Father Peter Stravinskas: Shame!

  • Thread starter Thread starter mauman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mauman

Guest
Today on the Al Kresta show (Ave Maria Radio), Al Kresta interviewed Father Peter Stravinskas about Sister Sandra Schneiders.

Kresta: “An influential American nun has called for ‘non-violent resistance’ against the Vatican investigation of womens’ religious orders. In an email message to colleagues that has now been published by the National Catholic Reporter, Sister Sandra Schneiders says that the apostolic vistitation recently announced by the Vatican will be ‘aggressive and dishonest.’ And she has said that religious orders cannot prevent the Vatican inquiry. However, we can receive them politely and kindly for what they are: uninvited guests who should be received in the parlor – not given the run of the house. When people ask questions they shouldn’t ask, the question should be answered accordingly. Joining me right now to discuss this incident: Father Peter Stravinskas – scholar, author, apologist, founder of the priestly society of the Venerable John Henry Cardinal Newman, and Newman Press. Father, good to have you back.”

Fr. Stravinskas: “Good to be with you, Al.”

Kresta: “I don’t know what to say. This is just – first of all, it’s rude, it’s just plain rude. What is she talking about?”

Fr. Stravinskas: “Well, I think in some sense, it’s like when an animal is cornered. The response is beyond all imagining – it’s totally out of proportion. In fact sometimes you’re even trying to, you know, heal the wounds on such a beast. And unfortunately, you know, the animal strikes back or bites or snarls. And some people are going to find the image I’m using rather unappealing, applied to women religious. Unfortunately, that’s the only image that one could conjure up from that kind of immoderate, intemperate response.”

Kresta: “Yeah.”

OK. I know that Al Kresta, as well as most orthodox Catholics disdain lower animals. (What they have done to deserve their horrible fate escapes me.) Is there any doubt how Fr. Stravinskas sees women?

A thought: how much of the billions of dollars the Church has shelled out because of the sex scandals has been due to women religious?

Anyone?
 
Orthodox Catholic, as opposed to…what? Unfathiful Catholics? Really, I have no words to speak. Nothing I say will change your mind, so I’ll just pray for you.
 
Is there any doubt how Fr. Stravinskas sees women?/quote]

I’m sure Fr. Peter sees women, and especially women religious, as a wonderful gift to the church. I prayerfully and financially support a couple of women religious orders, so I too see the value and dignity of women religious. However, it is abundantly clear that Fr. Peter is addressing Sr. Schneider’s pompous, presumptuous and prideful response to the Vatican visitations. What the heck is she fearful of? What is she hiding? I agree with Fr. Peter’s statement, and I’m sure he would make a similar analogy if a men’s religious organization made such statements as Sr. Schneider did. So please do not make this a gender issue… it is clearly an issue of whether an organization who claims to be Catholic is indeed faithful to the Magisterium.
 
mauman, I think it would be juvenile to extrapolate Fr Stravinskas’ comments on the behaviour of a certain Sr Schneiders to his opinion of women in general. His analogy, clearly on the action and response of certain women religious to the Apostolic Visitation, is a valid way of redescribing and naming what he sees that action and response are: irrational and out-of-proportion. It impunges nothing about the dignity of women at all in the excerpt. Analogies are not perfect, and it would be silly to try to find a parallel to everything in an analogy.

I would consider the Sr’s call to resistance and to arms as far more shameful. It denigrates the person of the Apostolic Vistator, and the agencies of the Holy See who are motivated by a desire for true reform and renewal of the religious life in the US. It is a scandal to call on other religious to oppose the legitimate authority of the Pope and the Bishops, and an blatant invitation to flirt with the father of lies. It is the ugly head of the primodial serpant, rearing its head as it once did in the Garden of Eden, when he tempted Eve to assert herself against God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top