Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Silly, silly, silly…Creationism doesn’t get anyone into heaven. Science should never be idolized. Science is just science. It’s not religion. Science isn’t about belief or faith or the here after or salvation or God. Creationism isn’t about those things either.Put your faith in Jesus, and explore science.
Nicely put, Namesake! Old prejudices against science die as hard as old prejudices against religion.
Petrus
 
Silly, silly, silly…

Creationism doesn’t get anyone into heaven. Science should never be idolized. Science is just science. It’s not religion. Science isn’t about belief or faith or the here after or salvation or God. Creationism isn’t about those things either.

Put your faith in Jesus, and explore science.
Gee you guys are thick. 😦 This was a hypothetical that was answering another post.

Perhaps I will phrase it this way.

If “a” is more successful than “b” in getting you into heaven then “a” is a good thing and be careful of “b”. Geessshhhhhh.
 
Sorry, Petrus, but that is a terrible analogy. Something can have multiple characteristics but it can only have one origin. Life was either created by God or in is the result of random mutations acted on by natural selection. The latter view does not need God and trying to introduce God into evolution amounts to putting lipstick on a pig.Gary
Gary, who’s to say pigs of either gender don’t look ravishing in lipstick?

But you’re still missing my point. Evolution describes not an origin but rather a process, that of selective pressures operating upon randomly generated mutations to diversify organic life into what eventually become separate species. Evolution does not argue that God did not create life. If someone does this he is stepping outside the framework of science and into that of physics, especially metaphysics.

Thus, one can be a “creationist” (as am I) who believes that God created the world and allows it to unfold marvelously through galactic and stellar evolution, nucleosynthesis of heavier elements in stars, geological evolution of planets, biological evolution of life on those planets, and cultural and theological evolution within rational species that happen to evolve.

We can eat our cake and still have it! (And male transvestite pigs can wear lipstick, too.)

Petrus
 
If “a” is more successful than “b” in getting you into heaven then “a” is a good thing and be careful of “b”. Geessshhhhhh.
Buffalo, you make "getting into heaven: seem rather like an application process. “Perform the appropriate actions, assent to the correct dogma, fill out forms A-D in triplicate, turn them in at the desk, and you’re done. Have a nice day…I mean, Eternity.”
 
Buffalo, you make "getting into heaven: seem rather like an application process. “Perform the appropriate actions, assent to the correct dogma, fill out forms A-D in triplicate, turn them in at the desk, and you’re done. Have a nice day…I mean, Eternity.”
I believe that our Lord gave us a very simple to understand formula. Believe in Me! That isn’t all that simple to do because of all the ramifications, but it is very simple to understand. It doesn’t require complex theology, it requires simple faith in Him.

Most people can understand that simple concept. Very few people can understand all the intricacies of theology. My guess is that Christ intended His message to be understood by common people, like me.
 
Namesake;3430111Most people can understand that simple concept. Very few people can understand all the intricacies of theology. My guess is that Christ intended His message to be understood by common people said:
Namesake, let me guess – it’s the filling-out-the-heaven-application-in-triplicate part that you resent most.

Petrus
 
Petrus,

You may not have intended to be insulting but essentially you called me stupid for not agreeing with your views on evolution and science in general. Granted you did not use the word ‘stupid’ but I have been told that I don’t understand how science works and I don’t undersand how evolution works. In other words, I’m being told I’m stupid. I find that insulting.
I hesitate to butt in, but it sounds to me like Petrus was pointing out that you were ignorant of certain pieces of knowledge, not stupid.

There is a difference between being stupid and being ignorant.

Happily, ignorance can be reduced by effective teaching, reading, etc. Unhappily, ignorance can be worsened by poor teaching, poor reading, etc.

I am happy to report that coming to these forums, and reading the posts and linked sources from many of the knowledgeable posters, I feel has been very helpful to reducing my own level of ignorance on many topics.🙂
(I’ll bet there are those who would disagree 😃 😃 )
 
(Barbarian points out that creationism is a potent atheist-maker)

It’s quite true. I have listened to many college students, who were told that creationism was Christian belief, only to learn that it couldn’t possibly be true. Many of them assumed that if creationism was false, then Christianity was false, too.

Yes.

**"But eventually, by 1994 I was through with young-earth creationISM. Nothing that young-earth creationists had taught me about geology turned out to be true. I took a poll of my ICR graduate friends who have worked in the oil industry. I asked them one question.

“From your oil industry experience, did any fact that you were taught at ICR, which challenged current geological thinking, turn out in the long run to be true? ,”

That is a very simple question. One man, Steve Robertson, who worked for Shell grew real silent on the phone, sighed and softly said ‘No!’ A very close friend that I had hired at Arco, after hearing the question, exclaimed, “Wait a minute. There has to be one!” But he could not name one. I can not name one. No one else could either. One man I could not reach, to ask that question, had a crisis of faith about two years after coming into the oil industry. I do not know what his spiritual state is now but he was in bad shape the last time I talked to him.

And being through with creationism, I very nearly became through with Christianity. I was on the very verge of becoming an atheist."**
home.entouch.net/dmd/gstory.htm

The loss of faith that creationism causes for Glenn Morton and his fellow creationists working in geology is quite common. It’s one thing to make up new doctrines like creationism; it’s quite another thing when people go out into the world and collide with reality.

The biggest evil of YE creationism, is that it produces atheists.

YE creationism is man’s attempt to revise God’s word. It’s not a good idea. And as you see, it is also destructive to faith.

It is always dangerous to add one’s own ideas to Scripture. There are some forms of OE creationism that are not contrary to Scripture, but the “life ex nihilo” doctrine of YE creationism is directly contrary to Genesis.
“life ex nihilo” is not contrary to Catholic belief. You are among others who point out that the Church allows Catholics to believe the world and man, were created in six days. Now why would the Church allow that? Especially in light of your YEC creates atheists statements? The Church has not ruled infallibly as to the age of the earth. Why do you think that is?

I am certain that the Church is aware of geology.

No, no one is adding anything to Scriptute. For the better part of 1800 years, Christians believed Genesis in a literal way. This is nothing new.

God bless,
Ed
 
“life ex nihilo” is not contrary to Catholic belief.
It sure is. In Genesis, God says that the earth brought forth living things. “Ex nihilo” means “from nothing.” And that’s contrary to Scripture.
You are among others who point out that the Church allows Catholics to believe the world and man, were created in six days.
Yep. But it doesn’t say, even if you take it literally, that living things were created from nothing. It says just the opposite.
Especially in light of your YEC creates atheists statements?
It’s a fact. I gave you some examples.
The Church has not ruled infallibly as to the age of the earth. Why do you think that is?
Nothing in Scripture or tradition rules that it is, and the Church is not about deciding scientific questions.
I am certain that the Church is aware of geology.
Indeed. But none of this has anything to do with the doctrine of “life ex nihilo”, which is directly contradicted by scripture.
No, no one is adding anything to Scriptute. For the better part of 1800 years, Christians believed Genesis in a literal way.
St. Augustine, for example, in “The Literal Meaning of Scripture”, said that the creation days weren’t actually periods of time. What the Church terminology means, maybe isn’t quite you mean by it.
This is nothing new.
Right.
 
“life ex nihilo” Unless you believe in the spontaneous generation of life, God did it. You are reading Scripture in a presumptuous way. First, there was nothing. Then, out of nothing, God created the earth. Then God called forth life. This is Genesis. Period. Nothing vague about it. You choose to believe that God did not do it. That life, and complex codes like DNA, arose spontaneously from dead rock.

God bless,
Ed
 
“life ex nihilo” Unless you believe in the spontaneous generation of life, God did it.
Of course God did it. But you seem dissatisfied with the way He did it.
You are reading Scripture in a presumptuous way.
Rather, you are simply denying what it says. It says the Earth brought forth living things. That’s how He did it. Not “ex nihilo.” Accept what He tells you about it.
First, there was nothing. Then, out of nothing, God created the earth. Then God called forth life.
What Scripture says is that the Earth brought forth living things as God intended. Why does this bother you, Ed?
Nothing vague about it.
You bet. Here’s how He did it:

Genesis 1:24**“And God said: Let the earth bring forth the living creature in its kind, cattle and creeping things, and beasts of the earth, according to their kinds.”**
You choose to believe that God did not do it.
Ed, I’ve repeatedly told you that God did it. Even if he didn’t do it the way you want, He still did it.
That life, and complex codes like DNA, arose spontaneously from dead rock.
As the Bible says, God actually made it happen. He decreed that non-living matter would bring forth living things, and so it did. That’s what it says. Accept it.
 
Nope. The science textbook does not state that. It all came about on its own.

You insisting God did it contradicts the science textbook.

You saying I should believe in evolution does not address the numerous problems with it. The least of which being that random mutation and natural selection brought about living things as we see them today. Look at dogs. Many different skull types and a wide rang of sizes compared to humans. But they are all dogs.

The scientific community wouldn’t support your assertion that God, or any supernatural force, intervened. It was all natural. This is the problem most Christians have with textbook evolution - it’s Godless. You tacking God onto to it does not change that fact.

Peace,
Ed
 
Nope. The science textbook does not state that. It all came about on its own.
Never read a science textbook like that. I don’t think there is one that says God wasn’t involved. It just can’t say one way or the other.
You insisting God did it contradicts the science textbook.
You’re still confused about the difference between not being able to say, and denying His role.
You saying I should believe in evolution does not address the numerous problems with it.
First, it really doesn’t matter if you accept any theory. But you could be leading people astray who might otherwise come to God.
The scientific community wouldn’t support your assertion that God, or any supernatural force, intervened.
Dobzhansky would. So would Ken Miller. Others wouldn’t care.
This is the problem most Christians have with textbook evolution - it’s Godless.
Evolution isn’t about God. Plumbing isn’t either. But most Christians know this, and aren’t bothered with it. I gather you now realize that Scripture explicitly rejects life ex nihilo.
 
If someone does this he is stepping outside the framework of science and into that of physics, especially metaphysics.
Lol! Since when is physics not science? I’m going to assume you mean philosophy…

Whenever I read these forums on evolution vs. creationism, I can’t help thinking of a quote by St. Augustine: “God is not what you imagine or think you understand. If you understand Him, you have failed.” I think C.S. Lewis said something similar in Mere Christianity, about trying to put God into a box. For me, an absolute literal reading of Genesis is like trying to put God into a box, saying we understand everything about Him and His ways.

Accepting the evidence of science does not make our faith any less “pure” or decrease our trust in God as the author of life and the human soul! Science does not “take God out of the equation”, but rather it allows us to use our limited human minds to grasp the workings of the universe around us, and to understand the complexity and beauty of creation. All scientists are not atheists; Dawkins and his ilk are not representative of science or the scientific community by any means.

Science can only complement theology, and never replace it. I’m still just a student, but everyday I am amazed by the beauty which is evident in both theology and science. God brings good out of absolute evil, and out of the greatest evil, He has brought the greatest good. Isn’t this a little like evolution, that out of random events is brought forth order and complexity? 🤷
 
I realize that God can perform miracles, even today. Two miracles are required for each candidate for sainthood. You insist on God behaving a certain way that denies His power. Jesus Christ, as God, raised the dead, gave sight to the blind and removed leprosy. A scientist standing next to Him would say it was impossible.

God created everything from nothing. And just like He can calm the wind in a moment and raise the dead in a moment or change the water to wine in a moment, He can do whatever He wants in a day (and the morning and the evening were the second, and so on, day). But you ignore that reference as if it were not there.

I am concerned about anyone who bases their faith on science. I actually read a post on another forum where a man threatened to turn to atheism if the science he so dearly believed was somehow not accepted. This is the wrong way to approach God.

Here is what is scriptural, The Father draws you to the Son, you accept the Son and the Holy Spirit comes to dwell inside you. That is real. That is a fact.

I believe that evolution science is corrupted and that your constant insistence that everyone simply accept it, and your diligence about it, just raises red flags. The marketing of this idea, and your involvement in it, tells me that the product here is not the ToE but an attempt to convince “rank and file” Catholics to go along with it by using a disingenuous, tacked on reference to God to make it palatable. The goal is a Scientific technocracy that will try to undermine the role of the Church in social policy making.

It will not work.

Peace,
Ed
 
You insist on God behaving a certain way that denies His power.
Ed. I showed you what He said in Genesis. Why will you not accept it?
God created everything from nothing.
God says that living things were brought forth by the Earth. Why are you so unwilling to believe it?
I am concerned about anyone who bases their faith on science.
Me too. How many times have I reminded you that science is unable to deal with the supernatural?
I believe that evolution science is corrupted
But you also believe that God created living things ex nihilo, instead of from the earth. So you can understand why that’s not very persuasive. There’s no conspiracy of scientists. And God did mean what He said in Genesis.
 
Buffalo, you make "getting into heaven: seem rather like an application process. “Perform the appropriate actions, assent to the correct dogma, fill out forms A-D in triplicate, turn them in at the desk, and you’re done. Have a nice day…I mean, Eternity.”
😃 I will have to look in the CCC’s appendix and forward you the application.
 
Lol! Since when is physics not science? I’m going to assume you mean philosophy…

Science can only complement theology, and never replace it. I’m still just a student, but everyday I am amazed by the beauty which is evident in both theology and science. God brings good out of absolute evil, and out of the greatest evil, He has brought the greatest good. Isn’t this a little like evolution, that out of random events is brought forth order and complexity? 🤷
Macian, thank you for the correction. You are quite right that I meant “philosophy,” not “physics.” I was under the influence of an uncomfortable dental procedure today.

I like your expression of the complementarity of science and theology, reminiscent of Ian Barbour’s third way of “dialogue” in Religion in an Age of Science (1992). God certainly does bring order out of random events; God works “in, swith and under the natural order.” I myself have witnessed it worked out dramatically in the case of a dear friend, whose life was rescued from final wreckage through an extraordinary event, an event that was equally susceptible of a purely naturalistic explanation.

Petrus
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top