I don’t know whether Putin could rightly be convicted of having committed crimes against humanity. I am, however, at least somewhat convinced of the accuracy of A.S. Solzhenitsyn’s assessment of those who were in the Checka/NKVD/MVD/KGB. He said no one could rise within that organization without having a heart of “oaken cruelty” (his words) with blood on his hands. Putin has said of himself “once a Chekist, always a Chekist”. Now, if some German, formerly in the SS said “once an SS man, always an SS man”, we would not think well of him and we would wonder what dark deeds he would be discovered to have been a part of if some lost archive was found. But we do not, and will probably never have, Putin’s full KGB dossier. Failing that, we will never know whether he committed tortures or murders such that he should rightly be convicted of “crimes against humanity”.
But not all of the Nuremberg defendants were convicted of crimes against humanity. Some, like Rudolf Hess, were convicted of conspiracy to conduct aggressive war. It is impossible to believe Putin is not guilty of that.
Calling such convictions “victors’ justice” is excessively cynical. Of course the victors conduct such things, but they’re not the only ones. Germans have been tried by Germans for crimes against humanity. Frenchmen by Frenchmen. Brits by Brits.
Sometimes societies cleanse themselves of their criminals of their own accord. Again, paraphrasing Solzhenitsyn, he felt Russia could never regain its soul until it fully exposed and faced the criminality in its history, including the complicity of many of its own citizens (as did France, post WWII) in genocides, tortures, and murders.
Instead, what we see in Russia now is the still-extant “shrine to Lenin” in Moscow, the restoration of the statues of Dzherzinsky to places of honor, and a populace, 40%+ of which has a favorable view of Stalin to this day. And we have a leader who says, proudly, “once a Chekist, always a Chekist”.