Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sideline said:

"Originally Posted by abu kamoon
My question is, why do you suppose God waited so long to reveal information about Himself? What about all the people who lived for those hundreds of thousands or millions of years? Why did God leave to their own devices? No divine revelation for all that time! How does that fit with Genesis?

Are you are sure there was no revelation in all that time?"

First, I don’t believe that there have been people around for millions of years. As to whether or not there was any other divine revelation that we are aware of, I would have to say that I don’t know, since I wasn’t there. Now if we could only get evolutionists to exibit that humble attitude.
 
"Quote:
Of course it’s nonsense, Chuck. But it is no more ridiculous than the idea that one species can “evolve” into another because of random mutations. Non bacterial maladies that afflict the human race like the sickle cell are the result of mutation. We don’t evolve from these mutations, we devolve.

What happens to the human body as it ages? Cells continue to reproduce, but mutations cause degeneration. It’s the same situation in the reproduction of offspring, but much slower. It involves errors caused by mutations in the genetic code. These errors do not create superior beings, the cause weaker offspring, more prone to disease and even extinction.

Why do evolutionists cling to this theory when what we can observe shows just the opposite?
You choose a rather bad example to show your point. At first glance it is easy to say that sickle cell devolves. When we look at a person suffering from sickle cell disease we see the suffering they go through. But the gene itself was a powerful answer to a biological problem faced in environments where malaria fluorishes. The carrier of a sickle cell gene is able to inhibit malaria and thus survive in areas where malaria is epidemic. It partner condition Beta Thalassemia is the allele which confers the same inhibitory effects on Mediterranean and Asian populations that face the same risks. Both mutations carry enormous benefits for carriers (heterozygotes with one normal, one mutated allele and so they persist in the populations because the heterozygous red blood cell; 1 has hemoglobin that is not readily available to the malarial parasite for food and 2 ruptures easily when invaded by the parasite so that it cannot mature and reproduce. The condition only presents an acute problem when it is in homozygous condition (.05% versus 85% for carriers) and is removed from the environment it where it was a positive mutation.

In the case of aging, mutations show a very low causal effect of any degeneration. The science now shows that as cells divide and reproduce the DNA they tend to decrease the telomeres which opens the chromosomes up for attack by the same endonucleases that protect us from virus attack so the genome gets “chewed on”.

In some cases a random deleterious mutation is fixed, not by nature but by human perversity. Hemophilia in the royal families of Europe is due to a single mutation in one man that had built up due to the fact that royal marriages created a very inbred population and stubborn refusal to be tainted by the “blood of commoners” allowed the gene to be passed and propogated in the small, inbred pure blood population.

So evolution and the study of gene development and mutation serves a very utilitarian and useful purpose in modern study.
 
Well… I guess I’m not much for being attacked in a discussion, or having my ability as a teacher insulted.
IAmEdmund, no one insulted your ability as a teacher. Suggesting something to study – such as the relationship between fact and theory – is a common practice among teachers. I have learned a lot from my colleagues in various universities; I’ve read up on areas in which I recognized my knowledge was deficient, and it has only enhanced my theology and philosophy teaching. Hang in there, and Happy Easter!

Petrus
 
Chuck H wrote:

?? Homo Sapiens (I guess that means people) were alive, but not yet ready to share the life of God? Where did you get that information? What happened to these Homo Sapiens when they died? How do you know?

I’m glad that I don’t put my trust in computer models. Computers are handy devices, but their output is totally dependent on the quality of their (name removed by moderator)ut.

So, I guess it all boils down to this: Either the first man was created by God with all his faculties, or the first man (men?) evolved millions of years ago, but were unable to be considered to be in the image of God. Now which is it?
First, this excerpt is taken out of context. It is a continuation of a hypothetical proposal that had been presented in an earlier thread and was a response to another’s post within that context.
If that proposal was approached with a literal belief in Genesis then it would be a foregone conclusion that it would be immediately rejected.
In order to be discussed:
  1. It must be assumed that mankind arose through a progression of natural evolution to a point where God was ready to give man a soul and begin a relationship.
  2. It then follows that there was a point in time where man was simply Homo-sapiens-sapiens a critter, followed by the next moment where God “breathed” into him supernatural life( the soul) and he became man “enhanced”.
  3. And finally, IF this were the case what should be able to be seen in genetics, archeology and anthropology which would support such a proposal.
It is not to be taken as dogma. It is simply a proposal for discussion within the context of the thread.
 
First, I don’t believe that there have been people around for millions of years. As to whether or not there was any other divine revelation that we are aware of, I would have to say that I don’t know, since I wasn’t there. Now if we could only get evolutionists to exibit that humble attitude.
Actually, if creationists developed more humble attitude towards science we wouldn’t even be having this conversation.

You have often posted that evolution is obviously not true, when the vast majority of scientists studying the subject have found that it is. I’m not sure how that squares with humility.

Scientists don’t claim to know it all, but there is much that we are certain of. How would it profit a scientist to be humble, and say evolution could be wrong, when much of it couldn’t. There are parts of the theory that are uncertain, but as a whole it is hard to imagine how a completely different theory could account for all of our observations.

Many people are alive today that wouldn’t be if there were no sickle cell anemia. Yet you claim this is a devolution. You claim with certainty that mutations can not be beneficial. That’s hardly a humble claim. It actually claims a much higher degree of knowledge about the human genome than scientists would ever claim to possess.

By the way, Homo sapiens sapiens are modern people. We are a subspecies of Homo sapiens, also called modern Homo sapiens. The species also includes archaic Homo sapiens. It’s still correct to call us Homo sapiens, but Homo sapiens sapiens is more precise. The term means “thinking man” (Homo - man, sapiens - thinking). Homo is the genus. There were several species in the genus Homo (Homo erectus, Homo habilis, Homo neanderthalesis). The genuses Australopithecus and Homo make up the hominid family.

Do you know much about biology? I’m not being snide. I’m just curious.
 
A final note on “creationism”. Creationism, going to the extreme says that “God did it, and I don’t care how he did it.” Science going to the extreme says that we have no need of God and/or We Know Everything. Balance is nice, but if one falls off the fence, one extreme leads to heaven and the other does not.
I left just enough in to tie this to your post. We are both (good gentiles) if you get the scripture reference.

If most evolutionists were like Kenneth Miller and Francis Collins life would be far easier. My own approach to evolution is a kid in a candy shop. “THIS IS SOOOOO COOL!” I think you also have these moments when an engineering problem presents a new and elegant solution. And I bet you have the old dictum filed somewhere in your mind or papers…“if God had meant us to fly, He would have given us wings”
Your final statement is strictly true in that many people can start and finish life successfully (spiritually) without ever having considered creation or evolution. The danger (within the matter of education) is also true. If a student goes out into the world of academia with little more than young earth creationism instilled in them as truth they will be shredded by those atheistic scientists who have physical evidence plus an enmity toward God plus a commanding academic persona. I think, after climbing up on the shoulders of giants like Francis Collins and Kenneth Miller I could listen to someone like Dawkins or Harris and see the flaws and misunderstandings of their arguments. In that light, one can see why Dr Hess claims an evil in the AiG museum since it sets up the young for an untenable position when faced with academia under the circumstances described above. If one follows that museum with ,say, attending Oral Roberts U then their beliefs are never questioned. The university of Wisconsin on the other hand will rip them apart.
 
The danger (within the matter of education) is also true. If a student goes out into the world of academia with little more than young earth creationism instilled in them as truth they will be shredded by those atheistic scientists who have physical evidence plus an enmity toward God plus a commanding academic persona. I think, after climbing up on the shoulders of giants like Francis Collins and Kenneth Miller I could listen to someone like Dawkins or Harris and see the flaws and misunderstandings of their arguments. In that light, one can see why Dr Hess claims an evil in the AiG museum since it sets up the young for an untenable position when faced with academia under the circumstances described above.
Chuck, nice formulation. My concern has always been for students who are first deprived of a sound scientific education by ignorant Young Earth or ID Creationists, and then possibly deluded out of their simplistic version of Christian faith because of a false assumption that evolution = atheism.

Regarding Dawkins, I have heard (anecdotally) that his initial antipathy to theism was increased exponentially after the world Trade Center attacks, both because they were the result of a faith-based Islamic initiative, and because of the absurd response of the like of Christian televangelist Jerry Falwell, who tied the attacks to the US’ continuing toleration gay and lesbian people.

I am not excusing Richard Dawkins’ simplistic argument, nor do I think his atheism is ultimately cogent, but if there were more humility on both sides of this argument tensions about the science might be greatly reduced.

Petrus

PS – Richard turned down a request to join our office’s pumpkin carving party last October – something about associating with a religious tradition!
 
So, I guess it all boils down to this: Either the first man was created by God with all his faculties, or the first man (men?) evolved millions of years ago, but were unable to be considered to be in the image of God. Now which is it?
Abu, such black and white thinking is not helpful and is embraced only by the likes of simplistic Corapians, who believe “the devil’s favorite color is gray.”

All creation is in God’s image, in the degree appropriate, in that all creation mirrors the goodness of the creator articulated in Genesis 1. The more neurologically a creature is endowed and therefore able to respond to God’s love, both morally and spiritually, the more one mirrors that imago Dei. Early hominids adumbrated – in their primitive way – the perfect image of God found in the man Jesus. Chuck has already noted the evidence from paleontological and anthropological studies that early hominids were developing psychologically and spiritually toward that image of God.

Petrus
 
No public university will tell you we are created in God’s image,

I think that’s what everyone needs to remember. If there is a sincere search for the truth, it needs to take that fact into consideration. If truth cannot contradict truth, people need to remember that whatever truth comes from science needs to align with the Church, otherwise, it is rejected.

Read Human Persons Created in the Image of God. Not all theories (plural) of evolution are acceptable to the Church.

God bless,
Ed
 
Chuck, nice formulation. My concern has always been for students who are first deprived of a sound scientific education by ignorant Young Earth or ID Creationists, and then possibly deluded out of their simplistic version of Christian faith because of a false assumption that evolution = atheism.

Regarding Dawkins, I have heard (anecdotally) that his initial antipathy to theism was increased exponentially after the world Trade Center attacks, both because they were the result of a faith-based Islamic initiative, and because of the absurd response of the like of Christian televangelist Jerry Falwell, who tied the attacks to the US’ continuing toleration gay and lesbian people.

I am not excusing Richard Dawkins’ simplistic argument, nor do I think his atheism is ultimately cogent, but if there were more humility on both sides of this argument tensions about the science might be greatly reduced.

Petrus

PS – Richard turned down a request to join our office’s pumpkin carving party last October – something about associating with a religious tradition!
Regarding Richard Dawkins: He is a perfect example of J.B. Phillips Your god is too small. By his own admission his younger theism was overcome and crushed by the science he studied (must have been one of those little pocket babylonian idols). Science wise, after digging into his “science” I was appalled. Other than a rather glaring plagiarism of earlier mneme work by a German scientist he has published nothing that could be called peer review.
He only publishes in book form and pontificates (forgive me fellow catholics-no disrespect meant). My impression is that in a good science debate with a real evolutionist he would fold like tinfoil. I was forced to the conclusion that he is the classical definition of a pseudo-intellectual; all puff and huff. I have since changed any reference to memes to the original Mnemes of the German to keep me honest.
 
All creation is in God’s image, in the degree appropriate, in that all creation mirrors the goodness of the creator articulated in Genesis 1. The more neurologically a creature is endowed and therefore able to respond to God’s love, both morally and spiritually, the more one mirrors that imago Dei. Early hominids adumbrated – in their primitive way – the perfect image of God found in the man Jesus. Chuck has already noted the evidence from paleontological and anthropological studies that early hominids were developing psychologically and spiritually toward that image of God.

Petrus
darned theologians! Well, back to Websters again!
 
I left just enough in to tie this to your post. We are both (good gentiles) if you get the scripture reference.

If most evolutionists were like Kenneth Miller and Francis Collins life would be far easier. My own approach to evolution is a kid in a candy shop. “THIS IS SOOOOO COOL!” I think you also have these moments when an engineering problem presents a new and elegant solution. And I bet you have the old dictum filed somewhere in your mind or papers…“if God had meant us to fly, He would have given us wings”
Your final statement is strictly true in that many people can start and finish life successfully (spiritually) without ever having considered creation or evolution. The danger (within the matter of education) is also true. If a student goes out into the world of academia with little more than young earth creationism instilled in them as truth they will be shredded by those atheistic scientists who have physical evidence plus an enmity toward God plus a commanding academic persona. I think, after climbing up on the shoulders of giants like Francis Collins and Kenneth Miller I could listen to someone like Dawkins or Harris and see the flaws and misunderstandings of their arguments. In that light, one can see why Dr Hess claims an evil in the AiG museum since it sets up the young for an untenable position when faced with academia under the circumstances described above. If one follows that museum with ,say, attending Oral Roberts U then their beliefs are never questioned. The university of Wisconsin on the other hand will rip them apart.
Hey, I think evolution is sooooo cool too. But I know that there are limitations to the theory, and in the end it may turn out not to be like we think it is today. As many have said, that’s how science works, it continually refines itself.

I posted my thoughts on what should be taught. And you disagreed with only a few minor points. I’m not a creationist. And none of my comments were related to the aig museum. I’ve never been there, nor have I read anything about it. Perhaps they have some evidence that will help refine the science of evolution.

I actually agree with Edwest that the biggest danger is not that we teach too little good science, but rather that we teach too little about God.
 
I actually agree with Edwest that the biggest danger is not that we teach too little good science, but rather that we teach too little about God.
If we taught more good science, we wouldn’t have a problem with creationism. And we’d need less remedial education about God.

Of course, if we did a better job of teaching people about God, creationism would be less of a problem, too.

Let’s do more of both.
 
Hey, I think evolution is sooooo cool too. But I know that there are limitations to the theory, and in the end it may turn out not to be like we think it is today. As many have said, that’s how science works, it continually refines itself.
No bragging intended just a clarification of my interest. I get to PLAY in the candy shop! 😃

Distribution of chromosomal polymorphisms in species and subspecies of squirrel monkeys. Moore, C.; Harris, C.; and C. Abee (1990) Cytogenet. Cell Genet 53:118-122

Identical cytogenetic clones and clonal evolution in pediatric monozygotic twins with acute myeloid leukemia: presymptomatic disease detection by interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization and review of the literature. Richkind KE, Loew T, Meisner L, Harris CP, Wason D. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol (1998) May-Jun;20(3):264-7
 
Where is the deficiency in teaching good science? Where is the lack?

And what is the importance of evolution-science over any other branch of science?

And who is talking about God here? I mean other than promoting naturalism with God tacked on to the end of it?

God bless,
Ed
 
[But when we decide that we can actually know everything (eventually) then we make ourselves equal to God, and that can never happen.

When we pursue knowledge, we need to remember that ultimately the first will be last and the last will be first. He will scatter the proud in their conceit. We must be like children to enter the kingdom of Heaven.

Science going to the extreme says that we have no need of God and/or We Know Everything. Balance is nice, but if one falls off the fence, one extreme leads to heaven and the other does not.
Exactly what I was trying to say before the shooting started. ;]

Well said! (Hope you got armor on… the Darwin Devotee’s are rabid around here!.. they’ve no sense of humor (Guess it was `naturally selected’ out because it has no use, eh!?))
[/quote]
 
Exactly what I was trying to say before the shooting started. ;]

Well said! (Hope you got armor on… the Darwin Devotee’s are rabid around here!.. they’ve no sense of humor (Guess it was `naturally selected’ out because it has no use, eh!?))
Three evolutionists walk into a bar. The religion teacher sees it and ducks.

no sense of humor???:rotfl:
 
. they’ve no sense of humor (Guess it was `naturally selected’ out because it has no use, eh!?))
What about all these humourous references to the classic Monty Python skit about the Spanish Inquisition? Or does that hit too close to closet desires for some Catholics to find it amusing?
 
darned theologians! Well, back to Websters again!
Sorry, Chuck – I meant in the sense of “hinted at” or “foreshadowed.” Also, Homo sapiens today still only adumbrates the imago Dei, until that day when the Gospel is lived in full. Long after humans have evolved into their successor species a million years from now, those successors will strive toward mirroring the image of God.
 
No bragging intended just a clarification of my interest. I get to PLAY in the candy shop!
So this means, because you’re in the shop and get to play there 😃 , you must be right and any threat to evolution you see coming down the pipe is wrong, and must come from those who DON’T play in the candy shop.

No bragging, but I worked in astrophysics on the eclipsing binary star system V356-Sgr:

aas.org/publications/baas/v29n5/aas191/abs/S045012.html

Does this mean that my light curve that I produced for this system is now the last and end all light curve for this system?.. Hey… I played in that candy store right? Certainly not. My light curve was, has, and will be improved upon by those that follow this line of study on this type of star system.

If I sound a bit edged, it’s because I take umbrage at hearing you throw the words and science babble around, as though your views were truth itself. I ask you to step away from the podium and the microscope and understand that theories are `proposed explanations whose status is conjectural’. I’m not going to debate terminology here… I’m telling you that theories are NOT truth… they are best guesses and CAN be altered, modified, refuted, supported, tossed, replaced, etc.

My whole engagement here in this thread was to address (as a teacher of Earth Science) the topic. I explained MY view, and got attacked because (clearly) I wasn’t a member of the evolution candy shop. Dude… my friend… God is bigger than ALL of our theories and conjectures and facts.

Again… I reiterate: God made it… science wants to see how it was done. That has always been my stance from word one on this thread.

If you wish to propose that he did it by Evolution, please do so face to face, not looking down from any degrees you may have in the field. Bring your expertise, not your bravado. Both you and I in our work stand on the shoulders of the giants before us, no? We are not the last word on the theories we use, handle, work on or present. Hence, let there be a shared and brotherly discussion.

After all… its Easter. Jesus is risen, and we won’t find THAT in our research papers or theories.

Peace, love and Eucharist, Bro!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top