Eucharist - Scriptures say it cannot be Christ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SonofMonica
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
God, Who is outside of time, and Who instituted time to give meaning and regulation to the life of the human body, could give His resurrected body to man before it had occurred in earthly time. Christ has always been resurrected in eternity.
po18guy,

I understand what you mean, I think, but in my opinion that way of viewing reality complicates things. In fact, I think you’ve hit on an important point when you say time gives meaning and regulation to the life of the human body. The Body of Christ existed in time in a meaningful way . . . such that Christ on his way to Golgotha wasn’t the Resurrected Christ.

I’m not sure why we would want to posit that Christ gave His Resurrected body to the Apostles at the Last Supper, when His Body (in the Room) at that moment wasn’t Resurrected. The other alternative (the giving of the non-Resurrected Body) seems to me to be more consistent with the teaching on the Real Presence, and, in my opinion protects that teaching.

VC
 
Well, I think what Jesus didn’t say (but may certainly be implied) is “When you eat my flesh, you eat all of me.” That is the final connection I’m attempting to make. Does that make sense?
Jesus said “I am the bread of life”. He didn’t say “my flesh is the bread of life”. Hope that helps!
 
so why then did Jesus also offer up the cup, and say “this is My Blood…”?

should He not have then said of the bread “this is My Body which contains My Blood, which is shed…”?

Christ also commands us to eat the bread and drink the cup and remembrance of Him, and treats the bread as His Body and the cup as His Blood as two different yet related and neccesary things.
Hi grace_,

Yes, that is right, they are two different yet related things.

From a Catholic point of view Christ was instituting a sacramental-sacrifice, and there is a deep richness to why the Body and Blood are consecrated separately.

As to why Christ said only “This is my Body” . . . it is because those words were effecting the reality, i.e. changing bread into Body. The other phrase you mentioned (“this is my Body which contains my Blood”) is a description of what existed* due to the change.

Again, this is from a Catholic view, so it might not be the way you approach it if you are not Catholic.

God Bless,
VC

*this is to say that Christ’s Body wasn’t always joined to His Blood. . . during the Passion there was a separation of His Body and Blood.
 
well, if Christ is blessing and offering up both bread and wine, body and blood, as distinct yet related elements, and asking His disciples to eat of the bread (His Flesh) and drink of the cup (His Blood), why would that also not apply to Christians today?

meaning, if His disciples ate the bread and drank the wine both that night in remembrance of Him, and as He commands us through the Bible to do the same (eat the bread and drink the cup, two seperate foods) in His memory, are we not then to do just that?

Christ does not ask us to eat the bread which as His Body contains His Blood of the New Covenant, but rather to eat the bread and drink the wine, both. the body is the Corpus on the cross, yet blood that stays inside the body is not shed. do you see what i mean?
 
well, if Christ is blessing and offering up both bread and wine, body and blood, as distinct yet related elements, and asking His disciples to eat of the bread (His Flesh) and drink of the cup (His Blood), why would that also not apply to Christians today?

meaning, if His disciples ate the bread and drank the wine both that night in remembrance of Him, and as He commands us through the Bible to do the same (eat the bread and drink the cup, two seperate foods) in His memory, are we not then to do just that?

Christ does not ask us to eat the bread which as His Body contains His Blood of the New Covenant, but rather to eat the bread and drink the wine, both. the body is the Corpus on the cross, yet blood that stays inside the body is not shed. do you see what i mean?
Do you have an idea of what substantially present under the signs or characteristics of bread or wine means?

I recently saw the word elements on a Protestant website. And I am wondering what elements means to Protestants and to you since you used the word. Do those who list themselves as Catholics use the word elements in reference to the Catholic Eucharist and what is meant.

Blessings,
granny

All human life is sacred.
 
i do have an idea of what it means, and can understand the idea behind the Catholic belief. the body contains the blood, so one can simply consume the Eucharistic wafer and eat the body and drink the blood at once.

“elements” here simply meaning the bread and the wine. which for Protestant are symbols of Christ’s body and blood, and for Catholics are His actual body and blood through transsubstantiation.

what i don’t understand is why Catholics do not take the wine and the bread, as Christ was clear the the wine was His shed Blood, not the blood still in His body. Christ’s body was broken on the cross for us, and His shed Blood, which left His body, is the precious blood which cleanses us from sin, and purchases us from sin, and the world.

Christ gave both bread and wine to His disciples at the last supper. why modern Catholics imitating and following Christ would not take the same two, distinct elements during communion (meaning bread and wine both) is not understood to me, as i read Scripture, and look at what Christ does and commands, and how the disicples respond.

the wine was His shed blood, poured out for the remission of sins, by which He has purchased us- not the blood still in His body. so why a Catholic would take the host and not the wine remains something i can not fathom. i can respect it, but i can not understand it.
Do you have an idea of what substantially present under the signs or characteristics of bread or wine means?

I recently saw the word elements on a Protestant website. And I am wondering what elements means to Protestants and to you since you used the word. Do those who list themselves as Catholics use the word elements in reference to the Catholic Eucharist and what is meant.

Blessings,
granny

All human life is sacred.
 
i do have an idea of what it means, and can understand the idea behind the Catholic belief. the body contains the blood, so one can simply consume the Eucharistic wafer and eat the body and drink the blood at once.

“elements” here simply meaning the bread and the wine. which for Protestant are symbols of Christ’s body and blood, and for Catholics are His actual body and blood through transsubstantiation.

what i don’t understand is why Catholics do not take the wine and the bread, as Christ was clear the the wine was His shed Blood, not the blood still in His body. Christ’s body was broken on the cross for us, and His shed Blood, which left His body, is the precious blood which cleanses us from sin, and purchases us from sin, and the world.

Christ gave both bread and wine to His disciples at the last supper. why modern Catholics imitating and following Christ would not take the same two, distinct elements during communion (meaning bread and wine both) is not understood to me, as i read Scripture, and look at what Christ does and commands, and how the disicples respond.

the wine was His shed blood, poured out for the remission of sins, by which He has purchased us- not the blood still in His body. so why a Catholic would take the host and not the wine remains something i can not fathom. i can respect it, but i can not understand it.
Thank you for your respect.

Practically speaking, our limited minds, even the mind of Thomas Aquinas, cannot fully understand how Jesus is truly present in the bread and wine. To think that we could completely understand our infinite loving God is downright silly. Yet, from the beginning (John Chapter Six) the Apostles accepted the hard saying of “Whoever eats My flesh and drinks My blood remains in Me and I in him.” Clearly the bread and wine referred to by Jesus would not be the same as normal bread and wine . A change would take place.

In the Early Church, the Greek word metapoteisthai, meaning change was used. As time passed the how (what was involved) of change was explored to the point that the original teaching of Jesus was in danger. This is when a Church Council, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, studied all that had been taught starting with the Apostles and determined that the change was substantial. This became the dogma of Transubstantiation which is supernatural, i.e., the action of God.

Once I am sure about the Catholic use of the word “elements” and how it differs from the Protestant usage and then add the Catholic use of the words “substance” and “substantially”, you may be able to see the reasoning for the Catholic belief. Actually, there is quite a bit more than " the body contains the blood, so one can simply consume the Eucharistic wafer and eat the body and drink the blood at once." Please understand that even good reasoning about supernatural action is limited by our natural minds.

Blessings,
granny

The quest for knowledge is worthy of the adventures of the journey.
 
After explaining the principle of concomittance in his book Seven Secrets of the Eucharist, Vinny Flynn of EWTN fame gives an interesting take on Pope Paul VI’s encyclical on the Eucharist, Mysterium Fidei, and his great profession of faith The “Credo” of the People of God. He keys in on the phrases that Christ is present in the Eucharist “as He is in heaven,” and “without leaving heaven.” Flynn points out that Christ is not alone in heaven. Christ is the second person of the Blessed Trinity, true God and true man, eternally united with the Father and the Holy Spirit forever. Just as there is no separation between Christ’s body and blood now, and no separation between Christ’s human and divine nature, likewise there is no separation of the Holy Trinity in terms of concrete reality.

Moreover, at the opening prayer of the Mass, the priest prays “We ask this through our Lord Jesus Christ, you Son, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, forever and ever.” How does he reign? As the Son of God and Son of Man, the King of Kings. He is surrounded by the whole heavenly court of angels and saints, and is eternally reunited with his Mother, the bless Virgin Mary, who, having been assumed into heaven, body and soul, now reigns with Him as Queen of heaven and earth.

The point is, Christ is never alone. When he becomes present in the Eucharist as he is in heaven, that means that all of heaven is present with Him. No wonder He told us, “The kingdom of heaven is within you.” (Lk. 17:21 RSV). So Flynn asks what this means for you and me. The answer he poses is that wheneer we receive Communion, we enter into communion with the Holy Trinity. With each reception of Holy Communion, we experience, on Earth, the same divine activity that we will experience in all its fullness in heaven – the divine activity of love eternally taking place within the Holy Trinity.

Flynn is quick to point out that only Christ is sacramentally present, that is, under the appearances of bread and wine. Only Christ, the second person of the Trinity, was made flesh and assumed a human nature. The Father and the Holy Spirit are not present sacramentally, but each is really and truly present with Christ because of the perfect unity of the Trinity. Flynn asks the rhetorical question, “What do we mean by really and truly present?” The answer, he says, is that the Catechism explains that there can be no full explanation, because even these terms “signify an ineffable mystery, infinitely beyond all that we can humanly understand.” CCC 251.

To the principle of consubstantiality (that each person of the Trinity are of the same divine nature or substance), the Church adds the principle of circumincession, which is the principle of the mutual presence of the three divine Persons – each is present in each other without ceasing to be distinct. Thus, whenever we receive Christ sacramentally, under the appearance of bread or wine, or both, the Father and the Holy Spirit become present with Him, not sacramentally, but nonetheless in a true and complete and substantial way.

Moreover, even though each saint is still and individual being, all are now one with each other and incorporated into the Trinity. See CCC #1023-1027. St. Padre Pio explained that Our Lady was present at every Mass, along with all the angels and the heavenly court. At each Mass, he saw the heavens open, the splendor of God, and the glory of the angels of saints. St. Therese experienced this at the moment of her first communion. She realized that not only was the Trinity about to dwell in her, but since the saints and angels in heaven are “perfectly incorporated into Christ” (CCC #1026), all of heaven would come to her, too.

During the ceremony, she was moved to tears, which some people misinterpreted to mean that she was sad because her mother had died and wasn’t there to share the first communion with her. To the contrary, Therese writes “It was beyond them that all the joy of heaven had entered one small, exiled heart, and that it was too weak to bear it without tears. As if the absence of my mother could make me unhappy on the day of my first Communion! As all of heaven entered my soul when I received Jesus, my mother came to me as well.”
 
I was reading a non-Catholic website that cites the 24th chapter of of St. Matthew for the following proposition:

How might one go about answering such an objection to Eucharistic Adoration? Thanks in advance.

Sincerely and respectfully,

SonofMonica
[bibledrb]Matthew 28:20[/bibledrb]

“Behold I am with you all days, even to the consummation of the world…” sounds like the Perpetual Presence of Jesus in His Church through the Eucharist to me 🙂
 
We must also remember that “Most” or “Some” Protestants have to discredit the Most Holy Eucharist. To say and believe that the Most Holy Eucharist is as the Catholic Church knows and teaches it to be, then “Most” or “Some” Protestants who, for the life of them would never agree on anything that the Catholic Church believes, would have to say that the Catholic Church is right about something, and if the Catholic Church is right about something then there must be other things that it is right about. Heaven forbid that the Catholic Church is right about something, especially on something of such immense importance. But then again “Most” or “Some” Protestants only see the Most Holy Eucharist and the scriptural references and just symbolism. Peace.
 
I understand what you mean, I think, but in my opinion that way of viewing reality complicates things. In fact, I think you’ve hit on an important point when you say time gives meaning and regulation to the life of the human body. The Body of Christ existed in time in a meaningful way . . . such that Christ on his way to Golgotha wasn’t the Resurrected Christ.

I’m not sure why we would want to posit that Christ gave His Resurrected body to the Apostles at the Last Supper, when His Body (in the Room) at that moment wasn’t Resurrected. The other alternative (the giving of the non-Resurrected Body) seems to me to be more consistent with the teaching on the Real Presence, and, in my opinion protects that teaching.

VC
Regarding the Resurrection, the catechism (CCC 645) teaches: “Yet, at the same time this authentic, real body possesses the new properties of a glorious body: not limited by space and time but able to be present how and when He wills”

CCC 647 teaches that “Although the Resurrection was an historical event that could be verified by the sign of the empty tomb and by the reality of the apostle’s encounters with the risen Christ, still it remains at the very heart of the mystery of faith as something that transcends and surpasses history.”

Just something to ponder, as all things are possible to God.
 
Here’s what bothers me about this line of thinking:
  1. Protestants read the words “Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day” and they say, if this were literally true, it would be cannibalism, therefore the passage of scripture is metaphoric and the elements of Holy Communion are merely symbolic.
The objection that “This would be cannibalism” was pretty much the objection made by the Jews, and the disciples who left Jesus when he was adamant about the point. To say “this is only symbolic flesh” doesn’t solve the problem, but instead creates a new one, as the rite of communion then could be correctly described as “symbolic cannibalism.” The point is that it is not “cannibalism” at all, because one can only cannibalize one’s own species. That which we eat in communion is not the same sort of flesh that we have, but is instead the essence of Christ’s body and blood under the species of bread and the species of wine.

You would do well to read what Aquinas has to say about this matter. You will find that in the Summa Theologica, Part III, questions 73 through 83.
newadvent.org/summa/4.htm
Do you get the rub that potentially exists?
I did, and dealt with it above (thus simultaneously answering the objection in #2.)🙂
 
Regarding the Resurrection, the catechism (CCC 645) teaches: “Yet, at the same time this authentic, real body possesses the new properties of a glorious body: not limited by space and time but able to be present how and when He wills”

CCC 647 teaches that “Although the Resurrection was an historical event that could be verified by the sign of the empty tomb and by the reality of the apostle’s encounters with the risen Christ, still it remains at the very heart of the mystery of faith as something that transcends and surpasses history.”

Just something to ponder, as all things are possible to God.
Thanks pg,

Excellent passages. They might have some sort of limitation, though.

Could we postulate that, for instance, Christ appeared to Mary in His Resurrected Body when she was a little girl? Could we postulate that Christ had a glorified body while suffering on the cross?

In regard to the Eucharist at the Last Supper, another important question, I think, is not what could of been done – but rather why would it be done?

Why would we want to posit a resurrected body before the resurrection, specifically at the Last Supper? Why would Christ will it to be so?

Thanks,
VC
 
Thanks pg,

Excellent passages. They might have some sort of limitation, though.

Could we postulate that, for instance, Christ appeared to Mary in His Resurrected Body when she was a little girl? Could we postulate that Christ had a glorified body while suffering on the cross?

In regard to the Eucharist at the Last Supper, another important question, I think, is not what could of been done – but rather why would it be done?

Why would we want to posit a resurrected body before the resurrection, specifically at the Last Supper? Why would Christ will it to be so?

Thanks,
VC
Only in God’s presence will we know the answers to the multitude of mysteries “contained” if you will, in both creation as well as in the uncreated. His ways are inscrutable and far beyond our comprehension. We have only a fragmented and imperfect concept of eternity, yet we strive toward it based upon His trustworthy promises. It is in attempting to grasp the reality of the eternal that we confront the depth of our own limitations.
 
Beautifully said.

With regard to the Apostles receiving the glorified body of Christ at the Last Supper, my suspicion is that this is often put forth for three main reasons:
  1. Misinterpreting those authors who state that Christ in the Eucharist has a glorified body. It is true, of course, but this is usually confined to teaching about what we, the faithful, receive in Holy Communion, now. It isn’t a teaching about Holy Communion in general. The sure teaching is that Christ is present Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity. And this leaves open the possibility that Christ gave the Apostles his non-glorified body.
  2. Misinterpreting the teaching on concomitance. Similar to the above, this teaching is often mentions that since Christ, who is now risen and glorified, can die no more (His Body, Blood, and Soul are always together). But again, this is speaking about the current state of affairs. Concomitance doesn’t depend on the glorified nature of Christ’s Body, but rather the connection between Body, Blood, and Soul.
  3. Thinking that the Eucharistic presence of Christ is dependent on Christ’s glorified body. In other words, positing that Christ can be present only because He has a glorified body. I’m not sure how much support this approach has, but I do know that there is a strong tradition of teaching that does not posit the glorified body as the means by which Christ is present in the Eucharist.
    In any event, when one looks at Aquinas and those who follow there is good authority that holds that the Apostles received the mortal body at the Last Supper. The reason for this is that it follows from the doctrine of the Real Presence. Christ is really present as He is, and the way he is at the Last Supper is passible.
One last thing: I have an opinion about one of my hypotheticals in my previous post. I don’t think it is possible for Christ to have had a glorified body while suffering on the Cross. A glorified body is impassible and Christ was manifestly passible on the Cross.

As St. Ignatius of Antioch says:
There is one Physician who is possessed both of flesh and spirit; both made and not made; God existing in flesh; true life in death; both of Mary and of God; first passible and then impassible— even Jesus Christ our Lord.
God Bless, thanks for the discussion,
VC
 
I don’t think it is possible for Christ to have had a glorified body while suffering on the Cross. A glorified body is impassible and Christ was manifestly passible on the Cross.
I was taught several years ago that we receive BOTH the glorified & non-glorified Christ in the Bread & Wine. We get ALL of Christ … the Christ that suffered & the Reigning Christ on High.

Recall this FCEMG ?
 
Hi brb,

I think that might have been a bit of an imprecision. While one could speak of receiving the Christ who has suffered and is glorified in Heaven, we couldn’t say that Christ is at the same time, right now, with a glorified body and a non-glorified body.

VC
 
Hi brb,

I think that might have been a bit of an imprecision. While one could speak of receiving the Christ who has suffered and is glorified in Heaven, we couldn’t say that Christ is at the same time, right now, with a glorified body and a non-glorified body.

VC
Nevertheless, we teach, per inspired scripture authority, that Christ died for us. His dieing body & blood redeemed us from sin … his sacrifice before/unto the Father.

And, those who believed upon him, before the Day of the Cross … were saved.

Its a Mystery my friend … our Church is founded on great mysteries. Thats why we must exercise FAITH.

Perhaps FCEMG can further help us understand more correctly this great Mystery.
 
And, those who believed upon him, before the Day of the Cross … were saved.
Yes, but they still had to *wait, *at least from our point of view.
Catechism of the Catholic Church:
637 In his human soul united to his divine person, the dead Christ went down to the realm of the dead. He opened heaven’s gates for the just who had gone before him.
40.png
brb:
Its a Mystery my friend … our Church is founded on great mysteries. Thats why we must exercise FAITH.
Yes, I agree wholeheartedly. But, what mystery are you referring to? There is no need to posit a mystery of how Christ could at the same time be both resurrected and non-resurrected. The Church, as far as I know, doesn’t posit that.

VC
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top