Explaining the Eucharist as the One Sacrifice

  • Thread starter Thread starter garysibio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

garysibio

Guest
I’ve been talking with an Evangelical who believes that Catholics are re-sacrificing Jesus at the Mass. I had an idea about how I might go about explaining it to him and wanted to bounce it off people here to see what they thought. Here’s what I was thinking:

Since Jesus is God, He is eternal. Therefore, when He sacrificed Himself at Calvary it was an eternal sacrifice. Since His act was eternal, it cannot be limited to a specific time and place therefore the Mass cannot possibly be a re-sacrifice.

What do you think?
 
Think: H.G. Wells’ “The Time Machine”

Mass makes a 2,000 year old sacrifice present in the here and now. God exists outside of time, so His sacrifice is not limited by man’s concept of time. We are present at the foot of the cross at mass. We are present in the upper room at mass. Jesus’ sacrifice never ends, since it is applied to each and every soul who accepts Him. So, it is being made present around the clock in Catholic Churches in each time zone - a perpetual 24/7/365 sacrifice present with us for all time. Remember Jesus saying “I am with you, even to the end of the age”? He is with us at the mass, in the Holy Eucharist.

We offer ourselves to God at the sacrifice, as well as the bread and wine which becomes the Body and Blood of Christ, in obedience to His sacred command to “Do this…”

When they wrap their head around that, tell them that Jesus is present in the Catholic Church and that they can go spend time with Him…
 
From the CCC - 1330
The Holy Sacrifice, **because it makes present the one sacrifice of Christ **the Savior and includes the Church’s offering…

Now, there are two ways in which this can be viewed. First is from our own present viewpoint in which the one sacrifice is “brought forward” to be present to us. The other viewpoint is from the time of the crucifixion, in which we are transported mystically to the crucifix. Either one suffices to make the point.
The Mass is not a “resacrifice”, but a making the one sacrifice present to us.

Peace
James
 
St. Thomas Aquinas talks about how God is pure action, there’s nothing potential about him, there’s nothing that he can be that he isn’t. Every action he takes, he takes in and for all eternity. It can’t be any other way, because otherwise it would mean that he’s within time, that he changes. By definition, in his nature there can be no before or after an action, there’s only a during the action.

So yes, that’s why it’s described in Scripture as an eternal sacrifice: it can’t be repeated because it’s unending.

Read Hebrews 9, in which Paul refers back to the Old covenant sacrifice on the Day of Atonement (Yom Kippur), which is the one day of the year that the High Priest entered the Holy of Holies to offer sacrifice. Pay close attention to verse 24:"For Christ did not enter into a sanctuary made by hands, a copy of the true one, but heaven itself, that he might now appear before God on our behalf."Hebrews was written decades after Christ died on Calvary, and yet Paul specifically says that Christ NOW offers sacrifice on our behalf. Christ was doing it decades after Calvary, and he’s doing it today… because it’s an eternal sacrifice given by the One, whose every act lasts from eternity past to eternity future.

Another thing: he probably rejects the dogma that the Blessed Sacrament is the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of our Lord. He thinks it’s just bread and wine. If that’s the case, he can’t also say that we’re re-sacrificing Christ, because that’s would be an admission that the Sacrament is what we believe it is. He can’t have it both ways.

One of the difficulties with these conversations is that what non-Catholics think we believe is, very often, actually an odd combination of what we really believe, what they think we believe, and what they believe themselves.
 
I’ve been talking with an Evangelical who believes that Catholics are re-sacrificing Jesus at the Mass. I had an idea about how I might go about explaining it to him and wanted to bounce it off people here to see what they thought. Here’s what I was thinking:

Since Jesus is God, He is eternal. Therefore, when He sacrificed Himself at Calvary it was an eternal sacrifice. Since His act was eternal, it cannot be limited to a specific time and place therefore the Mass cannot possibly be a re-sacrifice.

What do you think?
Perhaps it would help were your friend to hear how Catholics express this issue within the context of dialogue. This from a Lutheran / Catholic document:
56.Catholic and Lutheran Christians together recognize that in the Eucharist Jesus Christ “is present as the crucified who died for our sins and rose again for our justification, as the once-for-all sacrifice for the sins of the world”.42 This sacrifice can be neither continued, nor repeated, nor replaced, nor complemented; but rather it can and should become effective ever anew in the midst of the congregation.
prounione.urbe.it/dia-int/l-rc/doc/e_l-rc_eucharist.html

IOW, Catholics agree with Lutherans that it is a once-for-all sacrifice, and Lutherans recognize that Catholic teaching on the subject is not a repeated re-sacrifice.

Jon
 
Saint Paul sums it up (Heb 10:10):
And by that will, we have been made holy through the sacrifice of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.
ONCE, for ALL. Once means Calvary, ALL includes us.

We were not there at the Last Supper, yet we partake of the same consecrated bread and wine as Our Lord changed into his Body and Blood that night. That is why he commanded this first Eucharist be repeated by the Apostles (“do this”).

It is ONE sacrifice for ALL people - not only the people who were there at the time, but us as well. We may ALL partake of the heavenly food and drink. He alluded to this with the Samaritan woman at Jacob’s well, and made it abundantly clear following the multiplication of loaves and fishes (John 6:25-59).
 
As we continue to sin, we continually need a sacrifice for our sins.

As in the passover meal, the sacraficial victim must be consumed to complete the sacrifice.

Only in the mass do we offer again the sacraficial victim to the Father and do we consume the victim that those who consume may be saved.
 
Saint Paul sums it up (Heb 10:10):
ONCE, for ALL. Once means Calvary, ALL includes us.

We were not there at the Last Supper, yet we partake of the same consecrated bread and wine as Our Lord changed into his Body and Blood that night. That is why he commanded this first Eucharist be repeated by the Apostles (“do this”).

It is ONE sacrifice for ALL people - not only the people who were there at the time, but us as well. We may ALL partake of the heavenly food and drink. He alluded to this with the Samaritan woman at Jacob’s well, and made it abundantly clear following the multiplication of loaves and fishes (John 6:25-59).
While I agree with you 1000%, non-Catholics would not. They use this exact same verse to “prove” that the Eucharist is not necessary.
 
I’ve been talking with an Evangelical who believes that Catholics are re-sacrificing Jesus at the Mass. I had an idea about how I might go about explaining it to him and wanted to bounce it off people here to see what they thought. Here’s what I was thinking:

Since Jesus is God, He is eternal. Therefore, when He sacrificed Himself at Calvary it was an eternal sacrifice. Since His act was eternal, it cannot be limited to a specific time and place therefore the Mass cannot possibly be a re-sacrifice.

What do you think?
I would simply go the way of “that’s what is revealed in divine revelation.” Paul in 1 Cor. 10-11 talks about discerning the bread as Jesus’ body and also notes that it is indeed a participation in the blood of Christ.

1 Cor. 10:14-22 (especially v. 20-21) is important because it distinguishes the pagan “sacrifices” on their “table” with the Christian “table” that is a participation in Christ’s blood. You can also reference the “Lord’s table” which is defiled by “pagan sacrifice” in Malachi 1:6-8. Malachi 1:11 follows shortly thereafter in a prophesy of the Eucharist “pure” sacrifice (in contrast to futile pagan sacrifice) ever presented all over the world.

Protestants have long tried to rationalize the text of Hebrews 9:23 where the Greek mentions the superior NT “sacrifices” plural. Catholics or Orthodox or churches that believe in the sacrifice of the Eucharist can understand this passage as the one sacrifice with many re-presentations. Your Evangelical friend must invent meaning for the text external to the words in question.

If your friend has trouble comprehending how one sacrifice can be made many, I would echo what David said about the juxtaposition of the John 6 Eucharist discourse with the miracle of the loaves and fishes where “one” becomes “many” by way of a miracle.
 
I’ve been talking with an Evangelical who believes that Catholics are re-sacrificing Jesus at the Mass. I had an idea about how I might go about explaining it to him and wanted to bounce it off people here to see what they thought. Here’s what I was thinking:

Since Jesus is God, He is eternal. Therefore, when He sacrificed Himself at Calvary it was an eternal sacrifice. Since His act was eternal, it cannot be limited to a specific time and place therefore the Mass cannot possibly be a re-sacrifice.

What do you think?
Hi,

I think it is most unfortunate that an Evangelical would accuse Catholics “re-sacrifcing” Jesus for the simple reason that Christ cannot be sacrificed again and for the simple reason that Catholics don’t teach that Jesus is being “re-sacrificed” in the mass.

Nevertheless, there is something in this objection that Catholics need to take seriously. First, correct me if I’m wrong, but I do believe it is the teaching of Rome that every mass is a unique sacrifice and that the host is “immolated” in the mass. Right? So one could see how one might construe this as a re-sacrifice of Jesus or jump to the conclusion that “Christ dies again” at every mass even though this clearly isn’t Rome’s view.

Still–if this isn’t Rome’s view–what is it? Often I hear Catholics say that the mass–while itself a sacrifice–is at the same time a re-presentation of the one sacrifice on Calvary. This introduces a one-and-the-many problem and raises the question of whether or not the Catholic position is real distinction or a distinction without a difference.

My own view is that the doctrine of the mass developed in the exact opposite trajectory of the argument that the author to the Hebrews elaborates. The entire reason why the Christ’s sacrifice was better and perfect in comparison to the Old Testament sacrifices that Christ’s unique sacrifice fulfilled, was due in part to the fact that it was both once and for all. That is–it’s the non-repeatable nature of the sacrifice that makes it superior to repeated sacrifices. The doctrine of the mass, in contrast, seems to take the opposite tact. The one-non repeatable sacrifice is in a sense “repeated” every time the sacrifice of the mass is offered–because the mass isn’t just a memorial of a sacrifice, but is itself a sacrifice in which an immolation takes place. That seems very hard to square with the argument of Hebrews.
 
As we continue to sin, we continually need a sacrifice for our sins.

As in the passover meal, the sacraficial victim must be consumed to complete the sacrifice.

Only in the mass do we offer again the sacraficial victim to the Father and do we consume the victim that those who consume may be saved.
Evan, I like your explanation here, but you fall into the trap over the “repeated sacrafice” when you say, “Only in the mass do we offer again the sacraficial victim…” I know that is not what you mean so I would suggest changing your wording to:
Only in the mass may we partake of the one sacraficial victim…

What do you think?

Peace
James
 
While I agree with you 1000%, non-Catholics would not. They use this exact same verse to “prove” that the Eucharist is not necessary.
Yes, I know - that’s why I like it so much. They think it proves the Eucharist is unnecessary, while I use the plain wording of the exact same verse to establish that it is for everyone. It pulls the rug out from under their feet.

Now it’s time to grab Acts and show that the Apostles continued “in the breaking of the bread,” and how Jesus was recognized by the two disciples ONLY after he said Mass (even though they had been walking with him for hours).

And then hop over to 1Cor where Paul says “he received from the Lord what I handed on to you…” and immediately recounts the Last Supper (and he wasn’t there, yet says he has received it from the Lord, and he handed it on to the Corinthians). If the prots interpretation of Ephesians is correct, then Jesus would have handed it on, not Paul. This is an easy passage to find in a red-letter Bible because it’s the only passage in the epistles with red letters.

And then John 6.
 
Evan, I like your explanation here, but you fall into the trap over the “repeated sacrafice” when you say, “Only in the mass do we offer again the sacraficial victim…” I know that is not what you mean so I would suggest changing your wording to:
Only in the mass may we partake of the one sacraficial victim…

What do you think?

Peace
James
That’s true. For there is no new sacrifice, but the victim is re-presented, not to the Father who is present at all time, but for the people who are living in a timeline.

We had a priest in my parish who was getting his Ph.D. in Eucharist and he loaned me some books. In them it was explained that there is only one Mass, which we intersect with as we travel through time, or perhaps re-encounter. It is the mass described in revelation, the wedding feast of the Lamb. An eternal sacrifice that we partake in each time we re-enter the wedding feast at mass.

As the Holy Spirit takes our simple offerings of bread and wine and ‘brings them’ to the wedding feast, they become the body and blood of the victim, there already and eternally, and we receive them back that we may enter into the feast by consuming the victim.
 
Perhaps it would help were your friend to hear how Catholics express this issue within the context of dialogue. This from a Lutheran / Catholic document:

prounione.urbe.it/dia-int/l-rc/doc/e_l-rc_eucharist.html

IOW, Catholics agree with Lutherans that it is a once-for-all sacrifice, and Lutherans recognize that Catholic teaching on the subject is not a repeated re-sacrifice.

Jon
During the Refomation Mass continued to be said in many places where Lutheranism had taken root. One of the chief of Luther’s objectives was to combat the Mass as a sacrifice. He expressed this quite openly to Henry VIII in 1522:

“If I succeed in doing away with the Mass, then I shall believe I have completely conquered the pope. On the Mass, as on a rock, the whole of the papacy is based, with its monasteries, bishoprics, colleges, altars, services and doctrines . . . If the sacrilegious and cursed custom of Mass is overthrown, then the whole must fall.” - Contra Henricum regem Angliae

You guys have come a long way from your founders game plan.
 
Hi,

I think it is most unfortunate that an Evangelical would accuse Catholics “re-sacrifcing” Jesus for the simple reason that Christ cannot be sacrificed again and for the simple reason that Catholics don’t teach that Jesus is being “re-sacrificed” in the mass.

Nevertheless, there is something in this objection that Catholics need to take seriously. First, correct me if I’m wrong, but I do believe it is the teaching of Rome that every mass is a unique sacrifice and that the host is “immolated” in the mass. Right? So one could see how one might construe this as a re-sacrifice of Jesus or jump to the conclusion that “Christ dies again” at every mass even though this clearly isn’t Rome’s view.

Still–if this isn’t Rome’s view–what is it? Often I hear Catholics say that the mass–while itself a sacrifice–is at the same time a re-presentation of the one sacrifice on Calvary. This introduces a one-and-the-many problem and raises the question of whether or not the Catholic position is real distinction or a distinction without a difference.

My own view is that the doctrine of the mass developed in the exact opposite trajectory of the argument that the author to the Hebrews elaborates. The entire reason why the Christ’s sacrifice was better and perfect in comparison to the Old Testament sacrifices that Christ’s unique sacrifice fulfilled, was due in part to the fact that it was both once and for all. That is–it’s the non-repeatable nature of the sacrifice that makes it superior to repeated sacrifices. The doctrine of the mass, in contrast, seems to take the opposite tact. The one-non repeatable sacrifice is in a sense “repeated” every time the sacrifice of the mass is offered–because the mass isn’t just a memorial of a sacrifice, but is itself a sacrifice in which an immolation takes place. That seems very hard to square with the argument of Hebrews.
Wow…Miguel, you and I are running into each other on these forums in a different thread.

Couple points to bring up. Christ’s Sacrifice on the Cross was one and unique Sacrifice. This same Sacrifice is the One, Unique Sacrifice of the Church. This Sacrifice is to be offered by the Church. This Sacrifice of the Church is what is found in the Sacrifice of the Mass. So, in other words, Christ’s Sacrifice on the Cross is the very exact same Sacrifice of the Mass. The Sacrifice is nothing different other than how it is offered. As for “immolation,” yes, it is appropriate to say that Christ is immolated on the Altar. How? Because Christ IS immolated on the Cross, and this immolation becomes present in the Mass on the Altar.

Please explain how this is in contradiction to the Book of Hebrews…in fact I believe this is what Hebrews in saying.

Please raise objections…because it goes much much deeper than this.
 
Still–if this isn’t Rome’s view–what is it? Often I hear Catholics say that the mass–while itself a sacrifice–is at the same time a re-presentation of the one sacrifice on Calvary. This introduces a one-and-the-many problem and raises the question of whether or not the Catholic position is real distinction or a distinction without a difference.
Since Calvary is the only way a person’s sin can be forgiven and no one here existed at the time of Calvary, Calvary must be somehow made present to forgive our sins.
 
During the Refomation Mass continued to be said in many places where Lutheranism had taken root. One of the chief of Luther’s objectives was to combat the Mass as a sacrifice. He expressed this quite openly to Henry VIII in 1522:

“If I succeed in doing away with the Mass, then I shall believe I have completely conquered the pope. On the Mass, as on a rock, the whole of the papacy is based, with its monasteries, bishoprics, colleges, altars, services and doctrines . . . If the sacrilegious and cursed custom of Mass is overthrown, then the whole must fall.” - Contra Henricum regem Angliae

You guys have come a long way from your founders game plan.
Notice, here, he is talking about customs of the Mass. The sacrifice of the Mass, as Luther says. And this is still a bone of contention. Lutherans willingly describe the sacrifice as one of praise and thanksgiving.
Private masses, etc? These were the true issue of the time.

And you are, when one reads the documents that are the fruits of ecumenical dialogue, both sides have come a long way in filtering through the misunderstandings.

Jon
 
Notice, here, he is talking about customs of the Mass. The sacrifice of the Mass, as Luther says. And this is still a bone of contention. Lutherans willingly describe the sacrifice as one of praise and thanksgiving.
Private masses, etc? These were the true issue of the time.

And you are, when one reads the documents that are the fruits of ecumenical dialogue, both sides have come a long way in filtering through the misunderstandings.

Jon
Filter through this then.

The child of God, the saint, is according to the Church’s view essentially a creation of grace, a child of the eternal Love. And since it is a function of Christ and of Christianity to bring the love and grace of God to sense-bound man under the veil of visible and evident signs, therefore the first and chief duty of the Church’s educative activity is the sacramental mediation of the grace of Christ. The seven sacraments are God’s appointed means, whereby man will ordinarily experience the action of the grace of Christ, the elevation of his being into the stream of God’s life and love. This does not mean that extraordinary ways and activities of grace are excluded.

On the other hand - and here is the chief distinction between Catholic and the orthodox Lutheran conceptions - man is not purely passive under the action of grace like some lifeless stone or log. As the Church conceives original sin, the natural religious moral endowment of man was not destroyed by that sin, so that as the Lutheran “Formula of Concord” expresses it “no spark of spiritual power was left him for the knowledge of truth and accomplishment of good.” Man’s religious and moral faculties are not impaired in their natural substance, but weakened in their operation, inasmuch as original sin deflects them from their supernatural course and gives them therefore a false direction. The effect of grace, as the up-surging of the eternal love within him, is to bring a man’s faculties back again into their original course, and so to disengage them completely and set them free. Therefore grace is not merely compassionate mercy, nor is it like some brilliant cloak of gold thrown over the human corpse. On the contrary the Church conceives of it a vital force, which awakens and summons the powers of man’s soul, understanding, will and feeling, inspires them with a new love, with a new fear of God and His judgments, with a new yearning for transcendent holiness and infinite goodness. When grace thus works on the sinner, continually urging him on with its secret gold to the heights, it produces in man those spiritual acts of faith, fear and trust which are the preparation on the human side for justification. The justification itself which follows these acts is the sole work of God. In the sacrament of baptism or penance God answers the appeal of the penitent with His kiss of forgiving love: “I baptise thee, I absolve thee.”

I seems to me that reading through many of your posts you seem to be waiting for Rome to come around and accept the Lutheran conception of justification. If I am correct in my observation, your waiting will be in vain.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top