Embryos cannot be destroyed even for important research, says pope

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
VATICAN CITY (CNS) – In rejecting research using embryonic stem cells, the Catholic Church is not trying to impede science or delay treatment that can save lives, Pope Benedict XVI said.

The church’s opposition to the use and destruction of embryos flows from the conviction that all human life is sacred and that destroying the most defenseless will never lead to a true benefit for humanity, the pope said Nov. 12 to participants in a Vatican-sponsored conference on research using adult stem cells.

“When the end in view is so eminently desirable as the discovery of a cure for degenerative illnesses, it is tempting for scientists and policy-makers to brush aside ethical objections and to press ahead with whatever research seems to offer the prospect of a breakthrough,” the pope said.

However, “the destruction of even one human life can never be justified in terms of the benefit that it might conceivably bring to another,” he said.

catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/1104448.htm
 
VATICAN CITY (CNS) – In rejecting research using embryonic stem cells, the Catholic Church is not trying to impede science or delay treatment that can save lives, Pope Benedict XVI said.

The church’s opposition to the use and destruction of embryos flows from the conviction that all human life is sacred and that destroying the most defenseless will never lead to a true benefit for humanity, the pope said Nov. 12 to participants in a Vatican-sponsored conference on research using adult stem cells.

“When the end in view is so eminently desirable as the discovery of a cure for degenerative illnesses, it is tempting for scientists and policy-makers to brush aside ethical objections and to press ahead with whatever research seems to offer the prospect of a breakthrough,” the pope said.

However, “the destruction of even one human life can never be justified in terms of the benefit that it might conceivably bring to another,” he said.

catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/1104448.htm
👍 The ends do not justify the means.
 
👍 The ends do not justify the means.
Exactly, you do not get a good end from a bad means.

Recently I read something that said that embryonic stem cell research is not proving to be as successful as hoped or hyped. Because those stem cells can become anything, some tests have proven that embryonic stem cells have produced tumors. Actually, with illnesses like multiple sclerosis, use of non-embryonic stem cells have produced more promise.
 
VATICAN CITY (CNS) – In rejecting research using embryonic stem cells, the Catholic Church is not trying to impede science or delay treatment that can save lives, Pope Benedict XVI said.

The church’s opposition to the use and destruction of embryos flows from the conviction that all human life is sacred and that destroying the most defenseless will never lead to a true benefit for humanity, the pope said Nov. 12 to participants in a Vatican-sponsored conference on research using adult stem cells.

“When the end in view is so eminently desirable as the discovery of a cure for degenerative illnesses, it is tempting for scientists and policy-makers to brush aside ethical objections and to press ahead with whatever research seems to offer the prospect of a breakthrough,” the pope said.

However, “the destruction of even one human life can never be justified in terms of the benefit that it might conceivably bring to another,” he said.

catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/1104448.htm
In fact, as a Catholic, the whole argument should not exist; we are on a terrible course. As I recall, the Church is against IVF – fertilization outside of the body. So, there’s already a violation of Church teaching. And now the embryos are unused or unwanted or unclaimed, which should not have happened in the first place. The entire process is a moral problem because the initial procedure that produced these embryos is violative of Church teaching. That we even produce them is problematic for me. Because we “can” does not mean we “should.” So we “play” God and produce life outside the womb, and now we are going to destroy it too?

Further to my other post, I had reason to research a certain back problem which uses stem cells from the injured party’s own blood, separates out the stem cells, and the stem cells are injected into the injured area. While this type of therapy can use many other agents, some physicians are using the patient’s own blood stem cells which may be just as capable of producing a good or healing result. And no embryos are destroyed.

People have to become educated on this topic. We are not going to legislate it away. It’s important the people understand that playing God in the lab is going to have consequences.
 
Meanwhile the Obama admin has mandated more embryonic stem cell research:

lifenews.com/2011/09/28/obama-admin-mandates-more-embryonic-stem-cell-research-funding/
Well, consider the source.

As I said, since we are not going to get any legislation that life begins at conception, and IVF is wrong in the first place, so is destroying those unwanted embryos – we have to educate others on why this is both morally wrong and is leading us down a dangerous path.

As for those who had successful implantations after being unable to reproduce naturally, I am not sympathetic to that argument. God deals you a hand and you play the hand that is dealt. You do not go around God’s will because science has a way around it.

It may sound cruel of me to think of denying a couple a child that can be fertilized outside of the womb for reimplantation because there is an impediment in one partner or another. I am not denying them a child – that has already happened. Possibly God has not selected them to be parents in the natural way. There is adoption. And sometimes there just are no children that can be conceived in the natural way. We don’t know God’s reasons, but obviously these couples have another purpose or path that they must follow and children are not part of God’s plan for them.

And realizing how expensive these procedures are, it still burns me that they take many eggs and fertilize them outside the womb (but one is already too many). It bothers me that they implant multiples to increase the chances of “success”, still leaving embryos that are unwanted when the couple has the child or children that they wanted. Because of the cost of the procedures, they overproduce embryos (no pun intended), intentionally. I fail to see how anyone cannot see how irresponsible all this is – even if one is not Catholic.
 
Wanted to add here that some University’s lab in the mid-Atlantic or south eastern U.S. was paying young women to extract their embryos. This was right around the time that Bush denied federal funding for creating new lines of embryonic stem cells, limiting it to existing lines.

Some argue that this is a private issue. I agree in part. The federal government should NOT be funding this science. But neither am I sympathetic to the argument that medicine should raise their own funds to pursue this science, privately.

We would not have this question at all if we were not extracting eggs and fertilizing them outside of the womb. I don’t understand how anyone can claim to love children while allowing so many eggs to be extracted so that they go unused when they are not implanted because they have taken and fertilized 10 eggs, now have 10 viable embryos, but {of course} can only implant 4 of them.

I should have commented on the title of “important research.” What is important research and who decides what is important enough to warrant the destroying of these embryos? Everyone is in charge and no one is in charge.

We are becoming a society of death. Death penalty, abortion, IVF and destruction of embryos.
 
I love the Holy Father! We can always count on him to stand up for what is right, no matter the popular opinion. God Bless him! I truly hope and pray that our bishops will have the courage to follow him.
 
I love the Holy Father! We can always count on him to stand up for what is right, no matter the popular opinion. God Bless him! I truly hope and pray that our bishops will have the courage to follow him.
Yes, I love this Pope too. God Bless him. Hopefully God will grant him the benefit of time.
 
Wanted to add here that some University’s lab in the mid-Atlantic or south eastern U.S. was paying young women to extract their embryos.
Yet I can’t sell one of my kidneys? Isn’t it my body?
 
Yet I can’t sell one of my kidneys? Isn’t it my body?
Sure you can - you just need to ‘discover’ a long-lost relative. 😉 Incidentally, selling eggs is not usually openly called selling; it’s called being compensated for your time and effort - the eggs apparently are just incidental to the transaction.
 
Yet I can’t sell one of my kidneys? Isn’t it my body?
First, I mistyped. They were paying women to extract their eggs for fertilization. And you cannot sell a kidney as far as I know.

I don’t know what happened; it was right about the time when Bush cut off federal funding for future embyonic stem cell research. Whether or not they continued to lure women to donate their eggs for compensation, I do not know. It’s an abhorrence.
 
First, I mistyped. They were paying women to extract their eggs for fertilization. And you cannot sell a kidney as far as I know.

I don’t know what happened; it was right about the time when Bush cut off federal funding for future embyonic stem cell research. Whether or not they continued to lure women to donate their eggs for compensation, I do not know. It’s an abhorrence.
So I can be paid for the extraction of my kidney as long as I donate the actual organ?

Isn’t it my body?
 
As I recall, the Church is against IVF – fertilization outside of the body.
Could you provide a link to an article discussing this? My understanding is that the opposition or discomfort with IVF was due to the multiple embryos which are often produced (for economic reasons), yet not used. If multiple embryos were not produced, would the Church still be opposed?
 
Could you provide a link to an article discussing this? My understanding is that the opposition or discomfort with IVF was due to the multiple embryos which are often produced (for economic reasons), yet not used. If multiple embryos were not produced, would the Church still be opposed?
The main Catholic Answers site has a video that explains the child’s rights concerning his/her conception rather succinctly. There is also a Quick Question that refers to the Catechism.
 
Wanted to add here that some University’s lab in the mid-Atlantic or south eastern U.S. was paying young women to extract their embryos. This was right around the time that Bush denied federal funding for creating new lines of embryonic stem cells, limiting it to existing lines…We would not have this question at all if we were not extracting eggs and fertilizing them outside of the womb.
Extracting eggs, by itself, is not banned by Catholic moral theology. Unfertilized eggs are not the same as embryos. If the intent was to fertilize the eggs and to use the fertilized eggs for research purposes, that is a different matter, of course.
 
Exactly, you do not get a good end from a bad means.

Recently I read something that said that embryonic stem cell research is not proving to be as successful as hoped or hyped. Because those stem cells can become anything, some tests have proven that embryonic stem cells have produced tumors. Actually, with illnesses like multiple sclerosis, use of non-embryonic stem cells have produced more promise.
What I’ve heard from experts is that embryonic stem cells do not cure anything. All the helpful things that have been found from stem cells have been from adult stem cells. One thinks that adult stem cells will lead to a treatment for Parkinson’s within ten years.
 
The main Catholic Answers site has a video that explains the child’s rights concerning his/her conception rather succinctly. There is also a Quick Question that refers to the Catechism.
Hm… I am not fond of videos as a source, and the text link you provided doesn’t clarify the issue at all. It simply refers to “Church teaching”, without explaining what that is.

Is there an authoritative document which says that IVF, apart from the matter of multiple embryos (which we know is wrong), is forbidden?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top