For Catholics: Would you consider yourself anti-protestant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ALLFORHIM
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I love protestants. Martin Luther loved the catholic church he didnt want to divide it. In hes days the popes where commiting adultery, so where the monks. The church sold scrolls to all people so their sinds will be forgiven cause the church allows it. They belived they could exclude people from heaven, they where playing god.

If todays system existed back then Martin Luther wouldnt want to seperate.
Luther did more than separate from the Church, he caused the biggest schism in the history of Christianity, he Apostatized a whole population, he took unheard of liberties with the Bible, he re-invented Church history, and he re-built Christianity to fit his personal belief system. He should have tried to re-build the Church from within, like St Francis and others had done over the millenia. Read Church history, do you think abuses only happened in Luther’s lifetime. He was driven by more than paper scrolls and bad clergy. The result of his action, in MY* opinion *only, was absolutely catastrophic…but it is what it is, and it’s up to us to put the Church together, as it was meant to be
 
I believe that sex between a married person and an unmarried person is still adultery for both.
I agree but if both are umarried then its not adultery but fornication more than mere semantics. Dont u agree?
 
Luther did more than separate from the Church, he caused the biggest schism in the history of Christianity, he Apostatized a whole population, he took unheard of liberties with the Bible, he re-invented Church history, and he re-built Christianity to fit his personal belief system. He should have tried to re-build the Church from within, like St Francis and others had done over the millenia. Read Church history, do you think abuses only happened in Luther’s lifetime. He was driven by more than paper scrolls and bad clergy. The result of his action, in MY* opinion *only, was absolutely catastrophic…but it is what it is, and it’s up to us to put the Church together, as it was meant to be
Ditto although its not that simple and social and political mileau played a role but luther and his inane rantings were the spark that set the keg alight
God Bless
Arthur-Mater Dei ora pro nobis
 
We were kicked out of our Evangelical Free Church after we gave seven years of good service to the Christians in that church. Remember Laban and his trickery? Been there. It was pretty awful.

I was born and raised evangelical Protestant, and spent most of my life serving God and His people in church settings. I play piano, and as any evangelical knows, a willing piano player is almost as valuable as a willing tither. If I listed the many ministries I was involved with over the years, this Board would break down.

My husband and children were right there with me, serving God 4-5 days/evenings per week in church.

But all it took was one lying pastor (a woman, who was fired a year after we were ousted when she was caught in one of her lies) and they threw us out. Had a tribunal, condemned us as “unloveable and unteachable” and threw us out in February 2001. So this is a tough month for me.

Other Protestants that we had known over the years did not rush to defend us. That hurt beyond belief. They basically didn’t dare interfere with the rulings of another church and pastor. And Protestants say they don’t believe in a Pope. Baloney.

For many weeks I had grisly nightmares of myself and my family being chased, tried, and executed by Christians. My hands shook so hard I couldn’t play the piano. I cried a lot at work and home. I was afraid to read the Bible, and I didn’t read it for almost a year. After all, the people in that church had used the Bible (and twisted it) to justify their despicable treatment of my family. How could I be guaranteed that I wouldn’t interpret the Bible in such a twisted way? I didn’t want to take a chance on ending up like those people.

And for a year, I could not be in a room with Protestants. A few of them at a time in a secular setting (e.g., work) I could handle, but to sit in a sanctuary or auditorium made me panic. I knew they were all plotting against me. I couldn’t trust them. I was afraid of them and their deceitfulness hidden behind their loving hugs and “God bless yous.”

Worst of all, my two daughters stopped going to church. My older daughter said, “Mom, if they could kick you out after all the good works you’ve done over the years, what would they do to me?”

And my younger daughter screamed out, “I KNEW that church was evil. We never should have been there.”

God have mercy on that church for what they did to my two innocent daughters. They didn’t abuse them sexually (that I know of), but if they had, I could have at least pressed charges against them and brought them to justice before other men. Instead, even though that church treated us like garbage and shunned us, there’s nothing I can do about, no court to take them to other than the Court of God. Truly Jesus spoke the truth when He said that hatred is the same as murder.

It’s been several years now and I’ve mostly healed, mainly because I converted to Catholicism, the True Church. My older daughter is considering becoming a Catholic and so is my younger daughter. We don’t try to hurry them, since they still have a lot of distrust of churches and church people.

But I will never, ever trust Protestants again. Ever. I am grateful to those Protestants over the years who introduced me to Jesus and taught me the value of serving Him. But I will never be duped again. May God have mercy on them and lead them all to heaven.

I’m in good company. Acording to John 2:24-25, “Jesus, on His part, was not entrusting Himself to them, for He knew all men, and because He did not need anyone to bear witness concerning man, for He Himself knew what was in man.”
 
We were kicked out of our Evangelical Free Church after we gave seven years of good service to the Christians in that church. Remember Laban and his trickery? Been there. It was pretty awful.

I was born and raised evangelical Protestant, and spent most of my life serving God and His people in church settings. I play piano, and as any evangelical knows, a willing piano player is almost as valuable as a willing tither. If I listed the many ministries I was involved with over the years, this Board would break down.

My husband and children were right there with me, serving God 4-5 days/evenings per week in church.

But all it took was one lying pastor (a woman, who was fired a year after we were ousted when she was caught in one of her lies) and they threw us out. Had a tribunal, condemned us as “unloveable and unteachable” and threw us out in February 2001. So this is a tough month for me.

Other Protestants that we had known over the years did not rush to defend us. That hurt beyond belief. They basically didn’t dare interfere with the rulings of another church and pastor. And Protestants say they don’t believe in a Pope. Baloney.

For many weeks I had grisly nightmares of myself and my family being chased, tried, and executed by Christians. My hands shook so hard I couldn’t play the piano. I cried a lot at work and home. I was afraid to read the Bible, and I didn’t read it for almost a year. After all, the people in that church had used the Bible (and twisted it) to justify their despicable treatment of my family. How could I be guaranteed that I wouldn’t interpret the Bible in such a twisted way? I didn’t want to take a chance on ending up like those people.

And for a year, I could not be in a room with Protestants. A few of them at a time in a secular setting (e.g., work) I could handle, but to sit in a sanctuary or auditorium made me panic. I knew they were all plotting against me. I couldn’t trust them. I was afraid of them and their deceitfulness hidden behind their loving hugs and “God bless yous.”

Worst of all, my two daughters stopped going to church. My older daughter said, “Mom, if they could kick you out after all the good works you’ve done over the years, what would they do to me?”

And my younger daughter screamed out, “I KNEW that church was evil. We never should have been there.”

God have mercy on that church for what they did to my two innocent daughters. They didn’t abuse them sexually (that I know of), but if they had, I could have at least pressed charges against them and brought them to justice before other men. Instead, even though that church treated us like garbage and shunned us, there’s nothing I can do about, no court to take them to other than the Court of God. Truly Jesus spoke the truth when He said that hatred is the same as murder.

It’s been several years now and I’ve mostly healed, mainly because I converted to Catholicism, the True Church. My older daughter is considering becoming a Catholic and so is my younger daughter. We don’t try to hurry them, since they still have a lot of distrust of churches and church people.

But I will never, ever trust Protestants again. Ever. I am grateful to those Protestants over the years who introduced me to Jesus and taught me the value of serving Him. But I will never be duped again. May God have mercy on them and lead them all to heaven.

I’m in good company. Acording to John 2:24-25, “Jesus, on His part, was not entrusting Himself to them, for He knew all men, and because He did not need anyone to bear witness concerning man, for He Himself knew what was in man.”
Hi,
Im really truly sorry you were treated that way.😦 I pray your children will be able to trust church again.😃
 
Just curious;)

I have been reading alot of threads that just catholics are posting and I have seen some things written that are very negative toward protestants so I pose the question.

Im not accusing–just wondering. I figure since catholics accuse us(not all of us of course)protestants of being anti-catholic---------would you consider yourself anti-protestant?😦
The reason why I do not consider myself anti-protestant is because as a single woman who is a Republican Conservative pro-life Catholic who is loyal to and LOVES the Pope, I have found that Protestants tend to be friendlier to me than my fellow Catholics are. My best friend is a Methodist, and this past weekend at my favorite bed-and-breakfast inn where I’ve stayed for years, the Methodist innkeeper bestowed on me the honor of affectionately referring to me as her adopted daughter, for which I feel truly blessed! 🙂 :cool: 👍

I would definitely love to have Catholic friends, but it seems the Lord has other ideas.

~~ the phoenix
 
Yeah, I’d probably have to say that I am. It’s a result of bad experiences in the past.
 
Hi, Allforhim.

What did our Lord pray for on the night he was betrayed? He prayed that all would be one. John 17: 20-23.

I wonder what real unity of all christians would look like?
This unity will happen ! Jesus prayed for it to happen, we
don’t know how or when, but it will happen. He knew there would be divisions, just as the apostles abandoned him in his passion. Anyway this long answer is no!

Peace
OneNow1
 
We were kicked out of our Evangelical Free Church after we gave seven years of good service to the Christians in that church. Remember Laban and his trickery? Been there. It was pretty awful.

I was born and raised evangelical Protestant, and spent most of my life serving God and His people in church settings. I play piano, and as any evangelical knows, a willing piano player is almost as valuable as a willing tither. If I listed the many ministries I was involved with over the years, this Board would break down.

My husband and children were right there with me, serving God 4-5 days/evenings per week in church.

But all it took was one lying pastor (a woman, who was fired a year after we were ousted when she was caught in one of her lies) and they threw us out. Had a tribunal, condemned us as “unloveable and unteachable” and threw us out in February 2001. So this is a tough month for me.

Other Protestants that we had known over the years did not rush to defend us. That hurt beyond belief. They basically didn’t dare interfere with the rulings of another church and pastor. And Protestants say they don’t believe in a Pope. Baloney.

For many weeks I had grisly nightmares of myself and my family being chased, tried, and executed by Christians. My hands shook so hard I couldn’t play the piano. I cried a lot at work and home. I was afraid to read the Bible, and I didn’t read it for almost a year. After all, the people in that church had used the Bible (and twisted it) to justify their despicable treatment of my family. How could I be guaranteed that I wouldn’t interpret the Bible in such a twisted way? I didn’t want to take a chance on ending up like those people.

And for a year, I could not be in a room with Protestants. A few of them at a time in a secular setting (e.g., work) I could handle, but to sit in a sanctuary or auditorium made me panic. I knew they were all plotting against me. I couldn’t trust them. I was afraid of them and their deceitfulness hidden behind their loving hugs and “God bless yous.”

Worst of all, my two daughters stopped going to church. My older daughter said, “Mom, if they could kick you out after all the good works you’ve done over the years, what would they do to me?”

And my younger daughter screamed out, “I KNEW that church was evil. We never should have been there.”

God have mercy on that church for what they did to my two innocent daughters. They didn’t abuse them sexually (that I know of), but if they had, I could have at least pressed charges against them and brought them to justice before other men. Instead, even though that church treated us like garbage and shunned us, there’s nothing I can do about, no court to take them to other than the Court of God. Truly Jesus spoke the truth when He said that hatred is the same as murder.

It’s been several years now and I’ve mostly healed, mainly because I converted to Catholicism, the True Church. My older daughter is considering becoming a Catholic and so is my younger daughter. We don’t try to hurry them, since they still have a lot of distrust of churches and church people.

But I will never, ever trust Protestants again. Ever. I am grateful to those Protestants over the years who introduced me to Jesus and taught me the value of serving Him. But I will never be duped again. May God have mercy on them and lead them all to heaven.

I’m in good company. Acording to John 2:24-25, “Jesus, on His part, was not entrusting Himself to them, for He knew all men, and because He did not need anyone to bear witness concerning man, for He Himself knew what was in man.”
** It is so sad when this happens and people are hurt by so called christians. May the blessed virgin keep you and your family in her loving embrace and may she lead you to her son who is waiting for you **

God Bless

Arthur- Mater Dei Ora Pro Nobis
 
My catholic family will not discuss faith with me because I am born again. Why is that. They actually have rejected my faith
 
I am definitely not anti-Protestant because the Protestants helped me return to the Catholic Church. I was raised Catholic, went to CCD, Catholic high school and even Catholic college but never understood why. I left the Church when I was in my early twenties for 5 years because I thought it was just a bunch of rules I didn’t want to follow. The Baptists brought me back to the Catholic faith because a friend took me to a Christian music festival where somebody from the Baptist Church gave me a Bible which I read and I understood Who it was that I needed in my life. I had a born-again experience, went back to the Catholic Church after confessing my sin to God and my priest and have since joined Bible study at my parish. If it wasn’t for the Baptists, I would probably be living in sin right now. So I love my Protestant brothers and sisters for helping me to return to the Catholic Church. The Holy Spirit was working through them to show me the way.👍
 
My catholic family will not discuss faith with me because I am born again. Why is that. They actually have rejected my faith
Politics and religion. Unless all are in total agreement, or you can have a rational discussion w/o anger, it’s best to leave them alone among family and friends.
 
Just curious;)

I have been reading alot of threads that just catholics are posting and I have seen some things written that are very negative toward protestants so I pose the question.

Im not accusing–just wondering. I figure since catholics accuse us(not all of us of course)protestants of being anti-catholic---------would you consider yourself anti-protestant?😦
Anti- , no, but I’m a freely admitted Baptist-phobe. I do have some Baptist and evangelical friends but I no longer “go there” with Baptists and evangelicals. I’m not friends with any of the ones who told me I was an idolator or going to hell…not the way to win people over to your side no matter what your beliefs are!

Guess I should add them to my Lenten Divine Mercy Chaplets. 🙂
 
Personally, I am not anti-Protestant, anti-Eastern Orthodox,
anti-Jewish, anti-Muslim, or anti-anything. In fact, some of
my best friends were and are atheists. I think that I am
like most Americans - live and let live. The religious wars of
the past and present teach us that religion is a personal,
private matter. What is important is that we conduct
ourselves in a moral manner and obey the laws of the land.
Let God decide who is religiously right!
 
Just curious;)

I have been reading alot of threads that just catholics are posting and I have seen some things written that are very negative toward protestants so I pose the question.

Im not accusing–just wondering. I figure since catholics accuse us(not all of us of course)protestants of being anti-catholic---------would you consider yourself anti-protestant?😦
I brought someone into the Church some time ago & he still goes to the Baptist church sometimes… I’m not sure why… He lent me a book written by a Protestant & i have yet to read it because i am very cautious about what i read; i don’t appreciate anti-Catholic attitudes, which can be pervasive in these kinds of books… albeit often in only a subtle way. I am anti-Protestantism because it is, strictly speaking, a false religion… (tho not ALL false, of course.) But i don’t down individuals in the P churces because they can’t help it they weren’t raised in THE Church… Even so, sometimes there doesn’t seem to be much Christian love in (some of) the Catholic Churches i have been to… therefore, I have been tempted to return to some of the non-Catholic ones, if only 4 the social aspects… The real presence of Christ is in the Catholic Church… so how can anyone leave permanently?
 
I don’t consider myself anti-Protestant. I’ve had encounters with Protestants that have left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I guess it comes down to I don’t trust them; I will always be on guard waiting for them to say something negative about Catholics, Catholicism, etc.

On two recent occasions a friend has had encounters with Protestants where someone just had to include a slam against the Catholic church. It could have totally gone unsaid. It was not said in love; it was like an inside joke “you know how bad those Catholics are”… One of them, was a pastor. I can count on one hand the times I’ve heard a priest has said anything about Protestants, let alone anything negative or critical. One was sort of recent and I was on pins and needles the whole time hoping he wouldn’t go there.

Seriously, if one has to slam another’s religion to make their religion seem better…what do they say again when a person cuts down another person? Oh, yeah, that person has an inferiority complex. And how is this a winsome way to convince me they have something to offer?

I could go on…but I think this is a sore spot for me.
 
Bruised Reed, while I was Protestant (for 40 years), we learned a technique called “friendship evangelism.” The idea was to study John 4, and see how Jesus quickly won the Samaritan woman as a friend, then witnessed to her. So we should quickly win people as friends and then–POW!–witness to them about the Lord!

Catholics were prime targets, since they weren’t really Christians.

Perhaps you have you encountered this?

What’s sad is that I thought it was a good thing.
 
Bruised Reed, while I was Protestant (for 40 years), we learned a technique called “friendship evangelism.” The idea was to study John 4, and see how Jesus quickly won the Samaritan woman as a friend, then witnessed to her. So we should quickly win people as friends and then–POW!–witness to them about the Lord!

Catholics were prime targets, since they weren’t really Christians.

Perhaps you have you encountered this?

What’s sad is that I thought it was a good thing.
I think I’ve encountered the opposite. I have, on occasion, participated in events, bible studies that were open to any faith. I would enjoy conversations with people and it was only when I revealed (after being asked) that I was Catholic that things got uncomfortable. At one event, two women I was talking to looked at each other and without a word got up and left the table where we were sitting.

So they thought I was Christian but then found out otherwise. Maybe they thought I was a wolf in sheeps clothing. I just wanted fellowship with other young adult Christians (who weren’t boring). Still desire that.

I’ve thought about it and I really haven’t been pursued in the manner you describe above.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top