S
secondeve
Guest
Dear Roy, These fanatical views you are being given are NOT the teaching of the Holy Roman Church. The Church is not, and never has been, fundamentalist. Our Holy Father’s approach is much more balanced and sane. You certainly do not have to believe that God commanded genocide in order to be a Catholic.A couple quick thoughts.
Code:If you don't regard some Old Testament stories as presenting a false picture of God, then we obviously see things differently. When a god, any god, commands Joshua to murder everyone in Jericho and demands that Saul slaughter every remaining Amalekite, I consider such acts as evil\ and outrageous genocide, totally at odds with the Sermon on the Mount. Those who see it differently, fine. Frankly, I believe in a 'big tent' when it comes to Christianity. 'Think and let think.' That's why I have developed serious reservations about traditional Catholicism. Most Catholics I know aren't all that traditional. In this area, where Catholics are the largest faith community, the legislature has legalized gay marriage, which suggests how little influence the church now has here. As for God not making mistakes - well, if he actually gave such orders he certainly made mistakes. But, I believe the authors of those Old Testament books made mistakes and not God. They wanted to boost Hebrew nationalism and justify crimes againt humanity, so they piled them on God. What a sinful thing to do! But, as I recall, God even admitted making a mistake if we are to believe scripture entirely. My Bible says that God 'repented' that he had made mankind (Gen. 6:6) so decided to drown everybody but Noah and his family, even all the children and babies in the womb. Now, how can we take a principled stand against abortion but excuse God for drowning everyone is something that puzzles me. I have to conclude that that story is a legend, exaggerated as it was passed from generation to generation. Yes, there must have been a massive flood in that part of the world. There is an ancient Babylonian legend that is similar (Gilgamesh, I believe was the 'Noah' in that version), and I suspect that both legends have a kernel of truth that grew into myth proportions. Enough for now. I have to get to pressing chores, even though I do enjoy this sort of dialogue. God bless everybody - yes, even those who appear ready (in my view) to let our God of peace, mercy and love be misrepresented, distorted, and slandered.