First openly gay Eagle Scout

  • Thread starter Thread starter JTD_Eagle1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
One doesn’t choose to be black One does choose to engage in homosexual behavior
Which, I think, is part of the confusion. Many homosexuals are incapable of separating what they do with what they are. If they have SSA, then they are homosexuals. The inability to separate actions from being is part of the problem.
 
Which, I think, is part of the confusion. Many homosexuals are incapable of separating what they do with what they are. If they have SSA, then they are homosexuals. The inability to separate actions from being is part of the problem.
Off-topic:

I recognized your signature line as something a mystic poet would write.
“To love for the sake of being loved is human; to love for the sake of loving is Angelic.” – Alphonse de Lamartine

I particularly like this quote of his:

“Experience is the only prophecy of wise men” -Alphonse de Lamartine.
Thank you for introducing him. I will be reading more of Alphonse de Lamartine’s writings.
 
Exactly! In addition, one can’t help but wonder why they define their entire being, not on the fact that they are made in the image and likeness of God, but rather wholly on the basis of their *sexual *orientation.
I have personally found that more conservative Christians define gay people wholly on the basis of sexual orientation than gay people do.
 
And I have personally found the opposite.
When gay people say they are gay they don’t mean it ontologically anymore than when some says they are left handed. I have seen people act as though sexuality is the major part of them, but gay men don’t seem to do it at a (much) higher rate than men in general do.
 
When gay people say they are gay they don’t mean it ontologically anymore than when some says they are left handed. I have seen people act as though sexuality is the major part of them, but gay men don’t seem to do it at a (much) higher rate than men in general do.
says you. I know quite a few gay people and some who are very close to me. They would disagree. Their sexuality is the height of the definition of who they are. More so than religion or race. Your experience may be different but that is why anecdotal points are so easy to make and hard to back up.🤷
 
I have personally found that more conservative Christians define gay people wholly on the basis of sexual orientation than gay people do.
Is that an implication that conservative Christians have an agenda? 🙂

Many gays are upfront about their orientation because of their empathy for people who don’t like gays, they feel it is better to hear it straight out from themselves and get it out the open quickly so they (other people) are not embarrassment later.
 
I think we need to pay careful attention to the wording of the new poicy and not give up ground that has not yet been surrendered.

The new policy does not state that it allows “openly gay” scouts (if that term is being used synonymously with “practicing the gay lifestyle”). It simply states that scouts cannot be excluded based on sexual orientation alone…

Since the Boy Scouts have affirmed that sexual activity is contrary to the virtue of scouting, then there shouldn’t be any sexual activity among any of the scouts – whether of heterosexual orientation or homosexual orientation.
👍
 
I have personally found that more conservative Christians define gay people wholly on the basis of sexual orientation than gay people do.
First, your use of the qualifier “wholly” is a strawman. Nobody here has said “wholly” or anything similar. It isn’t that simple.

But further, it is impossible to say that sexual orientation has no impact on identification as gay. The very term gay is synonymous with sexual orientation. They cannot be separated.

I only know one gay person who is a staunch, Orthodox Catholic, and remains chaste. He recognizes his SSA, and he disagrees with you. Reflecting on the time before his re-conversion, he recognized that he very much identified himself with his sexual orientation. he says that even to this day he struggles to remind himself that his innate desires do not define him, but that his actions and his conscience do.

And for the other gay people I know, they very much identify with their sexuality. Indeed, it was central to who they were. I have never had any in-depth discussions as I did with the former individual I discussed, but these folk made it very clear that “who they loved, and how they loved them” was important. Separating being “gay” from “sexual orientation” is impossible.
 
When gay people say they are gay they don’t mean it ontologically anymore than when some says they are left handed. I have seen people act as though sexuality is the major part of them, but gay men don’t seem to do it at a (much) higher rate than men in general do.
If you have watched any of the talent shows lately like American Idol, The Voice, America’s Got Talent, you might have noticed an increasing number of openly gay people. They let it be known. Why? Probably to get the sympathy vote like everyone else who has a sad story to tell. I’m getting tired of hearing all the sad stories before even hearing them sing for the first time. A little more down the road, after we have gotten to hear their voice and judge their talent without the sympathy interfering with our decision, then it would be nice to eventually hear their story. But I don’t see straight young men announcing that they are straight. Why should we need to hear that someone has a same sex attraction any more that we need to hear that someone has an attraction to children or has any other temptation against chastity? Temptations do not define who we are.
 
But do we want to encourage that?
LOL! Let me answer that from what I imagine is the perspective of a young gay male. Are you kidding me? Shut those idiots up, I couldn’t care less about their macho imaginations.
 
I do not seek the morality of the Church to be reflected completely in a secular society-
We should strive to spread the Gospel in various ways.
where homosexuality is value-neutral.
:confused:

Thankfully, I don’t think we’re there quite yet.
 
Thank you for your kind concern. I was pleasantly surprised that you picked up on the mystic aspects of my insight. I don’t know if this will ally your concern but I begin all my meditation with prayer to the Creator and the Son asking their guidance and to St Francis DeSales who was a mystic and is my patron Saint.
Spirituality through Christ is good, without Him no.
 
First, your use of the qualifier “wholly” is a strawman. Nobody here has said “wholly” or anything similar. It isn’t that simple.

But further, it is impossible to say that sexual orientation has no impact on identification as gay. The very term gay is synonymous with sexual orientation. They cannot be separated.

I only know one gay person who is a staunch, Orthodox Catholic, and remains chaste. He recognizes his SSA, and he disagrees with you. Reflecting on the time before his re-conversion, he recognized that he very much identified himself with his sexual orientation. he says that even to this day he struggles to remind himself that his innate desires do not define him, but that his actions and his conscience do.

And for the other gay people I know, they very much identify with their sexuality. Indeed, it was central to who they were. I have never had any in-depth discussions as I did with the former individual I discussed, but these folk made it very clear that “who they loved, and how they loved them” was important. Separating being “gay” from “sexual orientation” is impossible.
I’m a lesbian. Why is that wrong to acknowledge? My SSAs are a part of me, and aren’t something I “do.” But guess what? There’s a place for gays and lesbians in the Church, just as there’s a place for straight men and straight women (and bisexual men and bisexual women). Trying to force people to stop agreeing that fundamental qualities about themselves (their hair color, their eye color, their skin color, who they’re attracted to) just makes them feel more trapped. Why do that when you could just accept them for who they are and how they feel and show them moral behavior?
 
What conquests? A lot of men have lousy dating skills. :o
I agree, but their imaginations often make up for their lack dating skills, making them the incarnation of Casanova in their own minds and whose fantasy escapades they freely share with anyone who will listen. Not to be outdone there is a gay equivalent version of the Casanova syndrome. Karen Horney (a German psychoanalyst who practiced in the United States during her later career.) would likely have referred to the Cassanova complex as an expression of our “Ideal self” to keep our “despised self” unconsciousness.
 
I’m a lesbian. Why is that wrong to acknowledge? My SSAs are a part of me, and aren’t something I “do.” But guess what? There’s a place for gays and lesbians in the Church, just as there’s a place for straight men and straight women (and bisexual men and bisexual women). Trying to force people to stop agreeing that fundamental qualities about themselves (their hair color, their eye color, their skin color, who they’re attracted to) just makes them feel more trapped. Why do that when you could just accept them for who they are and how they feel and show them moral behavior?
From a Christian standpoint, your SSA should mean nothing to me. In fact, it’s too much information. Do alcoholics announce over coffee and donuts after Sunday Mass that they are alcoholics? I am to treat you as I do everyone else with love and dignity because you are a child of God. Why do I need to know you are a lesbian?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top