FL Teachers Union Files Suit

  • Thread starter Thread starter Beau_Ouiville
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Beau_Ouiville

Guest
The new law means that public funds could go to vouchers for all types of religious programs; such as Rastafarians, Animists and the snake handlers.

"TALLHASSEE, Fla. - Individuals and groups representing Florida’s public schools and some religious communities have filed a lawsuit in state Circuit Court (2011-CA-1892) in Tallahassee. They are challenging a constitutional amendment placed on the ballot by the Florida Legislature. Amendment Seven would substantially alter the constitution’s no-aid provision, which has been in effect for more than 125 years. This provision (in Article 1, Section 3) protects the religious freedom rights of all Floridians by barring taxpayer-funded aid to religious institutions.

The proposed amendment, if approved by voters, would gut that protection, according to Florida Education Association (FEA) President Andy Ford.

“If Amendment Seven were to pass, it could open the flood gates for any school of any type to try and get state funding, at the expense of the public schools.”

publicnewsservice.org/index.php?/content/article/21331-1

Individuals who support voucher systems rarely deal with the question of its effect or constitutionality.
 
What I constantly find amusing is that those who tend to be against vouchers are usually against monopolies, except when that monopoly is a government entity.
 
What I constantly find amusing is that those who tend to be against vouchers are usually against monopolies, except when that monopoly is a government entity.
It would be a monopoly if there were no private or parochial schools.
 
It would be a monopoly if there were no private or parochial schools.
It wouldn’t be a monopoly if it wasn’t publically funded. Put “public” schools on equal footing with private schools and they would fall flat on their faces. They are a monopoly because public school is the default option. You an only opt out of it if you have the money, which is already begin deducted from your property and income taxes.
 
It would be a monopoly if there were no private or parochial schools.
Consider the Chicago Public Schools for a moment. Imagine producing a product so bad, that even many poor people won’t take it when you are giving it away for free. You know you are incompetent when people won’t take your product for free.
 
Judging by the opinions of others, because I go to a public high school, my education is sub-par. 😊 I guess for senior year this year, I should stop trying and stop getting my 4.3 GPA and forget about my 31 ACT. I’m obviously doing to well. 🤷
 
Judging by the opinions of others, because I go to a public high school, my education is sub-par. 😊 I guess for senior year this year, I should stop trying and stop getting my 4.3 GPA and forget about my 31 ACT. I’m obviously doing to well. 🤷
Not necessarily. You could be one of those students who attends a good school, of which there are many. It could also be the case that you are a motivated student. Self motivation can overcome even a particularly sub-par school. Self motivated students have the best chance of overcoming progressive teaching methods, which are the biggest problem in American education. But as a student, that’s not your issue. Your issue is preparing yourself for your future.

It would only serve to cut off your own nose despite your face for you to stop working hard. The fact is that in many ways, schooling is self-centered. Doing well in school often leads to success in the economy later on. Don’t sacrifice your future.

Jon
 
Given the fact that there are those who seem to want nothing more than to manipulate religious institiutions and force them to conform to their views, I would argue that this law would actually do more harm to Catholic schools. The money could only be offered to those schools that are willing to teach certain beliefs. (ex homosexuality) This would reward corrupt Christian schools at the expense of the others. I would be vary cautious about this.
 
All this scare tactic nonsense about rastafarian and snake handlers boils down to one simple issue: these guys are insistent that the government is more responsible for guiding kids education than parents are.

The existence of a few nut cases is a poor excuse for effectively setting a punitive tax on people who choose to opt out of the public school system.
 
Judging by the opinions of others, because I go to a public high school, my education is sub-par. 😊 I guess for senior year this year, I should stop trying and stop getting my 4.3 GPA and forget about my 31 ACT. I’m obviously doing to well. 🤷
Oh, not all public high schools are sub-par academically. No, indeed. Some are quite good, particularly those in wealthy suburbs. But in the main, they’re not.

Individual experiences and motivation do mean a lot too. I went to a public high school so bad that when I entered college (a Jesuit school. They had high expectations then.) I had no idea what the professors were talking about for the most part.

I had no language in high school like most of my peers who had attended private schools. So I forced myself to memorize conversations in French so I could at least survive until I could catch up.

But the real thing that saved me was having been in high school debate, without which I would have absolutely flunked out in the first semester. Forces one to research; to formulate arguments, to arrange thoughts and present them. Every paper I ever wrote in college was a “debate plan”. Every single one. Sometimes it was “affirmative” and sometimes it was “negative”, but it was always a debate plan. But debating is never “taught”. It’s learned by experience and I was fortunate enough to have attended a public school that, despite its other shortcomings, was very active in a debate circuit that was possibly the most challenging in the country.

Not sure what your salvation has been, and it’s good that you are doing well. But one person’s experience does not tell all there is to know about schools. Not yours and not mine either.

But your ACT score won’t save you from grief, nor will your GPA if you attend a truly challenging college. There aren’t very many of those anymore, but they do exist.
 
Wow, say the average cost per puplis is $10K, and say a student could go to public school for free, or get a voucher for half that, $5K, if they passed a test at the end of the year.

The government involved gets to save money, and the parents get to choose the best education for their child.
 
This provision (in Article 1, Section 3) protects the religious freedom rights of all Floridians by barring taxpayer-funded aid to religious institutions.
What an inane sentence. We must take away rights to protect rights.
 
Please explain how a CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT can be unconstitutional.
I am not familiar with the details, but I believe the legality of school voucher programs is dependent on how they are framed and implemented. What might be permitted under a state constitution may run afoul of the US Constitution.
 
Wow, say the average cost per puplis is $10K, and say a student could go to public school for free, or get a voucher for half that, $5K, if they passed a test at the end of the year.

The government involved gets to save money, and the parents get to choose the best education for their child.
Ten years ago, the average cost per student was $8800. My kids went to a great Catholic School for less than $4K each. If we could have received even a $2000 dollar voucher per child, we would have all benefitted.

The big loser however, is the union. They have the most to lose ($) and it’s no coincidence they are the first to file suit. They aren’t really interested in the religion issue, just the $$.
 
I am not familiar with the details, but I believe the legality of school voucher programs is dependent on how they are framed and implemented. What might be permitted under a state constitution may run afoul of the US Constitution.
Nothing in the US Constitution even touches on the issue.
 
Ten years ago, the average cost per student was $8800. My kids went to a great Catholic School for less than $4K each. If we could have received even a $2000 dollar voucher per child, we would have all benefitted.

The big loser however, is the union. They have the most to lose ($) and it’s no coincidence they are the first to file suit. They aren’t really interested in the religion issue, just the $$.
Today schools spend on average at LEAST $12k per student. Usually it is much higher, $15-20k per student.
 
The new law means that public funds could go to vouchers for all types of religious programs; such as Rastafarians, Animists and the snake handlers.

"TALLHASSEE, Fla. - Individuals and groups representing Florida’s public schools and some religious communities have filed a lawsuit in state Circuit Court (2011-CA-1892) in Tallahassee. They are challenging a constitutional amendment placed on the ballot by the Florida Legislature. Amendment Seven would substantially alter the constitution’s no-aid provision, which has been in effect for more than 125 years. This provision (in Article 1, Section 3) protects the religious freedom rights of all Floridians by barring taxpayer-funded aid to religious institutions.

The proposed amendment, if approved by voters, would gut that protection, according to Florida Education Association (FEA) President Andy Ford.

“If Amendment Seven were to pass, it could open the flood gates for any school of any type to try and get state funding, at the expense of the public schools.”

publicnewsservice.org/index.php?/content/article/21331-1

Individuals who support voucher systems rarely deal with the question of its effect or constitutionality.
Let me guess. The unions want more or keep what they have, no matter what. Oh, boo hoo hoo. Your lies aren’t moving anyone here. Public unions are the cancer of America.
 
Judging by the opinions of others, because I go to a public high school, my education is sub-par. 😊 I guess for senior year this year, I should stop trying and stop getting my 4.3 GPA and forget about my 31 ACT. I’m obviously doing to well. 🤷
Nope, sounds like you have a pretty good school. Just because a school is public does not automatically mean its subpar to the private schools anymore than one can presume just because a school is private that its better than public or other options, such as cyber schools or magnet schools.

I’m all for looking for other options to improve the schools that already exist, not vouchers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top