Florida Passes Plan For Racially-Based Academic Goals

  • Thread starter Thread starter K-McD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

K-McD

Guest
Palm Beach, Fla. (CBS TAMPA) – The Florida State Board of Education passed a plan that sets goals for students in math and reading based upon their race.

On Tuesday, the board passed a revised strategic plan that says that by 2018, it wants 90 percent of Asian students, 88 percent of white students, 81 percent of Hispanics and 74 percent of black students to be reading at or above grade level. For math, the goals are 92 percent of Asian kids to be proficient, whites at 86 percent, Hispanics at 80 percent and blacks at 74 percent. It also measures by other groupings, such as poverty and disabilities, reported the Palm Beach Post.

The plan has infuriated many community activists in Palm Beach County and across the state.

“To expect less from one demographic and more from another is just a little off-base,” Juan Lopez, magnet coordinator at John F. Kennedy Middle School in Riviera Beach, told the Palm Beach Post.

Link

To ignore racism is to condone it.
 
Palm Beach, Fla. (CBS TAMPA) – The Florida State Board of Education passed a plan that sets goals for students in math and reading based upon their race.

On Tuesday, the board passed a revised strategic plan that says that by 2018, it wants 90 percent of Asian students, 88 percent of white students, 81 percent of Hispanics and 74 percent of black students to be reading at or above grade level. For math, the goals are 92 percent of Asian kids to be proficient, whites at 86 percent, Hispanics at 80 percent and blacks at 74 percent. It also measures by other groupings, such as poverty and disabilities, reported the Palm Beach Post.

…
I’d like to know how they got those numbers.
“GATE-closing plan stirs parental debate at Lincoln Middle School”
By Adam Klawonn
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER
May 19, 2005
VISTA – Parents of Latino students at Vista’s most ethnically diverse school are incensed over a campaign by other parents to preserve an honors program there.
The policy debate is taking place at Lincoln Middle School, where the principal is proposing mixing some of the school’s most gifted students with others of mixed academic abilities in an effort to pump up test scores.
The proposal to dismantle the Gifted and Talented Education, or GATE, program at the school is supported by the Latino parents, opposed by parents of the GATE students.
…
“All students should be treated equally,” Latino parents said in a letter to the board and district administrators. “We believe that the school should not create differences between students who know more and students who know less.”
 
Or… and I know this might sound radical to some, but stick with me… let’s not really pay attention to any of that stuff, and just focus on teaching…

I’m not one to yell racism or anything like that… ever… but does this not seem a little bit racist to anyone else?
 
…
I’m not one to yell racism or anything like that… ever… but does this not seem a little bit racist to anyone else?
rac·ism, noun
  1. a belief or doctrine that inherent differences among the various human races determine cultural or individual achievement, usually involving the idea that one’s own race is superior and has the right to rule others.
  2. a policy, system of government, etc., based upon or fostering such a doctrine; discrimination.
  3. hatred or intolerance of another race or other races.
    dictionary.reference.com/browse/racism?s=t
I think 1 and 2 fit [especially 1]; 3 does not apply here. Don’t you think the folks pushing this think some races are inferior and can’t succeed? A black colleague told me he wouldn’t let his son play football in school unless he got a C or better in every class. He got a C or better in every class.
 
rac·ism, noun
  1. a belief or doctrine that inherent differences among the various human races determine cultural or individual achievement, usually involving the idea that one’s own race is superior and has the right to rule others.
  2. a policy, system of government, etc., based upon or fostering such a doctrine; discrimination.
  3. hatred or intolerance of another race or other races.
    dictionary.reference.com/browse/racism?s=t
I think 1 and 2 fit [especially 1]; 3 does not apply here. Don’t you think the folks pushing this think some races are inferior and can’t succeed? A black colleague told me he wouldn’t let his son play football in school unless he got a C or better in every class. He got a C or better in every class.
I’m not saying that I don’t think it’s racist, I’m just usually not the one calling things racist. This definitely meets the criteria though, for those who do.

I personally think we should forget about race. If we stopped mentioning it for one or two generations the concept would probably all but vanish 😛

And yes, I definitely think the people pushing this think that race plays a huge factor in your ability to succeed, rather than home life, parental involvement and personal attention to studies.
 
It’s really funny, and sad as well.

They are all starting at different points 38% of black children read at grade level! That is totally unacceptable. Setting a target of 74% is actually almost doubling the percentage of kids reading at grade level. 69% to 88% isn’t such a big expectation for white students.

Is setting a standard of, say, 90% reading at grade level across the board realistic?
 
I’m not one to yell racism or anything like that… ever… but does this not seem a little bit racist to anyone else?
No, I think it’s just realistic. Look at the second paragraph here:
On Tuesday, the board passed a revised strategic plan that says that by 2018, it wants 90 percent of Asian students, 88 percent of white students, 81 percent of Hispanics and 74 percent of black students to be reading at or above grade level. For math, the goals are 92 percent of Asian kids to be proficient, whites at 86 percent, Hispanics at 80 percent and blacks at 74 percent. It also measures by other groupings, such as poverty and disabilities, reported the Palm Beach Post…
As an example, the percentage of white students scoring at or above grade level (as measured by whether they scored a 3 or higher on the reading FCAT) was 69 percent in 2011-2012, according to the state. For black students, it was 38 percent, and for Hispanics, it was 53 percent.
The schoolboard can say:“Let’s raise scores by 20%” The easiest way to do that is focus on the kids who do best and incentivize them. Across-the-board scores will rise, but the at-risk kids get no help.

If you identify issues by demographics, then you MUST give extra help where it’s needed. Recognizing the fact that black students in general do worst, isn’t racism, it’s confronting some serious issues we still have after 50 years of integration with a social/cultural problem that results in a continually marginalized population.

Not good. Not for them, not for society at large. Doing it this way means every school has to work hard with every student. People should stop criticizing and applaud, IMO.
 
It’s really funny, and sad as well.

They are all starting at different points 38% of black children read at grade level! That is totally unacceptable. Setting a target of 74% is actually almost doubling the percentage of kids reading at grade level. 69% to 88% isn’t such a big expectation for white students.

Is setting a standard of, say, 90% reading at grade level across the board realistic?
It’s not a question so much of what is realistic but of what is expected. Children tend to give what is expected of them and will not excel unless they are challenged.

As a black parent, I have had the personal experience of seeing my precocious 3 yr old sit passively while a highly-trained educator instructed him on things he already knew! She never asked him or me; she simply was introduced to us and proceeded to assume that she somehow magically knew what his ability was.

Needless to say, when the episode was over, I let him know how I felt about his not showing what his knowledge was, and in a few days time he wowed her with his performance. Also needless to say, she took the credit for the incredible transformation, but that did not seem to impact her low expectations for him.

I shudder to think what would have happened if my child had had a succession of teachers like her and had been raised by parents who barely had enough time on most days, to do more than have dinner and tuck him in…
 
Let me start by saying that this is the wrong approach - the approach should rather be to ask for greater improvements in the lowest-performing groups while maintaining steady improvement in the best-performing groups. One cannot be sacrificed for the other and still call education comprehensive. Rather, teachers need to be free to allow students who can push themselves to perform at their best and give them what they need, while focusing additional resources on students least likely to do well.

The approach outlined in the article assumes failure at higher rates based on race. No, it’s disgusting to say that all blacks are only expected to perform at xx% of whites. It invites a more-deeply entrenched and institutional racism as well.

While I would reject the notion of disparate goals anyway, I would more readily accept a case being made by socio-economic level, since that’s honestly a better predictor for performance. Race correlates highly with income and education levels of the parents, especially when controlling for age, and so race tends to explain outcomes of education very well. But that’s simplistic to the point of error - there’s no physical mechanism to explain why a black student will perform less well than an Asian student or a white student.

There are, however, socio-economic mechanisms. The kids of parents in the lowest economic group have the lowest high school graduation rates. There are several reasons:
  • Culturally, parents who never attended college may not value it and do not pass that value on to their kids, who don’t get that impetus from home to succeed in school.
  • Economic difficulties at home may push students who work to support the family, leading either to poor scholastic performance or the choice to drop out early.
  • Temporal tradeoffs - I have personally known kids who, at 16, would rather work at the factory or auto shop making $12/hour ($25k/year) and so drop out. The alternative - college - is six more years of school (high school + college), $30k in debt, for a starting salary of what, $25k? Most students who finish college do not catch up in annual earnings to their peers who never attended college until the age of 28 or 30, and the college group does not surpass the non-college group in lifetime earnings until 35 or 40.
So I can see why lower socio-economic groups would score lower on standardized tests as an aggregate group. That doesn’t mean we should encourage it.
 
No, I think it’s just realistic. Look at the second paragraph here:

The schoolboard can say:“Let’s raise scores by 20%” The easiest way to do that is focus on the kids who do best and incentivize them. Across-the-board scores will rise, but the at-risk kids get no help.

If you identify issues by demographics, then you MUST give extra help where it’s needed. Recognizing the fact that black students in general do worst, isn’t racism, it’s confronting some serious issues we still have after 50 years of integration with a social/cultural problem that results in a continually marginalized population.

Not good. Not for them, not for society at large. Doing it this way means every school has to work hard with every student. People should stop criticizing and applaud, IMO.
I agree with all that, and I agree that special attention should be paid to those who excel. What I’m saying is basically, that it seems they are focusing on race rather than socioeconomic status. Socioeconomic status is probably the main driving force, and race should be secondary.

That’s just my opinion.

I do applaud them working to fix the problems though.
 
I agree with all that, and I agree that special attention should be paid to those who excel. What I’m saying is basically, that it seems they are focusing on race rather than socioeconomic status. Socioeconomic status is probably the main driving force, and race should be secondary.

That’s just my opinion.

I do applaud them working to fix the problems though.
I agree that the driving force is socioeconomic - that tends to be true not just in education status but in health as well. The fact that socioeconomic lines tend to be fall along ethnic ones is secondary, BUT when the effect of socioeconomic status on education attainment is used in this way to set policies which establish race-based standards, then it becomes discriminatory, IMO.

This seems to just be one big cop out, as in “let’s just throw our hands up in the air and accept that Asian will outperform and Blacks will under-perform”. That way the responsibility for correcting existing disparities can be officially shirked.
 
Question.
What happened to education? It seems to me that it had been thrown out the window!
 
:ouch: Florida and Palm Beach County strikes again. You know that we only do this stuff so that we can remain in the press don’t you? 😃
 
…
The schoolboard can say:“Let’s raise scores by 20%” The easiest way to do that is focus on the kids who do best and incentivize them. …
No, the easiest way to raise scores is to lower the standards. What I see here is ironic: the liberal educational establishment maintains an ideology that says there is no real difference in test scores between the various ethnic groups, and they keep trying to warp reality to fit that world view. 🤷
 
I agree that the driving force is socioeconomic - that tends to be true not just in education status but in health as well. The fact that socioeconomic lines tend to be fall along ethnic ones is secondary, BUT when the effect of socioeconomic status on education attainment is used in this way to set policies which establish race-based standards, then it becomes discriminatory, IMO.

This seems to just be one big cop out, as in “let’s just throw our hands up in the air and accept that Asian will outperform and Blacks will under-perform”. That way the responsibility for correcting existing disparities can be officially shirked.
You wrote this:
Children tend to give what is expected of them and will not excel unless they are challenged.
This program set up this way, forces teachers to “expect more.” My child, who was always exceptionally bright, had some learning disabilities. She was so smart, she compensated so well, it didn’t show on the standard tests, but she still could hardly read. her teacher had no expectations and tried to be very kind when she informed me my child was just well, a bit slow.

Moron. My kid had twice the teacher’s vocabulary when she was 4. Continual low expectations in school made the whole experience a tragic one for her. Now, we can’t just foist this issue off on economics, we must look at culture. And we can’t look only at the culture of the kids, we have to look even more at the culture of the teachers that lead them to see dark skin (or reading issues) and expect less and epicanthic folds and expect more.

This schoolboard is saying, “We don’t believe these children can only do this much, we believe they can do more and you teachers better get with the program.” But the problem is not pure socioeconomics, those Asian kids who do so well who are the first generation of boat-people parents, still outperform everyone else as a group. That’s culture.

One of the things, IMO, we have to do is stop making “smart” classes and “dumb” classes. It’s practically child-abuse.
 
It’s not a question so much of what is realistic but of what is expected. -]Children/-] people tend to give what is expected of them and will not excel unless they are challenged.
Indeed. Plenty of research studies have been done, showing the effect of expectation on performance. In that respect, certain charter school movements have been started over the last decade designed to motivate through expectation, counter-culturally to the students’ environments: thus, poor urban students from minority backgrounds have enrolled in ethnically homogeneous schools such as KIPP, Leadership, and Aspire, which all feature a College Culture, predicated upon long school days and rigorous academics which are contrary to the neighborhood environment and the in-home opportunities (and sometimes home expectations).

The educational results further validate those research studies I allude to: dramatically larger percentage of college matriculating students graduating from those secondary schools (vs. traditional public site schools from the same/similar neighborhoods), and most of those headed to 4-year colleges.
 
You wrote this:

This program set up this way, forces teachers to “expect more.” My child, who was always exceptionally bright, had some learning disabilities. She was so smart, she compensated so well, it didn’t show on the standard tests, but she still could hardly read. her teacher had no expectations and tried to be very kind when she informed me my child was just well, a bit slow.

Moron. My kid had twice the teacher’s vocabulary when she was 4. Continual low expectations in school made the whole experience a tragic one for her. Now, we can’t just foist this issue off on economics, we must look at culture. And we can’t look only at the culture of the kids, we have to look even more at the culture of the teachers that lead them to see dark skin (or reading issues) and expect less and epicanthic folds and expect more.

This schoolboard is saying, “We don’t believe these children can only do this much, we believe they can do more and you teachers better get with the program.” But the problem is not pure socioeconomics, those Asian kids who do so well who are the first generation of boat-people parents, still outperform everyone else as a group. That’s culture.

One of the things, IMO, we have to do is stop making “smart” classes and “dumb” classes. It’s practically child-abuse.
I think we see the problems with education along the same lines and I certainly have shared similar experiences as a parent; that’s why I’m not sure how the different standards make sense to you. Aren’t we all supposed to shoot for 100% in everything? We might never get there, but my philosophy is: the further you aim, the further you’ll shoot.

If a teacher has a class of 18, with half reading below grade level, to me setting the goal to 18 reading by grade level at year’s end, is not about being realistic - it’s about showing her how hard she has to work. Even if only 10 or 15 achieve the goal, she will still have made laudable progress but will not be allowed the luxury of resting on her laurels. Perhaps she’ll even start thinking about what she can do differently next year to improve performance. The point of a goal is to motivate. The way in which her achieved goal is handled administratively is what needs attention (as long as she is making constant progress, she should not be penalized for example).

On the other hand, setting her goal to 10 reading at grade level might mean that as long as she achieves this reachable goal, the other 8 kids can go fly a kite…Self-motivation aside, teachers also tend to give what is expected of them.
 
Indeed. Plenty of research studies have been done, showing the effect of expectation on performance. In that respect, certain charter school movements have been started over the last decade designed to motivate through expectation, counter-culturally to the students’ environments: thus, poor urban students from minority backgrounds have enrolled in ethnically homogeneous schools such as KIPP, Leadership, and Aspire, which all feature a College Culture, predicated upon long school days and rigorous academics which are contrary to the neighborhood environment and the in-home opportunities (and sometimes home expectations).

The educational results further validate those research studies I allude to: dramatically larger percentage of college matriculating students graduating from those secondary schools (vs. traditional public site schools from the same/similar neighborhoods), and most of those headed to 4-year colleges.
That makes sense because I’ve seen it in real life. Much is often made of how some kids overcome the same socioeconomic challenges that hold others back and I believe that expectation (and perhaps the kids’ personality) is what makes the difference.

I cannot count the number of successful people who have related stories to me of some teacher or the other telling them they would never amount to anything and how that comment/attitude spurred them on. Perhaps the untold story is that someone in their lives had already inspired them with positive expectations.
 
I think we see the problems with education along the same lines and I certainly have shared similar experiences as a parent; that’s why I’m not sure how the different standards make sense to you. Aren’t we all supposed to shoot for 100% in everything? We might never get there, but my philosophy is: the further you aim, the further you’ll shoot.

If a teacher has a class of 18, with half reading below grade level, to me setting the goal to 18 reading by grade level at year’s end, is not about being realistic - it’s about showing her how hard she has to work. .
But that was already the expectation. And I don’t think it’s different, if you raise those percentiles, across the system at all grade levels, you’ll markedly increase the number of children reading and doing math at an expected standard. Breaking it down by … sorry, I’m an anthropologist and there’s really no such things as “race” so I’d call it cultural background… means: “You don’t get have any excuses, all these kids need to improve.”

Anyway, someone even more knee-jerk liberal than myself will sue and the court will overturn. I think it’s too bad, I’d like to see the result of trying this.
 
But that was already the expectation. And I don’t think it’s different, if you raise those percentiles, across the system at all grade levels, you’ll markedly increase the number of children reading and doing math at an expected standard. Breaking it down by … sorry, I’m an anthropologist and there’s really no such things as “race” so I’d call it cultural background… means: “You don’t get have any excuses, all these kids need to improve.”

Anyway, someone even more knee-jerk liberal than myself will sue and the court will overturn. I think it’s too bad, I’d like to see the result of trying this.
Don’t know what I find more interesting Julia Mae, your views on the issue at hand, your self description as a ‘knee jerk liberal’ or your contention that there is no such thing as race…? 😉

Permission to quote you on the latter. I also believe it’s as ‘real’ as the emperor’s clothes but that what matters is not so much the ‘objective reality’ but the lived experience…🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top