French priest charged during exorcism

  • Thread starter Thread starter new_atheist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No need for quotes, he is most certainly a validly ordained Catholic priest.
 
The SSPX is not a “breakaway religious group;” it was founded by Archbishop Lefebvre in 1970 with the approval of Pope Paul VI. At any rate, here’s another priest that isn’t making any good PR for them.
 
Comments are welcome. Just no overstepping the boundaries, pls. The “priest” in question is a member of the breakaway, religious group, Society of St Pius X (associated with anti-Semitism).

ph.news.yahoo.com/french-priest-charged-rape-torture-during-exorcism-173230444.html
I would worry more about the source of this news item’s validity. (link) I have seen several stories there which were exaggerated to the point of no longer being recognizable to the seed of truth it was garnered from.

That being said, if the Priest has done these things he will need to answer for them to the authorities. To use a person’s past victimization to re-victimize them is a horrid and atrocious thing to do to someone, and can destroy them psychologically. (I know from experience, but it wasn’t through a religion that the re-victimization happened to me).
I will pray for all involved.
Even if the story is distorted beyond comprehension, someone can use the prayers right?

God bless.
 
The SSPX is not a “breakaway religious group;” it was founded by Archbishop Lefebvre in 1970 with the approval of Pope Paul VI. At any rate, here’s another priest that isn’t making any good PR for them.
Yet, the priests of the Society exercise NO lawful ministry in the Church as clarified by Pope Emeritus Benedict. I think we can forgive the OP, who is not Catholic, for using the quotation marks…while technically a validly ordained priest, he is absolutely forbidden by Holy Mother Church to act as a priest in any way… no sense mincing words.
 
This is a very disturbing story. Whether he “simulated” sexual acts or actually performed them, such wicked, perverse actions play no role in an authentic exorcism rite. This priest is out to lunch, and if the accounts are true, will hopefully be brought to justice. I pray and hope he has a true change of heart.

From a Catholic perspective, any attempts made by this priest would not be a true exorcism regardless of how it was performed. An SSPX priest exercises no canonical ministry in the Church, and only a priest who has been explicitly authorized by the local Bishop can validly perform an exorcism.
 
This is a very disturbing story. Whether he “simulated” sexual acts or actually performed them, such wicked, perverse actions play no role in an authentic exorcism rite. This priest is out to lunch, and if the accounts are true, will hopefully be brought to justice. I pray and hope he has a true change of heart.

From a Catholic perspective, any attempts made by this priest would not be a true exorcism regardless of how it was performed. An SSPX priest exercises no canonical ministry in the Church, and only a priest who has been explicitly authorized by the local Bishop can validly perform an exorcism.
My understanding is that the exorcism would be valid, but illicit.
 
Comments are welcome. Just no overstepping the boundaries, pls. The “priest” in question is a member of the breakaway, religious group, Society of St Pius X (associated with anti-Semitism).

news.yahoo.com/french-priest-charged-rape-torture-during-exorcisms-173230399.html;_ylt=A0SO81xFY0lTzB4AhBKzRwx.;_ylu=X3oDMTE1N3Q3MmVhBHNlYwNzcgRwb3MDMwRjb2xvA2dxMQR2dGlkA1ZJUFBIOTlfNzU-
You list “atheist, ex-catholic[sic]” in the religion space. I have to wonder what your motive is in posting this? Did you perhaps have a question?
 
My understanding is that the exorcism would be valid, but illicit.
I don’t think so. An exorcism is not a sacrament that functions ‘ex opera operato’…it is a sacramental of the Church and thus derives its authority from the Church. A priest would be very foolish to attempt an exorcism without first receiving authority to do so from the bishop. Certainly a mass celebrated by an SSPX priest would be “valid but illicit”…but this is another scenario.

Either way, I think all of this is immaterial to the story at hand. As I stated in an earlier post, if the account is true, this is a most disturbing incident. As to the motivations of the OP, what does it matter? He isn’t attacking Catholicism by posting a story regarding the disturbing activities of a priest who is NOT in good standing with the Holy See.
 
You list “atheist, ex-catholic[sic]” in the religion space. I have to wonder what your motive is in posting this? Did you perhaps have a question?
I had the same thought and question.

This is getting very wearisome.
 
I had the same thought and question.

This is getting very wearisome.
Why is it wearisome? Why are my fellow Catholics getting so defensive? I don’t see any attack on Catholicism in this thread. The OP posted a link to a real story of a real event that happened regarding an SSPX priest. The priest is not in good standing with the Church and the account happens to be extremely disturbing. This is news. We can discuss this without fear of the Church being smeared. Let’s not assume the worst about the OP.
 
Why is it wearisome? Why are my fellow Catholics getting so defensive? I don’t see any attack on Catholicism in this thread. The OP posted a link to a real story of a real event that happened regarding an SSPX priest. The priest is not in good standing with the Church and the account happens to be extremely disturbing. This is news. We can discuss this without fear of the Church being smeared. Let’s not assume the worst about the OP.
I don’t feel defensive. The poster is fairly new, and has already posted news of a similar incident. This one he posted with no question or comment of his own, yet inviting others to comment. What is one to make of that? I don’t know, which is why I asked.

Other than that, he seems very nice and friendly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top