Falling Out of Love With Wife

  • Thread starter Thread starter HopefulShepherd
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The only time love is a choice is when you start falling in love with someone and you decide to stay in the relationship and see what happens.Other than that, love can’t be turned off and on like a switch.

I am legally separated from my husband, NOT at my choice. The way it’s been explained to me, no sin has been committed until either one of us sleeps with a person or we marry a person in a civil ceremony - since without an Annulment neither of us could remarry in the Catholic church.
This latter part is correct, of course. The feeling here is that the original poster has not tried as hard as he needs to to preserve his marriage and family. He does not appear to have a compelling reason for taking such a drastic action which can lead to the sins you mentioned.
As for love being turned on and off like a switch, love in marriage is possible to be under one’s control, unlike infatuation. It is posible to rekindle when one partner has been badly wronged, as I will attest. I really did not see how I could possibly re-enter my marriage after being betrayed, but my adult son asked me if I really wanted to negate all the years that had come before and destroy the entire family for the sake of my pride, which is what I was contemplating. My husband was desperately anxious to keep our marriage alive, but I was certain it was dead, and wanted to escape as it was not the “perfect” marriage I thought it was.
We are happier now then ever, with the crisis, which both a priest and a psychologist described as a nervous breakdown due to stress st my hubsnd’s job, several years behind us. I had to make a deliberate decision to love when I felt no love, but I did feel compassion for my husband. You owe at least that to your spouse. The OP does not sound like he has much understanding of his wife at all.
 
Thank you for being “on my side” and thank you all for fighting for a marriage. I see that as a positive thing, and yes, divorce is, and must always bee, the last option.

One small thing though, I, my self, and maybe a few other need to take a long look at our self because so far we have been to busy, and I am most likely the main cause to it, to twist words and let other read our thoughts that we have totally forgotten one person, the OP. I think we have not really being helpful. So, I am sorry. I think I have to take the blame on this one. I really hope your marriage will be saved if that is what you really want. I am sure that you still have a few options to try and I will pray for you. And what ever you do, never think that you are alone. If you need someone to “talk” with send me a PM, I will answer as soon as I can. And one more time, I am sorry for the fact that I am responsible for the fact that your question got derailed. God bless you.
 
This is really hard to write, because I feel like a bad person, but I have nowhere else to really turn and I want to be as honest as possible. My wife and I have been together for almost 10 years. We’ve been married for about 4, and have a beautiful child together.

Although we’ve been married for 4 years, I’ve had doubts about our relationship even before we were married. I went through with the wedding, because I had a terminally ill parent and wanted them to be at my wedding I almost left my wife a few months into the marriage (I understand it was wrong, but I was very unhappy), and then I found-out she was pregnant.

Now it’s two years later and there is little to no affection between us (I don’t mean sex either, because that is not the issue, but when we do she is even rather un-affectionate in that as well). We don’t fight that much, but there is just this absence of warmth and/or feelings of love on both sides (I believe the blame lies somewhere in the middle). Please don’t get me wrong, I would never get a divorce, because I wouldn’t do that to God, or our child. But I am incredibly unhappy, and the longer time goes on, the more unattracted I become to her physically and as a person.

I’ve talked to several priests about this, but didn’t get any real advice except to pray and hang in there. I realize that our vows were until death, but it’s a depressing thought that her dying is the only way out of this unhappiness.

I’m sorry to babble on, and I’m not even sure if anyone will read this, but I just need to vent. Prayers and patience haven’t really helped. I almost resent seeing happy couples, because I haven’t felt that in so long. I’m just so frustrated, and at times recently that frustration has boiled over and been taken out on the wrong people or situations. I never expected it to be easy, but I never thought it would be this hard.

Thanks for reading. Has anyone been through this? Or have any advice?
Brother in Christ -

I am the spouse of a wife who has “fallen out of love”. My wife gave me the I love you, but not “in” love with you several years ago. I would encourage you to look at a few of my original posts to see a bit of my journey.

I was at first devastated to hear those words and typically true of our gender, dove headfirst into “fixing” my marriage. After a long battle of reading dozens of books, seeking professional help (as a couple and individually) and generally trying to coerce my wife back into the marriage, it hit rock bottom.

It was only then did I realize love is a choice. There was nothing I could do to “convince” my wife to love me again (we had a wonderful marriage before that…everyone was envious of us!), she would have to decide on her own. That was were my faith deepened tremendously! To this day I am so greatful to my wife for telling me those words as it has brought me much closer to the Lord! (BTW, I tell my wife that as well!)

Here we are a few years later, much happier than we were before. My wife still is struggling in the marriage; we have not been intimate in several years, she rarely kisses me, I have to initate a hug when she comes home, etc. But I will tell you, it is far better than all the anger, bitterness and comtempt we felt toward each other before.

Now let me also say, I am no saint…far from it! But through a daily rosary, regular confession and a ton of prayer I am able to understand the love Christ has for each one of us. And it is my vocation to love my wife as He loves us…unconditionally. Like I said, I fail regularly, mostly in my heart now, and that’s where regular confession has been so wonderful a sacrament for me. If Christ can forgive me for my sins, I certainly can forgive my wife for what I might percieve as an indiscretion toward me.

We have two children as well. They are observant little buggers too! And now I get to use our marriage as a teaching tool for them. Our kids understand that love and marriage is a continually sacrifice. They know that my priority is God, their mom and them. They know that without it being in that order, it will break down very quickly (as it did in the past). Basically what I am saying is you can control what your children see. They will see a bitter marriage only if you make it bitter.

Do I miss my wife and her affection? Tremendously. But I know in my heart, through a ton of prayer, she will come back to me. She grew up watching a horrible marriage with her parents. Her father was verbally and emotionally abusive toward her mother. I understand the baggage she carries and have empathy for that. That makes it easier to understand her behavior. It is my duty, promised to her in front of God on our wedding day to show her what a wonderful and beautiful marriage she has and love her as she deserves to be loved! It is my vocation to help her get to heaven!

It took her years to get to the point she did. I know it will take years for her to get back. I have learned much about patience and sacrifice and I have much more to learn. I have learned to find great joy in my sacrifice for my wife. That is love to me.

I love your moniker, HopefulShepard! Be that for your family! You are their shepard. Let Christ be yours and He will show you the path! Trust me, it is well illuminated! In our sin, we turn away from it and the path is dark and miserable. Prayer is a wonderful thing to help you stay on the path. And by the sounds of it, that is the wise counsel of the priests you’ve spoken too. Keep at it, open yourself to Christ coming fully into your heart.

A dear priest who helped me through my darkest time told me once, “many walk with Christ, but few encounter Him”. If you let Him into your heart, you will be amazed at the miracles He will grant you!

I am praying for you and your family. God bless!
 
I cringe when I read this. Catholics should not be encouraging others, especially another Catholic, to get a divorce, unless it is a situation involving abuse. And it is not true that kids are better off with divorced parents. Divorce is deeply harmful to children. Marriage is a covenant, for life. And for all practical purposes, there is no difference between taking marriage vows “to” God and “before” God.

No. Divorce should not even be on the table as an option here. The focus should be on saving the marriage and renewing the love and committment that they have promised to one another.
See the bolded statement above. English Teacher is 100% right. The ‘good divorce better than a bad marriage’ meme is cover for people attempting to assuage their own guilt, and it is poison to marriages in difficulty.
 
The only time love is a choice is when you start falling in love with someone and you decide to stay in the relationship and see what happens.Other than that, love can’t be turned off and on like a switch.

I am legally separated from my husband, NOT at my choice. The way it’s been explained to me, no sin has been committed until either one of us sleeps with a person or we marry a person in a civil ceremony - since without an Annulment neither of us could remarry in the Catholic church.
First paragraph: everyone on has a room in their house with double light switches, where one can turn on/off the light from two different entrances to the room. Imagine a situation just like that except both switches have to be turned on for the light to go on. I would say love can be turned on and off like a one of these dual switches, where both spouses have to hit the switch.

As to the second paragraph, and I am NOT speculating on you or your husband’s sinfulness; from a general standpoint it is wrong. A separation/divorce in and of itself can certainly be sinful for one or both people involved: even without subsequent adulterous activity.
 
Brother in Christ -

I am the spouse of a wife who has “fallen out of love”. My wife gave me the I love you, but not “in” love with you several years ago. I would encourage you to look at a few of my original posts to see a bit of my journey.

I was at first devastated to hear those words and typically true of our gender, dove headfirst into “fixing” my marriage. After a long battle of reading dozens of books, seeking professional help (as a couple and individually) and generally trying to coerce my wife back into the marriage, it hit rock bottom.

It was only then did I realize love is a choice. There was nothing I could do to “convince” my wife to love me again (we had a wonderful marriage before that…everyone was envious of us!), she would have to decide on her own. That was were my faith deepened tremendously! To this day I am so greatful to my wife for telling me those words as it has brought me much closer to the Lord! (BTW, I tell my wife that as well!)

Here we are a few years later, much happier than we were before. My wife still is struggling in the marriage; we have not been intimate in several years, she rarely kisses me, I have to initate a hug when she comes home, etc. But I will tell you, it is far better than all the anger, bitterness and comtempt we felt toward each other before.

Now let me also say, I am no saint…far from it! But through a daily rosary, regular confession and a ton of prayer I am able to understand the love Christ has for each one of us. And it is my vocation to love my wife as He loves us…unconditionally. Like I said, I fail regularly, mostly in my heart now, and that’s where regular confession has been so wonderful a sacrament for me. If Christ can forgive me for my sins, I certainly can forgive my wife for what I might percieve as an indiscretion toward me.

We have two children as well. They are observant little buggers too! And now I get to use our marriage as a teaching tool for them. Our kids understand that love and marriage is a continually sacrifice. They know that my priority is God, their mom and them. They know that without it being in that order, it will break down very quickly (as it did in the past). Basically what I am saying is you can control what your children see. They will see a bitter marriage only if you make it bitter.

Do I miss my wife and her affection? Tremendously. But I know in my heart, through a ton of prayer, she will come back to me. She grew up watching a horrible marriage with her parents. Her father was verbally and emotionally abusive toward her mother. I understand the baggage she carries and have empathy for that. That makes it easier to understand her behavior. It is my duty, promised to her in front of God on our wedding day to show her what a wonderful and beautiful marriage she has and love her as she deserves to be loved! It is my vocation to help her get to heaven!

It took her years to get to the point she did. I know it will take years for her to get back. I have learned much about patience and sacrifice and I have much more to learn. I have learned to find great joy in my sacrifice for my wife. That is love to me.

I love your moniker, HopefulShepard! Be that for your family! You are their shepard. Let Christ be yours and He will show you the path! Trust me, it is well illuminated! In our sin, we turn away from it and the path is dark and miserable. Prayer is a wonderful thing to help you stay on the path. And by the sounds of it, that is the wise counsel of the priests you’ve spoken too. Keep at it, open yourself to Christ coming fully into your heart.

A dear priest who helped me through my darkest time told me once, “many walk with Christ, but few encounter Him”. If you let Him into your heart, you will be amazed at the miracles He will grant you!

I am praying for you and your family. God bless!
This is both heart-breaking and extremely beautiful, all at the same time. Bless you!!
 
The only time love is a choice is when you start falling in love with someone and you decide to stay in the relationship and see what happens.Other than that, love can’t be turned off and on like a switch.

I am legally separated from my husband, NOT at my choice. The way it’s been explained to me, no sin has been committed until either one of us sleeps with a person or we marry a person in a civil ceremony - since without an Annulment neither of us could remarry in the Catholic church.
Well, yes and no. The obligation of marriage is not purely negative, a matter of avoiding what you may not do. There is a positive obligation to nurture the life of the relationship, to the extent that the choice exists. Still, it can happen that a couple may separate with the bond remaining without anyone else being able to leap to any conclusions that one or both spouses must be offending God. The duty is real, but there is not a moral obligation to do the impossible.

This is a matter for pastoral care, because of course very few people go into marriage knowing what difficulties might arise. We should not assume we know what kind of heroism or failure is going on in other people’s marriages. The main message for the OP is that the willingness to be heroic in an effort to nurture or save a marriage is part and parcel of the vocation. There are no guarantees, though, even for the heroic. The other message is that it is worth getting help when things become difficult. Being willing to suffer is not enough, and “hanging in there” alone very often won’t stop the kind of slide the OP describes.

Mostly, though, the rest of us need to encourage others in their marriages, but also to treat those having difficulties as going through something that those on the outside can’t really know. It is not as if objective wrong can’t exist, but rather that in a particular case we usually have no business and insufficient knowledge to make a judgment. We can and ought to encourage and we can and ought to defend the truth, but we have to stop short of thinking we know someone else’s life.
 
I am sorry for those disagree but “falling out of love” is not a good enough reason to divorce. Speaking as a child of a broken home, it is horribly painful. Sure, my parents went on and proclaimed that all was well but forgot to check with me. To this day there are problems resulting from my parents’ selfish action of divorce.
I no longer consult with them over holidays because they decided to get divorced and refuse to attend the same functions. So they’re basically out of my family loop unless they play by my rules.
Me? I have been married 27 years. Were they all happy? No. But we gritted our teeth through the bad times and drank champagne in the good years. And I fully expect to be married unto death. Divorce is simply not an option.
Of course, I am very blessed. My DH treats me with cherishing love.
 
  1. Read Eph 5. All of it. Then read it again. and again. Then memorize the part about husbands loving wives as Christ loved the church. Repeat to yourself 5 times a day, every day.
  2. Fast. Join e5men.org
  3. Pray. Adoration and daily mass, if at all possible. this is your vocation. Your job to get her to heaven. You will be held accountable for your part in this, so treat it like YOUR avenue to get to heaven. Go to confession often. Confess every detailed thing that you do/have done that has been hurtful or harmful to your wife. Pray that, as you are one flesh, your heart breaks when hers breaks. Find saints to intercede. Pray to her guardian angel. Mary will be top notch in this battle.
  4. Serve your wife. Be a servant. Give of yourself so utterly and completely that it hurts. If you are doing price comparisons on an item, many people write off the cheapest price tag because it usually has less value. If you have to work harder (pay more), we value it more and take care of it more. Your wife’s price tag is your WHOLE LIFE. Be a gift-- self-gift, like Christ, you will value her. Watch Fireproof, and do the love dare (yes, cheesy movie, but good message)
  5. Pray together. Every day. LEAD HER TO HEAVEN. Pray for her. Pray for her to get to heaven, for her health and for her happiness.
  6. Make sure you are giving money to charity/church. Puts God and money in the right order of priorities.
Do this for several months and come back here and let me know how things are going.
 
You cannot “Fall” out of love. Love is a choice. Sometimes we have to make it again and again, day after day, week after week, month after month, year after year. You did choose your wife. Work on yourself with your priest or with a faithful Catholic counselor. You chose your wife for six years prior to marrying, you chose to enter into marriage, with a sexual relationship that resulted in a new life. You must keep on choosing to love your wife and your child. The answer to your problems lies within you. Your obligation is to discover for yourself how to truly love someone. Practice acting with love toward your wife every day, join with her in prayer, choose to devote yourself to your chosen vocation : husband and father. Feelings are not facts. I will pray for you in this time of temptation Ask Jesus to show you how to be a good and faithful husband and father and He will do it.
 
I guess my definition of love is very different from many of the posters here. I believe we do not have control over the emotions we feel. We do have control over how we act upon the emotions. How many of us would have chosen to fall in love with the person that we did? After almost 2 years I can say that I still love the husband that left me with no warning. If he said he wanted to try counseling I would. But, I can say that I don’t like big parts of his personality now, nor do I trust him much. If I could turn off the emotion of loving him I would have more than a year ago.
 
I guess my definition of love is very different from many of the posters here. I believe we do not have control over the emotions we feel. We do have control over how we act upon the emotions. How many of us would have chosen to fall in love with the person that we did? After almost 2 years I can say that I still love the husband that left me with no warning. If he said he wanted to try counseling I would. But, I can say that I don’t like big parts of his personality now, nor do I trust him much. If I could turn off the emotion of loving him I would have more than a year ago.
Hmmm…you’re talking about lots of things. Can we choose who we feel affection for? Not entirely, and although we can cultivate affection for someone if we choose to, most of us would much prefer the person for whom affection came automatically. You’re right about that. Still, automatic affection had better not be the only reason we married our spouse. If we don’t think about whether or not the person has the character to stay in a hard situation because it is the right thing to do, we’re on very dangerous ground, and could easily find ourselves attempting an impossible marriage.

Even after marriage, no, you don’t have control over your emotions. Your feelings tell you how you are doing, not the other way around. Still, you do have control over your habitual thoughts. A lot of what makes us “fall out of love” has to do with how we have managed or failed to manage our habitual thoughts about our spouse and about our marriage. If the habitual thoughts of one spouse towards the other run towards contempt, personal attacks, defensiveness (my faults aren’t as bad as hers or are really her fault), or avoidance, that marriage is in very serious trouble. Likewise, if we habitually cultivate positive thoughts about our spouses and voice them, we are more likely to feel positively about our spouse.

Having said that…this doesn’t mean that human relationships are mind over matter. There is a reason you don’t trust your husband. He has given you reason to believe you can’t depend on him. He has failed to meet your expectations. Had those been unspoken expectations, that would not be fair of you. What he has done, though, is to seriously violate the plain meaning of your wedding vows. When one spouse chooses to sin habitually and/or seriously, that doesn’t render a marriage invalid. It can, however, render the common conjugal life too much to endure. It takes two to make a marriage work, but in the end it only takes one to ruin one.

Good marriages can be ruined, and they can be ruined by one spouse alone. Even though it doesn’t render a valid marriage invalid, that kind of choices can still make the common conjugal life too difficult. The Church recognizes this. Still, even when divorce is morally permissible, it is still ardently to be avoided. It is more like an amputation than anything else. That is the kind of “option” that it is. I’m not saying that you’re saying otherwise, but to clarify that it is far better to try to mend a marriage than to divorce, even if the supporting emotions aren’t there.
 
I guess my definition of love is very different from many of the posters here. I believe we do not have control over the emotions we feel. We do have control over how we act upon the emotions. How many of us would have chosen to fall in love with the person that we did? After almost 2 years I can say that I still love the husband that left me with no warning. If he said he wanted to try counseling I would. But, I can say that I don’t like big parts of his personality now, nor do I trust him much. If I could turn off the emotion of loving him I would have more than a year ago.
Jahosacat –

I can empathize with you. There are some days I feel like my wife will up and leave as well. She has left me at some level emotionally… but I still love her. And I have to continually show her my love through my actions.

The evil one has done his work poisoning the definition of love in western, secular society. Individualism, minimalism and particularly hedonism seem to define love today. If it doesn’t “feel” good to “me” then “I” need to “feel” better and “I” will take the easy way out…which sadly is usually divorce. That last statement is purely my opinion based on observation and no judgment on you.

Literally billions of people have married in arranged marriages and billions still do. I have observed many of them and I see loving couples. Clearly, both spouses need to be invested in that mindset for it to work. I sometimes wonder where we have gone so horribly wrong with marriage in western culture that we have such a high divorce rate. One only has to watch this section on CAF to see the frequency of posts on troubled marriages.

Do we “feel” love? Most certainly! It feels wonderful! Do we control those feelings? I respectfully submit we do, maybe to a degree more than we know or like to admit (as individuals). There have been a number of studies of brain functionality that point to actions leading to feelings. I have no links to provide, only anecdotal remarks of things I have read in the past.

I am truly sorry for what happened to you. I empathize with you, I do. Of all my prayers, I ask the Virgin Mother to pray to strengthen bad marriages and help us get back to where strong marriages are the norm. It is the foundation of our society. It gives me strength to fight as hard as I do for my marriage, so I (and someday with my wife) can show our children what a strong marriage is. So they can be successful in their future marriages.
 
I read the original post not the following four pages, so I am not sure if this suggestion has been offered…

You both need to read the book 5 Love Languages. My wife and I did and I know many others have. It is amazing. It is written by a Christian doctor and has helped many people. He has a website and a number of books. I read the “men’s” edition, while the “standard” edition is fine for everybody.

Good luck and God bless!
 
I cringe when I read this. Catholics should not be encouraging others, especially another Catholic, to get a divorce, unless it is a situation involving abuse. And it is not true that kids are better off with divorced parents. Divorce is deeply harmful to children. Marriage is a covenant, for life. And for all practical purposes, there is no difference between taking marriage vows “to” God and “before” God.

No. Divorce should not even be on the table as an option here. The focus should be on saving the marriage and renewing the love and committment that they have promised to one another.
I think if both you and your wife are motivated to do a couples encounter and you both want your marriage to work, there is no reason to divorce. Marriage requires a lot of work. But if you are both up for it, go for it!

My parents were never in love. They stayed married until I was 21. I grew up with a very poor model of a relationship. My parents divorce was a blessing for us kids. My dad has since remarried and although it hurts, I do see that he is truly happy with his new wife. And is having a fulfilling marriage. Indeed, with this marriage he has even returned to faith in God.

My mom, too, has found peace as a single woman. Indeed, I have found peace. Living with my parents from childhood until emerging adulthood was so difficult. My parents passive-aggressiveness and unwillingness to compromise and unwillingness to fix their marriage (my mom wanted to, my dad did not) was toxic in my life. It certainly added to my allostatic load.

So, yes, marriage is good. But only if both people want it. Otherwise, even if it isn’t so clearly abuse, it can be bad for kids.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top