Florida Passes Plan For Racially-Based Academic Goals

  • Thread starter Thread starter Yerusalyim
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

Yerusalyim

Guest
The Florida State Board of Education passed a plan that sets goals for students in math and reading based upon their race.

On Tuesday, the board passed a revised strategic plan that says that by 2018, it wants 90 percent of Asian students, 88 percent of white students, 81 percent of Hispanics and 74 percent of black students to be reading at or above grade level. For math, the goals are 92 percent of Asian kids to be proficient, whites at 86 percent, Hispanics at 80 percent and blacks at 74 percent. It also measures by other groupings, such as poverty and disabilities, reported the Palm Beach Post.
tampa.cbslocal.com/2012/10/12/florida-passes-plan-for-racially-based-academic-goals/

wrong and racist.
 
What in the name of the tiny-voiced Hatsune Miku is this?
Crescentinus,

This is the Florida Board of Education being racist. The goals they’ve set for Asians reading at proficency levil is 90%…86% for whites, 80% for hispanics and 74% of blacks. This is nothing more than racism. A standard is a standard. Either we expect 85% of ALL STUDENTS regardless of race to read at proficiency level…or we don’t. To parse it out like this by race is first, racist, and second hurts the minorities that aren’t expected to score as high.
 
The new policy sounds unusual, and I don’t understand its rationale. Is it simply a matter of lowering the standards by which schools are evaluated?

In a quick check for information the Florida Board of Education website has posted a link to a “letter to the editor” defending the new policy. The letter was written by a staffer at a Washington DC based organization called The Education Trust. I have to wonder if “The Education Trust” may have advised the Florida Board of Education in adopting the new goals.

fldoe.org/news/

edtrust.org/dc/press-room/press-release/response-from-the-education-trust-to-news-coverage-of-florida-board-of-e

Is anyone familiar with The Education Trust or have more information about the new Florida policy?
 
Those rates sound like the passing scores now. The goal may be 85% over all - but the actual rates will break out by race/income about how they listed it.

My guess this is the state trying to make things harder on the schools so that they can’t say they met the overall goal (85%), but did so with only 65% of Blacks passing vs 95% of Asians.
 
I’ll leave blacks and Hispanics out of this because I’m neither. So I’ll beat up on my own “race” exclusively.

88% of whites are supposed to function at or above grade level? Wait a minute, that’s AT OR ABOVE GRADE LEVEL. Why is it okay for 12% of whites not to function at grade level, particularly when “grade level” is really not very demanding at all.

Are these people daft? Accepting a 12% failure rate? That’s what it is…they are accepting it that 12% of whites will FAIL. :eek:
 
It seems Florida is not the only US state which has implemented racially based standards for schools, apparently to avoid failing the federal standards established by the No Child Left Behind law.
Other states, such as Virginia, have also come under fire in recent months for setting achievement goals based on race. The Virginia Legislative Black Caucus sent a letter to Gov. Bob McDonnell in August after that state released its new goals, calling the benchmarks “insulting and narrow-minded.”
palmbeachpost.com/news/news/state-regional-education/florida-to-measure-student-goals-by-race/nSbNt/
The new standards [for Virginia] still require every student, regardless of background, to correctly answer the same number of questions to pass SOL tests.
For example, every student who takes the third-grade math exam must answer correctly 23 of 35 questions to pass, no matter their race or background.
The state did set new pass rates, or goals for how many students in each group pass each exam.
Using the same example of the third-grade math test: the state goal is for 45 percent of black students to answer 23 of 35 items correctly and for 82 percent of Asian students to answer 23 of 35 items correctly.
articles.dailypress.com/2012-08-16/news/dp-nws-subgroup-discontent-20120816_1_new-achievement-goals-black-students-asian-students

The racially based standards seem to be attempts by different states to avoid failing to meet the standards imposed by the US Congress.
 
Crescentinus,

This is the Florida Board of Education being racist. The goals they’ve set for Asians reading at proficency levil is 90%…86% for whites, 80% for hispanics and 74% of blacks. This is nothing more than racism. A standard is a standard. Either we expect 85% of ALL STUDENTS regardless of race to read at proficiency level…or we don’t. To parse it out like this by race is first, racist, and second hurts the minorities that aren’t expected to score as high.
Oh boy. D:
Remind me not to study in Florida.
 
Well I guess it’s safe now to start whistle Dixie in FL…I guess tha South’s risin’ again. :rolleyes:

I love how the anti-racists have just completed a 360…congrats y’all back at where you came from. What’s next welfare programs for African-Americans where they work for free but get room and board? oh wait that’s the US Penitentiary System.

Sad :sad_yes:
 
I also feel that this is wrong and racist. The standards should be the same for all students, not customized based on a student’s race.
 
I am mixed about this because I am not too sure that all races have equal abilities. For instance, blacks tend to be superior athletes in many cases.

Races have equal RIGHTS but I fear even if scientists conduct a study that find that ABILITIES are statistically different people will jump to assume that it is bigotry. It is like egalitarianism taken to an absurd level like when feminists declare that men and woman are equal in every way, when natural abilities tend to be different, especially due to biology. I am not too sure that all races have equal abilities. For example why do Indians perform horribly at athletics but well in science contests? Why are people of African descent so good at athletics? I don’t think that it is only due to cultural differences.
 
I am concerned about any law that marks some races as inferior. Besides perpetuating stereotypes (Asians are smart and Blacks are dumb), racism by its very nature de-humanizes people by viewing them through the filter of skin color.
 
I believe that children of all races will succeed if given the same educational opportunities. That’s why I like the concept of school vouchers for inner city children. I’m a white lawyer and I appear before many black judges in court, all of whom are superior jurists. Similarly, I work with many black lawyers whom I consider to be excellent advocates for their clients (and my dear friends). I hold no stereotypes when it comes to intelligence and God-given ability. A good education is the key to success for all races.
 
I believe that children of all races will succeed if given the same educational opportunities. That’s why I like the concept of school vouchers for inner city children. I’m a white lawyer and I appear before many black judges in court, all of whom are superior jurists. Similarly, I work with many black lawyers whom I consider to be excellent advocates for their clients (and my dear friends). I hold no stereotypes when it comes to intelligence and God-given ability. A good education is the key to success for all races.
^This! 👍

Here in Manila, there’s a stereotype that the Filipino-Chinese are somehow better than everyone else at math. Of course, that stereotype does not hold water for two reasons.
  1. A child that has a good background at math (for instance, being taught math at an early age) and keeps it up will be very good at it regardless of race, or even other subjects for that matter.
  2. I know for a fact that not all Filipino-Chinese are good at math and they are not a minority within the Filipino-Chinese community either. The fact that there are Filipino-Chinese parents (as well as parents who are not Filipino-Chinese) who send their children to some other type of school after school proves this fact well.
 
Racism is rampant in education. Affirmative action, racial quotas for college enrollment, pushing kids who aren’t ready into colleges they won’t succeed in just because they’re a minority, and race based hiring of staff are all common. Having different standards for different races is no surprise.

Affirmative action: the idea that you can defeat racism by treating one race much worse than another, and that you can close an achievement gap between races by requiring the one in front to work much harder than the one that is doing poorly.
 
I am mixed about this because I am not too sure that all races have equal abilities. For instance, blacks tend to be superior athletes in many cases.

Races have equal RIGHTS but I fear even if scientists conduct a study that find that ABILITIES are statistically different people will jump to assume that it is bigotry. It is like egalitarianism taken to an absurd level like when feminists declare that men and woman are equal in every way, when natural abilities tend to be different, especially due to biology. I am not too sure that all races have equal abilities. For example why do Indians perform horribly at athletics but well in science contests? Why are people of African descent so good at athletics? I don’t think that it is only due to cultural differences.
This is so incrediably insulting. Please read TampaDave’s response several times. The color of someon’s skin has absolutely nothing to do with their potential on a test or their athletic ability. :mad:

The biological differences between men and women have nothing to do with the intellectual capacity of people of different race categories.
 
Skin color means nothing, but genetic factors might. They are in no way lesser humans because genes might influence which abilities are statistically likely. A human doesn’t derive his value by his abilities. All men have equal rights but is it plainly clear that all men are not equal in ability. Genes may play a role.

Tell me, are my physical abilities the same as yours because I am born with a genetic disability? Clearly not. But Catholicism does not value humans by their abilities, so I do not see what is offensive of stating that not all people are endowed with the same abilities. This is an objective fact, and I believe that genetics might be a factor. 🤷

The bible also states that different people are blessed with different gifts of the Holy Spirit. Why not complain to God that all people should receive the same gifts? In the same sense God endows us at birth different talents, and genes are a part of birth. Nobody is “inferior” because we may have different abilities. I happen to believe that genes are a factor into which abilities we mau have.
 
Skin color means nothing, but genetic factors might. They are in no way lesser humans because genes might influence which abilities are statistically likely. A human doesn’t derive his value by his abilities. All men have equal rights but is it plainly clear that all men are not equal in ability. Genes may play a role.

Tell me, are my physical abilities the same as yours because I am born with a genetic disability? Clearly not. But Catholicism does not value humans by their abilities, so I do not see what is offensive of stating that not all people are endowed with the same abilities. This is an objective fact, and I believe that genetics might be a factor. 🤷

The bible also states that different people are blessed with different gifts of the Holy Spirit. Why not complain to God that all people should receive the same gifts? In the same sense God endows us at birth different talents, and genes are a part of birth. Nobody is “inferior” because we may have different abilities. I happen to believe that genes are a factor into which abilities we mau have.
There are many blacks who have exhibited a high intelligence, so I do not think that there are genetic factors.

Unfortunately, when our country discriminates among races “in favor of” blacks, it seems to backfire, because everyone ends up with the idea that there must be a deficiency since we need to help them just to make them equal.

I think we should change the school system and put more responsibility on the parents than the teachers by simply having instruction and making the passing of tests be a marker for moving on rather than having everything based on age, which is a totally arbitrary marker. Also, more single-sex schools, esp middle and high schools: less distraction for the students! More male teachers wouldn’t be a bad idea either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top