Elisha and the Bears

  • Thread starter Thread starter Questioner28
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Christians are followers of the laws of the new Testament not exodus.
You cannot understand the New Testament without that of the Old, and you can’t understand the Old Testament without that of the New.

It’s a grave error to ignore the Old Testament as it is the word of God.
 
Doesn’t anyone actually study the Bible, or at least open it up and read the words it says?

Elisha had just been comissioned by Elijiah. With his new authority as a prophet, he had probably just shaved his head as part of a nazarite vow.

Elisha was going up to Bethel which is where king Joroboam who ruled the ten northern tribes of Israel had put a golden calf for the people to worship saying Here is your God, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt (1 Kings 12:29) Bethel was a place of pagan worship of the worst kind, where children like the boys who mocked Elisha were sacrificed by their own parents, burned alive as sacrifice to the god Molech. The parents of these kids cared so little for them that they were able to sacrifice them to a pagan god. Elisha wasn’t just sensitive to criticism… the boys were probably going to die anyway.

Elisha, as a nazarite consecrated to God and as a prophet given authority by Elijiah, was heading straight into the worst pagan city to preach the word of God.

-Tim-
It was a joke. Elisha would have certainly appreciated the humor of his mentor Elijah, which was demonstrated when he mocked the followers of Baal who had failed to get their deity to light their altar as they had said he would. He asked “maybe your God is a sleep?” Which he later followed with "Talk louder. Maybe he went for a walk. Maybe he is busy. Don’t give up. Louder. Try it again.”

Thus, I think Elijah might have appreciated my comment 🙂
 
So you still don’t have the guts or the honesty to answer my question. I don’t know how you can embarrass yourself in this way…
… The irony being that it is you who hasn’t the guts or honesty to admit that you wholly oppose large chunks of Scripture. You just keep dancing around that fact with transparent excuses like “finding the ‘correct’ interpretation”. What nonsense. Satan does the same thing, you know (Matthew 4) - it’s useless. Believe whatever heretical twaddle you like, though; there’s obviously no getting anywhere with this. You’ll be in my prayers - even if you do consider our Lord “Hitler-like”.
 
… The irony being that it is you who hasn’t the guts or honesty to admit that you wholly oppose large chunks of Scripture. You just keep dancing around that fact with transparent excuses like “finding the ‘correct’ interpretation”. What nonsense. Satan does the same thing, you know (Matthew 4) - it’s useless. Believe whatever heretical twaddle you like, though; there’s obviously no getting anywhere with this. You’ll be in my prayers - even if you do consider our Lord “Hitler-like”.
I think it is truly disgraceful that you keep on pontificating whilst refusing to answer a simple question. Plainly you don’t have the courage of your convictions. I ask you once again,

" Do you believe that God commanded the Israelites to commit genocide, murder and torture babies and rape women? If God commanded you to rape a woman and murder her baby would you do it?"

They are simple enough questions; why are you afraid to answer them?
 
" Do you believe that God commanded the Israelites to commit genocide?
Yes. Although refer back to the article I linked.
If God commanded you to rape a woman and murder her baby would you do it?"
As I have access to the fulfillment of the laws through Christ I do not believe that God would ever command this today. Now if I didn’t have access to the teachings of Christ and was transported back in time to Jericho…I have no idea. I wouldn’t be the same person I am.

Although God never commanded rape. Indeed, sexual relations between the Hebrews and gentiles was very frowned upon.
 
Yes. Although refer back to the article I linked.

As I have access to the fulfillment of the laws through Christ I do not believe that God would ever command this today. Now if I didn’t have access to the teachings of Christ and was transported back in time to Jericho…I have no idea. I wouldn’t be the same person I am.

Although God never commanded rape. Indeed, sexual relations between the Hebrews and gentiles was very frowned upon.
I did not address these questions to you, but since you have decided to respond. I will too.

Firstly, I am astonished and appalled to read that you believe God commited genocide. I have not had time to locate your reference, so perhaps this qualifies your admission. If not, then I can only say that you believe in a vile evil deity which I could not possibly worship. I worship the God of Love.

Secondly, for you even to consider the possibility that (even in some former age ) you could have raped a mother and murdered her baby on the orders of “God” shows again that the God you believe in is capable of great evil, and is not the God I worship.

Thirdly, you are wrong about rape. Forced marriages were not unknown in Israel (I shall look up the reference later, if I may) which implied rape, and consider this passage from Isaiah (forgive me for it’s length):

Raise a banner on a bare hilltop,
shout to them;
beckon to them
to enter the gates of the nobles.
3 I have commanded those I prepared for battle;
I have summoned my warriors to carry out my wrath—
those who rejoice in my triumph.

4 Listen, a noise on the mountains,
like that of a great multitude!
Listen, an uproar among the kingdoms,
like nations massing together!
The LORD Almighty is mustering
an army for war.
5 They come from faraway lands,
from the ends of the heavens—
the LORD and the weapons of his wrath—
to destroy the whole country.

6 Wail, for the day of the LORD is near;
it will come like destruction from the Almighty.[a]
7 Because of this, all hands will go limp,
every heart will melt with fear.
8 Terror will seize them,
pain and anguish will grip them;
they will writhe like a woman in labor.
They will look aghast at each other,
their faces aflame.

9 See, the day of the LORD is coming
—a cruel day, with wrath and fierce anger—
to make the land desolate
and destroy the sinners within it.
10 The stars of heaven and their constellations
will not show their light.
The rising sun will be darkened
and the moon will not give its light.
11 I will punish the world for its evil,
the wicked for their sins.
I will put an end to the arrogance of the haughty
and will humble the pride of the ruthless.
12 I will make people scarcer than pure gold,
more rare than the gold of Ophir.
13 Therefore I will make the heavens tremble;
and the earth will shake from its place
at the wrath of the LORD Almighty,
in the day of his burning anger.

14 Like a hunted gazelle,
like sheep without a shepherd,
they will all return to their own people,
they will flee to their native land.
15 Whoever is captured will be thrust through;
all who are caught will fall by the sword.
16 Their infants will be dashed to pieces before their eyes;
their houses will be looted and their wives violated.

17 See, I will stir up against them the Medes,
who do not care for silver
and have no delight in gold.
18 Their bows will strike down the young men;
they will have no mercy on infants,
nor will they look with compassion on children.
19 Babylon, the jewel of kingdoms,
the pride and glory of the Babylonians,**
will be overthrown by God
like Sodom and Gomorrah.**
 
This passage is depicted as being a simple matter of God’s vengeance and cruelty. Unfortunately, this is a somewhat naïve and erroneous portrayal of this extract. There are a number of background elements and context that contribute to the full understanding of this occurrence. The writer uses contextual historic literary methods to describe a spiritual truth that is not within the faculty of many modern readers to grasp. Nonetheless, I think it is possible to provide a limited tropological and anagogical understanding of the event.

First off, the term term “children” is not used simply to denote chronological age. Most of the “casualties” of the attack would be young men. This designation is to signify their state of their faith and morals. They are able to distinguish between good and evil but refuse to appropriately act on the revealed truth provided by Elijah as God’s vassal. This immoral state is shown by the manifestation of their taunts and by expressing that he “go up”, which is to shown they care not for the moral ascent the Elijah calls on the people to do, to reject their idolatry practices and impiety. They do not follow but instead they actively reject. The jeering of baldness is intended to connote a scornfulness of a “hoary” head or a respect for elders, in this case moral elders (and by extension God).

By failing to render the deference to God’s instrument, they mock of the miraculous works of God and fail to abide by the moral standards set by Elijah (and by God). They do not rescind their deeds or recoil as Elijah turns towards and looks upon them, representing God’s scrutiny of their behaviour. Consequently, they invite God’s judgment. This is represented by Elijah pronouncement of the curse. He does not act in haste or anger. It is a deliberate and thoughtful act, done out of neither malice nor haste but done out of the need to discipline those that show irresolute improbity. It is emblematically exhibited by the appearance of she-bears. The use of this literary device is an obvious allusion to the warning expounded in Leviticus:

“‘If you remain hostile toward me and refuse to listen to me, I will multiply your afflictions seven times over, as your sins deserve. I will send wild animals against you, and they will rob you of your children, destroy your cattle and make you so few in number that your roads will be deserted.
  • Leviticus 26:21-22
To expound further, such animals normally not prone to attack but if sufficiently provoked to protect their young, they become especially vicious. The intent is to show that God will decisively act after judgment against those that actively and knowingly threaten His ‘young’; those that serve Him and act in accordance to His morality. The “deaths” are of course representative of the eternal censure after judgment.

When looked upon with thought and a more detailed understanding of historical context, the passage resolves its intention to show a moral lesson regarding the consequences of evil and turpitude and is not about Elijah or God being capricious or callous. There are, other historical context considerations that can be examined in more detail within the text. This requires, however, a more detailed understanding of culture, ancient literary techniques and context. Regardless, taking text literally is not key to understanding them.
 
I did not address these questions to you, but since you have decided to respond. I will too.

Firstly, I am astonished and appalled to read that you believe God commited genocide. I have not had time to locate your reference, so perhaps this qualifies your admission. If not, then I can only say that you believe in a vile evil deity which I could not possibly worship. I worship the God of Love.
Approaching God and the Bible can be a very challenging thing to do. The gap between our knowledge and God’s knowledge is wider than the intellectual gap between me and my dog. When you come across a part of scripture that you find difficult you can’t immediately try to get out of the difficult consequences of these passages by trying to find a way out.

A philosopher once commented that if horses could draw pictures of God they would draw a pictures of horses. We must resist the temptation to think we know and understand everything as well as God does.

Msgr. Charles Pope in the article I linked (blog.adw.org/2010/01/did-god-command-genocide/) did a very good job of showing different approaches to how to interpret the Ban and then explained the benefits and weaknesses of each. You should read the article along with the many comments at the bottom of the page.

As Saint John said “God is love” but we don’t have complete access to how and why he applies his love. God could send us all to Heaven right now if he wanted to, but he doesn’t. God could end all misery and evil in the world…this very second. But, he doesn’t. This does not mean that God is not love, but that at some level God is beyond our comprehension.
 
Approaching God and the Bible can be a very challenging thing to do. The gap between our knowledge and God’s knowledge is wider than the intellectual gap between me and my dog. When you come across a part of scripture that you find difficult you can’t immediately try to get out of the difficult consequences of these passages by trying to find a way out.

A philosopher once commented that if horses could draw pictures of God they would draw a pictures of horses. We must resist the temptation to think we know and understand everything as well as God does.

Msgr. Charles Pope in the article I linked (blog.adw.org/2010/01/did-god-command-genocide/) did a very good job of showing different approaches to how to interpret the Ban and then explained the benefits and weaknesses of each. You should read the article along with the many comments at the bottom of the page.

As Saint John said “God is love” but we don’t have complete access to how and why he applies his love. God could send us all to Heaven right now if he wanted to, but he doesn’t. God could end all misery and evil in the world…this very second. But, he doesn’t. This does not mean that God is not love, but that at some level God is beyond our comprehension.
This is, with respect, a poor attempt at mystification to justify a literal reading of the text.

Fact: Parts of Scripture, if taken literally, portray a cruel, evil God who commits genocide and encourages rape and murder.
Fact: We know God is Love and could not do this.
Therefore we must try to give these texts an allegorical or mystical meaning.

To insist always on a literal interpretation puts us in the company of those who try to justify dodgy politics, and also with those who seriously sit down and try to work out how Noah could keep a vast number of species in the Ark. Such people make of the Christian religion a laughing stock.
 
This passage is depicted as being a simple matter of God’s vengeance and cruelty. Unfortunately, this is a somewhat naïve and erroneous portrayal of this extract. There are a number of background elements and context that contribute to the full understanding of this occurrence. The writer uses contextual historic literary methods to describe a spiritual truth that is not within the faculty of many modern readers to grasp. Nonetheless, I think it is possible to provide a limited tropological and anagogical understanding of the event.

First off, the term term “children” is not used simply to denote chronological age. Most of the “casualties” of the attack would be young men. This designation is to signify their state of their faith and morals. They are able to distinguish between good and evil but refuse to appropriately act on the revealed truth provided by Elijah as God’s vassal. This immoral state is shown by the manifestation of their taunts and by expressing that he “go up”, which is to shown they care not for the moral ascent the Elijah calls on the people to do, to reject their idolatry practices and impiety. They do not follow but instead they actively reject. The jeering of baldness is intended to connote a scornfulness of a “hoary” head or a respect for elders, in this case moral elders (and by extension God).

By failing to render the deference to God’s instrument, they mock of the miraculous works of God and fail to abide by the moral standards set by Elijah (and by God). They do not rescind their deeds or recoil as Elijah turns towards and looks upon them, representing God’s scrutiny of their behaviour. Consequently, they invite God’s judgment. This is represented by Elijah pronouncement of the curse. He does not act in haste or anger. It is a deliberate and thoughtful act, done out of neither malice nor haste but done out of the need to discipline those that show irresolute improbity. It is emblematically exhibited by the appearance of she-bears. The use of this literary device is an obvious allusion to the warning expounded in Leviticus:

“‘If you remain hostile toward me and refuse to listen to me, I will multiply your afflictions seven times over, as your sins deserve. I will send wild animals against you, and they will rob you of your children, destroy your cattle and make you so few in number that your roads will be deserted.
  • Leviticus 26:21-22
To expound further, such animals normally not prone to attack but if sufficiently provoked to protect their young, they become especially vicious. The intent is to show that God will decisively act after judgment against those that actively and knowingly threaten His ‘young’; those that serve Him and act in accordance to His morality. The “deaths” are of course representative of the eternal censure after judgment.

When looked upon with thought and a more detailed understanding of historical context, the passage resolves its intention to show a moral lesson regarding the consequences of evil and turpitude and is not about Elijah or God being capricious or callous. There are, other historical context considerations that can be examined in more detail within the text. This requires, however, a more detailed understanding of culture, ancient literary techniques and context. Regardless, taking text literally is not key to understanding them.
Just what I have been trying to point out on here. The key to understanding such passages is to read them in the context in which they were written. They are essentially stories rather than “blow by blow” historical accounts of what actually happened. When read in this way they cease to be a problem, and God ceases to be seen as cruel and evil.
 
I did not address these questions to you, but since you have decided to respond. I will too.
your rudeness is getting unbearable
consider this passage from Isaiah (forgive me for it’s length):
Very well. First, I note that it is prophetic. Second, I note that it is poetic.
Raise a banner on a bare hilltop,
shout to them;
beckon to them
to enter the gates of the nobles.
3 I have commanded those I prepared for battle;
I have summoned my warriors to carry out my wrath—
those who rejoice in my triumph.
4 Listen, a noise on the mountains,
like that of a great multitude!
Listen, an uproar among the kingdoms,
like nations massing together!
The LORD Almighty is mustering
an army for war.
5 They come from faraway lands,
from the ends of the heavens—
the LORD and the weapons of his wrath—
to destroy the whole country.
God calls together His people. Nice.
6 Wail, for the day of the LORD is near;
it will come like destruction from the Almighty.[a]
7 Because of this, all hands will go limp,
every heart will melt with fear.
8 Terror will seize them,
pain and anguish will grip them;
they will writhe like a woman in labor.
They will look aghast at each other,
their faces aflame.
9 See, the day of the LORD is coming
—a cruel day, with wrath and fierce anger—
to make the land desolate
and destroy the sinners within it.
10 The stars of heaven and their constellations
will not show their light.
The rising sun will be darkened
and the moon will not give its light.
11 I will punish the world for its evil,
the wicked for their sins.
I will put an end to the arrogance of the haughty
and will humble the pride of the ruthless.
12 I will make people scarcer than pure gold,
more rare than the gold of Ophir.
13 Therefore I will make the heavens tremble;
and the earth will shake from its place
at the wrath of the LORD Almighty,
in the day of his burning anger.
The Day of the Lord is standard code for the coming of the Messiah. It can refer to either the time Jesus walked among us or it can mean His return at the end of the World when He will judge all.

How do you think an obstinate sinner would feel on that day?
14 Like a hunted gazelle,
like sheep without a shepherd,
they will all return to their own people,
they will flee to their native land.
15 Whoever is captured will be thrust through;
all who are caught will fall by the sword.
16 Their infants will be dashed to pieces before their eyes;
their houses will be looted and their wives violated.
Sounds hellish, doesn’t it? Maybe because it’s a description of Hell?
17 See, I will stir up against them the Medes,
who do not care for silver
and have no delight in gold.
18 Their bows will strike down the young men;
they will have no mercy on infants,
nor will they look with compassion on children.
Poetry lesson: In English we rhyme the sounds of words, right?

In Hebrew, guess what they rhyme. (look at my next post for the answer)
19 Babylon, the jewel of kingdoms,
the pride and glory of the Babylonians,**
will be overthrown by God
like Sodom and Gomorrah.**
 
Just what I have been trying to point out on here. The key to understanding such passages is to read them in the context in which they were written. They are essentially stories rather than “blow by blow” historical accounts of what actually happened. When read in this way they cease to be a problem, and God ceases to be seen as cruel and evil.
Maybe you misunderstand him. SoldierofGod is not saying these events did not happen, like you seem to be doing. He is merely providing the additional background information - the kind that I have been saying is necessary to biblical interpretation. Notice how he weaved in Catholic teaching, a Catholic reading of Scripture, genre, language, etc. etc. etc. He brought all of those out to bear on the passage, but you allegorized it away.
 
It was a joke. Elisha would have certainly appreciated the humor of his mentor Elijah, which was demonstrated when he mocked the followers of Baal who had failed to get their deity to light their altar as they had said he would. He asked “maybe your God is a sleep?” Which he later followed with "Talk louder. Maybe he went for a walk. Maybe he is busy. Don’t give up. Louder. Try it again.”

Thus, I think Elijah might have appreciated my comment 🙂
Yea, I got that when I came back to my PC after a while. Sorry about that. Blame it on my zeal for the Lord and please forgive me.

That part where he says “Talk louder” had my bible study in stitches.

-Tim-
 
Just what I have been trying to point out on here. The key to understanding such passages is to read them in the context in which they were written. They are essentially stories rather than “blow by blow” historical accounts of what actually happened. When read in this way they cease to be a problem, and God ceases to be seen as cruel and evil.
Yes, they are stories or apologues but they are also simultaneously historical accounts and are not necessarily to be solely construed as myth or metaphors. Additionally, many accounts we may find, from our perspective, “offensive” serve not to promote or endorse abhorrent practices but to serve as an indictment against them. Regardless, a literalist interpretation may not be the most appropriate sense to view scripture and in many cases, will only serve to confuse or distress those individuals that solely read them as such.

With that said, there are some biblical books that are myth but they contain moral truths and instruction, which is one of the primary points of the bible. Biblical exegesis and hermeneutics requires a deeper understanding of ancient historical literary methods, context and cultural understanding than most people generally have. That it is why it’s important for many to defer to tradition, the ministry or those steeped in exegesis to provide valid interpretations and it behooves us not to merely discount or allegorize passages we find disturbing.
 
your rudeness is getting unbearableVery well. First, I note that it is prophetic. Second, I note that it is poetic.
God calls together His people. Nice.

The Day of the Lord is standard code for the coming of the Messiah. It can refer to either the time Jesus walked among us or it can mean His return at the end of the World when He will judge all.

How do you think an obstinate sinner would feel on that day?

Sounds hellish, doesn’t it? Maybe because it’s a description of Hell?

Poetry lesson: In English we rhyme the sounds of words, right?

In Hebrew, guess what they rhyme. (look at my next post for the answer)
Your arrogance is misplaced as you are really quite ignorant. You have totally missed the point. I have argued on this thread against fundamentalism ie the dogma that every word in the bIble is literally true. You have just demonstrated that I am right. The passage from Isaiah states that God is going to punish people by (amongst other things)
slaughtering children and raping women. If we take this literally God must be a dreadfully cruel being; therefore we treat it in a non-literal way.
 
Yes, they are stories or apologues but they are also simultaneously historical accounts and are not necessarily to be solely construed as myth or metaphors. Additionally, many accounts we may find, from our perspective, “offensive” serve not to promote or endorse abhorrent practices but to serve as an indictment against them. Regardless, a literalist interpretation may not be the most appropriate sense to view scripture and in many cases, will only serve to confuse or distress those individuals that solely read them as such.

With that said, there are some biblical books that are myth but they contain moral truths and instruction, which is one of the primary points of the bible. Biblical exegesis and hermeneutics requires a deeper understanding of ancient historical literary methods, context and cultural understanding than most people generally have. That it is why it’s important for many to defer to tradition, the ministry or those steeped in exegesis to provide valid interpretations and it behooves us not merely discount or allegorize passages we find disturbing.
I agree. My main point was that we should not be led into believing that God is a cruel being who actually encourages torture, murder etc. I do think that you should point out that the word “history” does not have the same meaning as what we should expect to find in a modern textbook.
 
I agree. My main point was that we should not be led into believing that God is a cruel being who actually encourages torture, murder etc. I do think that you should point out that the word “history” does not have the same meaning as what we should expect to find in a modern textbook.
What are stating, to a certain degree, is correct. By today’s Western thinking, chronicling history generally means “what actually happened” in an event. However, in practice it is almost unmanageable to attain true certainty without some inherent bias by those writing the account. We see pluralist accounts of even recent historical events and, thus, we cannot rely upon them as a source of truth in the strictest sense, which is somewhat ironic.

However, to the mind of the ancient hagiographer or chronicler, an important question is “what does this mean”, which is a more exalted motive and pertinent to transferring a moral message. The ancient mind in this regard is conveying a message with his account and it comes through at times through the use of literary devices. The accounting may not be as concerned to be perfectly faithfully to intricate details. The account is generally historically true but is also serves as a conduit for a message.

Both the modern and ancient historians are concerned with facts but the ancient accounts within the bible are also conveying a moral message to us. We just need to adjust our mindset to understand the meaning of the event rather than focus on the event particulars. Conclusions drawn upon objective reading of the accounts will invariably lead one astray.
 
your rudeness is getting unbearableVery well. First, I note that it is prophetic. Second, I note that it is poetic.
God calls together His people. Nice.

The Day of the Lord is standard code for the coming of the Messiah. It can refer to either the time Jesus walked among us or it can mean His return at the end of the World when He will judge all.

How do you think an obstinate sinner would feel on that day?

Sounds hellish, doesn’t it? Maybe because it’s a description of Hell?

Poetry lesson: In English we rhyme the sounds of words, right?

In Hebrew, guess what they rhyme. (look at my next post for the answer)
The depth of your misunderstanding is so great I don’t know where to start.

I am merely answering the poster who denied that there are any instances in Scripture of God commanding or legitimizing rape. This is one of a number of instances where He does so. For fundamentalists this is a problem, but not for those of us who don’t subscribe to that fanatical belief. Now do you understand?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top