Enthusiastic and Shallow Faith

  • Thread starter Thread starter PumpkinCookie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PumpkinCookie

Guest
I know many people who seem to have an enthusiastic, or even zealous faith. Many of these people are young, and seem to be sincerely joyous and filled with earnest desire to be faithful and to “evangelize.” However, I perceive among them an aura of naivete and lack of depth. I often wonder if many of these people have weak personalities and were just overwhelmed by “youth ministry” efforts at a young age which contributed to their self proclaimed “faith.”

I wonder, what do you think? Is it possible to be enthusiastic and zealous but also quite shallow? Is it possible to sing loud worship and praise music, go on monthly “feel-good” retreats, volunteer for several “youth ministries” and yet still have almost no real relationship to the real God? Is it possible to deceive oneself so thoroughly? Are people like this “worshiping” a false image of God they have created in order to give themselves emotional fulfillment?

Many have told me that those who are quiet, questioning, and contemplative have a weak or lacking faith, but I am wondering if precisely the opposite is true: that those who shout out the loudest to others have the least going on within their own souls. What do you think?
 
I think it’s wrong to judge the state of someone’s heart, spiritual depth or intentions. Just because it may not be the way you would do something, doesn’t make it insincere.
 
I wouldn’t assume that they don’t have a real relationship with the real God. When I was a “new” Christian I was over-enthusiastic, but lacking in wisdom.
 
I think everyone responds to God’s grace in their soul differently. There are different personality types in the world. Some are more inclined to ponder things in their heart, like Mary did. And some are called to shout it from the rooftops like Peter. Doing one or the other doesn’t make you more or less faithful or more or less shallow. It depends on the person.

I’m actually glad there are all sorts of different types of people in the Church. “If all were a single organ, where would the body be? As it is, there are many parts but one body.” (1 Cor 12:19-20) Praise God for that! 👍
 
I know many people who seem to have an enthusiastic, or even zealous faith. Many of these people are young, and seem to be sincerely joyous and filled with earnest desire to be faithful and to “evangelize.” However, I perceive among them an aura of naivete and lack of depth. I often wonder if many of these people have weak personalities and were just overwhelmed by “youth ministry” efforts at a young age which contributed to their self proclaimed “faith.”

I wonder, what do you think? Is it possible to be enthusiastic and zealous but also quite shallow? Is it possible to sing loud worship and praise music, go on monthly “feel-good” retreats, volunteer for several “youth ministries” and yet still have almost no real relationship to the real God? Is it possible to deceive oneself so thoroughly? Are people like this “worshiping” a false image of God they have created in order to give themselves emotional fulfillment?

Many have told me that those who are quiet, questioning, and contemplative have a weak or lacking faith, but I am wondering if precisely the opposite is true: that those who shout out the loudest to others have the least going on within their own souls. What do you think?
An interesting question, and it may be as you propose. As in all things, it depends on the individual. I think, however, that in both the enthusiastic believer and the contemplative one, they and others may better be able to evaluate the nature of their faith after its being put to the test. IOW, it is much easier to have faith when things are going fairly well in one’s life or when one can notice some improvements, whether materialistic, emotional, or spiritual, since becoming a true believer. It’s quite another thing to maintain one’s faith, whichever kind it is, after a tragic event or two have taken place.
 
Many have told me that those who are quiet, questioning, and contemplative have a weak or lacking faith, but I am wondering if precisely the opposite is true:
These adjectives describe the Blessed Virgin Mary. We have the freedom to either criticize her nature, or strive to emulate it.
 
Is it possible to be enthusiastic and zealous but also quite shallow? Is it possible to sing loud worship and praise music, go on monthly “feel-good” retreats, volunteer for several “youth ministries” and yet still have almost no real relationship to the real God? Is it possible to deceive oneself so thoroughly? Are people like this “worshiping” a false image of God they have created in order to give themselves emotional fulfillment?
Yes, I think it is possible and in fact I have seen such things when I was younger. I guess it is a part of not being all grown up and mature. religion can be a part of one’s identity like playing sports, liking a certain type of music or films. Some of these enthusiastic people I knew then left the faith and moved on to something else. Some of them stayed in the church and matured.

I was addicted to retreats and pilgrimages with my youth group, although I was not into evangelising (too shy for that). But I don’t think I had a deep faith, it was mostly about fellowship and travelling. I have also matured since then. 🙂
 
I know many people who seem to have an enthusiastic, or even zealous faith. Many of these people are young, and seem to be sincerely joyous and filled with earnest desire to be faithful and to “evangelize.” However, I perceive among them an aura of naivete and lack of depth. I often wonder if many of these people have weak personalities and were just overwhelmed by “youth ministry” efforts at a young age which contributed to their self proclaimed “faith.”

I wonder, what do you think? Is it possible to be enthusiastic and zealous but also quite shallow? Is it possible to sing loud worship and praise music, go on monthly “feel-good” retreats, volunteer for several “youth ministries” and yet still have almost no real relationship to the real God? Is it possible to deceive oneself so thoroughly? Are people like this “worshiping” a false image of God they have created in order to give themselves emotional fulfillment?

Many have told me that those who are quiet, questioning, and contemplative have a weak or lacking faith, but I am wondering if precisely the opposite is true: that those who shout out the loudest to others have the least going on within their own souls. What do you think?
They are just being young. Most young people who join in religious communities are members of highly closed Catholic families. They suddenly find themselves free from the observance of adults during these events. I observe some even smoke after choir practice or after meetings. When religious practices have become commonplace, there is a sort of an attempt at “breakaway” in any form of rebellion against “being square”. So although, religiousity is the object, some have a tendency to show off in loud voices.
 
Just bought a Randy Jackson limited edition guitar from HSN and am well pleased. Which brings me to the point of enthusiasm and shallow faith. I led praise for both catholic mass and non-denominational services. Couple this with an intense desire and active practice of “desert” spirituality and one could easily assume there was a problem with deeper commitments here. In some ways that was true. The struggle became intense. I opted to drop all the “shallow” things and focused on contemplation. It took years to realize that the “shallow” things are just as necessary as the “deeper” things. Of all the spiritual practices I’ve pursued, life with a community of believers has been the most rewarding.
 
I wonder, what do you think? Is it possible to be enthusiastic and zealous but also quite shallow? Is it possible to sing loud worship and praise music, go on monthly “feel-good” retreats, volunteer for several “youth ministries” and yet still have almost no real relationship to the real God? Is it possible to deceive oneself so thoroughly?
Possible? Yes, of course almost anything is possible.
Are people like this “worshiping” a false image of God they have created in order to give themselves emotional fulfillment?
How could anyone, other than God, know the answer to that question/
Many have told me that those who are quiet, questioning, and contemplative have a weak or lacking faith, but I am wondering if precisely the opposite is true: that those who shout out the loudest to others have the least going on within their own souls. What do you think?
I wouldn’t dare stand in judgment of others on such an important subject as to the state of their souls based on their outward appearance, be they charismatic, contemplative, or somewhere in between. *I think *a thorough meditation on Luke, Chapter 6 is in order, particularly verses 31, 37, 41, and 43-44.
 
I know many people who seem to have an enthusiastic, or even zealous faith. Many of these people are young, and seem to be sincerely joyous and filled with earnest desire to be faithful and to “evangelize.” However, I perceive among them an aura of naivete and lack of depth. I often wonder if many of these people have weak personalities and were just overwhelmed by “youth ministry” efforts at a young age which contributed to their self proclaimed “faith.”

I wonder, what do you think? Is it possible to be enthusiastic and zealous but also quite shallow? Is it possible to sing loud worship and praise music, go on monthly “feel-good” retreats, volunteer for several “youth ministries” and yet still have almost no real relationship to the real God? Is it possible to deceive oneself so thoroughly? Are people like this “worshiping” a false image of God they have created in order to give themselves emotional fulfillment?

Many have told me that those who are quiet, questioning, and contemplative have a weak or lacking faith, but I am wondering if precisely the opposite is true: that those who shout out the loudest to others have the least going on within their own souls. What do you think?
Neither is true. Everyone has a different personality. What I may do with great zeal, you may do with quiet confidence. They are on fire for the Lord. How exciting that is!

God gives us different levels of understanding and wisdom and of knowing Him at different stages at our life. In my own experience, at different stages in my life, I have felt called to be outspoken or quiet, zealous or calm, participating or observing. Our journey never ends to know Him. It is better to sing/pray his Praises, than to do nothing. I can’t judge what others do on their journeys; I just have to stay on the path He wants for me.

God bless.
Christina
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top