AND give us all your interpretation of the passages which state that God commanded the Israelites to murder babies, it would be more useful.
 
It is you who misunderstand. You are confused about the meaning of the word “history”. History in the modern sense did not exist in those days.

To see God as cruel is NOT my interpretation. The books clearly are saying that God ordered the Israelites to rape women, slaughter babies etc. I am sure I don’t need to quote chapter and verse to you; you know the passages I am talking about.
That’s being presumptive. Not everyone can reasonably recognize the exact passages that draw your ire.
God is breaking his own laws.
Not possible by definition. God is not beholden to laws in any sense. Not those we impose on ourselves. Not even those He has given to us. Nobody has jurisdiction to impose laws upon Him and He has no need to pronounce any upon Himself.
You seem to be determined to argue even when there is nothing to argue about. I am NOT rejecting Scripture.
Your arguments so far indicate otherwise to me.
 
Perhaps if, instead of pontificating and trying to impress us all with your knowledge of Hebrew, you were to answer my simple question AND give us all your interpretation of the passages which state that God commanded the Israelites to murder babies, it would be more useful.
That’s the thing, I am not qualified to do that. Neither are you. The difference is that 1) I know enough to know that what you are peddling is simply a poor reading of Scripture 2) I know enough to know that I should be very hesitant before I put forth an interpretation and proclaim it to other Christians as true.
 
Perhaps if, instead of pontificating and trying to impress us all with your knowledge of Hebrew, you were to answer my simple question AND give us all your interpretation of the passages which state that God commanded the Israelites to murder babies, it would be more useful.
To murder is sinful. Only God has the power to bestow life and death.

But. . .if it is God who is calling for someone to die, is it murder then, since God alone has the power to determine life or death? It seems that’s the real question.

Either God can bestow life or death. . .and if He chooses to bestow death on anyone, from babe to oldster, man or woman, that cannot be ‘murder’. . .

Or He can’t.

And that means that you’re holding God to human standards and saying, No one can murder, not even God, and if God asks for somebody’s death, it’s murder.

But you’ll say, “But God asked MEN to do it. That means the men murdered babies because only God has the power of life and death.” So what should God have done, just ‘zapped’ the babies? Leaving people to wonder what happened and (of course) to claim that Israel didn’t have anything to do with it, so they needn’t submit to Israel?

Should God not have done anything at all, just assured the Israelites, “Hey, I’m gonna zap all these people, because I can since I gave them life, you just ‘pretend’ to kill them but I’ll really be doing it --that way, everybody will be scared of you.”

I tend to be a little leery of people who try to make God into something completely, totally, understandable --and of course, completely, totally, ‘in sync’ with whatever those people think is morality. These are the people who say that GOD never did anything like what the Old Testament claims, because God can’t go beyond their image of morality.

Strangely enough you’ll often (not always but often) find these same people who bristle at the idea that GOD could ‘kill babies’ usually have no problem with abortion itself at some stage, or with the idea of gay marriage, or divorce, or contraception. Nope, no problems there. . .they have no worries whatsoever about going against God’s words there. . .but GOD can’t POSSIBLY have killed babies because they just can’t believe in ‘that kind of god’.

Because they can only believe in a god made in THEIR image who does what they think is right and ‘completely understandable’. . .

And that can’t be the real God who by definition we can’t possibly understand completely.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top