FBI admits using drones to spy in US

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

markomalley

Guest
From The Hill:
The FBI uses drones to watch specific targets within the United States, bureau Director Robert Mueller revealed on Wednesday.
The news seemed to catch lawmakers by surprise, prompting calls for more oversight and scrutiny of the FBI’s use of unmanned aircraft for domestic surveillance.
Code:
Mueller, making what will likely be his final appearance on Capitol  Hill as FBI director, tried to reassure members of the Senate Judiciary  Committee that the bureau uses drones infrequently for surveillance in  the U.S., and only in regards to specific investigations.  “Our footprint is very small,” Mueller said. “We have very few and have limited use.”
But with trust in the intelligence community slipping after revelations about secret surveillance at the National Security Agency, lawmakers indicated they would not let the subject drop.

Also see CNN, RT articles on the same subject.

I personally don’t have an issue with the use of drones by LE (to include the FBI) under certain, limited circumstances: for example to do some reconnaissance prior to performing a SWAT raid on a hostage situation, busting a meth lab, etc. Those kind of situations should be able to be covered by a properly prepared and authorized search warrant (stating the target and what the surveillance is for).

However, recent revelations with this government have proven that they have absolutely no qualms whatsoever about violating the rights of the public. And so I would not be at all surprised that, when it is all said and done, we find that they are up there just doing “pre-crime” surveillance in case somebody does something.

And that is utterly wrong.
 
:tsktsk: THAT’S not a nice thing to call our tax people. Or a smart thing. Shhh! :onpatrol::onpatrol:

Thoughtful post. You are ahead of me on this.

I’d say more but … (you know). :frighten:
 
However, recent revelations with this government have proven that they have absolutely no qualms whatsoever about violating the rights of the public. And so I would not be at all surprised that, when it is all said and done, we find that they are up there just doing “pre-crime” surveillance in case somebody does something.

And that is utterly wrong.
Pre-emptive surveillance…how about “pre-emptive detention”
 
While America still probably doesn’t make the top 100 alltime list for detention and torture, I think this country has become one of the worst states in history for spying on it’s own people. How soon will it be before the same state that continues to justify constant surveillance of it’s citizens begins to rationalise the detention and torture of the same.
 
While America still probably doesn’t make the top 100 alltime list for detention and torture, I think this country has become one of the worst states in history for spying on it’s own people. How soon will it be before the same state that continues to justify constant surveillance of it’s citizens begins to rationalise the detention and torture of the same.
Maybe I’m just not understanding something here.

We’re surveilled in lots of ways, and have been for a long time. How many decades, for example, have they used plane and infrared spotting to find fields of marijuana? How many times have law enforcement people watched the movements of suspects? I have at various times seen the results of surveillance in the insurance industry, and it’s astounding what those people can do without anybody detecting it.

If one way of doing surveillance is blocked, they’ll come up with other ways.

What troubles me is not so much that there are these new ways of doing surveillance, but what a totalitarian-minded government does with it. Think about it. There was no electronic or drone surveillance in the IRS targeting of conservative fundraising groups, yet it could have been a decisive factor in the 2012 election. That was a result of a totalitarian attitude shared by seemingly a significant number of partisans of an administration that, itself, has that mindset. If the government wants your hide for political reasons, they don’t need drones to do that.
 
. That was a result of a totalitarian attitude shared by seemingly a significant number of partisans of an administration that, itself, has that mindset. If the government wants your hide for political reasons, they don’t need drones to do that.
The drones help though.
 
Yet even another reason to vote Obama out. ** The Drone Scandal!**
 
Maybe I’m just not understanding something here.

We’re surveilled in lots of ways, and have been for a long time. How many decades, for example, have they used plane and infrared spotting to find fields of marijuana? How many times have law enforcement people watched the movements of suspects? I have at various times seen the results of surveillance in the insurance industry, and it’s astounding what those people can do without anybody detecting it.
It’s one thing to use a plane or drone to look for something, when you have actual information indicating it is there, and you go to a judge to get a warrant. It is entirely different to simply have planes/drones hovering overhead all the time watching us.
 
As great tools, I like drones. They are very useful and perform excellently when operated properly. They must be handled with caution and not misused (or the warranty will be cancelled). They can fly like a “Top Gun” is onboard or they can be invisible. Whats not to like about drones? I would not want to be targeted by one of them but if its just spying…
no problems - I’m not a spy. I might be a little nosy, but not a spy! I am an American and as long as me and my fellow Americans continue to be the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave - the FBI has to do what we say; they work for us! So, we are the ones using the drones. Good job everyone! (Except for some, who we will be replacing soon!)forums.catholic-questions.org/images/smilies/thumbsup.gif
 
Be rational, not frightened.

What? A drone is going to follow you to work, see you taking out the trash, walking your dog? I know what would be their recommendation on me:

“Subject is not, repeat, not a threat. In fact, he’s boring as all get out. Drop him from the list or I’m quitting, now!”

Unless, of course, you and others are stealing electricity and moving into abandoned homes to do… uh, illegal things, like making pipe bombs in quantity or…

fbi.gov/miami/press-releases/2013/twelve-defendants-sentenced-in-murder-marijuana-grow-house-conspiracy

I’ll quote a (fictional) drone manufacturer: “See. Ya gotta understand dat drones can go wherever they want and da Feds wanna save money, ya know? So I get some bizness and da Feds don’t gotta pay a drone a pension down da line. You know what I’m talkin’ about?”

Ed
 
Yah I get the practical aspects of drones.

What I do not get is the privacy invasion.

I also do not like the idea of the Government watching people sunbathe, perhaps nude, in their fenced backyard. Or what ever. Many concerns here.

Will the drones eventually have X ray capability? One day to be sure. Then what? In the name of National Security we need to x- ray this familie’s home!?

The inertia of government is well documented. Yes?
 
So the government using manned air platforms and unmanned space platforms is perfectly ok, but unmanned air platforms to do the exact same job as the manned platforms is somehow crossing a line? Um, ok…
 
It frightens me that some in America think like this.
No kidding. Willingly throwing away their freedom for some fake “security”.

Wake up people. Our govt couldn’t protect us from the Boston bombers, even when the Russian govt told us repeatedly about the older brother.

Govt always moves towards totalitarianism unless it is fought against.
 
I won’t post a list of known surveillance capabilities here, but it goes way beyond drones. But back to the topic. Drones are expensive, have to be fueled and maintained, and the sensors and optics they carry aren’t cheap either. There’s a target list, just like the government keeps a no-fly list. That’s right, you can be denied entry to the US by plane or ship.

As far as in-country surveillance, instead of sending a stake-out team, a drone does a fly-by, the images are analyzed in real time, and if probable cause is determined, then more fly-bys or real people get involved. If the target area is determined safe and legal, it’s off the list, or gets checked periodically if new activity is reported.

There’s no time to waste. If a target does something unusual or a known terrorist is spotted, there may be little time to intercept. In the end, all of this is evidence. It has to be logged and the times have to be on the video. Even if the drone has a high hour endurance, even the maintenance crew needs to know when it’s logged X hours so that the engine and other components can be checked and replaced if necessary. Structural integrity has to be checked as well.

So, I highly doubt that those in charge of drone operations are going to waste time, fuel or possible discovery, by doing fly-bys where people are sunbathing, for example. The officer in charge will need to, for example, pull a recording, and will not be happy if he sees a gap between 0500 hours and 0515 hours. Someone will have some explaining to do.

Ed
 
Yah I get the practical aspects of drones.
What I do not get is the privacy invasion.
I also do not like the idea of the Government watching people sunbathe, perhaps nude, in their fenced backyard. Or what ever. Many concerns here.
Will the drones eventually have X ray capability? One day to be sure. Then what? In the name of National Security we need to x- ray this familie’s home!?
The inertia of government is well documented. Yes?/QUOTE}
***************************************************************************************************Whoa now! You think the drones want to watch nude people sunbathe in their yard, or next will have Xray capability? :tsktsk: Nah! they are too sophisticated for that stuff. I think their missions are more like going after terrorist trucks loaded with nuclear or biological weapons to use on us; or activities on the waterfront with container ships. Maybe strange gatherings of people running around covered in black from head to toe, carrying rpg’s on their shoulders and strapped with bomb vests. Ya know, the ususal! You can rest easy, no worries.
 
No kidding. Willingly throwing away their freedom for some fake “security”.

Wake up people. Our govt couldn’t protect us from the Boston bombers, even when the Russian govt told us repeatedly about the older brother.

Govt always moves towards totalitarianism unless it is fought against.
  1. The government doing something smart and learning from the private sector that unmanned air platforms can do the same job manned air platforms can at less cost and less risk isn’t really a sign of it moving towards totalitarianism.
  2. What would be a sign of a move towards totalitarianism is if the government could have somehow stopped the Boston bombers because it had agents actively tracking and watching every person named by a foreign government as possibly a “bad guy”.
  3. Your comment pretty much boils down to- shame on the government for not being totalitarian enough to stop the Boston bombers and shame on the government for trying to do with unmanned air platforms what it and the private sector, which does it more and better, already does with manned air platforms.
  4. I have a feeling no one would care if the term “radio controlled model aircraft” was used instead of drones. That or everyone would be up in arms about the government spending money on “toys.”
 
Fundamentally it boils down as to whether a Gov’t can be trusted.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm… IRS targeting anyone? E- mail snooping?

So. Drones? Why would Obama not use drones too if they are useful? It seems other sanctions of appropriate use of Gov’t agencies are indeed in question. Yes?
 
Obama doesn’t know the workings of a drone. It is an efficient means of locating, tracking and determining if targets are engaged in illegal or terrorist activity. Who do you trust on the internet?

This is a cost-saving, time-saving and even life-saving measure. So, unless you are a criminal or a terrorist or have a big belly, you have nothing to fear.

Ed 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top