I think the Bishops who have served over Father Pfleger have failed in guiding him.
From what I have experienced in my life when a priest handles an agenda or confronts a situation that is emotional, such as; abortion, the poor, scandals etc… the emotions can become quite strong and blinding. I think it is the duty of the Bishop to spiritually guide the priests.
It appears to me that Father Pfleger once upon a time decided that his approach to evangelize would be ‘when in Rome do as the Romans’. This is good, but, there is a line and Father Pfleger blinded by his emotions and dedication has long ago failed to see that line which now appears so vague to him that it is invisible. He is lost and needs to find his way back. Where is his Bishop?
This reminds me of a priest in the Dominican Republic who was very famous and outspoken. A young priest. He had been assigned to the parish of the poorest neighborhood of the capitol. He was taking on the war for the poor and their rights. He was very emotional and dedicated and often in the news. Once he went a little too far and he defended himself in the name of the poor. The second time was the last. He was removed from the parish. He was heart broken. He was in the market sort of speak for a parish to request him but no parish requested the good father. He had become too political and too rebellious. Finally, I heard that he was working at a parish and in an interview he stated that he was fine at his new parish. He needed to be transferred from his other parish and it did him well. He was getting so involved that he was loosing his vision.
A similar thing happened with another young priest. But, he was not as famous yet his immaturity showed in dealing with his vocation. He was sent to serve in Rome.
Bishops, need to take the responsibility that is theirs to guide their priests, especially those who are dealing with, what I would describe as emotional agendas(abortion, war, scandal, poverty, illness). How can one expect a person that has been blinded to find his way. It is always easier to condenm than to take responsibility. A Bishop is in command and should act upon his authority to guide their priests and not permit intimidation due to the fame of a priest. Of course, I recognize the debility and responsibility of the priest but I also recognize the responsibility of the Bishop.
I also think that it is worth noting that these things happen and many similar to these and they just simply need to be addressed when they do. The faithfuls and their leaders are not perfect but, when we encounter problems we simply need to address them. There are people, Catholics and non-Catholics alike, who immediately take advantage of these situations to criticize the Church but this is illogical. Problems simply need to be addressed with love and charity and of course, responsibility.
I will certainly pray for Father Pfleger.
Peace,
Abba