Free Will To Sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter OkeyDokei
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
OkeyDokei:
Whats the worry for the homosexuals, be gay, be sorry, live and forgive! šŸ™‚
The being sorry part is what the issue is. Many people are trying to tell them that they do not have to be sorry and that they should give in whenever they feel like. They need to be sorry and strive to live chastely–like we all do.
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
Whats the worry for the homosexuals, be gay, be sorry, live and forgive!
Because in order to be sorry one must have a firm conviction to not repeat the sin.
 
Scott Waddell:
Fact: that many people commit sin, does not make sin not sin.

Whether they go to Hell depends on their personal culpability. And then you admitted that this one sin is repented in confession and we are truly sorry. So yes, if a homosexual repents of his acts of sodomy, he will be forgiven. But which argument do you want to pursure? Whether homosexual acts are sinful? Whether homosexual acts are forgivable?

Scott
I do not know if it is sinful…I used to believe the bible’s Lev 20 but i am starting to logically think for myself. I either need to be pulled back into christianity or given a shove out of theism…

Is it forgiveable? I do not know either…Lev 20 says to immediatly kill/stone them to death…This being the word of ā€œgodā€ is not assuring. I thought he was mercifull and just and now i am just confused. Personally i think it is, if i worship a god i do not believe he is naive enough to damn somebody for this…
 
Sexual relief? Sexual sensations? Oh boy! Sex is meant to pro-create and bond. Even nature itself shows us this. Homosexuality is even a flaw in nature (the survival of the fittest). Why does it always have to be about sex? Why not love? True love and starting a family. Not a fake shell apperance of looks.

What about people who are born with chemical inbalances that efecct and frustrate them to the point of them choosing evil? I can speak of this PERSONALY! Yet by following God’s ways and having faith, you would be surprised at easy it can be to reject sins.

I have heard of a case where one man lost his boyfriend from aids, he became depressed and began seeking God. Eventualy he converted to Catholicism, BUT he still had no attraction for women, just truly men, so he vowed to God to remain celibate.

The Catholic Church also offers classes and gives aid to homosexuals who believe they are suffering from phycological problems that cause them to be attracted to men and much help comes from this.

I would rather have a heart of compassion than the mind of a genuiess
God give you peace:)
 
40.png
puzzleannie:
no, homosexuality is not a sin, if you mean the condition or disorder of same sex attraction or homosexual inclinations, it is a disorder but a disorder is not a sin, although it may prove a temptation to sin.
Consensual homosexual activity however is a sin, and can only be done by a conscious decision. This would not apply in a case where one was raped or abused of course. But homosexuals do have free will on how they chose to use or abuse their bodies. No one is compelled to act out sexually, whether they engage illicit genital activity with a partner of the same or opposite sex. For a person to say his actions are at the mercy of his sex drive is to deny is human will and reduce him to the level of an animal.
We are fallable animals…We are mamals who are not perfect and will at times be slaves to emotions/sex drives/irrational things… This is what makes us human, not the ability to restrain ourselves. I have major problems with the bible’s belief in this subject…Am i not christian if i disagree with some key issues such as these?
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
We are fallable animals…We are mamals who are not perfect and will at times be slaves to emotions/sex drives/irrational things… This is what makes us human, not the ability to restrain ourselves. I have major problems with the bible’s belief in this subject…Am i not christian if i disagree with some key issues such as these?
Wrong. We are called to not be slaves. That is what makes us human. The Truth will set you free my friend. Do not be a slave to your concupiscence. Slavery is an affront to human dignity.
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
Fact: Over 90% of Males have admitted to masturbating once in their life.

Fact: Over 70% of Males (Age 45 and under) admit to masturbating on a weekly basis.
-Okey
your opinions are not facts
if you are going to continue making claims like this you will have to cite credible sources
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
We are fallable animals…We are mamals who are not perfect and will at times be slaves to emotions/sex drives/irrational things… This is what makes us human, not the ability to restrain ourselves. I have major problems with the bible’s belief in this subject…Am i not christian if i disagree with some key issues such as these?
you are wrong not only in your moral theology but in your definition of a human being. You are certainly not a Christian if you deny the dignity of the human being with soul and intellect and free will that places him in an order of creation higher than the animals who act and react solely on instinct. If you wish to continue meaningful discussions on this forum may I suggest you leave of the habit of making untrue statements, then posing an argument based on knocking down or supporting that untrue statement. As of now, nothing you have posted is of any usefulness in an informed discussion, so I am out of here. In any case, this thread belongs on the morality forum, not apologetics.
 
J.W.B.:
Sexual relief? Sexual sensations? Oh boy! Sex is meant to pro-create and bond. Even nature itself shows us this. Homosexuality is even a flaw in nature (the survival of the fittest). Why does it always have to be about sex? Why not love? True love and starting a family. Not a fake shell apperance of looks.

What about people who are born with chemical inbalances that efecct and frustrate them to the point of them choosing evil? I can speak of this PERSONALY! Yet by following God’s ways and having faith, you would be surprised at easy it can be to reject sins.

I have heard of a case where one man lost his boyfriend from aids, he became depressed and began seeking God. Eventualy he converted to Catholicism, BUT he still had no attraction for women, just truly men, so he vowed to God to remain celibate.

The Catholic Church also offers classes and gives aid to homosexuals who believe they are suffering from phycological problems that cause them to be attracted to men and much help comes from this.

I would rather have a heart of compassion than the mind of a genuiess
God give you peace:)
Please do not cite Darwinism as evidence…It goes against everything the bible tells us…Homosexuality is a natural result of Human reproduction…The chances that somebody is born as or to become a homosexual range from 3-10 percent depending on what source you trust. Either way, nature has gave homosexuals a way to reproduce, they just dont do it…

I would rather have a heart of compassion than the mind of a genuiess

I disagree, a intelligent logical mind can provide a mind of compassion where compassion is deserved. A mind of intelligence can decifer through lies and find truth, find jesus, find god. ( in a Islam or Atheist world )
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
I do not know if it is sinful…I used to believe the bible’s Lev 20 but i am starting to logically think for myself.
If you were thinking logically, you would recognize that you are setting up a false dichotomy between faith and thinking for one’s self. One does not necessarily exclude the other.
Is it forgiveable? I do not know either…Lev 20 says to immediatly kill/stone them to death…This being the word of ā€œgodā€ is not assuring. I thought he was mercifull and just and now i am just confused. Personally i think it is, if i worship a god i do not believe he is naive enough to damn somebody for this…
The law of Leviticus does not apply because we are in the New Covenant, BUT the sodomy is still a sin, not primarly just because Leviticus says so (this is why you will see that goofy email about goats and stuff), but because it is disordered against God’s purposes. As the Church teaches, it is forgivable, and personal culpability is a factor, but there are also consequences for not availing yourself of that forgiveness.

Scott
 
Many of you think we are not at times ā€œslavesā€ to our emotions or other non logical things…But you do not realize we are so often! Temptation is fufilled in our daily lives from sleeping in late, eating the donut on your way to work to having homosexual or heterosexual (not married) relations…Humans are fallable and ALL sucuum to temptation at some level. We cannot prevent all temptation, if you can, you are not human.
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
We are fallable animals…We are mamals who are not perfect and will at times be slaves to emotions/sex drives/irrational things… This is what makes us human, not the ability to restrain ourselves. I have major problems with the bible’s belief in this subject…Am i not christian if i disagree with some key issues such as these?
You are a christian if you have been baptised in the Trinitarian forumla. You are a heritic if you are a christinan and refuse to belileve what you know the Church teaches.

What makes us human is that we are created in the image and likeness of God. Otherwise we would just be some darn animal.

Dude, quite makeing excuses. Man up and accept the fact that we do have the capibilities to decern our actions. Life is hard, get over it, you have no other choice. Everyone has crosses to bear that they don’t want to, but most shoulder them and march on to Calvary, the rest go insane.

One can’t deny themselves into heaven, but I’m sure they can deny themselves into hell.
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
Many of you think we are not at times ā€œslavesā€ to our emotions or other non logical things…But you do not realize we are so often! Temptation is fufilled in our daily lives from sleeping in late, eating the donut on your way to work to having homosexual or heterosexual (not married) relations…Humans are fallable and ALL sucuum to temptation at some level. We cannot prevent all temptation, if you can, you are not human.
Mary did and she was fully human. šŸ‘
 
Scott Waddell:
If you were thinking logically, you would recognize that you are setting up a false dichotomy between faith and thinking for one’s self. One does not necessarily exclude the other.

Scott
****ā€œThe way to see by faith is to shut the eye of reason.ā€

Your statement is only opinion

To Trelow: Please do not tell me to ā€˜man up’. For one i cannot take you seriously when you do. Two, If you are not baptised at birth, and you are a convert, are you not christian? 3, Life is hard, but we still all give in to temptatin, we are fallable, please do not argue otherwise.

 
40.png
Genesis315:
Mary did and she was fully human. šŸ‘
Can you give citations? Where Mary or any other person did not relief themselves by giving into temptation wether it be getting up, having sex, eating pork, or murdering an enemy…
 
OkeyDokei said:
**** If you are not baptised at birth, and you are a convert, are you not christian?****

One should be baptized at the time of their conversion.
 
40.png
OkeyDokei:
Many of you think we are not at times ā€œslavesā€ to our emotions or other non logical things…But you do not realize we are so often! Temptation is fufilled in our daily lives from sleeping in late, eating the donut on your way to work to having homosexual or heterosexual (not married) relations…Humans are fallable and ALL sucuum to temptation at some level. We cannot prevent all temptation, if you can, you are not human.
Yes. Everyone struggles with temptation. But with the help of God, it CAN be resisted succesfully. Temptations are not sinful in and of themselves, acting on them is. Whether doing so warrants eternal punishment depends on the nature of the sin.

I have to recommend that you pick up a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church and study.

Scott
 
40.png
Genesis315:
One should be baptized at the time of their conversion.
And if they are not? They are not christian, and not accepted into heaven?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top