Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
originsnet.org/mindmp.htmlThis the death and burial site. If you can’t find the scriptures… well you is just in trouble! :eek:
Thank, Chuck – Ah is jest in a heap o’ trouble; ain’t nobody knows de trouble ah’m in…

Got to run and fetch hot cross buns, and then report to choir rehearsal for tonight and the Easter Vigil, and finish my talk for Indianapolis on “Can I both believe in God and accept evolution?”

Penitentially yours,
Petrus
 
Creationism has a corrosive effect on faith. Children who are raised on a diet of anti-science creationism are forced to make the false choice between (1) atheistic science and (2) primitive, anti-science religion. It’s a tragedy that most people who abandon their faith are abandoning a very immature reading of that faith. I don’t believe in the God atheists don’t believe in either!
The creationists I’ve seen post here have invariably been polite, respectful of others’ opinions, and generally humble. Not so for most of those who are gung-ho for evolution. The most respectful gung-ho evolution guy I’ve seen is actually a Buddhist.

I’ve posted this many times, but here it is again:

The US Catholic Catechism for Adults is a document created by the Church specifically for the purpose of instruction of Catholics. Quote directly from the US Catholic Catechism for Adults - page 60 (2007):
“Christian faith does not require the acceptance of any particular theory of evolution, nor does it forbid it, provided that the particular theory is not strictly materialistic and does not deny what is essential to the spiritual essence of the human person, namely that God creates each human soul directly to share immortal life with him.”
This quite clearly states that:
  1. Catholics are free to reject any and all forms of evolution.
  2. Catholics are forbidden to accept theories of evolution which are strictly materialistic, etc. (as described above).
  3. Catholics may accept forms of evolution which are not forbidden, as above.
Creationism is not forbidden by the Catechism, or by the Catholic faith in general. I’m not a creationist, but if I were to express belief in it, that would not be against Church teaching.

Do you disagree?
 
Creationism has a corrosive effect on faith. Children who are raised on a diet of anti-science creationism are forced to make the false choice between (1) atheistic science and (2) primitive, anti-science religion. It’s a tragedy that most people who abandon their faith are abandoning a very immature reading of that faith. I don’t believe in the God atheists don’t believe in either!
See you on a salvation thread?
 
The creationists I’ve seen post here have invariably been polite, respectful of others’ opinions, and generally humble.
You’ve missed a lot, then. I don’t remember any evolutionist here calling another person posting here a liar. But that’s happened more than once from creationists.

One who claims that evolution is contrary to Catholic faith is dissenting from the teaching of the Church. Such person is free to deny what the Pope says is “virtually certain,” but he is not free to say that evolution is contrary to our faith.
 
Creationism has a corrosive effect on faith. Children who are raised on a diet of anti-science creationism are forced to make the false choice between (1) atheistic science and (2) primitive, anti-science religion. It’s a tragedy that most people who abandon their faith are abandoning a very immature reading of that faith. I don’t believe in the God atheists don’t believe in either!
Amen to that. The most destructive effect of creationism is not that it attacks science, but that it produces atheists.
 
Creationism is not forbidden by the Catechism, or by the Catholic faith in general. I’m not a creationist, but if I were to express belief in it, that would not be against Church teaching.Do you disagree?
I don’t disagree at all. The Catechism is not in any position to dictate what Catholics believe about any science. A Catholic can reject the theories of gravity, plate tectonics, biological evolution, subatomic forces, and pulmonary circulation of the blood, and still be a Catholic in good standing. They will not likely succeed in careers in science, but this does not in any way prejudice their Catholicism.

Petrus
 
Amen to that. The most destructive effect of creationism is not that it attacks science, but that it produces atheists.
Yes – I’ve run into a number of atheists who came out of fundamentalist anti-science backgrounds.
 
One who claims that evolution is contrary to Catholic faith is dissenting from the teaching of the Church. Such person is free to deny what the Pope says is “virtually certain,” but he is not free to say that evolution is contrary to our faith.
You’ve previously agree to item 2 in my post 335 above. Certainly, evolution in some forms is contrary to our faith. Based on some previous posts, you seem to deny that (or are unwilling to admit that) there actually ARE any forms of evolution that are contrary to our faith. That’s not what the catechism says.

If you agree with the Catechism, then you need to admit that some forms of evolution are contrary to Church teaching.
 
You’ve missed a lot, then. I don’t remember any evolutionist here calling another person posting here a liar. But that’s happened more than once from creationists.
I probably don’t read their posts, so it is quite possible that I missed that.

But I’ve seen many very polite, respectful, thoughtful posts by creationists (or even those like myself who are not creationists, but aren’'t quite as gung-ho as some of the evolutionists) who were subsequently attacked immediately thereafter in a very negative way.

But back to my comment on pride+Science…Pride is still considered one of the 7 deadly sins. Creationism is not.
 
Certainly, evolution in some forms is contrary to our faith.
The practice of medicine, in some forms is contrary to our faith. But there is nothing in medicine contrary to our faith. That some things that are true and useful can be twisted to evil purposes is not what we are talking about.
Based on some previous posts, you seem to deny that (or are unwilling to admit that) there actually ARE any forms of evolution that are contrary to our faith.
There are no forms of evolution that are contrary to our faith. They are, after all, creations of God; truth cannot contradict truth. There are of course, some unscientific ideas about evolution that are contrary to our faith. This is why the scientists here (and the Pope) have repeatedly reminded you that any “theory” of evolution that denies God is not science at all.
If you agree with the Catechism, then you need to admit that some forms of evolution are contrary to Church teaching.
You’ve confused the phenomenon with some people’s beliefs about that phenomenon. As you know, scientists regard the idea that science can deny God to be equally foolish as the idea that science can endorse God.
 
But back to my comment on pride+Science…Pride is still considered one of the 7 deadly sins. Creationism is not.
How about pride+creationism? Some might consider “creationists are polite and scientists are rude” to be an expression of pride, um? It’s best to remember that we are all capable of that kind of thing.
 
And your last dozen or so posts have been about what? :rolleyes:
Nice touch. eliminate anything with meat on it and infer deceit.

skip the idea that almost all of them have been on what science can tell us.
Also skip the idea that most of them hypothesize on how God can be shown to working within the context of the science.
 
There are no forms of evolution that are contrary to our faith. They are, after all, creations of God; truth cannot contradict truth. There are of course, some unscientific ideas about evolution that are contrary to our faith. This is why the scientists here (and the Pope) have repeatedly reminded you that any “theory” of evolution that denies God is not science at all.
Your’re mincing words. Instead of “form”, I’ll say “theory” instead to say exactly what the catechism says.

Perhaps you should explain this to the folks that wrote the Catechism. They seemed to want to put it in there for a reason.
You’ve confused the phenomenon with some people’s beliefs about that phenomenon. As you know, scientists regard the idea that science can deny God to be equally foolish as the idea that science can endorse God.
This has nothing to do with anything. I said nothing about proving God or denying God with evolution.

I merely quoted the catechism above.
 
A belief in evolution is not a requirement of our faith. Proper faith formation requires the Bible and a relationship with the person of Jesus Christ.

Non-theistic evolution is against our faith.

Peace and God bless,
Ed
 
Nice touch. eliminate anything with meat on it and infer deceit.

skip the idea that almost all of them have been on what science can tell us.
Also skip the idea that most of them hypothesize on how God can be shown to working within the context of the science.
We are all free to go back and read them.
 
Stay on topic and avoid the personal comments or expect the thread to be locked.
MF
 
What should a Catholic biology teach in a Catholic high school about creation and evolution?
IMHO - We should teach the following:
  1. God created everything. We have some insights into how that was done, and we can create models of how it was done, but we’ll never know for sure because we’re not God.
  2. Science is a tool that God gave us (part of intellect and reason). It is one more way that we can come to know God, as we do through Art, Music, and other ways in which we exercise our intellect.
  3. Scientific evidence points to an earth that was created about 13 billion years ago, and an earth that was created 4.5 billion years ago.
  4. Scientific evidence also points to the fact that complex life forms exist today, and much simpler ones billions of years ago. There is a transition in the fossil record that shows a gradual increase of complexity over time.
  5. Scientific evidence shows that natural selection plays a part in ensuring the survival of species which are more fit than others.
  6. Scientific evidence shows that genetic mutations are responsible for providing the increased complexity on which natural selection operates.
  7. Science cannot determine exactly what mutations occurred and over what time period to cause this increasing complexity.
  8. Catholics must believe that God is responsible for both the creation of the universe, as well as the creation of man.
  9. Catholics must believe that we originated from a single set of human parents.
  10. Catholics can believe that God created our human bodies via evolutionary processes as described above, but that these human “bodies” did not become fully human until infused with souls from God.
  11. Catholics must believe that our souls are directly created by God, and did not evolve. (since they consist of only 1 part, it is impossible for it to evolve).
And a good summary that I’ve posted before:

Quote directly from the US Catholic Catechism for Adults - page 60 (2007):
“Christian faith does not require the acceptance of any particular theory of evolution, nor does it forbid it, provided that the particular theory is not strictly materialistic and does not deny what is essential to the spiritual essence of the human person, namely that God creates each human soul directly to share immortal life with him.”
This quite clearly states that:
  1. Catholics are free to reject any and all forms of evolution.
  2. Catholics are forbidden to accept theories of evolution which are strictly materialistic, etc. (as described above).
  3. Catholics may accept forms of evolution which are not forbidden, as above.
 
The Barbarian observes:
There are no forms of evolution that are contrary to our faith. They are, after all, creations of God; truth cannot contradict truth. There are of course, some unscientific ideas about evolution that are contrary to our faith. This is why the scientists here (and the Pope) have repeatedly reminded you that any “theory” of evolution that denies God is not science at all.
Your’re mincing words.
Nope. Words mean things. Say what you mean.
Instead of “form”, I’ll say “theory” instead to say exactly what the catechism says.
Perhaps you should explain this to the folks that wrote the Catechism. They seemed to want to put it in there for a reason.
They aren’t scientists, after all. But properly speaking, a “theory” that addresses the supernatural isn’t a scientific theory at all. The Catechism is using “theory” in the informal sense.

Barbarian observes:
You’ve confused the phenomenon with some people’s beliefs about that phenomenon. As you know, scientists regard the idea that science can deny God to be equally foolish as the idea that science can endorse God.
This has nothing to do with anything.
It has to do with the misconception that there can be a scientific theory of evolution that is contrary to the teaching of the church. We should clearly teach students that science has nothing to say about those things.

To your list, I’d make two corrections:
  1. “Complexity” is not part of evolutionary theory, and often, complexity is reduced in evolution.
  2. Science can indeed make accurate inferences about things that happened in the past.
 
Non-theistic evolution is against our faith.
Peace and God bless,Ed
Except that evolution is a matter of science, not faith. Non-theistic gravity and plate tectonics would be against our faith as well, if faith had anything to do with those theories.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top