Finding a good Catholic spouse

  • Thread starter Thread starter misfitz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
that wasn’t very nice.
Neither are all the attempts to make people feel that they are “not whole enough”.

I’m trying to take concepts to their logical conclusion. Sometimes the only way to see whether it is valid or not is to see how far to the extreme we are willing to go with that concept.
 
Hi Norseman,
Yes I am the one that is looking into foster care. That doesn’t mean I don’t want to get married and have children of my own. I am licensed now by the way! I haven’t heard anything from my agency as of yet. I have a family trip planned for July (cruise out of the country) so I am thinking it be best if I wait for a placement until I get home. Thanks for remembering though - that is nice.

What I meant by my comment is you need to be content with yourself. You can’t have the idea that once I am married I will be happy, or once I have kids I will be happy. I USED to think this way years ago when all my friends were getting married and having babies :crying: . Finally I realized I am single and I need to embrace it. I got involved, started volunteering more, getting together with friends, taking Catholic related classes, etc. and guess what … Being single isn’t all that bad :bigyikes: . That doesn’t take away the fact that I have a STRONG desire to be married and be a mother SOMEDAY when GOD will’s it.

I also believe that we have to help God out. What I mean by that is you need to get out there and make yourself available to meet the type of man/woman you are seeking. So I am on a Catholic dating website, I go to Catholic functions, I volunteer and maybe one day I will meet my future spouse. And until I do I am happy doing the things I am doing. I couldn’t become a foster care parent just because God put the desire in my heart. I had to take the classes, prepare my home and do all the necessary things to make myself available to it.

This thread is great because I am finding out I am not alone in my pursuit of finding a good Catholic spouse :signofcross: .
 
Hi Norseman,
Yes I am the one that is looking into foster care. That doesn’t mean I don’t want to get married and have children of my own. I am licensed now by the way! I haven’t heard anything from my agency as of yet. I have a family trip planned for July (cruise out of the country) so I am thinking it be best if I wait for a placement until I get home. Thanks for remembering though - that is nice.

What I meant by my comment is you need to be content with yourself. You can’t have the idea that once I am married I will be happy, or once I have kids I will be happy. I USED to think this way years ago when all my friends were getting married and having babies :crying: . Finally I realized I am single and I need to embrace it. I got involved, started volunteering more, getting together with friends, taking Catholic related classes, etc. and guess what … Being single isn’t all that bad :bigyikes: . That doesn’t take away the fact that I have a STRONG desire to be married and be a mother SOMEDAY when GOD will’s it.

I also believe that we have to help God out. What I mean by that is you need to get out there and make yourself available to meet the type of man/woman you are seeking. So I am on a Catholic dating website, I go to Catholic functions, I volunteer and maybe one day I will meet my future spouse. And until I do I am happy doing the things I am doing. I couldn’t become a foster care parent just because God put the desire in my heart. I had to take the classes, prepare my home and do all the necessary things to make myself available to it.

This thread is great because I am finding out I am not alone in my pursuit of finding a good Catholic spouse :signofcross: .
You have such a good attitude. I try to think like this but it is difficult. 😦 I hate being single. It would mean so much to me to be married. I think it stems from the fact that my mother died when I was a baby and I have no brothers and sisters. Being the generation that I am I grew up in Ireland where the average family was 4 or 5 kids at least. It’s not that I am trying to replace my childhood or anything like that. I just feel such a strong call to marriage. Having said that I wouldn’t marry someone just for the sake of it. It would have to be the right person. It seems people found it alot easier years ago to meet someone. I wonder is it that our expectations have become too high?
 
Thank you Catherine! It isn’t always easy for me either. My best friend gave me this advice MANY times and I either argued with her (saying you don’t understand you’re married with kids) or agreed but didn’t do anything. Then I started taking baby steps. I took a tennis lesson, took a class on Theology of the Body, started volunteering, got more involved in church, and now I am so busy it is actually hard to find time to date. Of course if I meet someone I connect with I will make time but that hasn’t happended yet. Making myself busy with interesting things has made me much happier, stronger in my faith and probably more interesting to others. Of course I haven’t told my friend she was right yet :tsktsk: .

I understand your frustration, believe me. I have wanted children for as long as I can remember. I am now 34 years old so I can get freaked out at times. But being freaked out isn’t good for anyone so I say a prayer at those times, call a friend, read, go shopping, ect. Pretty much anything to keep me from dwelling.

God Bless!
 
Thank you Catherine! It isn’t always easy for me either. My best friend gave me this advice MANY times and I either argued with her (saying you don’t understand you’re married with kids) or agreed but didn’t do anything. Then I started taking baby steps. I took a tennis lesson, took a class on Theology of the Body, started volunteering, got more involved in church, and now I am so busy it is actually hard to find time to date. Of course if I meet someone I connect with I will make time but that hasn’t happended yet. Making myself busy with interesting things has made me much happier, stronger in my faith and probably more interesting to others. Of course I haven’t told my friend she was right yet :tsktsk: .

I understand your frustration, believe me. I have wanted children for as long as I can remember. I am now 34 years old so I can get freaked out at times. But being freaked out isn’t good for anyone so I say a prayer at those times, call a friend, read, go shopping, ect. Pretty much anything to keep me from dwelling.

God Bless!
Thanks for the advice. I know you are right and it does make your life more interesting and fulfilling to be involved in things, not to mention the fact that you are more likely to meet someone the more things you are involved in and the more places you go!!! I am 34 too so I understand all about freaking out!!
The only person I talk to about it is my best friend and I don’t know really if this is a good thing or not. I talk to her about everything as you do with your best friend. The problem is she is in a disasterous marriage and all she keeps on saying to me is " marriage is terrible, stay single, you’ll have a great life if you are single, I wish I had never gotten married"! She thinks nearly all marriages are bad but I just can’t agree with her on that. I know in my heart I will marry one day (hopefully sooner rather than later!!). If undertaken properly, it is a beautiful vocation.
Anyway thanks so much for your thoughts. It is nice to hear them from someone who is single and knows what they are talking about.
 
Now that we’ve had a few days to let things calm down…

Sorry, but I disagree - this whole topic is more of a “permissive will” thing. Let me give you a clear-cut example:

Paul and Mary are dating. They are both practicing Catholics who are still virgins, go to Mass every Sunday/holy day of obligation, are educated in the Catholic faith, etc. Mary, though, decides to break up with Paul to date Joe. Joe is dovorced, and since his annulment request was turned down, he is not eligible to marry in the Catholic Church. Mary knows this but yet still dates Joe and they get married in a civil ceremony. Now, think about these points:
  1. Whose fault is it that Mary broke up with Paul and married Joe? Is it because of God, or because Mary reneged on her Catholic faith?
  2. Is this an example of God’s permissive will or determinate will?
Just because God permits evil does not mean we should accept it; if anything, we still are obligated to confront it and fight it as best we can - and I personally feel that this is sorely lacking in today’s world that is preoccupied with political correctness and “nonjudgmentalism” of wrong actions, and this does apply as well in the dating world (which is how this relates to the topic at hand).
God ALLOWED this, and God’s allowing something is another way of saying it happened according to God’s permissive will. This is, I believe, Church teaching. This is explained by the Jesuit Father Jean Baptiste Saint-Jure in the book, “Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence”, pages 11-26, under the titles: “The Will of God Made and Governs All Things”, “God Controls All Events, whether Good or Bad”, “How Can God Will or Allow Evil?”. No, this priest was not a heretic.
 
While I can see were it is possible to be too picky so to speak, I also think it is possible to jump into marriage with the wrong person.
As a lot of my older mentors and wise friends always say: WAY better to be too picky than to not be picky enough. We know marriages that are borne from the latter - WHOA! Talk about a huge mess!
 
Depending on what she meant by “felt like trash”, I might take it as a compliment.
Well, l think there is a very serious problem if she is saying this because she is deriving her sense of self-worth from the relationship in general, and in particular from the attention that you are showing her. It is a problem because although she probably doesn’t realise it or mean to, she is actually using you as an emotional tranquiliser, and you are only making the situation worse by feeding it in the belief that both of you are in love.

The danger is when both parties lack the insight to see that they are really using each other. They go on to get married, and then eventually the attention they used to show each other out of unspoken and unrecognised necessity must be directed towards the children, and then they wonder what went wrong because each person feels deprived of attention from the other. In fact, nothing went wrong because it wasn’t right to begin with.

You see, neither person in the above example is capable of love because their relationships with other people are driven by getting rather than giving. Eventually something has to give, and in the context of this thread, that often and sadly means separation.

It’s a bit like an example l heard about piety. A person can attend daily Mass, say the Rosary daily, go to frequent Confession, and yet habitually fly off the handle at their neighbour for the smallest thing. How is such a thing possible? Probably because piety to that person is what a bottle of alcohol, a hit of heroin, a packet of cigarettes, or the attention garnered from wearing immodest clothes is to another: a temporary distraction from some form of pain, incurred either during their childhood or during their adult life, which the person never really confronts. The pain becomes buried, it simmers, and then it takes a hold of the person in other ways which leaves them painfully and, if left unresolved or untreated, permanently mystified. Often, though, people just resign their identity to their pain without ever acknowledging it. They might even say that’s how God made them when in fact it could be how they made themselves or allowed themselves to become.

In the case of a husband and wife, well, when the temporary hits of spousal affection wear off, enter alcohol addiction, enter adultery, you name it. The other person has become like a bottle of beer, but unlike a beer, a human being cannot be thrown away, cannot be consumed at leisure and to excess whenever the need arises. What happens when their partner becomes seriously ill or depressed?

This is just one example. I could give many others. My point being, and it’s a pretty simple one, is that instead of turning to God when they should, people turn to each other for fulfillment. It might work for a while, but it’s not sustainable, and by the time either person realises what’s gonig on, the damage has already been done. They turn to God at the end rather than at the beginning.

I hope my post shows a few possible consequences of that.

When people talk about being “whole”, they are simply talking about what makes them tick, what drives them. Unfortunately, secular culture encourages people to draw all of their strength from within, and to base all of their value on what they can provide and possess. The problem comes about when a person goes through hard times, as we have already seen, since everything they’ve based their life on and around is in pieces. Faith and trust in God is replaced by consumerism, careerism and exploitation that is cleverly rebadged as some kind of spirituality. But enough of that tangent.

What we need to do is to examine who we are, in a psychological or natural sense, in the context of what we are in a supernatural sense.

I don’t think l’m saying anything unreasonable or heretical here.

Just my :twocents: 🤷
 
God ALLOWED this, and God’s allowing something is another way of saying it happened according to God’s permissive will. This is, I believe, Church teaching. This is explained by the Jesuit Father Jean Baptiste Saint-Jure in the book, “Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence”, pages 11-26, under the titles: “The Will of God Made and Governs All Things”, “God Controls All Events, whether Good or Bad”, “How Can God Will or Allow Evil?”. No, this priest was not a heretic.
OK, you answered #2. Good.

Now, what is your answer to #1?
 
Well, l think there is a very serious problem if she is saying this because she is deriving her sense of self-worth from the relationship in general, and in particular from the attention that you are showing her. It is a problem because although she probably doesn’t realise it or mean to, she is actually using you as an emotional tranquiliser, and you are only making the situation worse by feeding it in the belief that both of you are in love.

The danger is when both parties lack the insight to see that they are really using each other. They go on to get married, and then eventually the attention they used to show each other out of unspoken and unrecognised necessity must be directed towards the children, and then they wonder what went wrong because each person feels deprived of attention from the other. In fact, nothing went wrong because it wasn’t right to begin with.

You see, neither person in the above example is capable of love because their relationships with other people are driven by getting rather than giving. Eventually something has to give, and in the context of this thread, that often and sadly means separation.

It’s a bit like an example l heard about piety. A person can attend daily Mass, say the Rosary daily, go to frequent Confession, and yet habitually fly off the handle at their neighbour for the smallest thing. How is such a thing possible? Probably because piety to that person is what a bottle of alcohol, a hit of heroin, a packet of cigarettes, or the attention garnered from wearing immodest clothes is to another: a temporary distraction from some form of pain, incurred either during their childhood or during their adult life, which the person never really confronts. The pain becomes buried, it simmers, and then it takes a hold of the person in other ways which leaves them painfully and, if left unresolved or untreated, permanently mystified. Often, though, people just resign their identity to their pain without ever acknowledging it. They might even say that’s how God made them when in fact it could be how they made themselves or allowed themselves to become.

In the case of a husband and wife, well, when the temporary hits of spousal affection wear off, enter alcohol addiction, enter adultery, you name it. The other person has become like a bottle of beer, but unlike a beer, a human being cannot be thrown away, cannot be consumed at leisure and to excess whenever the need arises. What happens when their partner becomes seriously ill or depressed?

This is just one example. I could give many others. My point being, and it’s a pretty simple one, is that instead of turning to God when they should, people turn to each other for fulfillment. It might work for a while, but it’s not sustainable, and by the time either person realises what’s gonig on, the damage has already been done. They turn to God at the end rather than at the beginning.

I hope my post shows a few possible consequences of that.

When people talk about being “whole”, they are simply talking about what makes them tick, what drives them. Unfortunately, secular culture encourages people to draw all of their strength from within, and to base all of their value on what they can provide and possess. The problem comes about when a person goes through hard times, as we have already seen, since everything they’ve based their life on and around is in pieces. Faith and trust in God is replaced by consumerism, careerism and exploitation that is cleverly rebadged as some kind of spirituality. But enough of that tangent.

What we need to do is to examine who we are, in a psychological or natural sense, in the context of what we are in a supernatural sense.

I don’t think l’m saying anything unreasonable or heretical here.

Just my :twocents: 🤷
First of all, I prefaced what I said with “depending on what she meant”. And it is really unfair for anyone to jump to the conclusion that his will automatically lead to addictive behavior.

The fact of the matter is that we were not born to be alone, and the person may have “felt like trash” simply due to rejection, and the fact that this person is perhaps for the first time not being rejected (provided the person accepting her is not “using” her in a toxic way (I have to walk on eggshells with my choice of words here, since I never know when the self-appointed PC-police will barge in)) is probably exactly what she needs in life.

Sometimes simply showing a person love is all that is needed. Or are you simply unable or unwilling to show love to someone who may have had a rough break in life? Remember, St. Paul does say that we need to “bear each others burdens” (Galatians :2), and I seriously wonder if this Jansenistic requirement to “be whole first” is just a pathetic attempt to avoid doing the Christian duty of “bearing another’s burdens”.
 
First of all, I prefaced what I said with “depending on what she meant”. And it is really unfair for anyone to jump to the conclusion that his will automatically lead to addictive behavior.

The fact of the matter is that we were not born to be alone, and the person may have “felt like trash” simply due to rejection, and the fact that this person is perhaps for the first time not being rejected (provided the person accepting her is not “using” her in a toxic way (I have to walk on eggshells with my choice of words here, since I never know when the self-appointed PC-police will barge in)) is probably exactly what she needs in life.

Sometimes simply showing a person love is all that is needed. Or are you simply unable or unwilling to show love to someone who may have had a rough break in life? Remember, St. Paul does say that we need to “bear each others burdens” (Galatians :2), and I seriously wonder if this Jansenistic requirement to “be whole first” is just a pathetic attempt to avoid doing the Christian duty of “bearing another’s burdens”.
I do understand what you meant by “depending on what she meant”, and apologise for causing any offense. I only intended to take one example and run with it, I wasn’t having a go at you personally. I will be more careful with my language next time 😊

Norseman, l agree with you. Just to give a personal example, l do some volunteer work which routinely brings me into contact with people who are former prison inmates, have serious mental illnesses, are living in domestic violence situations, and so forth. They often have quite a few children and cannot work for a variety of reasons. Although we are principally there to give them financial and material assistance, often the greatest thing we can do for them is to love them just for who they are, warts and all. This gives them the confidence they need to able to help themselves where they can and rebuild their shattered lives.

Some of the strongest examples of faith l have seen in my life are amongst the destitute. I’ve heard a saying that goes something like: “Faith isn’t faith until it’s all you’re holding onto”. I think there’s a lot of truth in that.

But it’s one thing to help another person to carry their cross, and it’s another to take it off them. I heard a very beautiful analogy once. It basically says that you can’t have the butterfly after the caterpillar without the intervening struggle as the butterfly fights its away out of its cocoon. If you help the butterfly out of its cocoon, it won’t survive.

So, all l wanted to say is that there are some things that a person really needs to come to terms with before they jump into a relationship. Otherwise, like the example of the butterfly, they will find it very hard to survive the rigors of marriage when they come. That’s all.

BTW, l am not PC in the least. Feel free to be as un-PC as you like 😉
 
Further to my last post, l just want to make sure that l haven’t given the impression that l think spouses shouldn’t be relying upon one another for support. They are ultimately there to help one another and their children to get to heaven, whatever that may entail.

This is a thread about finding spouses, though. My point is that we need to make sure that we don’t commence this journey with the wrong person for all the reasons that l’ve previously discussed.

Hope this clears up any confusion.
 
I do understand what you meant by “depending on what she meant”, and apologise for causing any offense. I only intended to take one example and run with it, I wasn’t having a go at you personally. I will be more careful with my language next time 😊

Norseman, l agree with you. Just to give a personal example, l do some volunteer work which routinely brings me into contact with people who are former prison inmates, have serious mental illnesses, are living in domestic violence situations, and so forth. They often have quite a few children and cannot work for a variety of reasons. Although we are principally there to give them financial and material assistance, often the greatest thing we can do for them is to love them just for who they are, warts and all. This gives them the confidence they need to able to help themselves where they can and rebuild their shattered lives.

Some of the strongest examples of faith l have seen in my life are amongst the destitute. I’ve heard a saying that goes something like: “Faith isn’t faith until it’s all you’re holding onto”. I think there’s a lot of truth in that.

But it’s one thing to help another person to carry their cross, and it’s another to take it off them. I heard a very beautiful analogy once. It basically says that you can’t have the butterfly after the caterpillar without the intervening struggle as the butterfly fights its away out of its cocoon. If you help the butterfly out of its cocoon, it won’t survive.

So, all l wanted to say is that there are some things that a person really needs to come to terms with before they jump into a relationship. Otherwise, like the example of the butterfly, they will find it very hard to survive the rigors of marriage when they come. That’s all.

BTW, l am not PC in the least. Feel free to be as un-PC as you like 😉
OK, I don’t dispute that in serious cases (like addictions, severe mental problems, violent behavior, etc.) these need to be worked out, because these are problems that will endanger a relationship and marriage should not be used as . However, the majority of people, I would imagine, have less serious problems that are not of the relationship-threatening type (at this time) and are worked on “en route” (which is probably true about our lives in general). I think distinguishing betwen these two is the key here, for if we wait until we are “perfect” I don’t think there will be any marriages!

Additionally, a person can “have it all together” - and yet still will have that longing tug within them that says that something is missing, and that is where it is determined that what is missing is the spouse and family life. That is why I express doubts that we can be 100% whole in this lifetime and be completely content single; if I were completely content single then that would mean I could handle lifelong celibacy, in which case there is a good chance I probably would be wearing a collar. And maybe the fact that I approach it from the standpoint of a male who has discerned priesthood might be the source of some of our different viewpoints.

Maybe instead of saying we need to be “whole” we should say “whole enough”.

Anyway…

OP, my apologies if this has gone off topic and derailed, I just have had to listen to a lot of bad advice and cliches in my life and I just hope that my rantings and ravings may help someone else reading this thread not be suckered into some of the modern-day cliches of relation-babble.
 
Mizfit, When I was in the dating field, before I found my spouse, I was told by a wise person that if you’re looking, you also need to be advertising. I read that you’re already on websites, which is great. In fact, my sister, who has been looking for a loooong time for a good catholic guy, found one who lived half a state away. They wrote for half a year, and when they were serious, they decided to meet. It was amazing, and after meeting a few times they decided to become engaged. My sister’s two requirements for engagement (because she’d had a few poor experiences with boyfriends in the past) were that the guy have a job, and that to pursue and strengthen their relationship, he move to be nearer. As they are now engaged to be married, he did both of those things, moved to the same town, and they’re working on building a beautiful relationship from teh Long Distance Relt. that they had. I would suggest you not be afraid of finding a compatible guy that is a little further away, because that can always change if you decide to become serious.

Also, When I mentioned you need to advertise, I also meant that you need to tell your friends, family, and everyone you know that you are in the “market” for such and such a man. I met my husband through the grapevine, so it is a great way to get your name out there!

Good luck!
 
I have to answer this question by telling you what worked for me. I am getting married June 21st to the most wonderful Catholic man ever. I was in your same boat not too long ago (about 6 months to be more precise). I tried a web site called Ave Maria Singles. If you are looking for devout Catholic men who love the Lord and His Church, this is the place for you! There is a prayer to St. Raphael on the homepage, which I used to pray all the time. I owe my delirious happiness to the Lord and to Ave Maria Catholic Singles!!! (This is not a paid advertisement, just a testimonial from an extremely satisfied customer!!)
 
I wonder if it would be inappropriate to have a forum here on this site for single Catholics who would like to meet…? I know there are special sites for this already out there, but it seems like a lot of people here have questions about being single and wanting to find other singles…
 
I have to answer this question by telling you what worked for me. I am getting married June 21st to the most wonderful Catholic man ever. I was in your same boat not too long ago (about 6 months to be more precise). I tried a web site called Ave Maria Singles. If you are looking for devout Catholic men who love the Lord and His Church, this is the place for you! There is a prayer to St. Raphael on the homepage, which I used to pray all the time. I owe my delirious happiness to the Lord and to Ave Maria Catholic Singles!!! (This is not a paid advertisement, just a testimonial from an extremely satisfied customer!!)
I am so happy this worked for you! God bless you and your fiance in your upcoming marriage!

I have been on AMS for over a year and have had little luck. Perhaps it’s the age range (I’m 40) or my status (single mom) or my civil marriage and subsequent annulment – but all those devout Catholic men who love the Lord and His Church aren’t budging where I’m concerned. I’m intelligent, compassionate, quick-witted, joyful, prayerful, financially stable, loyal, playful, blah, blah, blah. Doesn’t make a whit of difference if those devout men won’t even respond to a “hello” email 🤷

It does work for some – but for the vast majority, AMS or any other website does not work. Just look at the numbers on the AMS homepage. It is, in fact, one possibility for meeting a man – but not the only one, and probably not the best.

Gertie
 
I’m still young, in school, and working on becoming financially independent (I just got a job, YAY!). I’m also discerning religious life.

However, I’m completely open to dating and marrying a good Catholic boy, if marriage is indeed what I’m called to. I have no issues meeting people or w/e. But it is hard, even if you’re a young person, simply because it seems that people just aren’t into the Church, disagree with a lot of its teachings, aren’t good people (even if they’re practicing Catholics), are devout Christians but not Catholic, are just not interested, or have girlfriends.

Honestly, I don’t care if the guy’s an absolute spotless virgin or not, simply because that doesn’t make him a good Catholic or a good person. I’d rather have a guy who’s honest, kind, compassionate, sensitive, peaceful, and prayerful, regardless if he’s had sex in the past or not. Looks don’t matter to me, because I find that as I become closer to a guy emotionally (when one of us starts thinking of the other in “that way”), I start to see him as very handsome, even if others don’t. I find that I’m attracted to practicing Catholic guys who make me laugh, are genuinely good to people, and who are very sweet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top