For Harry Potter Fans (NO SPOILERS)

  • Thread starter Thread starter child_of_God85
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“had” a soft spot?! What does that mean?! What happens to Snape?! You’re killing me, here!!! 😃
did I say had??? Still do, personally, I really like the guy

READ AND FIND OUT.

I couldn’t bear to wait that long and just skipped around the book looking for him and, well…I found him alright:thumbsup:

(it’s killing me not to tell, I LOVE to read spoilers and can’t see why others don’t:D)
 
I got mine from Amazon today at 1230, I finished it like 20 minutes ago. I cried at the deaths of certain people at the beginning of the book and at the end of the book. And I got misty when from all the support Harry got from people who were friends, and people who he didn’t realize were friends, but who believed in the cause.

It was really good. I’m sad it’s over. What am I going to read now?
 
I was right that Snape is with Dumbledore all along. Too bad about what happened to him (I’m not giving it away, but you might want to read the Wiki spoiler :D).
 
Careful folks, don’t spoil anything for those who haven’t read it yet!!!

My thoughts (without reference to plot points): Disappointed.

I had figured everything out correctly, or at least most everything. I wanted to be surprised!
 
I think I attended what may have been the nation’s largest Hype Harry Potter event last night in Hudson OH with the grandkids. Paper says attendance was more than the anticipated 12,000 and I believe it. . All our kids were in costume as were about 10,000 other people. Every character from every book was represented as well as various of the animals in the stories, dragons, owls, gryphons etc. It was started by the local bookstore owner for the 4th book, and repeated for each successive book, this is of course billed as “the last extravaganza”.

Hudson is a small Western Reserve town with many of the downtown bldgs on the historic register, village green and other features of WR towns. The newer shopping district adjacent has kept the 19th c architectural style, so the setting was perfect. All the storeowners decorated windows and sometimes renamed their stores for the Hogsmead or Hogwarts motif, all stores stayed open with special promotions, sales etc. Participants first went to the bookstore for “sorting” into houses, got wristbands for their house, and visited the various stores to do activities and earn “house points” redeemable for little prizes.

all the restaurants had special HP menus, community center had several shows–magic, owls and raptors, snakes and reptiles etc., local radio station played HP soundtracks, lantern parade for all in costumes. Scavenger hunt through local businesses began at 2, other programs through the evening. Those with pre-order tickets picked up their books at the bookstore at 12:01 am.

DD and girls were there as volunteers with their GS troop to direct traffic, run info booth etc, I left at 8 with the little ones, but they did not get home until after 1 by the time traffic cleared out. kids are playing with magic wands, flavored candies in gross colors, and other souvenirs today. paper also says booksellers in the main will lose money on the book, but pick up profit on related merchandising and licensed items, but for once the author will clean up. as an author I say more power to her. 10% of bookstore’s proceeds on the book are going to a program in Summit Cty to encourage disadvantaged children to own books and read.

they are all fighting over 3 copies of the book this morning, but the aunts for whom the extra copies were purchased have just shown up to claim theirs, and I anticipate a battle. Nobody has flipped to the last chapter for the spoiler as yet.
 
My daughter and I have been reading most of the day. We’re both about 2/3 done. Please, no plot spoilers!
 
Now that the book is out and in the hands of the fans, I’ve changed the title of this thread to reflect that no spoilers will be in this thread.

Let’s keep this thread a “Safe Zone” where people can discuss the entire series, the movies, the characters, the parties and hype surrounding the release of the last book and such rather than the details of this final story.

There is another thread here discussing the last book, including spoilers. Feel free to share your opinions there.

Thank you all for your cooperation. Happy reading! :coffeeread:
 
i would just like to know…

i have heard from a friend of mine that i should not read the latest edition of Harry Potter due to the fact that the Pope had said that we as Catholics should not read it. my question is…where can i find this source of information? is there some type of internet page where i could find the…“decrees” that Pope Benedict makes? or any other Pope had made in the past besides our current Pope?
 
I went toi Borders… So it was crazy hadn’ t preordered and felt claustrophic. So I drove, to two walmarts to see if they were open, that were on my way to a Super Walmart.

When I got to the Super walmart, it was pretty easy to get my book. There was like a 1 minute line for the book, and then a longer line at the checkout…
 
i would just like to know…

i have heard from a friend of mine that i should not read the latest edition of Harry Potter due to the fact that the Pope had said that we as Catholics should not read it. my question is…where can i find this source of information? is there some type of internet page where i could find the…“decrees” that Pope Benedict makes? or any other Pope had made in the past besides our current Pope?
The Pope has not said this. I would challenge your friend to provide you with documentation, proving this.
 
i would just like to know…

i have heard from a friend of mine that i should not read the latest edition of Harry Potter due to the fact that the Pope had said that we as Catholics should not read it. my question is…where can i find this source of information? is there some type of internet page where i could find the…“decrees” that Pope Benedict makes? or any other Pope had made in the past besides our current Pope?
Read this Jimmy Akin article about that:

jimmyakin.org/2005/07/pre16_on_harry_.html
 
i would just like to know…

i have heard from a friend of mine that i should not read the latest edition of Harry Potter due to the fact that the Pope had said that we as Catholics should not read it. my question is…where can i find this source of information? is there some type of internet page where i could find the…“decrees” that Pope Benedict makes? or any other Pope had made in the past besides our current Pope?
if you check the beginning of this thread, it is supposed to be about positive comments, for people who like the books. there are a number of anit-HP threads, the last one was when the last movie came out, may even be in the archives. there you can find links to more anti articles.
 
Read this Jimmy Akin article about that:

jimmyakin.org/2005/07/pre16_on_harry_.html
I just read that. First of all, the book he mentions, Starswarm by Jerry Pournelle is excellent. I just read it a couple weeks ago.

Likewise, the article he links to from The Guardian (UK) is also very good. It’s funny – I like the Potter series but I’ve tolerated a lot of sloppiness from Rowling that I’d never put up with from a science fiction novel.

It also strikes me how inferior “magic” is to “muggle” technology. Sending messages by owl – I mean, really! I’m sure Hermione could have scored some cell phones and explained how to use them. And I’d certainly trust my health to modern medicine before I went to St Mungo’s!!
 
It also strikes me how inferior “magic” is to “muggle” technology. Sending messages by owl – I mean, really! I’m sure Hermione could have scored some cell phones and explained how to use them.
Owls are commonly believed to be embody the soul of a deceased person. I’m not sure if this is spelled out in Harry Potter, but that might be the reason for using owls.
 
I just read that. First of all, the book he mentions, Starswarm by Jerry Pournelle is excellent. I just read it a couple weeks ago.

Likewise, the article he links to from The Guardian (UK) is also very good. It’s funny – I like the Potter series but I’ve tolerated a lot of sloppiness from Rowling that I’d never put up with from a science fiction novel.

It also strikes me how inferior “magic” is to “muggle” technology. Sending messages by owl – I mean, really! I’m sure Hermione could have scored some cell phones and explained how to use them. And I’d certainly trust my health to modern medicine before I went to St Mungo’s!!
well it had come to my attention while reading the 7th installment of HP that it had been 1981 at the time of Harry’s parents’ deaths. so Harry being at the age of 17 in the seventh book, the appropriate year for HP the 7th year would 1998. which in 1998 itself in real life, cell phones were pretty inferior and were very expensive.
 
If they were using cell phones, their messages could be intercepted by muggles. The owls were overlooked by muggles, and therefore a more secure means of communication.
 
If they were using cell phones, their messages could be intercepted by muggles. The owls were overlooked by muggles, and therefore a more secure means of communication.
Pretty weak – how would anyone know to try to intercept their cellphone calls?
Even granting the point – pay phones, seeing as how Harry, Ron & Hermione were always sneaking out to the village. Given Arthur Weasley’s love of muggle-tech he probably would have figured a way to get a phone into the Burrow.

And speaking off weak plotting, I’m halfway thru Deathly Hallows and Harry & companions have once more been gotten into serious trouble entirely thru his doing something he knew better than to do. Of course they’ll get out of it because there are 300 pages to go.
 
It also strikes me how inferior “magic” is to “muggle” technology. Sending messages by owl – I mean, really! I’m sure Hermione could have scored some cell phones and explained how to use them. And I’d certainly trust my health to modern medicine before I went to St Mungo’s!!
Rather than compare “messages by owl” to a telephone we should probably compare it to the postal service…

Besides that there are many other magically ways to communicate instantly (e.g. talking patronus, through the fire place, in person via appartion)

Catholig
 
Here are some reasons why cell phones aren’t in the wizarding world -
  1. Wizards probably distrust muggle technology.
  2. The cellphones probably wouldn’t work in the wizarding world anyway (you know Hogwarts, Hogsmead, & Diagon Alley).
  3. And they’d have to get muggle money to pay for the service if it did work.
Catholig
 
I love all the books. Rowling’s writing grew in depth and somberness as the series went on, culminating in the last book of the series, which had me blubbering in more than one spot.

I also LOVE Mary Grandpre’s cover artwork, which also grew in sophistication with each volume.

Sad to think there will be no more Midnight Harry Potter Book parties.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top