I didn’t actually vote because I have to admit I can’t remember most of the songs on the list. I have never like the song Immaculate Mary, probably because of the way we sang it in grade school…im MAC u late MA ry your PRAISES we sing…Maybe you have to hear Maybe you need to hear 500 grade schoolers sing it to get the same sound in your head that I have.
I love the Gregorian Ave Maria which was the only one we ever used when I was a kid. Even at a wedding, that’s what we sang. There was a different Ave Maria at my wedding, but I’m not sure I remember the composer’s name, something like Rosewig or Rosensweig. I do like that one too, but the Schubert has lost it’s charm for me. I’ve heard it mangled and seen people ice skate to it, and even been in Blossom Time’s chorus about 35 years ago.
I like I Know That My Redeemer Lives, the one that has the next line goes The one that calls me home. NOT the one that says He lives over and over and ends the first verse with my ever living head. I don’t like that one at all, not the words and I can’t sing it well because there’s no place to breathe in a couple lines.
An old song I’ve only recently learned is In Christ There Is No East or West, and I really like that. I wouldn’t call it a Catholic song specifically, but I like the melody and words, and there’s plenty of time to breathe.