Fig tree parable Luke 13

  • Thread starter Thread starter fin
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe, BobCatholic, there is another path for you to consider taking a look at? Maybe God is slamming shut the door to a dead end, so you will be able to open a new door to a better possibility.
I am at the point in my career where I want to make a change in my career yet again.

Let’s call my job title A. If I can get to A1 - take my existing job title, add a particular skill - that would make my career more stable. But there’s that catch-22. No experience, no job, no job, no experience. So I can’t go to job A1. Every employer wants A1’s with experience in A1, not A. A1 is not available in a school, and no employer is willing to train.

So I went back to school, studied for job title B. Got a degree (4.0 GPA) in less than a year thanks to my previous transfer credits. Got a very nice certification by nailing the certification exam. Tried to apply for jobs in B. Rejected, no experience.

I did it again. So I went back to school, studied for job title C. Got a certificate. Got a very nice certification by nailing the certification exam. Tried to apply for jobs in C. Rejected, no experience.

I’m thinking of going back to school yet again and trying to get another certificate and certification in D. I really don’t want to do it because of the catch-22, but I don’t want to go back to job A because of the bad job market in A.

Every single time I meet the hiring manager, they’re impressed with my background, I nail the interviews nicely, but…that rejection letter always comes. Job on hold. Budget cuts. Hired someone else.

I hate the job market in A. There is no future in it. Mind you, I’m good at A and I like working in A.

So if God is slamming the door shut on A, he’s not opening any other doors. So I’m doomed.
 
"According to this passage of Mark, Jesus was coming from the house of figs, that is from Bethany and found a fig tree in leaf, that is giving the external appearance of bearing fruit. On inspection the tree was devoid of figs and Jesus cursed it. Many of the early Fathers see in that episode a condemnation of those who have all the appearance of following Jesus but bear no real faith.
This is 100% correct.

Trees represent nations in the Bible. The fig tree represents Israel/Judea.

“Under the fig tree” is an idiom for an observant Jew who obeyed the law of Moses.

Jesus was about to tear down the fig tree of Israel. That literally happened in 70 AD. He established a new nation with a new law.

-Tim-
 
This is 100% correct.

Trees represent nations in the Bible. The fig tree represents Israel/Judea.

“Under the fig tree” is an idiom for an observant Jew who obeyed the law of Moses.

Jesus was about to tear down the fig tree of Israel. That literally happened in 70 AD. He established a new nation with a new law.

-Tim-
Food for thought indeed.
 
As an ememy.

No.

So let’s take your examples which don’t fit my life, and give you better examples.

Imagine you and I are walking down the street. A gang of thugs approach you and start beating you up. I have a concealed weapon and can easily draw it to save your life (and you know about it) You ask me for help and I refuse.

Am I a friend?

When I ask God to protect me from evil, and he refuses, is that acting like a friend? or is my request for something horrifically evil?

Imagine I am a hiring manager and have a job opening. You are a great fit for the role. You apply for the job. Clearly you are above the others and the best candidate for the job. I hire someone else.

Am I a friend?

So when I ask God to help me find a stable career, and he refuses, is he a friend? Or is my request for a stable career something horrifically evil?
Hi, Bob!
…so you do understand the bartering system… and you do understand friendship…

Let’s take your example… if I were your friend, I would know that you are married and have kids… as a friend I would have to place your interests ahead of mine… I would have to either command you not interfere or pretend that I did not know that you had the weapon on you…

…you might think: 'yeah, you’re just saying that 'cause it’s just a postulation… well, here’s reality: one evening, after I walked Mom to Church I went to buy something. I saw a man that appeared to be drunk being followed and taunted by a group of young thugs; I intervened asking them to let the man be. They quickly turned on me. They were so young (early to mid teens) that I could not see myself facing them… one guy grabbed me; as I lifted a fist to the air about to strike him… another grabbed my arm; instantly I saw the vision of God holding Abraham’s arm as he was about to strike Isaac (vision–not recollection of Scriptures) and I relaxed my stance… I got hit over and over (in the middle of all I could see two of the younger ones asking the others to stop–I thought they recognized me from a youth group ran by some Nuns). The pushing and tugging and hitting continued. I began to panic. Since I could not get away from them (I had not thrown a single punch as of yet) and they were enraged (three to five were taking turns going at me) I made the decision to make it all stop. I needed a weapon. I scanned for something metal, heavy, sharp. I was going to go down… but I was going to take two or three of them with me…

Here’s where my Friend/Abba stepped in…

Right as I spotted the weapon I would use… an older gentleman appeared… he simply said: “¿Ángel qué está pasando?” (That’s: Angel, what’s going on?). Everything stopped. My Mom’s friend and myself were left alone on that street corner…

Had I proceeded with my plan or had my best friend or one of my acquaintances come across the incident… most likely there would have been one or two dead kids… Mom could have had died of a heart attack (she was very sensitive and had had chronic heart issues) and my life would have forever changed for me…

God used a weak man, one that could not have embolden me to retaliate as I was thinking, to control the event. Was God not being my Friend/Father because He allowed me to fall into the hands of those thugs?

…well… I could determine to see it that way… or I could put all things together: a) the hand of God stopping me from striking, b) the thugs releasing their violence on me and not on a drunk who could have died at their hands, c) Christ received affirmation that I heed His Call to be a friend (“who gives his life…”), d) I heeded God’s Call to not give in to violence, e) I accepted God’s aide–not in the form of a weapon or an ally who could’ve help me put some of those thugs in a hospital/grave, f) Mom shed tears for my misfortune instead of me shedding tears for Mom’s hospitalization or death…

…and about the loss of opportunity… have you ever had the CEO of a corporation and the Union’s Secretary of that corporation both ask that you allow them the opportunity to assist you in getting gainful employment? …I opted for the CEO’s hook–I mean, if the CEO of a corp cannot help you get a job in his company who can, right?

Final outcome: Over qualified vs. under qualified–yep, no job on both counts!

…and the one time I went to a “fo-sure-agency” that would not only promote you but “guarantee” employment? …well… I took the comprehensive tests… no job; no help–turns out I tested above their level–I did not qualify because I was not dumb enough!

…I have oh so many more stories…

We cannot barter with God!
God’s Friendship is not about financial and physical health.
The littlest things can mean a great/wondrous relationship with Abba/Friend/Bro/Spirit.

Maran atha!

Angel
 
Hi, Bob!
…so you do understand the bartering system… and you do understand friendship…
This is not bartering.
God used a weak man, one that could not have embolden me to retaliate as I was thinking, to control the event. Was God not being my Friend/Father because He allowed me to fall into the hands of those thugs?
OK, so I used a bad example, or two, or twenty seven… I’m a bad communicator when I’m down, so that makes the situation worse. I’m unable to communicate what I’m feeling because everyone else has a story that’s worse. Everyone else’s cross is heavier than mine (but they have that personal relationship with God which I don’t). Everyone else has something I don’t have. I’m not envious, but I am jealous when God treats others better than me, while all I have are scars.
We cannot barter with God!
I know. God needs nothing we have and we have nothing God wants.

There is no way to get God to change his mind. God’s will be done. Nothing else gets done.
God’s Friendship is not about financial and physical health.
It is about the cross. It is about having life beat the tar out of me. It is all about watching how others get blessed and I get passed by. It is all about others getting good and pleasant things in life and I’m not allowed to.

Only the cross is guaranteed, nothing else.

There is no hope in life, only in the afterlife.
 
OK, so I used a bad example, or two, or twenty seven… I’m a bad communicator when I’m down, so that makes the situation worse. I’m unable to communicate what I’m feeling because everyone else has a story that’s worse. Everyone else’s cross is heavier than mine (but they have that personal relationship with God which I don’t). Everyone else has something I don’t have. I’m not envious, but I am jealous when God treats others better than me, while all I have are scars.
For starters, both you and jcrichton are going over my head when you’re talking about bartering … probably I’m missing something, so I’m not understanding, and that’s just me. So I won’t even try to address the bartering end of things. :o

That said, now you seem to be saying in the same breath that “everyone else has a story that’s worse” and “everyone else has something I don’t have.” It seems to me that it’s hard to compare individuals that way. Some have a worse story than yours, some have a better story, some have something you don’t have, some are lacking things that you do have.

If I remember right, both St. Therese the Little Flower and Saint Teresa of Avila asked Jesus why some people seemed to be more blessed with consolations than others … St. Therese’s answer was along the lines of, there are many kinds of flowers in the garden, not all of them are roses, and if all of them were roses that would be a shame, because we’d be missing out on the beauty of violets and daisies. St. Teresa of Avila’s answer was along the lines of don’t try to understand this. (I may have forgotten something along the way, so if I am making an error, I hope someone will please correct me. Maybe the Lord was saying to St. Teresa of Avila that she should be paying more attention to her own relationship with Him, and paying less attention to His relationship with others.)
I know. God needs nothing we have and we have nothing God wants.
We have something God wants … He wants our love.
There is no way to get God to change his mind. God’s will be done. Nothing else gets done.
Prayer changes things … and yes, God’s Will be done.
It is about the cross. It is about having life beat the tar out of me. It is all about watching how others get blessed and I get passed by. It is all about others getting good and pleasant things in life and I’m not allowed to.

Only the cross is guaranteed, nothing else.

There is no hope in life, only in the afterlife.
The cross comes to everyone sooner or later. And it could well be that some of these people you see getting blessed have crosses that you don’t see, such that their smiles are either a phony act or an attempt at bravery, or it could be (if switching parables is allowed) something along the lines of Lazarus and the rich man.

To try get back on topic as much as I can, how about thinking of the cross as a fig tree?



.
 
If I remember right, both St. Therese the Little Flower and Saint Teresa of Avila asked Jesus why some people seemed to be more blessed with consolations than others … St. Therese’s answer was along the lines of, there are many kinds of flowers in the garden, not all of them are roses, and if all of them were roses that would be a shame, because we’d be missing out on the beauty of violets and daisies.
That explains why people are different, but not why some are blessed more than others. If God is no respecter of persons, and rain falls on the sinner and saint alike, then we should be blessed without someone being passed by.
We have something God wants … He wants our love.
I want to love God. I’m at the point in my life where an intellectual acceptance of the faith is not enough for me, I want to know and love God.

I tried to get closer to God, and failed.
Prayer changes things … and yes, God’s Will be done.
Prayer does not change God’s will. If God says no, no amount of prayer will change his mind.
The cross comes to everyone sooner or later. And it could well be that some of these people you see getting blessed have crosses that you don’t see, such that their smiles are either a phony act or an attempt at bravery, or it could be (if switching parables is allowed) something along the lines of Lazarus and the rich man.
Some people have a lighter cross and more blessings and vice versa.
To try get back on topic as much as I can, how about thinking of the cross as a fig tree?
Seeing how Christ treats fig trees (cursing them) - I’m not wanting to go there, then that means I must be cursed and all hope is lost.
 
This is not bartering.
Hi, Bob!
…if there’s an exchange (goods/services for goods/services) there’s bartering going on…
**OK, so I used a bad example, or two, or twenty seven… **I’m a bad communicator when I’m down, so that makes the situation worse. I’m unable to communicate what I’m feeling because everyone else has a story that’s worse. Everyone else’s cross is heavier than mine (but they have that personal relationship with God which I don’t). Everyone else has something I don’t have. I’m not envious, but I am jealous when God treats others better than me, while all I have are scars.
Thanks Bob… you’ve just gave me a great gift… :rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

…actually, I think that you are a good communicator… you are able to express intimate feelings and your highest expectations… that’s grand–too many people will chatter/text about nothing day after day after… also, you are able to show your pain–ego and pretentiousness keeps them from being real even to themselves… today… today I found out that you can laugh at yourself (blue highlighted text); that, to me, is the greatest sign of a master communicator–to be so unpretentious that you view not only your highlights but also your frailties as part of your whole… well, that’s the path of humility and candor.

…yet, I do find that you are stuck… you keep longing for greener pasture as you’ve convinced yourself that others enjoy the greener grass…

…do you recall the passage where our Lord meets Zacchaeus? …the man was short in stature… great in sin… oblivious to Christ’s design… it so happened that Jesus entered his heart and mind and determined to sup with him!

…the difference between Zacchaeus and us is that Jesus actually made a public announcement (it was needed for His Teaching) while with us we barely recognize/acknowledge Him.
I know. God needs nothing we have and we have nothing God wants.
There is no way to get God to change his mind. God’s will be done. Nothing else gets done.
It is about the cross. It is about having life beat the tar out of me. It is all about watching how others get blessed and I get passed by. It is all about others getting good and pleasant things in life and I’m not allowed to.
Only the cross is guaranteed, nothing else.
There is no hope in life, only in the afterlife.
…if you let me, I will prove to you that you are wrong in one single Scriptural passage:
33 These things I have spoken to you,** that in me you may have peace**. In the world you shall have distress: but have confidence, I have overcome the world. (St. John 16:33)
…you are far from being right in your convictions… God wants you to have confidence (though people jump right into an ego trip with passages such as this); do you see it?, read what is going on… it is not confidence in the form of “self-confident” or “self-involvement.” God wants us to have confidence in Him so that we may have Peace: “I Have overcome the world.” Have Confidence in ME!

Maran atha!

Angel
 
That explains why people are different, but not why some are blessed more than others. If God is no respecter of persons, and rain falls on the sinner and saint alike, then we should be blessed without someone being passed by.
The following Bible verse comes to mind: “Jesus saith to him: Because thou hast seen me, Thomas, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and have believed.” ~~ John 20:29
I want to love God. I’m at the point in my life where an intellectual acceptance of the faith is not enough for me, I want to know and love God.
You’re in good company.

“I am told God lives in me – and yet the reality of darkness and coldness and emptiness is so great that nothing touches my soul,” ~~ Mother Teresa of Calcutta, now a Saint
I tried to get closer to God, and failed.
Remember my previous answer? About what Jacob said when he wrestled God, “I’m not letting You go until You give me a blessing.”
Prayer does not change God’s will. If God says no, no amount of prayer will change his mind.
Can we agree on this answer from Catholic Answers?

"God does not change his mind in response to our prayers or our actions. Though Scripture sometimes speaks as if he does, this language is figurative, not literal. If he did change his mind, that would mean that God had imperfect knowledge.

However, the fact that God does not change his mind does not mean that we should refrain from praying. God, in his perfect wisdom, has made some things we need contingent on our praying for them. He does this so that we may turn our hearts to him, rely on him, trust in him, and grow in the virtues of faith, hope, and charity."

catholic.com/quickquestions/does-prayer-change-gods-mind
Some people have a lighter cross and more blessings and vice versa.
I once had a friend who had a heavy cross with congenital heart problems, cancer, lots of things going on that caused pain and suffering … she hadn’t been expected to live into adulthood. Once I told her that I felt bad complaining about my tiny little problems when hers were way more serious (as in, it wouldn’t have surprised me if she had flopped over dead at any time). She answered that we’re all different, and what might seem small to her was big to me, so she was happy to listen.
Seeing how Christ treats fig trees (cursing them) - I’m not wanting to go there, then that means I must be cursed and all hope is lost.
Christ doesn’t curse all fig trees … only those which don’t produce fruit, especially when they give the false appearance of having fruit because after all, they have a whole bunch of nice, showy leaves.



.
 
Christ doesn’t curse all fig trees … only those which don’t produce fruit, especially when they give the false appearance of having fruit because after all, they have a whole bunch of nice, showy leaves.



.
Maybe it is sinful, but I don’t believe in cursing any plants. Does this need to be confessed?
 
Maybe it is sinful, but I don’t believe in cursing any plants. Does this need to be confessed?
“The Lord gives, the Lord takes away … blessed be the name of the Lord.” ~~Job 1:21

God created the fig tree. God has the right to destroy the fig tree.

Now that I’ve gotten into painting this year, I can use it as an example.
I’m an artist.
I apply paint to a canvas.
I’m not happy with the results.

My choices are:
A) Paint over what I don’t like in order to improve it.
B) Remove the offending paint as best I can and start fresh.
C) Burn / destroy the canvas and throw it in the trash.
D) Live with the results.

As the creator of the painting, I get to say what happens to it.
 
Hi, Bob!
…if there’s an exchange (goods/services for goods/services) there’s bartering going on…
I said I have nothing God wants, and God wants nothing I have. There can’t be a barter.
…yet, I do find that you are stuck… you keep longing for greener pasture as you’ve convinced yourself that others enjoy the greener grass…
And God won’t make me unstuck.
…if you let me, I will prove to you that you are wrong in one single Scriptural passage:
You skipped over the middle passage which has the key point:

“In the world you shall have distress”

The cross is guaranteed in life.

“but have confidence, I have overcome the world.” means he has taken care of the spiritual part, which I am confident in. I’m not confident I will avoid distress or be protected from it in life.
 
Maybe it is sinful, but I don’t believe in cursing any plants. Does this need to be confessed?
…actually, you are missing the point: the Creator can determine ***what ***and ***when ***about the Universe He Created… just as He Cursed His Son to Die an accursed Death for man.

In your conclusion you are suggesting that you are holier than God since your morality/convictions compels you to the understanding that you “don’t believe in cursing” even a plant.

Forgetting the idiom of language, do you believe that your heart, mind and spirit are more righteous than God’s?

Maran atha!

Angel
 
I said I have nothing God wants, and God wants nothing I have. There can’t be a barter.

And God won’t make me unstuck.

You skipped over the middle passage which has the key point:

“In the world you shall have distress”

The cross is guaranteed in life.

“but have confidence, I have overcome the world.” means he has taken care of the spiritual part, which I am confident in. I’m not confident I will avoid distress or be protected from it in life.
Hi, Bob!
…in Spanish we have a fine word “escudriñar” (which is roughly translated to scrutinize); in Spanish the meaning (at least to me) seems deeper since it actually implies that there’s deep thought in searching and understanding even the tiniest of information not evidently seen…

I love my old Spanish Bible because it tells me that God actually “escudriña” (which is far more meaningful than “searches”) man’s heart (his thoughts, his innermost being).

…though you seem to know this (from what I’ve gathered from your various posts), you are constantly placing God at infinite-reach…

…noticed how you focused not on what I highlighted in the Scriptural text that I cited but on a, since I do not have a better term, side-dish?

…first Christ wants us to Know that in Him we can find Peace–but this is something that you refuse to even consider…

…right after giving us a dose of reality about the world, Christ assures us that even in the moments of heightened distress we can have Confidence in Him–still… this factor is something you choose to reject/ignore/annul…

God cannot unstuck you because you are stuck on yourself!

…let’s take the barter issue up again… to barter means to exchange goods/services for goods/services… when I first noted your posts you were insisting on being given spiritual gifts from God–that you fully trusted Him on issues dealing with your spiritual wellbeing; you then explained that you could not trust God in matters of temporal things… that you’ve searched for means to become closer to God… to know Him on a deeper plane… to have His Friendship… why not, you’ve reasoned, since others are blessed and enjoy such intimacies with God…

…you, my friend, in your heart, have engaged in barter: ‘I know you this way (spiritually) so why not this other way (temporal values); you’ve established relations with “x,” “y,” and all those “zs”–why am I left out?’

…interestingly enough, you are not the only person in the world who have ever felt that way you do–even “self-confessed” atheists feel left out as they complain that “a good” God would not reject/condemn/allow anyone to not gain Salvation…

The ailment is the same… as is the cure:
5 Have** confidence in the Lord **with all thy heart, and lean not upon thy own prudence. (Proverbs 3:5)
Maran atha!

Angel
 
…though you seem to know this (from what I’ve gathered from your various posts), you are constantly placing God at infinite-reach…
It s the other way around. I’ve tried many times to get closer to God. Nothing worked. If there was something guaranteed to get God’s attention and actually get him to talk to me, I’m open to it.
…noticed how you focused not on what I highlighted in the Scriptural text that I cited but on a, since I do not have a better term, side-dish?
Right. The verse has bitter and sweet, and you only talked about the sweet without the bitter part. The sweet part has a catch - the bitter part.
…first Christ wants us to Know that in Him we can find Peace–but this is something that you refuse to even consider…
The peace comes in the afterlife. The cross is guaranteed here and there is no peace while carrying a cross, just pain.
God cannot unstuck you because you are stuck on yourself!
I’m stuck in a situation I can’t get out of, not stuck on my self
you were insisting on being given spiritual gifts from God–
What spiritual gifts? I wanted to have a conversation with God, not a monologue.
…you, my friend, in your heart, have engaged in barter: ‘I know you this way (spiritually) so why not this other way (temporal values); you’ve established relations with “x,” “y,” and all those “zs”–why am I left out?’
How did I barter? I have not offered God anything and he has not promised me anything temporal in exchange. In order for there to be a barter, there must be an exchange offered - and none was offered.
The ailment is the same… as is the cure:
How do I have confidence in the Lord (in temporal things) when he has made it abundantly clear he does not care about those things, that he ONLY cares about the spiritual things? Christ died on the cross to remedy a spiritual problem, not a temporal problem.

Temporally, our bodies are not even redeemed yet! Romans 8:23. We are held temporally responsible for the sins of our ancestors. Spiritually, we are not held responsible for the sins of our ancestors, Christ took care of that.

God loves my soul, my body is 2,409,320,303th place in his mind. And that is me being lucky. The soul is far more important to God than the body.

When I ask God to protect me from evil and he refuses, either he broke a promise (which means he is not trustworthy) or he didn’t promise that.

When I ask for temporal things and he refuses, either he broke a promise (which means he is not trustworthy) or he didn’t promise that.

Right now, I’m of the opinion God never promised temporal help or to protect us from evil on this speck of dust. Hence, how am I to be confident in God for temporal things if he didn’t promise anything? If I were to do that, that is presumptuous and a sin. How am I to be confident that God will protect me from evil on this planet, if he did not promise anything? If I were to do that, that is presumptuous and a sin.

God is 100% trustworthy on spiritual things. On that, I am confident in.
For temporal things, he promised nothing. So I have no confidence there.

So you have a choice. Either God broke a promise, or he never made a promise in the first place.

Your posts seem to indicate God made a promise to protect us from evil, and to always provide for us temporally. If that is the case, then God broke his promises and that goes against who God is - he is always faithful. In addition it smells a lot like Joel Olsteen “prosperity gospel” stuff which goes against the promised cross.

I know the cross is promised and guaranteed on this planet. What I don’t understand is why some people are exempted from the cross.
 
It s the other way around. I’ve tried many times to get closer to God. Nothing worked. If there was something guaranteed to get God’s attention and actually get him to talk to me, I’m open to it.
Hi, Bob!
You want God to come down to you, and to walk with you, and to dialogue with you… this is the yearning of every single Believer that has ever come across the Revelation of Yahweh God.

Sadly, most of us are so impure that God cannot stand being in the same town, let alone being next to us…

…your second problem is that you want to dictate the relationship–it is as though you think therefore he must; quite frankly, you’ve misconstrued God’s Communication with man: He Is therefore we are; He Conditions and Dictates–we move within His Works.

You refuse to find God in the smallest things in your life; you want a direct one on one; you want body armor; you want a cornucopia of material wealth; God’s Providence does not come to us in such a way–remember the Hebrews’ trek on the desert? Yahweh Provided Water (Jesus) and manna; but only enough for “our daily bread.” The response of His chosen people: “We had it better in Egypt, why should we not return to the slavery of the world?” (accented and paraphrased)
Right. The verse has bitter and sweet, and you only talked about the sweet without the bitter part. The sweet part has a catch - the bitter part.
The peace comes in the afterlife. The cross is guaranteed here and there is no peace while carrying a cross, just pain.
I’m stuck in a situation I can’t get out of, not stuck on my self
…the misconstruction continues… you highlight the despair while fully rejecting/ignoring/obliterating Christ’s Call to yield to Him and to find Peace in Him–in your dualism you render God’s Word void since you confabulate so ‘a la carte.’

Here’s what Jesus said about His Peace:
27 Peace I leave with you, my peace I give unto you: not as the world giveth, do I give unto you. Let not your heart be troubled, nor let it be afraid. (St. John 14:27)
We cannot sample God through an ‘a la carte’ menu–picking and choosing as our fancy is tweeted. Yes, we are going to face turmoil; yes, we’ll be engaged by persecution, pain, sorrow, perils, and we will be force to endure hardships… but the key is that we “can do all things in Jesus,” since in Him we will have Peace and Strength. “Do not be afraid,” is a temporal imperative. It is not a futuristic “in me you will have,” but an empirical: “I AM your PEACE; I AM your STRENGTH.”
What spiritual gifts? I wanted to have a conversation with God, not a monologue.
How did I barter? I have not offered God anything and he has not promised me anything temporal in exchange. In order for there to be a barter, there must be an exchange offered - and none was offered.
How do I have confidence in the Lord (in temporal things) when he has made it abundantly clear he does not care about those things, that he ONLY cares about the spiritual things? Christ died on the cross to remedy a spiritual problem, not a temporal problem.
Temporally, our bodies are not even redeemed yet! Romans 8:23. We are held temporally responsible for the sins of our ancestors. Spiritually, we are not held responsible for the sins of our ancestors, Christ took care of that.
God loves my soul, my body is 2,409,320,303th place in his mind. And that is me being lucky. The soul is far more important to God than the body.
When I ask God to protect me from evil and he refuses, either he broke a promise (which means he is not trustworthy) or he didn’t promise that.
When I ask for temporal things and he refuses, either he broke a promise (which means he is not trustworthy) or he didn’t promise that.
Right now, I’m of the opinion God never promised temporal help or to protect us from evil on this speck of dust. Hence, how am I to be confident in God for temporal things if he didn’t promise anything? If I were to do that, that is presumptuous and a sin. How am I to be confident that God will protect me from evil on this planet, if he did not promise anything? If I were to do that, that is presumptuous and a sin.
God is 100% trustworthy on spiritual things. On that, I am confident in.
For temporal things, he promised nothing. So I have no confidence there.
So you have a choice. Either God broke a promise, or he never made a promise in the first place.
Your posts seem to indicate God made a promise to protect us from evil, and to always provide for us temporally. If that is the case, then God broke his promises and that goes against who God is - he is always faithful. In addition it smells a lot like Joel Olsteen “prosperity gospel” stuff which goes against the promised cross.
I know the cross is promised and guaranteed on this planet. What I don’t understand is why some people are exempted from the cross.
Here’s what St. Paul say to that:
11 I speak not as it were for want. For I have learned, in whatsoever state I am, to be content therewith. 12 I know both how to be brought low, and I know how to abound: (everywhere, and in all things I am instructed) both to be full, and to be hungry; both to abound, and to suffer need. 13 I can do all these things in him who strengtheneth me. (Philippians 4:11-13)
In your understanding you seem to imply that God’s concern for man terminates on the spiritual; that’s bordering on Arianism where the temporal is evil and the “good” God wages war against it. It predicates that man can only assist the “good” God by engaging in the culture of death in an effort to contain evil. It, erroneously, rejects Creation.

Maran atha!

Angel
 
Hi, Bob!
You want God to come down to you, and to walk with you, and to dialogue with you… this is the yearning of every single Believer that has ever come across the Revelation of Yahweh God.

Sadly, most of us are so impure that God cannot stand being in the same town, let alone being next to us…
I know. I’m a useless speck of dust, who am I to believe I could possibly have a personal relationship with God? That’s why I can only have a corporate relationship with God only.
…your second problem is that you want to dictate the relationship–it is as though you think therefore he must; quite frankly, you’ve misconstrued God’s Communication with man: He Is therefore we are; He Conditions and Dictates–we move within His Works.
No. Unless the words have been perverted to mean things I don’t know what they mean.

Father - a loving caring person who created me and cares deeply about me, providing what I need, and does not begrudge any good thing.

Of course, I don’t have that, so obviously I don’t have a Father as defined above. I have a different Father who everyone claims loves me, but I can’t feel the love. Especially when he begrudges me the ability to earn a living to provide for my family.
God’s Providence does not come to us in such a way–remember the Hebrews’ trek on the desert?
Precisely. God’s providence is the cross. That’s the only thing guaranteed in this life on this planet.
…the misconstruction continues… you highlight the despair while fully rejecting/ignoring/obliterating Christ’s Call to yield to Him and to find Peace in Him–in your dualism you render God’s Word void since you confabulate so ‘a la carte.’
I want to. Went to adoration many times, got no peace. Got no sense that he cared.
Here’s what Jesus said about His Peace:
Precisely. Not as the world gives - temporal peace. Christ gives us supernatural peace - in the afterlife.
Yes, we are going to face turmoil; yes, we’ll be engaged by persecution, pain, sorrow, perils, and we will be force to endure hardships…
And that is the only thing guaranteed.
Here’s what St. Paul say to that:
And that confirms my belief that God never promised any temporal help. Paul was up and down, and no stability - because no stability was promised. If good things happen, they’re not guaranteed to stay.
In your understanding you seem to imply that God’s concern for man terminates on the spiritual; that’s bordering on Arianism where the temporal is evil and the “good” God wages war against it. It predicates that man can only assist the “good” God by engaging in the culture of death in an effort to contain evil. It, erroneously, rejects Creation.
I don’t think that’s Aranism, but more like Manicheanism…

I believe that the temporal was created good, but treated as evil by God. God says “Christ’s sacrifice is not enough, you must also sacrifice the temporal goods in your life. You must give up all your possessions, and follow me”

This is why I believe that as a married layman, who has a kid, that I am a second class citizen (if I’m lucky) in the Kingdom of God. God prefers the religious orders, and clergy over me. That’s fine, they gave up more to follow him.

I’m no more than a dog to Christ, and that’s probably prideful, in reality, I am a worthless speck of dust, an unprofitable servant.
 
I know. I’m a useless speck of dust, who am I to believe I could possibly have a personal relationship with God? That’s why I can only have a corporate relationship with God only.

No. Unless the words have been perverted to mean things I don’t know what they mean.
Hi, Bob!
…again, I explicitly stated that “we” (as in mankind) and you single yourself out so that you can then add your preferred clause: “corporate relationship.”

Your habitual defaults will forever render you a peg in a corporate scenario as you actively and consciously became the architect of your own design–your stubbornness rejects God’s Design.
Father - a loving caring person who created me and cares deeply about me, providing what I need, and does not begrudge any good thing.
Of course, I don’t have that, so obviously I don’t have a Father as defined above. I have a different Father who everyone claims loves me, but I can’t feel the love. Especially when he begrudges me the ability to earn a living to provide for my family.
God’s Design is not to spoon-feed all the “good” boys and girls. But unless you have what you perceive as the tell-tale proof (wealth and health at your bequest) you reject His Parenthood.

You claim Christ while simultaneously rejecting His Command to Call God: Father.

…yet, you do not believe that you are bartering even when you base your relationship with God on ‘if He lavishes me with “x, y, z” then we can be friends and He can be my Father’.

Are you aware that Christians have been and are being raped, tortured and murdered because they refuse to renounce Christ? These Believers have not constructed a duality… they have not constructed a design by which God proves His Fatherhood by the wealth and health that He lavishes on them; these Christians have taken Christ at His Word: they, as I, Believe that in Christ we are/become children of God; and they’ve called God “Abba” (Daddy) even when forced to experience all sorts of mental and physical traumas–even when facing death, for Christ’s sake.
Precisely. God’s providence is the cross. That’s the only thing guaranteed in this life on this planet.
I want to. Went to adoration many times, got no peace. Got no sense that he cared.
Precisely. Not as the world gives - temporal peace. Christ gives us supernatural peace - in the afterlife.
And that is the only thing guaranteed.
…you may not accept this… but you are calling Christ and St. Paul liars since both Christ and St. Paul share, through the Holy Spirit, both a temporal and a spiritual relationship (that’s why I mistook the term Gnostic with Arianism when I was thinking about your posts, since you seem to exclude the Holy Trinity in you Faith-design–yet, the dual theology of Manicheanism also seems to apply).

You depend on two filters… the first filter renders a built-in default: ‘God takes care of the spiritual but man must takes care of the physical.’ In essence, you have constructed a duality: God is God of the Spiritual Realm; man is his own temporal god (I know you are rejecting this… but consider it carefully: if we do not submit our will to God’s we are willfully rejecting God’s Authority over us).

…your other filter is set at: ‘when God take care of my temporal needs, then He can be my Father.’ This is conditioning; you’ve basically taken Thomas’s faith-base as your own: ‘let God do what I say and I will believe.’
And that confirms my belief that God never promised any temporal help. Paul was up and down, and no stability - because no stability was promised. If good things happen, they’re not guaranteed to stay.
…no; you refuse to see the forest for the trees! St. Paul learned to be content in good times and bad because he confided in Christ. His Peace, his Faith, and his existence did not depend upon wealth or health… he clearly states this in Romans 8: “nothing… not even death, can separate us from God’s Love.” (paraphrased)

You remind me of an old argument about osas–they state that nothing can take the sheep from the Father’s Hand… they refuse to accept the fact that the sheep can choose to place itself outside of the Father’s Love, er Hand!
I believe that the temporal was created good, but treated as evil by God. God says “Christ’s sacrifice is not enough, you must also sacrifice the temporal goods in your life. You must give up all your possessions, and follow me”
This is why I believe that as a married layman, who has a kid, that I am a second class citizen (if I’m lucky) in the Kingdom of God. God prefers the religious orders, and clergy over me. That’s fine, they gave up more to follow him.
I’m no more than a dog to Christ, and that’s probably prideful, in reality, I am a worthless speck of dust, an unprofitable servant.
…until you, a married layman who has a kid, accept God as your Father and stop placing yourself outside of the Father’s Hand… you will be the least in the Kingdom of Heaven…

…as for the religious orders and clergy… they suffer daily for Christ and for His Followers; some are tortured, raped, and murder… most suffer and die in obscurity while the US, UN and other “good” meaning people ignore and malign them… all, because they Stand for Christ.

Your Vocation, if you choose to accept it, is to take your cross and offer it to Christ–offer it for the Church, for those who Follow Christ and are persecuted, oppressed, tortured, raped and murdered… offer them for the confused and ignorant Believers, offer them for those “Catholics” who are bent on following the world (Satan) rather than Christ, offer them for yourself, your wife, and your child, and lastly, offer them for me.

…when you engage God in this manner not only will you be an agent of Christ, you will be a child to God!

Maran atha!

Angel
 
Hi, Bob!
…again, I explicitly stated that “we” (as in mankind) and you single yourself out so that you can then add your preferred clause: “corporate relationship.”
Unless God has singled me out for ignoring every plea for help (please give me a steady job, or restore my ability to earn a living) - I think others also are in the same boat. God never promised temporal help.
Your habitual defaults will forever render you a peg in a corporate scenario as you actively and consciously became the architect of your own design–your stubbornness rejects God’s Design.
God’s design is that he doesn’t care about the temporal.
God’s Design is not to spoon-feed all the “good” boys and girls. But unless you have what you perceive as the tell-tale proof (wealth and health at your bequest) you reject His Parenthood.
A father who refuses to help their son is failing as a father.

I’m not demanding wealth and wealth, he gives that to others, not me. Other people are exempt from the cross, not me. That’s because I’m not good enough.
You claim Christ while simultaneously rejecting His Command to Call God: Father.
Yeah, he is my father, distant and unloving.
…yet, you do not believe that you are bartering even when you base your relationship with God on ‘if He lavishes me with “x, y, z” then we can be friends and He can be my Father’.
No. A relationship is a two way street. He won’t approach me, he does not want me in a personal way. So corporate is the only way for me.
Are you aware that Christians have been and are being raped, tortured and murdered because they refuse to renounce Christ?
I do not take comfort or joy in other people’s sufferings, I am not a sadist. In addition, many people are exempt from the cross so God does play favorites.
You depend on two filters… the first filter renders a built-in default: ‘God takes care of the spiritual but man must takes care of the physical.’ In essence, you have constructed a duality: God is God of the Spiritual Realm; man is his own temporal god (I know you are rejecting this… but consider it carefully: if we do not submit our will to God’s we are willfully rejecting God’s Authority over us).
I don’t believe man is a temporal god, I believe man is an abandoned child trying to make the best of their own - in the temporal realm.
…your other filter is set at: ‘when God take care of my temporal needs, then He can be my Father.’ This is conditioning; you’ve basically taken Thomas’s faith-base as your own: ‘let God do what I say and I will believe.’
Nope. You misinterpreted what I said.

What kind of father abandons their child? What kind of father beats their kid into a pulp? What kind of father ignores their kid’s cries for help?
…no; you refuse to see the forest for the trees! St. Paul learned to be content in good times and bad because he confided in Christ. His Peace, his Faith, and his existence did not depend upon wealth or health… he clearly states this in Romans 8: “nothing… not even death, can separate us from God’s Love.” (paraphrased)
St. Paul had a personal relationship with Christ. Christ actually talked to him, he had an abundance of revelations. It was EASY for him.
…until you, a married layman who has a kid, accept God as your Father and stop placing yourself outside of the Father’s Hand… you will be the least in the Kingdom of Heaven…
I already am least in the kingdom of heaven. I’m a second class citizen, if I’m lucky, but in reality, I am a useless speck of dust with zero value to God.
…as for the religious orders and clergy… they suffer daily for Christ and for His Followers; some are tortured, raped, and murder… most suffer and die in obscurity while the US, UN and other “good” meaning people ignore and malign them… all, because they Stand for Christ.
And that’s why God loves them more.
Your Vocation, if you choose to accept it, is to take your cross and offer it to Christ–offer it for the Church, for those who Follow Christ and are persecuted, oppressed, tortured, raped and murdered… offer them for the confused and ignorant Believers, offer them for those “Catholics” who are bent on following the world (Satan) rather than Christ, offer them for yourself, your wife, and your child, and lastly, offer them for me.
I did that daily while employed. God wasn’t pleased, since that job is now gone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top