Final Solution? Infant Circumcision Outlawed in Germany!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Qwestions
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Q

Qwestions

Guest
Religious persecution of all faiths is not something that might happen again some day in the future; it’s happening all over the world, now, today, and it’s been going on for a long time while we’ve raised insufficient Cain. Jimmy Akin, in the 7-20-12 edition of National Catholic Register, details the current situation with the Jewish religious practice of circumcision: "Final Solution? Infant Circumcision Outlawed in Germany! ncregister.com/blog/jimmy-akin/final-solution-infant-circumcision-outlawed-in-Germany/

We need to be aware and on the alert, ready to defend any religious group from having to violate their consciences because of manmade laws–or governmental decrees as an end-run around their governing bodies. A blow to one group is just a few governmental steps, mandates, or decrees away from a blow to another group.

Abortion, prohibiting counseling for would-be aborters, not informing parents of distribution of contraceptives to high schoolers and abortions performed on under-age girls, both without parents’ consent, with our tax dollars supporting these efforts–and even paying for contraceptives and abortions abroad (the oval office “administration” has just given over $400,000.00 more in foreign aid for that purpose through Planned Parenthood, even though we owe trillions!)–these actions all mock our regligious beliefs and slap our faces amounting to just a warm-up for the travesties of this health care mandate debacle.

I don’t think that the transgressions over our right to freely express our religious beliefs without encumbrances is nearing an end. Throw in the restrictions upon Bible availability in the millitary and government buildings; the censoring of what military chaplains can say (and when and where); the removal of Jewish or Christian symbols in chapels on government property; the banning of simple prayers at public events, including school classrooms, convocations, sports events, and graduations; the removal of nativities and the word “Christmas” in public places where they had been traditionally a part of Christmas; the abolishment of oval office recognition of a National Day of Prayer (and the first-time recognition for such an occasion for Muslims); the banning of crosses on chains and other religious symbolism in our schools and some work places; plus the “cultural legislation” that has been all but rammed down our throats–and, by golly, you can see a pattern here! Unfortunately, it’s not one that bodes well for people who are trying to be true to the tenets of their faiths.

It doesn’t make any difference whether or not we agree with the religious practice that is now outlawed in Germany. What matters is that religious beliefs are being trampled.
 
So, OP, what form of bodily modification of children for religious reasons would you not accept? Anything? Or is any cutting, scarring or surgery ok as long as the reason is religious? And is it not the case that the Church until very recently in Ireland succeeded in restricting the practice of sterilization by those to whom it was a religiously good, and often necessary act?
 
So, OP, what form of bodily modification of children for religious reasons would you not accept? Anything? Or is any cutting, scarring or surgery ok as long as the reason is religious? And is it not the case that the Church until very recently in Ireland succeeded in restricting the practice of sterilization by those to whom it was a religiously good, and often necessary act?
Settle down.

If we’re going to kill whole human beings in utero and support it, I don’t understand how someone can be irrationally against the removal of some foreskin. Mind you secular philosophers are even advocating for infanticide until the age of 6 months. Back to circumcision, the parents of course are not coerced to do this, they can LEAVE the religion if they want and NOT HAVE TO have their child circumcised or stay in the religion uncircumcised depending on the religion. Now if that was impossible, I’d agree with you that there was a group of people forced to do something they didn’t want to do, but that’s not the case.

I don’t see why the parents can’t have control over their children in such minor matters as a little foreskin removal, matters which have not been an issue for thousands of years and are not an issue for most who’ve had this procedure, or would you have parents cede all control to the state, or to you? Obviously not all body modification is the same. But your straw-man shows itself. Wearing braces to straighten teeth can also be considered child abuse because a child may not want to look bad and be laughed at and it’s very painful sometimes. Ask me.

I expect it’s better to allow the state to send the children to gender neutral pre-schools and have them choose their own gender at 13.

Disclosure: I’m not circumcised and won’t circumcise my male kids but I won’t block others from doing so.
 
Settle down.

If we’re going to kill whole human beings in utero and support it, I don’t understand how someone can be irrationally against the removal of some foreskin. Mind you secular philosophers are even advocating for infanticide until the age of 6 months. Back to circumcision, the parents of course are not coerced to do this, they can LEAVE the religion if they want and NOT HAVE TO have their child circumcised or stay in the religion uncircumcised depending on the religion. Now if that was impossible, I’d agree with you that there was a group of people forced to do something they didn’t want to do, but that’s not the case.

I don’t see why the parents can’t have control over their children in such minor matters as a little foreskin removal, matters which have not been an issue for thousands of years and are not an issue for most who’ve had this procedure, or would you have parents cede all control to the state, or to you? Obviously not all body modification is the same. But your straw-man shows itself. Wearing braces to straighten teeth can also be considered child abuse because a child may not want to look bad and be laughed at and it’s very painful sometimes. Ask me.

I expect it’s better to allow the state to send the children to gender neutral pre-schools and have them choose their own gender at 13.

Disclosure: I’m not circumcised and won’t circumcise my male kids but I won’t block others from doing so.
Parents do not have rights over their children except in so far as the children’s independent rights have to be modified in their own interests. It is never in anyone’s interests to have unnecessary surgery with life-long consequences and no significant benefits that cannot be achieved in other less intrusive ways.
 
Interestingly enough in the circumcision debates - which have beengoing on for ages - it is now recommended as a way to help stop the spread of AIDS. So in Africa adult men are being encouraged to be circumcised. Because of course the no one wants to admit that the programs to encourage monogamy worked just as well. :rolleyes:
 
Interestingly enough in the circumcision debates - which have beengoing on for ages - it is now recommended as a way to help stop the spread of AIDS. So in Africa adult men are being encouraged to be circumcised. Because of course the no one wants to admit that the programs to encourage monogamy worked just as well. :rolleyes:
Of course everyone accepts that monogamous relationships between previously virgin people will stop the spread of aids: for those people. But I bet there is no evidence of it working in a general population. Circumcision of infants is not needed to lessen the spread of HIV.
 
Of course everyone accepts that monogamous relationships between previously virgin people will stop the spread of aids: for those people. But I bet there is no evidence of it working in a general population. Circumcision of infants is not needed to lessen the spread of HIV.
Of course it will stop the spread in the general population. If an infected man limits himself to one partner, he will stop infecting all the other people who might have been his partners. The same for an infected woman.

The arguement in favor of circumcision limiting the spread of AIDS, is that infected semen is less likely to be passed from partner to partner by being caught under the foreskin. It doesn’t make sense to me, but I’m not an epidemiologist studying the transmission of AIDS in Africa. If that is the case though, circumcising a boy as an infant will carry that protection through to when he becomes sexually active. The reason why adult men are being circumcised is that there is no tradition of infant circumcision in the particular cultures where this is being studied.

All of that has nothing to do with the German law, which was based on the idea that circumcision is mutilation and violates the child’s natural rights. Since male circumcision is a long standing religious practice that is not physically on par with female circumcision (and the sewing shut of the labila), I am glad to see that the proposed law is being changed.
 
Parents do not have rights over their children except in so far as the children’s independent rights have to be modified in their own interests. It is never in anyone’s interests to have unnecessary surgery with life-long consequences and no significant benefits that cannot be achieved in other less intrusive ways.
And what exactly are those “less intrusive ways” to achieve the same benefits as circumcision? :rolleyes:
 
All of that has nothing to do with the German law, which was based on the idea that circumcision is mutilation and violates the child’s natural rights.
I just want to point out that Germany doesn’t have a law against infant circumcision, per se. However, a judge recently ruled that infant circumcision was against German law.

The distinction may be slight, but I think it is important. German legislators did not debate the topic and pass a law. Rather, the government was blindsided by a judicial ruling. Perhaps many Americans here can relate to that experience.
 
I just want to point out that Germany doesn’t have a law against infant circumcision, per se. However, a judge recently ruled that infant circumcision was against German law.

The distinction may be slight, but I think it is important. German legislators did not debate the topic and pass a law. Rather, the government was blindsided by a judicial ruling. Perhaps many Americans here can relate to that experience.
Thanks for the clarification. Yes, the situation is common here in the US. 😉
 
Please excuse my typo. The National Catholic Register published the info on 7-29-12, not 7-20-12, as stated in my opening post.

I, too, oppose the surgery, but I am 100% in favor of the free exercise of religion in this matter and am relieved to hear that steps are being taken to remedy the judge’s interpretation through legislation.
 
I just want to point out that Germany doesn’t have a law against infant circumcision, per se. However, a judge recently ruled that infant circumcision was against German law.

The distinction may be slight, but I think it is important. German legislators did not debate the topic and pass a law. Rather, the government was blindsided by a judicial ruling. Perhaps many Americans here can relate to that experience.
When we think of infant circumcision, we naturally think about Jews and the practice of their faith in circumcising boys at 8 days old. However, since Germany has a large influx of of immigrants from Africa and many are Muslim, there is a practice of circumcising females. I am wondering if the Judge or the laws are aimed at that which a number of countries in the west are trying to ban. While one can point to some health benefits to male circumcision and I am not trying to debate with any about that, there is absolutely no benefit to female circumcision and it scars women for life, make sex very painful along with having children. I kinda doubt that with an extremely small Jewish population in Germany and with the history of Hitler that the Germany government is trying to take aim at Jews practicing their faith. I am wondering if it is aimed at female circumcision.
 
When visiting Cairo I found that the Coptic Christians tattoo a cross to their babies’ wrist so if the Muslims steal it, it will still be identifiably Christian. My understanding is that the Muslims sometimes stole their kids or forced their girls to become wives of Muslim men.

The tattoo, while initially painful, was a form of protection. It is hard for Muslims to cut the tattoo out from the veins of the wrist without killing them.

To this day the Copts are a persecuted minority in Egypt. Many of them live in the “garbage cities”; I met a 14 year old girl who woke up at 4 a.m. or so every morning to go into the city to gather rubbish.
 
Parents do not have rights over their children except in so far as the children’s independent rights have to be modified in their own interests. It is never in anyone’s interests to have unnecessary surgery with life-long consequences and no significant benefits that cannot be achieved in other less intrusive ways.
What are the life-long (negative) consequences of the Jewish (and Islamic) religious ritual of circumcision? There may even be some physical health benefits; this issue has been debated. It is not regarded by anyone as surgical mutilation but rather as a very significant and age-old religious rite, which does no physical or psychological harm to the child.
 
When visiting Cairo I found that the Coptic Christians tattoo a cross to their babies’ wrist so if the Muslims steal it, it will still be identifiably Christian. My understanding is that the Muslims sometimes stole their kids or forced their girls to become wives of Muslim men.

The tattoo, while initially painful, was a form of protection. It is hard for Muslims to cut the tattoo out from the veins of the wrist without killing them.

To this day the Copts are a persecuted minority in Egypt. Many of them live in the “garbage cities”; I met a 14 year old girl who woke up at 4 a.m. or so every morning to go into the city to gather rubbish.
It is estimated that about 80% of the Muslim women in Egypt have been forced to undergo female circumcision. I am really wondering if the Judge’s ruling was aimed at this and not Jews. Other cultures have their daughter’s ears pierced as infants.
 
I think it’s because in general secular people see no acceptable reason to do anything that would cause a child pain unless it’s for medical purposes, e.g. vaccinations.

However there are unacknowledged spiritual reasons for secular people to stop spiritual people from practicing their religions. E.g. they don’t want to accept people of a certain religion or they don’t want people to practice the religion.

As I was just reading in Maccabees (I am just becoming a Catholic), some Jewish mothers were martyred before Christ came because they circumcised their boys, just as God had told them to. Their martyrdom was not because they “injured” their boys but because they were faithful to God.
 
I am wondering if it is aimed at female circumcision.
The judge’s ruling (which is non-binding, it should be noted) was regarding the case of a four year old boy who had been circumcised by a physician. The doctor was acquitted, but the judgment noted that the “fundamental right of the child to bodily integrity outweighed the fundamental rights of the parents”.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-18604664

According to that news article, female circumcision is already outlawed in Germany.
 
The judge’s ruling (which is non-binding, it should be noted) was regarding the case of a four year old boy who had been circumcised by a physician. The doctor was acquitted, but the judgment noted that the “fundamental right of the child to bodily integrity outweighed the fundamental rights of the parents”.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-18604664

According to that news article, female circumcision is already outlawed in Germany.
thanks for the clarification.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top