Fort Carson troops will soon deploy, 'supporting Ukraine'

  • Thread starter Thread starter Exiled_Child
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
NATO wouldn’t dare attack Novorossiya outright.

The volunteer forces of the NAF will win the day over Karkhov, Azov, and Western mercenaries.
 
It’s just sabre rattling and not even much of that. NATO knows that Russia has alot more resolve than they do when it comes to dealing with problems on there doorstep.
I find myself agreeing with you. One doubts Obama would defend the White House from Russia if Putin sent a barge load of soldiers up the Potomac.

I agree it’s not even sabre rattling. These soldiers probably won’t even go into Poland, a NATO member where they have every right to go, and a state to whose defense the U.S. is committed.
 
I know there’s been a tremendous amount of debate on the whole issue of Ukranian neo-Nazis, and I realize that it’s a very divisive and inflammatory subject, but to me it seems clear that the US helped install a government with blatant neo-fascist leanings. There are plenty of people who would go even further than me, of course. The NATO and NAZI comparisons always used to seem questionable to me, but when they openly lend their blessings and support to Ukraine’s new government what can one say? NATO is being extremely aggressive toward Russia with their ever encroaching military presence, added to the United States ever encroaching military bases surrounding Russia. We, the West, are needling Russia and forcing their hand, and when they predictably respond our news stations frame the situation by saying that Russia is the aggressor. it’s plain to see what is really going on, and it’s sickening. It would be exactly as if Russia opened 15 military bases on the Mexican border, 15 bases on the Canadian border, 5 bases in the Caribbean islands and then installed a neo-Alaskan government to declare independence and break away from the US, all the while airing endless television news programs which loudly and belligerently screamed that the US was hostile for no reason whatsoever!
Incorrect on all counts.

First, the “neo fascists” in Ukraine ALL TOGETHER did not garner as many votes in the recent election as did one Jewish candidate. Less than 2%. Some Nazis those are! :rolleyes:

U.S. soldiers are hundreds of miles from Ukraine, let alone from Russia, while Russian troops are in Ukraine; a Ukraine that Russia agreed would remain inviolate, including Crimea which Russia has outright annexed. Never mind that the majority of eastern Ukrainians, even the Russian speakers want to remain part of Ukraine, not Russia.

And the U.S. is being aggressive toward Russia? For goodness sake, if Obama pledged to defend New York, would that be too aggressive to suit?
 
So you are saying the troops are there to attack Russia? :confused:

And Moldova has their breakaway pro-Russian region too.

Guess this is more of the “West” needling Russia! :rotfl:

Let’s see, USA has not controlled Mexico, Caribbean islands.

Let’s see, USSR controlled all of those countries that use to be a part of it, Belarus and so on, Iron Curtain countries had Soviet domination too, Czech Republic, Romania, East Germany and so on.

Great analogies! 👍
The US overthrew governments with the CIA and built a little canal out of the goodness of their hearts, blockade another country to this day and tried to overthrow it. Caribbean Islands? Does puerto Rico count, what about the Philippines?
 
Incorrect on all counts.

First, the “neo fascists” in Ukraine ALL TOGETHER did not garner as many votes in the recent election as did one Jewish candidate. Less than 2%. Some Nazis those are! :rolleyes:

U.S. soldiers are hundreds of miles from Ukraine, let alone from Russia, while Russian troops are in Ukraine; a Ukraine that Russia agreed would remain inviolate, including Crimea which Russia has outright annexed. Never mind that the majority of eastern Ukrainians, even the Russian speakers want to remain part of Ukraine, not Russia.

And the U.S. is being aggressive toward Russia? For goodness sake, if Obama pledged to defend New York, would that be too aggressive to suit?
Poroshenko set up a farce vote that surprisingly he won in. Who would have guessed?

Well maybe Russian troops are their because Russia borders Ukraine not the US? Russia didn’t agree to acting stupid by letting an illegal pro western coup to damage their foreign interests by placing a NATO satellite on their border. The US has no problem not following “international” laws. Crimea is Russian ethnically and if you are so upset over countries changing then look at the US and the land they stole from the serbs. The serbs didn’t want the western hypocrites to steal their historical land.

Why does the US care about this anyway. Why do they have to be the big bad cop of the world. This has nothing to do with them economically, security wise, its not a exceptionally murderous conflict. The only thing they have in this is damaging Russia which they are jumping at an opportunity to do.
 
The US overthrew governments with the CIA and built a little canal out of the goodness of their hearts, blockade another country to this day and tried to overthrow it. Caribbean Islands? Does puerto Rico count, what about the Philippines?
The CIA didn’t exist when the Panama canal was built, if that’s the reference. Puerto Ricans voted to remain in commonwealth status last time it was put to a vote. When the government of the Philippines asked the U.S. to leave the massive installation at Subic Bay, the U.S. did, turning all the infrasture over to the Philippines.

And the atrocities of the Cuban communist government are well known. The Castro brothers deserve to be overthrown and tried for their crimes against humanity. Even China is better, though it must be admitted North Korea is almost certainly worse.
 
I find myself agreeing with you. One doubts Obama would defend the White House from Russia if Putin sent a barge load of soldiers up the Potomac.

I agree it’s not even sabre rattling. These soldiers probably won’t even go into Poland, a NATO member where they have every right to go, and a state to whose defense the U.S. is committed.
I love this, Obama doesn’t start world war 3 by attacking Russia over Ukraine so obviously he would let Russia attack the US duh it makes complete sense. An thing not happening Americas way is a sign of weakness, there are no degrees or limits to this. A president not obliterating a country saying no to him is a clear sign of a weak leader.
 
The CIA didn’t exist when the Panama canal was built, if that’s the reference. Puerto Ricans voted to remain in commonwealth status last time it was put to a vote. When the government of the Philippines asked the U.S. to leave the massive installation at Subic Bay, the U.S. did, turning all the infrasture over to the Philippines.

And the atrocities of the Cuban communist government are well known. The Castro brothers deserve to be overthrown and tried for their crimes against humanity. Even China is better, though it must be admitted North Korea is almost certainly worse.
I was referring to Iran mainly but they also made their influence felt in Guatemala, Chile…

Do you think Putin should be tried with crimes against humanity? Its just victors justice anyway.
 
Poroshenko set up a farce vote that surprisingly he won in. Who would have guessed?

Well maybe Russian troops are their because Russia borders Ukraine not the US? Russia didn’t agree to acting stupid by letting an illegal pro western coup to damage their foreign interests by placing a NATO satellite on their border. The US has no problem not following “international” laws. Crimea is Russian ethnically and if you are so upset over countries changing then look at the US and the land they stole from the serbs. The serbs didn’t want the western hypocrites to steal their historical land.

Why does the US care about this anyway. Why do they have to be the big bad cop of the world. This has nothing to do with them economically, security wise, its not a exceptionally murderous conflict. The only thing they have in this is damaging Russia which they are jumping at an opportunity to do.
Oh, there’s a matter of an agreement to which Russia agreed, twice, that Ukraine, including Crimea, was to remain independent and inviolate. Russia’s invasion should have a lot of people concerned, and a lot of people are concerned. It has been 20+ years now that Eastern Europe (and half of Germany) lived under the Russian heel, and a heavy heel it was. Should they have forgotten about that already? Is there some compelling reason why they should not be concerned about Russian invasion of next-door Ukraine? Having been flayed and starved by the KGB, should they regard a former KGB colonel in charge of a heavily-armed neighbor that rules non-Russian ethnicities with an iron hand, with no fear whatever?

Poles, for example, actually lived under Russian domination. Their next door neighbor is invaded and part of it annexed. Are they truly to be blamed for being worried about it? And the Baltic states, who also have Russian minorities due to Russian genocide. Should they have no concern about some bogus Russian 'vote" to join the new Russian Empire, followed by Russian “little green men”, then tanks?

Why does Russia’s border with Ukraine justify Russian troops in Ukraine? Does the U.S. border with Canada justify seizing and annexing, say, southern Saskatchewan?
 
Poroshenko set up a farce vote that surprisingly he won in. Who would have guessed?

Well maybe Russian troops are their because Russia borders Ukraine not the US? Russia didn’t agree to acting stupid by letting an illegal pro western coup to damage their foreign interests by placing a NATO satellite on their border. The US has no problem not following “international” laws. Crimea is Russian ethnically and if you are so upset over countries changing then look at the US and the land they stole from the serbs. The serbs didn’t want the western hypocrites to steal their historical land.

Why does the US care about this anyway. Why do they have to be the big bad cop of the world. This has nothing to do with them economically, security wise, its not a exceptionally murderous conflict. The only thing they have in this is damaging Russia which they are jumping at an opportunity to do.
-The Crimea is ethnically Russian now because of what happened to the population of the Crimea (who weren’t ethnically Russian) under the USSR
-Last I checked being ethnically Russian did not in fact make one a Russian citizen or somehow make where ethnic Russian lived a part of Russia.
-So Russia’s answer to “NATO satellites on Russia’s border” is to annex its neighbors into Russia? Or did I miss the part about the Crimea not being annexed into Russia and instead has been declared by Russia to be the legitimate and independent Ukraine?
 
Why does Russia’s border with Ukraine justify Russian troops in Ukraine? Does the U.S. border with Canada justify seizing and annexing, say, southern Saskatchewan?
Well southern Saskatchewan is full of ethnic Americans, and it does border on the US, and we all know how Canadians treat ethnic Americans, so…😃
 
One doubts Obama would defend the White House from Russia if Putin sent a barge load of soldiers up the Potomac…
Heh

Surprisingly, some months back, in an interview with CBS News Mr. Obama noted: “They’re not interested in any kind of military confrontation with us, understanding that our conventional forces are significantly superior to the Russians. We don’t need a war”

He is correct about the ability of the United States military but he may be missing the point that Mr. Putin was never a fan of Détente.
I agree it’s not even sabre rattling. These soldiers probably won’t even go into Poland, a NATO member where they have every right to go, and a state to whose defense the U.S. is committed.
Imo, **OP Atlantic resolve ** is nothing more than having a token military presence in areas where none of any significance exist.
 
Do you think Putin should be tried with crimes against humanity? Its just victors justice anyway.
I don’t know whether Putin could rightly be convicted of having committed crimes against humanity. I am, however, at least somewhat convinced of the accuracy of A.S. Solzhenitsyn’s assessment of those who were in the Checka/NKVD/MVD/KGB. He said no one could rise within that organization without having a heart of “oaken cruelty” (his words) with blood on his hands. Putin has said of himself “once a Chekist, always a Chekist”. Now, if some German, formerly in the SS said “once an SS man, always an SS man”, we would not think well of him and we would wonder what dark deeds he would be discovered to have been a part of if some lost archive was found. But we do not, and will probably never have, Putin’s full KGB dossier. Failing that, we will never know whether he committed tortures or murders such that he should rightly be convicted of “crimes against humanity”.

But not all of the Nuremberg defendants were convicted of crimes against humanity. Some, like Rudolf Hess, were convicted of conspiracy to conduct aggressive war. It is impossible to believe Putin is not guilty of that.

Calling such convictions “victors’ justice” is excessively cynical. Of course the victors conduct such things, but they’re not the only ones. Germans have been tried by Germans for crimes against humanity. Frenchmen by Frenchmen. Brits by Brits.

Sometimes societies cleanse themselves of their criminals of their own accord. Again, paraphrasing Solzhenitsyn, he felt Russia could never regain its soul until it fully exposed and faced the criminality in its history, including the complicity of many of its own citizens (as did France, post WWII) in genocides, tortures, and murders.

Instead, what we see in Russia now is the still-extant “shrine to Lenin” in Moscow, the restoration of the statues of Dzherzinsky to places of honor, and a populace, 40%+ of which has a favorable view of Stalin to this day. And we have a leader who says, proudly, “once a Chekist, always a Chekist”.
 
-The Crimea is ethnically Russian now because of what happened to the population of the Crimea (who weren’t ethnically Russian) under the USSR
-Last I checked being ethnically Russian did not in fact make one a Russian citizen or somehow make where ethnic Russian lived a part of Russia.
-So Russia’s answer to “NATO satellites on Russia’s border” is to annex its neighbors into Russia? Or did I miss the part about the Crimea not being annexed into Russia and instead has been declared by Russia to be the legitimate and independent Ukraine?
-They are Russian now and if you want to play the historical game Kiev was actually the first Russian major city not Moscow
-Last I checked the West didn’t care one bit about nationality or laws when they created a new one for the people of Kosovo to suit their goals.
-Yes they annexed Crimea from the eager westerners and they would be stupid to let a Russian majority district with important strategic implications to go into the hands of western backed mob government.
 
I don’t know whether Putin could rightly be convicted of having committed crimes against humanity. I am, however, at least somewhat convinced of the accuracy of A.S. Solzhenitsyn’s assessment of those who were in the Checka/NKVD/MVD/KGB. He said no one could rise within that organization without having a heart of “oaken cruelty” (his words) with blood on his hands. Putin has said of himself “once a Chekist, always a Chekist”. Now, if some German, formerly in the SS said “once an SS man, always an SS man”, we would not think well of him and we would wonder what dark deeds he would be discovered to have been a part of if some lost archive was found. But we do not, and will probably never have, Putin’s full KGB dossier. Failing that, we will never know whether he committed tortures or murders such that he should rightly be convicted of “crimes against humanity”.

But not all of the Nuremberg defendants were convicted of crimes against humanity. Some, like Rudolf Hess, were convicted of conspiracy to conduct aggressive war. It is impossible to believe Putin is not guilty of that.

Calling such convictions “victors’ justice” is excessively cynical. Of course the victors conduct such things, but they’re not the only ones. Germans have been tried by Germans for crimes against humanity. Frenchmen by Frenchmen. Brits by Brits.

Sometimes societies cleanse themselves of their criminals of their own accord. Again, paraphrasing Solzhenitsyn, he felt Russia could never regain its soul until it fully exposed and faced the criminality in its history, including the complicity of many of its own citizens (as did France, post WWII) in genocides, tortures, and murders.

Instead, what we see in Russia now is the still-extant “shrine to Lenin” in Moscow, the restoration of the statues of Dzherzinsky to places of honor, and a populace, 40%+ of which has a favorable view of Stalin to this day. And we have a leader who says, proudly, “once a Chekist, always a Chekist”.
You keep harping about Russia and the communist past they have but ignore western examples like the French glorifying the French revolution and basing their country on that brutal legacy.

If your too naive to see that you kind of have to be a tough or “cold” man to work in a powerful countries intelligence agency then you are just being unrealistic and very biased. Look up the terrible murders and crimes that you beloved Mossad committed.

It is victor’s justice. How many soviets where sentenced to death, how many non vichy french, how many Americans? The winners always seem to be angels in these non biased very fair court trials.
 
Well southern Saskatchewan is full of ethnic Americans, and it does border on the US, and we all know how Canadians treat ethnic Americans, so…😃
I hope you guys give back Texas to Mexico after that little to many Americans there event.
 
-They are Russian now and if you want to play the historical game Kiev was actually the first Russian major city not Moscow
-Last I checked the West didn’t care one bit about nationality or laws when they created a new one for the people of Kosovo to suit their goals.
-Yes they annexed Crimea from the eager westerners and they would be stupid to let a Russian majority district with important strategic implications to go into the hands of western backed mob government.
Precisely. It was the intervention of outside parties in relation to the Ukraine protests and overthrowing of the government that was preposterous.

Let’s, for example, say Chinese government officials (if they were not friendly with Russia), came into Ukraine and visibly supported the protests against the existing Ukrainian government whilst handing out ‘fortune cookies’🙂 - why would the Chinese or any outside country have a need or right to be involved in the first place.
 
-They are Russian now and if you want to play the historical game Kiev was actually the first Russian major city not Moscow
Kiev was, indeed, the initial “capital” of the Rus, but, as even Russian writers would acknowledge, it departed from Muscovy culturally, linguistically and in its sense of identity. Again, the majority of eastern Ukrainians, including the majority of Russian-speakers, want to remain part of Ukraine. That, of course, is to say nothing of western Ukrainians who have never identified with Russia in any way.

Quite possibly, part of the reason even Russian speaking Ukrainians want to remain in an independent Ukraine is the Russian genocide visited upon Ukraine. Some 10 million were starved to death during the Holodomor. More were removed to the Gulags and the northern regions. It’s not adequate to wave it away by saying “oh, well, the communists were the ones who did it.” Yes, it’s true, but it was carried out by Russian cadres. The Ukrainians welcomed the Germans with bread and salt when it appeared the Germans were going to liberate them from Russian domination. Then, when the Russians returned, they carried out further massacres and genocide against the Ukrainians, moving ethnic Russians into it just as they did in the Baltic states. Of all the tragic scenes ever created in history is the miles-long lines of Ukrainians fleeing Ukraine behind the German troops (whom, by that time Ukrainians also hated and feared…but less than the Russians)

Can anyone really wonder why Ukrainians don’t want to be ruled by Russians today, and particularly by a country run by a member of the hated KGB?

And yet, Putin conquered Crimea and is in the process of conquering an eastern Ukraine that doesn’t want his dominion. Perhaps the “oaken cruelty” Solzhenitsyn talked about has not changed.
 
-They are Russian now and if you want to play the historical game Kiev was actually the first Russian major city not Moscow
-Last I checked the West didn’t care one bit about nationality or laws when they created a new one for the people of Kosovo to suit their goals.
-Yes they annexed Crimea from the eager westerners and they would be stupid to let a Russian majority district with important strategic implications to go into the hands of western backed mob government.
You might want to brush up on Russian history. Kiev didn’t start out as Russian.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top