Eucharist Receiving Clarification

  • Thread starter Thread starter adawgj
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

adawgj

Guest
Just to make sure I don’t disrespect Eastern Catholic liturgies when I visit one.

Are Latin Rite Catholics able to receive the Eucharist in Eastern Rite churches?
 
Yes. Any Catholic (properly disposed) can receive the Eucharist at any Catholic Mass/Divine Liturgy.
 
Yes. Any Catholic (properly disposed) can receive the Eucharist at any Catholic Mass/Divine Liturgy.
👍

I am looking forward to visiting a Melkite Mass someday. Along with a many others of those sharing the same communion of faith.

:highprayer:
 
Just to make sure I don’t disrespect Eastern Catholic liturgies when I visit one.

Are Latin Rite Catholics able to receive the Eucharist in Eastern Rite churches?
Make certain to talk to the cleric at least 15 min before liturgy if you want to receive.
 
Actually, it is as much as to ensure that they can figure out you’re either Catholic or Orthodox!
Boy…I travel to quite a lot of Byzantine Churches here in the US as well as abroad…and have never met with the priest before hand…if the priest wants to question me which I find very rare…he does so at the chalice.
 
Boy…I travel to quite a lot of Byzantine Churches here in the US as well as abroad…and have never met with the priest before hand…if the priest wants to question me which I find very rare…he does so at the chalice.
Yea, and that’s a strange thing that the priest would question one about whether they were Catholic or Orthodox :confused:. As I’ve said before, I guess the Syriac churches might be much more lax because I know our priests who commune SO weekly and their children.
 
Make certain to talk to the cleric at least 15 min before liturgy if you want to receive.
Our priest and deacon are busy with Proskomedia at that point, but any of the regular attenders/parishioners would be happy to answer any questions. Most parishes are fairly small, generally recognize a visitor, and reach out to welcome them, in my experience, with ECCs and Orthodox. Sometimes our deacon will come out from the holy place after Proskomedia if they finish before the choir shows up and Liturgy begins. When he does he will connect with visitors.

We also regularly commune Orthodox who visit our parish, if they present themselves for Eucharist. Some do go forward, some don’t.
 
Rev. Fr James turned away a Catholic he didn’t know recently.

I don’t know why.

He routinely communes the Orthodox who make themselves known to him, so I suspect there’s a reason.

Not my place to say.

The proper thing, however, is to make oenself known to the clergy prior so that they know you’re elligible to receive.
 
The proper thing, however, is to make oenself known to the clergy prior so that they know you’re elligible to receive.
I don’t disagree on that, but unlike the Russian Orthodox who definitely want to hear who you are and know you’ve just gone to confession, I have in my experience around here found the EC clergy generally more like the Latins-- if someone presents themselves for Eucharist it is trusted they are properly disposed to receive. I suppose if someone was acting peculiar during the rest of Liturgy something might be asked at the chalice.

I consider you fortunate to have clergy who make a point of this. Someone in my parish happened to mention to me that he/she had never been to confession. He/she was received into the Church in our parish years ago. Thankfully there has been more emphasis on receiving confession the past year. It’s not the laity’s fault, they haven’t been catechized.
 
I don’t disagree on that, but unlike the Russian Orthodox who definitely want to hear who you are and know you’ve just gone to confession, I have in my experience around here found the EC clergy generally more like the Latins-- if someone presents themselves for Eucharist it is trusted they are properly disposed to receive. I suppose if someone was acting peculiar during the rest of Liturgy something might be asked at the chalice.

I consider you fortunate to have clergy who make a point of this. Someone in my parish happened to mention to me that he/she had never been to confession. He/she was received into the Church in our parish years ago. Thankfully there has been more emphasis on receiving confession the past year. It’s not the laity’s fault, they haven’t been catechized.
Of late, if someone acts strange and is unknown, Fr. James blesses them using the chalice and sends them back to the pews, with a “Talk to me after liturgy.”

We have him for one more week - he’s been given transfer orders for Assumption of the Theotokos in Anaheim.

On the other hand, he did put pews back in. 🤷
 
Make certain to talk to the cleric at least 15 min before liturgy if you want to receive.
Actually, it is as much as to ensure that they can figure out you’re either Catholic or Orthodox!
🙂

Not that I’m doubting you or anything, but my experience as a Greek Catholic is definitely different from yours. (I’ve noted that on other occasions but I don’t think I’ve said so until now.)
 
Rev. Fr James turned away a Catholic he didn’t know recently.

I don’t know why.

He routinely communes the Orthodox who make themselves known to him, so I suspect there’s a reason.

Not my place to say.

The proper thing, however, is to make oenself known to the clergy prior so that they know you’re elligible to receive.
Knowing Fr. James quite well I highly doubt he turned a catholic away from the chalice just because he didn’t know them. I’m sure there was more to it than that.
 
I’m just adding in my experience to the mix here. I’ve attended the Divine Liturgy at three different Melkite churches and two different Ukrainian churches and I’ve never been refused communion at any of them.

Understandably some clerics want to make sure that the person is properly disposed, but I’ve never run into this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top