French troops begin intervention into Mali conflict

  • Thread starter Thread starter kelvinf
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

kelvinf

Guest
France has begun an intervention in Mali to help stem a push by Islamist rebels. The president of Mali has declared a state of emergency.

Malian soldiers launched their own counteroffensive against militants to wrest a town back from their control on Friday.

“French forces brought their support this afternoon to Malian army units to fight against terrorist elements,” Hollande told reporters. “This operation will last as long as is necessary.”

French President Francois Hollande said UN Security Council resolutions provide for the intervention. Earlier Friday, he had said that France would stop any further southward drive by Islamist rebels.
dw.de/french-troops-begin-intervention-into-mali-conflict/a-16516617

Très bien! But why only France (from the West)?
 
Why just France? I don’t know, but it may simply be that France was able to take unilateral action quickly. The Islamist advance seems to have taken everyone by surprise.
[President Hollande] said resolutions by the United Nations Security Council, which in December sanctioned an African-led military intervention in Mali, meant France was acting in accordance with international law.
A military operation had not been expected until September due to the difficulties of training Malian troops, funding the African force and deploying during the mid-year rainy season. However, Mali’s government appealed for urgent military aid from France on Thursday after Islamist fighters took Konna.
EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton called on Friday for “accelerated international engagement” and said the bloc would speed up plans to deploy 200 troops to train Malian forces, initially expected in late February.
news.yahoo.com/mali-islamists-capture-strategic-town-residents-flee-020417886.html

France would not say whether or not they had ground troops involved in the recent fighting. If so, it would contradict previous statements of intent.
 
I think it has something to do with the former French colonization of Mali and political relation between them. I don’t really know, I just usually have the news on the radio on the way to work. France has been trying to get Algeria to get involved.
 
I don’t know if the invitation to assist was even extended to other countries.
 
I think it has something to do with the former French colonization of Mali and political relation between them. I don’t really know, I just usually have the news on the radio on the way to work. France has been trying to get Algeria to get involved.
Yes, I would say it does. France has a relationship to Mali somewhat like Britain has with her former colonies that are now part of the Commonwealth. Its only natural I suppose that the European nation with the most vested interest and history in the country would lend it assistance in its time of need. The Mali president specifically asked the French to intervene, as far as I am aware, to save the country from being overrun by the Islamists (who are linked to al-Qaeda).
 
Not to mention the fact the US is already involved in enough wars without starting another.
 
Yes, I would say it does. France has a relationship to Mali somewhat like Britain has with her former colonies that are now part of the Commonwealth. Its only natural I suppose that the European nation with the most vested interest and history in the country would lend it assistance in its time of need. The Mali president specifically asked the French to intervene, as far as I am aware, to save the country from being overrun by the Islamists (who are linked to al-Qaeda).
Britain has no such relationships with her former colonies. Most of her colonies have better armed forces than Britian does. IN fact if you looked at history. It is her colonies that have done the majority of the rescuing
 
Britain has no such relationships with her former colonies. Most of her colonies have better armed forces than Britian does. IN fact if you looked at history. It is her colonies that have done the majority of the rescuing
Hmm…what is this supposed to mean, I wonder? Are you referring to the Second World War ie Canada, Australia & India? How did they “rescue” the UK? They helped greatly and indispensably her war against the Nazis who were overunning continental Europe but “rescued” I would contest. ANZAK troops and Canadians not to mention the 1 million volunteer Indian Army made a sterling contribution to the war effort but that shouldn’t undermine Great Britain’s either. We are, after all, the ones who declared war on Nazi Germany and fought on after the Fall of France largely stranded from the Empire by considerable territorial distance (although many Poles fought in the Battle of Britain too).

The current Coalition government has cut military expenditure and the armed forces but I wouldn’t say its anywhere near as dire as you suggest. Britain made an indispensable contribution to Allied victory in WW2. After the war the “empire struck back” during the Falklands War, which demonstrated to everyone that the UK was not a pushover, third-rate power but a force to be reckoned with. In the Falklands Britain stepped in to repulse the forces of the invading Argentinian army under the fascist junta, who thought that the UK had “lost its star” so would let the islands go to them - and surprise, surprise they got an absolute wallopping and are still licking their wounds to this day. France seems to be doing a similar thing in Mali not against fascists (like Britain did) but against Islamists (except of course that Britain still has sovereignity over the Falklands whereas Mali is an independent country).

I can only assume that you aren’t particularly fond of Britain (why I can’t say) although I concede that I may have misinterpreted you friend 😛 😃 If I did, “sorry” but please do explain to me what you mean.
 
Kelvinf, this is good to hear. I’ve been a bit intrigued by the French Foreign Legion which partly led me to reading two books on them some years ago. I wonder if the FFL will be involved in this in any way?
Britain has no such relationships with her former colonies. Most of her colonies have better armed forces than Britian does. IN fact if you looked at history. It is her colonies that have done the majority of the rescuing
The Brit’s and had colonies in Africa too. I think modern day Nigeria was one of them. Some how I don’t think Nigeria has a better armed and trained military force than the Brits.

For the Brits population and geographic size they have a pretty remarkable military.

The power and military projection of that power on a global scale probably makes the United States more an anomaly of all the earths nation-states today.

I suspect–though I don’t know for certain–the French Foreign Legion is particularly well fitted for desert warfare too. Mali does have deserts yes? My geography is poor. But from the looks of the video it seemed that nation has some desert regions.
 
Kelvinf, this is good to hear. I’ve been a bit intrigued by the French Foreign Legion which partly led me to reading two books on them some years ago. I wonder if the FFL will be involved in this in any way?
I think the French Foreign Legion is always the first to be sent into conflict. Why send your own countrymen to die when you can send (primarily) foreigners instead. 🤷
I suspect–though I don’t know for certain–the French Foreign Legion is particularly well fitted for desert warfare too. Mali does have deserts yes? My geography is poor. But from the looks of the video it seemed that nation has some desert regions.
That seems to be a reasonable assumption considering that the French Foreign Legion was heavily involved in the colonial expansion of the French Empire in Africa and eventually the Algerian War of Independence.
 
Hmm…what is this supposed to mean, I wonder? Are you referring to the Second World War ie Canada, Australia & India? How did they “rescue” the UK? They helped greatly and indispensably her war against the Nazis who were overunning continental Europe but “rescued” I would contest. ANZAK troops and Canadians not to mention the 1 million volunteer Indian Army made a sterling contribution to the war effort but that shouldn’t undermine Great Britain’s either. We are, after all, the ones who declared war on Nazi Germany and fought on after the Fall of France largely stranded from the Empire by considerable territorial distance (although many Poles fought in the Battle of Britain too).
Canada, Australia and New Zealand etc… Also declared war on Nazi germany. Most of the victories of the allies came through the efforts of former British colonies.
Britain made an indispensable contribution to Allied victory in WW2
Yes they did. They were a great staging post. It wasn’t the Birtish army, navy or airforce that saved Britian during WW2. But the English channel
.
After the war the “empire struck back” during the Falklands War, which demonstrated to everyone that the UK was not a pushover, third-rate power but a force to be reckoned with. In the Falklands Britain stepped in to repulse the forces of the invading Argentinian army under the fascist junta,
A army even in worse shape than the birtish army at the time
I can only assume that you aren’t particularly fond of Britain (why I can’t say) although I concede that I may have misinterpreted you friend 😛 😃 If I did, “sorry” but please do explain to me what you mean.
I have nothing against Britian. Just like to speak the truth is all.
 
Kelvinf, this is good to hear. I’ve been a bit intrigued by the French Foreign Legion which partly led me to reading two books on them some years ago. I wonder if the FFL will be involved in this in any way?

The Brit’s and had colonies in Africa too. I think modern day Nigeria was one of them. Some how I don’t think Nigeria has a better armed and trained military force than the Brits.
Which is why i said most.
For the Brits population and geographic size they have a pretty remarkable military.
.
They do. Until they come up against any cilvilization that didn’t rely on spears as their main weapon.
 
They do. Until they come up against any cilvilization that didn’t rely on spears as their main weapon.
Could you name the units in the German, Turkish, Japanese, N. Korean, Egyptian, Argentine, and Iraqi that were armed with spears?
 
They do. Until they come up against any cilvilization that didn’t rely on spears as their main weapon.
Isn’t that generally the case for all superpowers including the United States? When the great powers create rules of war and we find ourselves in combat with those who don’t abide by them, no matter how rustic, then we also find ourselves unable to figure out how to play the game effectively. Its why we’ve been bogged down in the Middle East for 11 years.
 
French Commandos commit raid in Somalia which is quite a ways away from Mali where a Frenchman was held hostage.

bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-20996963
Reports from Somalia suggest French commandos have carried out an operation to free a hostage, in which a number of people died.
Witnesses in Bulo Marer said they had heard helicopters above the southern town before explosions and gunfire.
Al-Shabab militants are believed to be holding a Frenchman hostage there.
An al-Shabab spokesman told AFP news agency one French soldier had been killed and that the hostage had not been in the area.
 
France would not say whether or not they had ground troops involved in the recent fighting. If so, it would contradict previous statements of intent.
This ^!

BTW, I support an intervention in Mali! But let’s look at the bigger picture.

The invitation from Mali was received on Thurday:

Mali asked for military help from France after residents of the strategic northern town of Konna said Islamist rebels drove out the Malian army on Thursday, the fiercest fighting since militants took control of the country’s north nine months ago.

French U.N. Ambassador Gerard Araud confirmed receipt of a request from the Malian government for military assistance and said the “nature of the response to the letter will be announced in Paris tomorrow.”

U.S. Ambassador Susan Rice described the request for help from Mali, which was sent to the Security Council: “It wasn’t specific, but it basically said, ‘Help, France.’”

france24.com/en/20130111-mali-asks-france-military-help-islamists-seize-konna-militants

But by Friday, the French president confirmed the offensive by French troops in Mali:

French troops are backing the Malian army’s counter-offensive against Islamists who control the country’s north, President François Hollande confirmed on Friday.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-20995180

So we don’t know when the French troops got there. What is clear is that, on Friday the French President did not say he is sending troops as requested but confirmed that French troops were already on the ground. For me, it is more than clear that this mission was planned a long time ago.

Of course one could argue that France has a permanent military base in Senegal, a neighbour of Mali. Hence it is easy to move troops into Mali.


jeuneafrique.com/Article/JA2678p036-037.xml0/

But that can not explain such a rapid military response. Or is there a military operation that does not involve thorough planning? And it is only today that we saw images of (additional) French troops arriving in Mali.

According to the French Defence Minister, the 3rd objective of this mission is to protect French citizens. There are lots of French businesses and subsequently French citizens living in “former” French colonies in Africa.

Fact is, since independence from France, France has persistently and unilaterally been intervening military in Africa under the umbrella of an invitation (sometimes from tyrannical governments) or in the name of protecting French citizens or preventing a coup d’état or as part of some bilateral defence agreement (with dictators).

Chad, Central African Republic, Gabon and Ivory Coast are all examples of countries where the French military or French special forces have been active.

As the French Senat says:

Notre présence militaire en Afrique prend diverses formes qu’il faut appréhender globalement pour donner une juste idée de nos capacités d’intervention et d’appui à la stabilité du continent.

Il convient donc de distinguer :

Les forces prépositionnées;
Les forces de souveraineté;
Les forces engagées par un accord bilatéral;
La participation de forces françaises à des opérations internationales, en particulier de l’Union européenne.


senat.fr/rap/r10-324/r10-3244.html

Africans definitely wouldn’t see this a just some nice friend trying to ensure stability on the continent as the French Senat claims.
 
France has a relationship to Mali somewhat like Britain has with her former colonies that are now part of the Commonwealth.
I don’t think so. I believe France has way more influence and strategic interests in her colonies in Africa than Britain does.

What I have never understood is why they don’t use their influence to ensure democracy. French Presidents have continuously been having warm relationships with dictators in Africa. Hollande promised to act differently, but we are still waiting to see.
 
I don’t think so. I believe France has way more influence and strategic interests in her colonies in Africa than Britain does.

What I have never understood is why they don’t use their influence to ensure democracy. French Presidents have continuously been having warm relationships with dictators in Africa. Hollande promised to act differently, but we are still waiting to see.
Thank you for this Kelvin 👍 I had largely assumed that France, like most former colonial powers, would have adopted the British line of decolonization and independence for the countries, probably with just a few military bases left (much like the British have in Australia and the Rhineland in Germany) coupled with strong cultural and diplomatic links like the UK has through the Commonwealth.

I had not known that France maintained such a powerful presence in Africa and supported dictators. That certainly doesn’t sound healthy although I too support the Mali intervention.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top