Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is interesting but I was driving across Wisconsin one time into an area where there is nothing but religious programing. I actually heard (and I won’t claim he was baptist) this guy who was reminded that Jesus drank wine. He actually said, “if we had been there we could have shown Him why it was wrong”. whoa!!! I almost drove into a ditch.
 
Wildleafblower wrote a glowing review of a presentation showing an alleged timeline of the creation of the universe, the first humans & c. Here is part of it:

"Date Event
January 1 - -Big Bang
February 7 - -Birth of the Milky Way
August 14 - -Birth of the Earth
September 4 - -First appearance of life on Earth
December 15 - -The “Cambrian explosion”
December 25 - -Dinosaurs appear
December 30 - -Dinosaurs become extinct

The last day of the year is a very rich one.

December 31 Event
7:00:00 pm - - First hominids
11:58:00 pm - - First humans
11:59:30 pm - - Age of Agriculture
11:59:47 pm - - Building of the Pyramids
11:59:58 pm - - Jesus is born
11:59:59 pm - - Galileo is born
12:00:00 Midnight Today"

Now this timeline shows humans originating (I guess from some ape-like creature) a full two minutes ago. Since Jesus was born only two seconds ago, I presume that two minutes represents a pretty long time.

My question is, why do you suppose God waited so long to reveal information about Himself? What about all the people who lived for those hundreds of thousands or millions of years? Why did God leave to their own devices? No divine revelation for all that time! How does that fit with Genesis?
 
(removed for brevity)
My question is, why do you suppose God waited so long to reveal information about Himself? What about all the people who lived for those hundreds of thousands or millions of years? Why did God leave to their own devices? No divine revelation for all that time! How does that fit with Genesis?
It is involved more than can be typed here, but briefly. Homo sapiens was a biological reality but not yet ready for sharing the life of God through the soul or grace. Having the natural body was not sufficient until the brain could perceive what difference the soul could make. There is a computer modeling experiment that uses genes for brain size and collection of what are termed memes. Homo sapiens sapiens underwent a gradual increase in brain size to the point where the birth process could no longer accommodate the increase in infant skull size. During that time period of natural development homo sapiens was gaining brain capacity but was not yet capable of perceiving or acting on having a soul. The geological record shows a period of time where we had a larger brain but skeleton data was “strewn” across the landscape. Suddenly we see graves with personal effects and sometimes flowers and decorations placed in the graves with the body. Aha! now we see the effect of the soul. Not yet ready for the ten commandments yet but getting closer and close enough to perceive the afterlife. One can easily come to the conclusion that God would judge this people not by the commandments or by Paul’s epistles but exactly where they were at in that time frame and at stage of development.
Suddenly archeology begins to see graves that demonstrate a care for the infirm and arthritic elders. That is altruism beyond biological necessity and we see it both in homo sapiens sapiens and in homo sapiens neanderthalis. I can see the work of God here and evidence that in this period God considers us ready to give us a share of His life and grace however humble the beginnings
 
Wildleafblower wrote a glowing review of a presentation showing an alleged timeline of the creation of the universe, the first humans & c. Here is part of it:

"Date Event
January 1 - -Big Bang
February 7 - -Birth of the Milky Way
August 14 - -Birth of the Earth
September 4 - -First appearance of life on Earth
December 15 - -The “Cambrian explosion”
December 25 - -Dinosaurs appear
December 30 - -Dinosaurs become extinct

The last day of the year is a very rich one.

December 31 Event
7:00:00 pm - - First hominids
11:58:00 pm - - First humans
11:59:30 pm - - Age of Agriculture
11:59:47 pm - - Building of the Pyramids
11:59:58 pm - - Jesus is born
11:59:59 pm - - Galileo is born
12:00:00 Midnight Today"

Now this timeline shows humans originating (I guess from some ape-like creature) a full two minutes ago. Since Jesus was born only two seconds ago, I presume that two minutes represents a pretty long time.

My question is, why do you suppose God waited so long to reveal information about Himself? What about all the people who lived for those hundreds of thousands or millions of years? Why did God leave to their own devices? No divine revelation for all that time! How does that fit with Genesis?
answersingenesis.org/articles/am/v1/n2/billions-of-people
 
My question is, why do you suppose God waited so long to reveal information about Himself? What about all the people who lived for those hundreds of thousands or millions of years? Why did God leave to their own devices? No divine revelation for all that time! How does that fit with Genesis?
Are you are sure there was no revelation in all that time?
 
I am sorry to say that is just flat wrong.
That presentation of “evidence and reasoning” is so far off the mark and so easily broken on the wheel of scientific evidence it is not even worth considering. To even go there requires the complete denial of all rationality and even the most basic of science.
I think you owe it to us to tells us how so. Do you believe in the Genesis Flood?
 
I think you owe it to us to tells us how so. Do you believe in the Genesis Flood?
In short, no.

The flood has been demonstrated as a localized flood of the Tigress Euphrates rivers that was severe enough to create myths across the early civilizations. The fact that several groups have the same myth demonstrates that no general destruction of mankind happened.

And no I will not tell you how so. The reason why is simple. No science example I can give you will suffice. The web site you give makes it clear that science has nothing to say to you. It is literalism and cannot be argued with. One either believes that science has something to offer or rejects science completely. In the latter case it is futile to offer any scientific evidence.
 
In short, no.

The flood has been demonstrated as a localized flood of the Tigress Euphrates rivers that was severe enough to create myths across the early civilizations. The fact that several groups have the same myth demonstrates that no general destruction of mankind happened.

And no I will not tell you how so. The reason why is simple. No science example I can give you will suffice. The web site you give makes it clear that science has nothing to say to you. It is literalism and cannot be argued with. One either believes that science has something to offer or rejects science completely. In the latter case it is futile to offer any scientific evidence.
In short then, my friend, you reject scripture and follow the speculations and “science” of godless men who assume away in light of their godless worldview. You are flat wrong and God is flat right.
 
Are you are sure there was no revelation in all that time?
If you use the New Testament then The prime law of God is seen. Love God with your whole heart and soul and love your neighbor as yourself. From what I have proposed this would be the first revelation to man and can be seen in the support and care of both the cro-magnon and neanderthalis elderly and infirm.
To see graves of tribe members bearing damage that caused infirmity and yet old enough to have completely healed as old old wounds seems to support the idea of supernaturally inspired altruism well beyond natural altruism seen in any other species of hominids.
 
In short then, my friend, you reject scripture and follow the speculations and “science” of godless men who assume away in light of their godless worldview. You are flat wrong and God is flat right.
And that is exactly why I do not answer. You reject Louie Pasteur, you reject Mendel. In short, you reject. Fair enough.
 
(msg. 295)Wildleafblower wrote a glowing review of a presentation showing an alleged timeline of the creation of the universe, the first humans & c. Here is part of it: [snip]
wildleafblower;3450623:
(msg. 249)
drpmjhess;:
(msg. 213) He spoke tonight on “The Dance of The Fertile Universe: Did God Do It?” He seriously believes Intelligent Design Creationism is the great heresy of our time.Petrus
George Coyne gave a great lecture in 2006. 🙂

**AAAS Dialogue on Science, Ethics, and Religion **
(DoSER) Public Lecture March 27, 2006
The Dance of the Fertile Universe: Chance and Destiny Embrace
George V. Coyne, S.J. Director, The Vatican Observatory

SUMMARY
**When talking about evolution in a very broad sense there is a classical debate about chance and necessity. “According to Modern Science,” declared George V. Coyne, Jesuit and director of the Vatican Observatory, “the debate is mistaken.” What is missing in the debate, he argued in his lecture on March 27, 2006 presented in the series sponsored by the AAAS Dialogue on Science, Ethics, and Religion, is “the fertility of the universe.” The evolution of the universe is propelled by fertility as well as chance and necessity, he proposed.

If the universe evolved only by chance, then there would be no place for a God of purpose. If the universe evolved only by necessity, this might tend to lead to an affirmation of God. But if it
evolves due to both, then, he said, “we are caught in between.” Coyne used this point to emphasize that in the debate between materialism and non-materialism or atheism and theism,
“science is completely neutral.” This neutrality is a consequence of both the inherent limitations of the scientific method and the profound depth of human ignorance about the universe, even in
the face of all the knowledge that has been gained.

To begin defining what he meant by “the fertility of the universe” Coyne offered the following numerical illustrations:

• There are about 30,000 human genes, but only about 2010 vary among human beings.
• Thus the genetic variance between human beings is 22010 or 10605 .
• Each individual human can produce 10605 different eggs or sperm.
• In the visible universe there are 1076 atoms. What sense does it make to compare 10605 and 1076 ?

It is not clear, but it is a marvel, he suggested, that a universe with this number of atoms has produced such a degree of human fertility. Of course, one of the difficulties with trying to come to terms with large numbers e.g., 10605, a 1with six hundred and five 0s following it, is that they are so far from ordinary human experience. It is helpful to use a metaphor from a more common experience of time to relate astronomical time. So, for example, if the whole 13.7 billion year history of the universe were stretched over only one Earth year, significant events in evolution would be dated as follows:

Date Event**
January 1 - -Big Bang
February 7 - -Birth of the Milky Way
August 14 - -Birth of the Earth
September 4 - -First appearance of life on Earth
December 15 - -The “Cambrian explosion”
December 25 - -Dinosaurs appear
December 30 - -Dinosaurs become extinct

The last day of the year is a very rich one.
*
December 31 Event*
7:00:00 pm - - First hominids
11:58:00 pm - - First humans
11:59:30 pm - - Age of Agriculture
11:59:47 pm - - Building of the Pyramids
11:59:58 pm - - Jesus is born
11:59:59 pm - - Galileo is born
12:00:00 Midnight Today

If you look at cosmic history this way, all of modern science happened “in the last second.” Coyne concluded, “So, if there are a few gaps in our knowledge [of how the universe works] – if there is some ignorance – give us more time; we’ve only had one second.” [please read and view the graphics presented in his lecture.] For him religious faith “is a free gratuitous gift and it is a personal relationship not just a rational relationship. “God,” he declared, “is not a God of explanation but a God of love.” It is only after the “moment of personal relationship” that the question of the meaning of “God” arises, and how our understanding of the universe bears on this question. . . .Coyne closed his talk by turning to the question: “If I believe in God, what does this sort of fertile universe say about God?” First, he stated, it does not prove that God exists. This, in his view, is the false premise that underlies the intelligent design movement (ID). The universe seems to exhibit an intrinsic destiny in the process of volutionary complexification through natural processes. But recognizing this does not require that a person believe in God nor does it lead to belief in God. . . .
aaas.org/spp/dser/02_Events/Lectures/2006/02_Lecture_2006_0327.pdf
http://www.aaas.org/spp/dser/02_Events/Lectures/2006/02_Lecture_2006_0327.pdf
abu kamoon, please read the above pdf again. Best not to quote-mine and cherry pick the lecture by George V. Coyne, S.J. that the American Association for the Advancement of Science provided. Thanks.

Let’s get back on track! Consider my messages here:

Is The Theory of Evolution mandatory for the modern worldview
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=3420299#post3420299
http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=3420299#post3420299
Yes! Alec’s Evolution Pages too!
evolutionpages.com/
http://www.evolutionpages.com/
AND here:
👍

Whew! That’s enough teaching for me today. Happy Easter to everyone! Remember Jesus loves you.😃
 
I am sorry to say that is just flat wrong.
That presentation of “evidence and reasoning” is so far off the mark and so easily broken on the wheel of scientific evidence it is not even worth considering. To even go there requires the complete denial of all rationality and even the most basic of science.
Hey, Chuck – after my lecture in Indianapolis next week I was planning on driving to see the AiG “museum” with a friend, although I have some moral qualims ginving money to those folks to suypport their evil and deceitful works.

I asked my executive director whether I should go openly or incognito, and she advised the latter. If Ken Ham finds out who I am, they may screen me from the more juicy bits, as they did when she went last year. I understand they’ve pulled the videos of Adam made by Eric Linden (they discovered he’s a porn star!).
 
OK, oh learned one. you got me. what is auto da fe?
Burning people at the stake to give them an opportunity to show their love for Christ. Surely you’ve seen the Monty Python episode about the Spanish Inquisition? The most terrifying instrument of the Church was the “comfy chair.”
 
I know how we can solve this argument. Let’s all contribute come money in the interest of science and purchase a brand new car. We’ll leave the car parked in a field for let’s say, twenty five years. Hopefully, the weather and other environmental conditions can induce a few random mutations in the car. Then we can all see how the car evolves into a more advanvced model.
Abu, you walked into that HEB and bought several kags to chug, didn’t you. And on Good Friday of all days!
 
In short, no.

And no I will not tell you how so. The reason why is simple. No science example I can give you will suffice. The web site you give makes it clear that science has nothing to say to you. It is literalism and cannot be argued with. One either believes that science has something to offer or rejects science completely. In the latter case it is futile to offer any scientific evidence.
Chuck, have you noticed how writing on a Catholic Answers forum is like educating a parade? After a few weeks of good serious discussion and clarification of presuppositions people begin finally to get on the same page, and then someone else comes waltzing in and we have to start at ground zero all over. But that’s what my organization is all about.

Petrus
 
In short then, my friend, you reject scripture and follow the speculations and “science” of godless men who assume away in light of their godless worldview.
If so, he does so with the blessings of the Church, which allows the interpretation of the flood as not world wide. Indeed, “eretz” does not mean “the whole world.”
You are flat wrong and God is flat right.
Not unless God made a mistake in Hebrew.
 
Chuck, have you noticed how writing on a Catholic Answers forum is like educating a parade? After a few weeks of good serious discussion and clarification of presuppositions people begin finally to get on the same page, and then someone else comes waltzing in and we have to start at ground zero all over. But that’s what my organization is all about.[/quiote]
Getting people exposed to the science involved is the important thing. There are lurkers and those just interested in reading the debate.
The best thing is to expose the facts and let people think about it.
 
My apologies to all. I caved and slipped off into slumber last night around twelve. There are apparently more ardent posters on here than me.
:rotfl:

Barbarian brought me up to date on both fe and the comfy chair. Either that bit was on a Monty Python show that I missed or if it was in a movie I have lost those particular memory neurons. The only Inquisition scene in a movie that I have was the nuns who peeled off their habits and became a swim ballet in History of the world part I.

I am beginning to think I am in the company of more than mere laity grousing and arguing here. How will I be able to boldly go forth in the face of learnedness and erudition? I may limit my future posts to “Uh and Duh”😊

My thanks for the direction to “Is the Theory of evolution mandatory…” thread. Most interesting. I didn’t read everything so if this did come up skip over this thought.
Rather than the human mind being a simply biochemical process. Brain science indicates a major event which is synthetic. The synthesis of having chemical messengers and neuronal connections to such an extent that the combination literally creates a next step state beyond the sum of the parts. This synthesis can be seen in anthropoid apes but not to the extent it is seen in humans.
In my post to Abu, I examine this in light of the momentous change in human behavior toward fellow humans. Chimpanzee moms may mourn the loss of an infant (though little regard is shown toward adult death in the chimp world) but eventually the body is left behind for natural decomposition. Archeology shows a distinct change in early man. At first we are the same in how we handle the dead and infirm. Then suddenly graves appear where the people inside them show arthritis (osteo arthritis=old age) and wound damage that is old indicating the individual had to cope with infirmity for a long time. The graves often also show a sense of the afterlife with personal possessions and tokens of affection placed with the deceased. Both caring for weaker members and concern for deceased are altruistic behaviors beyond natural altruism suggesting the affect of having been given a share of God’s life that transcends the completely natural state.

Just a hypothesis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top