Hi Jon,
In part, time frame. In 1523, he wrote a book, Jesus Christ Was Born a Jew". In it he was trying to disprove the charge against him that he thought Joseph was Jesus’ natural father, but also to confirm Jesus as a Jew, and maybe win some Jews to Christianity.
He also in his early career was rather supportive of the Jews, and called for tolerance of them. “I would request and advise that one deal gently with them [the Jews] and instruct them from Scripture; then some of them may come along."
A standard part of the (false) Legend of Luther is that he was generally ‘nice’ about the Jews except for the very end of his life when he was old, sick and cranky. Better this than he just hated the Jews his whole life. In other words all of those horrible things he recommended happen to the Jews were just some sort of anomaly in an otherwise spotless record on Jewish ‘relations’. NOTHING could be further from the truth.
Thankfully there are plenty of honest Protestant Scholars who have more interest in protecting their professional reputations than they are in protecting the (false) Legend of Luther. From Luther’s earliest writings, even before his 95 Theses, until his death, Luther was consistently ‘anti-Jewish (at least) with the possible exception of 1523 to 1527. Even in those few years, Luther’s focus in his Jewish ‘relations’ was NOT the Jews but his hatred of the Catholic Church.
The most forgiving of Luther’s “defenders” typically represent his later writings against the Jews as being out of place in the whole of his thoughts on the subject. This approach forces a more positive view of Luther than the historical record would suggest.
In one of this earliest known letters, to his friend George Spalatin in 1514, Luther demonstrates that his views of the Jews were very negative, even this early in his career:
“’I have come to the conclusion that the Jews will always curse and blaspheme God and his King Christ, as all the prophets have predicted. He who neither reads nor understands this, as yet knows no theology, in my opinion. And I also presume the men of Cologne cannot understand the Scripture……If they are trying to stop the Jews blaspheming they are working to prove the Bible and God liars…’
“Luther concluded the letter with the observation that the wrath of God has made the Jews incorrigible; such people become worse when others are trying to make them better.” (Lutheran Professor) Eric W. Gritsch, “Martin Luther’s Anti-Semitism”, pg. 50-1
Gritsch also suggests that it Luther’s early attitudes towards the Jews were relatively negative over the course of his career.
“It may be, however, that there was not so great a change in Luther’s attitude toward the Jews (over time) as has commonly been thought. A closer inspection of his utterances on the question throughout his career reveals that he was never so unambiguously positive toward them as a reading of his 1523 treatise in isolation would suggest. Wilhelm Maurer has demonstrated, in fact, that Luther’s earliest lectures—those on the Psalms, delivered in 1513–1515—already contained in essence the whole burden of his later charges against the Jews. The Jews, Luther asserts in these lectures, suffer continually under God’s wrath; they are paying the penalty for their rejection of Christ. They spend all their efforts in self-justification, but God will not hear their prayers. Neither kindness nor severity will improve them. They become constantly more stubborn and more vain. Moreover, they are active enemies of Christ; they blaspheme and defame him, spreading their evil influence even into Christian hearts. As for Jewish efforts to interpret Scripture, these, Luther asserts, are simply lies. They forsake the word of God and follow the imaginations of their hearts. It would be quite wrong, he concludes, for Christians to extend tolerance to those who hold such views.
Similar sentiments are expressed in Luther’s Lectures on Romans of 1515–1516…
In short, the evidence indicates that the Luther of these earlier years shared to the full in the medieval prejudices against the Jews. From this perspective, his more favorable attitude toward the Jews as expressed in the early 1520’s is to be understood as a temporary modification of the underlying negative stereotype which characterized his earliest statements, and to which he returned in his later treatises. That underlying stereotype, in turn, can be understood only in terms of the medieval background.” The Editors of Luther’s Works, (1999). Vol. 47, pg. 126–127 `
Of course explaining away Luther’s recommendations against the Jews in terms of ‘the medieval background’ doesn’t exactly satisfy given that ONLY Luther made those horrific recommendations as to what he wanted to happen to the Jews. A more plausible explanation was simply an extreme and lifelong hatred of the Jews.
“Luther’s career as a professor of Bible and the University of Wittenberg began with lectures on the Psalter, which he delivered over the years 1513-1515. These first lectures by the young professor are saturated with anti-Jewish references and allusions.” (Lutheran Professors) Schramm and Stjerna, “Martin Luther, The Bible, and the Jewish People” pg. 129
In regards to Luther’s early lectures (1513-1515) Lutheran Professors Schramm and Stjerna note that Luther was uniformly opposed to the Jews:
“The reader of these lectures in toto will note how pervasive is the polemic directed against either the Jews or the synagogue, so pervasive in fact that it rises to the level of a central characteristic of the lectures.” Schramm and Stjerna, “Martin Luther, The Bible, and the Jewish People” pg. 41
My God Bless You and Yours During this Holy Week, Topper