French kissing

  • Thread starter Thread starter Windfish
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well that is an interesting point, I feel very compelled to completely agree with you, albeit the possibility that different bodies/brains can respond differently and have different outward actions labelled differently internally. I know that for a lot of folks even that hand holding could be that near occasion, where as depending on background, it could be very tame… at any rate, I cant say I have really had the chance to properly test this (not even that I would) since I cannot seem to meet people whom share the faith as I do, in any of the circles I travel in (work, school, church) the people who believe and are my age are just not present in my life. So my theoretical supposition on this matter kinda just hangs there. It would be my life long dream come true if I could meet a young woman who would actually not want to pressure me into doing anything uncomfortable. Kinda off topic but that lament is so relevant today probably for everyone who frequents this site.
Aw, come on. I know it’s tough to find someone, but I’m guessing you have time to be creative. Join a young singles group at another parish – they’ll welcome you, even if you don’t go there. Find something like Theology on Tap. Try Protestants, they don’t bite. 😛

There’s gotta be someone for you to French kiss out there. 😃
 
Aw, come on. I know it’s tough to find someone, but I’m guessing you have time to be creative. Join a young singles group at another parish – they’ll welcome you, even if you don’t go there. Find something like Theology on Tap. Try Protestants, they don’t bite. 😛

There’s gotta be someone for you to French kiss out there. 😃
Thank you for the vote of confidence 🙂 thats not a bad idea about seeking out some social groups from another parish, just last weekend I did have to attend another local church due to a wedding at mine, and it struck quite a cord with me. I’ll have to check out Theology on Tap, or even Protestants ;). Its definitely crucial for all us believers to stick together, with each passing year Im feeling more and more alienated by the secularism dripping out of everything!

And who knows, maybe I’ll figure out why Im so shy about finding a spouse too? :cool:
 
Thank you for the vote of confidence 🙂 thats not a bad idea about seeking out some social groups from another parish, just last weekend I did have to attend another local church due to a wedding at mine, and it struck quite a cord with me. I’ll have to check out Theology on Tap, or even Protestants ;). Its definitely crucial for all us believers to stick together, with each passing year Im feeling more and more alienated by the secularism dripping out of everything!

And who knows, maybe I’ll figure out why Im so shy about finding a spouse too? :cool:
God grant you courage, brother! 👍
 
why in the world is the topic of French kissing a serious thread, yet when talking about the rules of the Catholic Church regarding premarital sex as being a sin, and then trying to figure out if having premarital sex can lead one to being a more mature and healthier person, learning how to realize what is appropriate in a relationship and what is not, that topic cant be discussed.

or i guess the topic of why premarital sex in the Catholic Church is a sin, and then how society and or psychologists will argue and prove how not having a healthy sexual relationship with someone of the opposite sex can lead to more problems in the realm of mental health and probably just lead to more intimacy problems when one does enter into a relationship.

that does not get discussed,

yet we get a big laugh an real discussion of is French kissing a sin or what does it lead to, ha ha ha ha.

what’s up with that ?
 
why in the world is the topic of French kissing a serious thread, yet when talking about the rules of the Catholic Church regarding premarital sex as being a sin, and then trying to figure out if having premarital sex can lead one to being a more mature and healthier person, learning how to realize what is appropriate in a relationship and what is not, that topic cant be discussed.

or i guess the topic of why premarital sex in the Catholic Church is a sin, and then how society and or psychologists will argue and prove how not having a healthy sexual relationship with someone of the opposite sex can lead to more problems in the realm of mental health and probably just lead to more intimacy problems when one does enter into a relationship.

that does not get discussed,

yet we get a big laugh an real discussion of is French kissing a sin or what does it lead to, ha ha ha ha.

what’s up with that ?
Do you have statistics to back up the claim that marriages are more sexually fulfilling when a person has had experiences with premarital sex? Do you have any concrete support for this?

In many conversations with friends, I’ve always heard that *communication *is the key to a good sex life. That’s been my experience in my marriage, as well. Good habits of communication and emotional intimacy can occur before marriage, certainly.
 
Do you have statistics to back up the claim that marriages are more sexually fulfilling when a person has had experiences with premarital sex? Do you have any concrete support for this?

In many conversations with friends, I’ve always heard that *communication *is the key to a good sex life. That’s been my experience in my marriage, as well. Good habits of communication and emotional intimacy can occur before marriage, certainly.
dude what in the world are you talking about, do I have statistics to back up claims ? I was talking about that such things on here are not even discussed or blocked right off the bat, let alone lets just forget that you chose to not acknowledge the rest of what I said, nor understood what I said at all, then to top things off, how in the world is your marriage the standard for anything ?

try re-reading what I was saying before assuming I was making a flat out statement, I don’t have the energy to try and slowly spell things out one word at a time.
 
dude what in the world are you talking about, do I have statistics to back up claims ? I was talking about that such things on here are not even discussed or blocked right off the bat…
Is there some sort of Catholic Answers ban on talking about premarital sex? Or starting threads about it? If so, I completely agree with you that such a ban is silly.
 
From the link:

“Prolonged” and “passionate” are important qualifiers that I alluded to in my original post - I placed them under the canopy of “local” factors. Tim Staples also included those qualifiers in his answer. What I am suggesting is that french kissing, or when two tongues make contact, is not always “prolonged” or “passionate” enough to place one near an occasion of fornication. And I think that is easily imaginable. And your link acknowledges that, too:

As you can see, your link acknowledges the “local” and “global” factors that I was referring to in my original post. These factors mitigate whether or not this or that instance of french kissing is a near occasion of sin. So it is not a simplistic, unilateral condemnation.

I think that about settles it, but I really do think there is something to be said about the fact that the Church has not stipulated any teaching at all on the matter, which definitely makes it a matter of prudential judgment and not a simplistic condemnation. We have to determine, through reason, if this or that case of french kissing is appropriate. Of course, that is very legalistic, and to anyone reading this, what is more important is developing an attitude of chastity and purity so that you will instinctively avoid such situations.

Still, as I said, I think there can be legitimate disagreement on this matter.
No it is not a sin.Form your conscience.The Catechism doesn’t even mention occasion of sin
 
French kissing is pretty much by nature in the “directly stimulating actions” that you will note in he article from EWTN are never to be done by the unmarried.

It does not have to be “prolonged” or “passionate”…it just has to involve the tongue…

such really is to be left to the married…

Directly stimulating things…are not just near occasions …they are the very matter for sins against the virtue of chastity.

(though deliberately entering or remaining in near occasions can be sins too)

Many things of the moral life do not receive direct detailed teachings from the Magisterium…the Church teaches the virtue of Chasity etc etc…but moral theology often is left to give certain details…

It would seem to me that such kissing is pretty much by nature in the directly stimulating category.

I can not see such as just a chaste sign of affection for the unmarried…it is directly orientated towards arousing…as a form of foreplay in marriage.
First of all the Catechism doesn’t mention this vague unintelligle so called Occasion of sin.Secondly the catechism teaches you must form your conscience & in the end have the right to act sccording to conscience.Thirdly arousal is healthy proper & normal.Its what you do with it that may or may not be sin.
 
First of all the Catechism doesn’t mention this vague unintelligle so called Occasion of sin…
The Catechism is not meant to be a moral theology textbook or an exhaustive source. Yes Occasion of sin is part of Catholic Teaching and will not cease being so.

From: Compendium of the Catechism -issued by Pope Benedict XVI:

**Act of Contrition
**
O my God, I am heartily sorry for having offended Thee, and I detest all my sins because of thy just punishments, but most of all because they offend Thee, my God, who art all good and deserving of all my love. I firmly resolve with the help of Thy grace to sin no more and to avoid the near occasion of sin. Amen.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

As to sexual pleasure --seeking sexual pleasure outside of marriage - is lust- see Catechism on Lust.

This is an Old thread -please do not bring old threads back to life.
 
The Catechism is not meant to be a moral theology textbook or an exhaustive source. Yes Occasion of sin is part of Catholic Teaching and will not cease being so.

From: Compendium of the Catechism -issued by Pope Benedict XVI:

**Act of Contrition
**
O my God, I am heartily sorry for having offended Thee, and I detest all my sins because of thy just punishments, but most of all because they offend Thee, my God, who art all good and deserving of all my love. I firmly resolve with the help of Thy grace to sin no more and to avoid the near occasion of sin. Amen.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

As to sexual pleasure --seeking sexual pleasure outside of marriage - is lust- see Catechism on Lust.

This is an Old thread -please do not bring old threads back to life.
Yes it has stopped being so,thats why you never hear about it.Theres no document that deals with the issue because its unintelligible. If you follow it you would have to abandon devotion to Mary & Saints because as Vatican II & Trent mentioned abuses have crept in.Hence devotion to Mary & saints is occasion of sin because it obscures God or Christ & braks the commandement.

Expressing affection thru kissing is not sin or lust. The reference to lust(which is ambigious & unintelligible) is a reference to matters like sexual promiscuity.There is no mention whatsoever on kissing.
It seems like your acting or supporting the Jansenist or Manichaest heresies that hold the body & pleasure always bad.
Conscience is the Aboriginal Vicar Of Christ----CCC 1778

Where does the catechism mention Kissing ? It mentions fornication,masturbation etc but not this.
Your breathing way too much into this
 
Yes it has stopped being so,thats why you never hear about it.
Huh? Incorrect.
I quoted that from the Compendium issued by Pope Benedict XVI just a few years ago!

There is no question here - we are to avoid the near occasion of sin (see any good work of moral theology, or theological dictionary etc.

There is modest and chaste kissing and immodest and unchaste kissing. Can kissing be a good sign of affection? yes. Can it be lustful? that too can be --and often is in our culture.

I do not have time to rehash all this here – remember too that the Catechism is not an exhaustive text -it is not meant to be. It is not a moral theology textbook that gets into all sorts of detailed questions. Feel free to contact the Catholic Answers Apologists they can assist in more detail…

But please cease posting on this thread -it is an OLD THREAD–we are not to revive them.
 
If you follow it you would have to abandon devotion to Mary & Saints because as Vatican II & Trent mentioned abuses have crept in.Hence devotion to Mary & saints is occasion of sin because it obscures God or Christ & braks the commandement.
I missed this part -it is important to clarify what an occasion of sin basically is so a few more words to add:

A* near occasion* for a mortal sin (often that is the focus) is some thing or person or place etc what* generally* or even always leads one to commit a particular mortal sin (or likely here and now will cause one to commit the mortal sin in question).

Such can be of a nature that it generally leads most to sin…or particular to a person.

Ordinarily we are obliged to avoid such. Though there can be exceptions.

It is not just a temptation per se. Often times one must be around certain temptations due to duty or the simply the society we live in.

And it is not a* “remote occasion*” where one could be tempted but generally one does not fall. Such are often in our society.

There can also be “necessary” occasions…one can speak with ones confessor in regards to such.

Fostering authentic devotion to Our Lady or the Saints is a good and is not usually any near occasion of mortal sin - some abuses in the past do not make something a “near occasion of sin”.

But again this is an OLD Thread. Lets let it rest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top