Gender, sexuality and marriage

  • Thread starter Thread starter mayonnaise
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mayonnaise

Guest
Good morning brothers and sisters,

I am helping someone to collect information about people’s opinions on marriage, with specific reference to gay marriage. However, she has so far had very few respondents who have been anti gay marriage (only 7 of 407 I believe). As the Vatican has taken a stance against gay marriage, I figured that asking on this forum would help her to broaden the sample range.

Here is the survey.

Many thanks!
 
I’ve taken the survey.

The survey appears a neutrally designed one. It is good that you have posted the link here, although I hope that we do not “stuff the ballot box”. I hope your friend has good data from it.
 
I took the survey.

Who my neighbor marries is none of my business.
 
Good morning brothers and sisters,

I am helping someone to collect information about people’s opinions on marriage, with specific reference to gay marriage. However, she has so far had very few respondents who have been anti gay marriage (only 7 of 407 I believe). As the Vatican has taken a stance against gay marriage, I figured that asking on this forum would help her to broaden the sample range.

Here is the survey.

Many thanks!
And have you posted the same on a gay forum or did you just post this here on a Catholic forum to boost the anti-gay votes 🙂 🙂 🙂 oh dear, oh dear 🙂 🙂 🙂

What do you mean by ‘broaden the sample range’? The only thing I can see you doing is to tamper with the ‘sample range’ 😉
 
Good morning brothers and sisters,

I am helping someone to collect information about people’s opinions on marriage, with specific reference to gay marriage. However, she has so far had very few respondents who have been anti gay marriage (only 7 of 407 I believe). As the Vatican has taken a stance against gay marriage, I figured that asking on this forum would help her to broaden the sample range.

Here is the survey.

Many thanks!
Uhm, this isn’t much a of a survey when you solicit and target a specific audience that may likely hold similar views.

That’s like an Atheist creating a survey with the question;
  1. Do you believe in God
and then going to an Atheist conference to hand out the survey. :rolleyes:
 
Good morning brothers and sisters,

I am helping someone to collect information about people’s opinions on marriage, with specific reference to gay marriage. However, she has so far had very few respondents who have been anti gay marriage (only 7 of 407 I believe). As the Vatican has taken a stance against gay marriage, I figured that asking on this forum would help her to broaden the sample range.

Here is the survey.

Many thanks!
if she has to go looking for pro or anti forums to find her survey sample and to get some more anti results, her sampling techniques are faulty and she needs to refine them or the entire project is a waste of time.
 
if she has to go looking for pro or anti forums to find her survey sample and to get some more anti results, her sampling techniques are faulty and she needs to refine them or the entire project is a waste of time.
Not necessarity, as she does ask what religion you practice and your age and country. This data can be shown when she describes her method of research and in statitical analysis. I.E graph on age who agree disagree, graph on non-religious, etc

All studies have flaws, to ask only college aged students leaves out a huge block of people . She is doing her best to include all age groups and religions, there are numerious website forums for all religions and types of people. Heck, she may want to include ‘adult’ forums, they too affect our culture.

Happy Spring to All
 
And have you posted the same on a gay forum or did you just post this here on a Catholic forum to boost the anti-gay votes oh dear, oh dear
What do you mean by ‘broaden the sample range’? The only thing I can see you doing is to tamper with the ‘sample range’
Oh, no, I see I’ve not been very clear!

The survey is being posted on many many forums, but the forums they were first posted to were gay rights forums, so for the first few days the results were skewed in their favour.

The forums that it’s being posted to are mostly not specifically “pro” or “anti” gay marriage, for example forums about keeping snails as pets, forums about horticulture, and forums about crafts.

And the point of the survey is not specifically on the amount of people “for” or “against” gay marriage, more about the reasoning behind people’s decisions- what makes someone decide to take a stance against gay marriage? what makes someone decide to support gay marriage (especially if they themselves are not gay)? Are people making decisions based on their own morals and opinions, or simply copying the decisions of the people around them, without much thought as to the ethics behind their decision?

There is a list of forums, ranging from ones where she expects the majority to be pro gay marriage, to ones where she expects there the majority to be anti gay marriage. She began working through the list, but the first ones to come up were ones that she expected to be “pro” gay marriage. As she was beginning to worry that if for some reason she was unable to conclude the distribution of the survey, she would have nearly no information on the reasoning behind individuals’ decisions to be anti- gay marriage, I volunteered to help her through the list, starting with forums where she expected there to be more people who were anti gay marriage.

Oh, and I want to add that she doesn’t think that Catholics hate gay people (she’s met me 🙂 🙂 🙂 )! We are just one in a list of religious groups whose official stance is that gay marriage should be forbidden. The religious forums I have visited thus far have been quite positive, with people who are prepared to think about WHY they are pro- or anti- gay marriage, and accepting of the fact that I am Catholic. The bad ones have been where I have had to visit forums where there is blind hatred (of women, of different races, of homosexual people :(:(:(), where people do not even want to fill in the survey, because they do not want to have to justify themselves 😦

Clearly, I am not very good at communicating any of this! I wonder now if asking an arts student was the best idea 🙂 I am not very good at conveying my meaning!

I hope that this very long post made sense! And many thanks to those of you who have filled in the survey!
 
Hi mayonnaise

OK, this is now begining to make sense

However, is there an option on the poll which says, “I don’t care one way or the other since it neither affects me nor am I bothered about it”
 
As others have pointed out, this will not be a statistically valid survey. Its results, whatever they are, will be indefensible.

I completed it anyway with the same answers most of us here will.
 
I’ve looked at your friends survey.

What exactly does she hope to accurately glean from this though, when you are posting it on a religious site such as this one? Surely the figures will now be an inaccurate and unfair reflection on the general public and will subsequently jump from anti gay marriage (only 7 of 407 I believe it was) to something quite in the other sides favour?

I fear you are doing your friend, and fellow gay men and women, quite the injustice…

I personally feel that gay men and women deserve the civil right to gay marriage. They should be treated as equals and be allowed to marry the one they love.
 
*Although I read through the survey and wish to take part, in the end I failed to answer your friends questions as the results captured will in essence be fallacious.

I would advise your friend to either discount the results captured from this site, or to keep in mind the pre-influenced view point that you may have received during this period.

I wish you all the best.x
 
As others have pointed out, this will not be a statistically valid survey. Its results, whatever they are, will be indefensible.

I completed it anyway with the same answers most of us here will.
No social statistic is true anyways, even though the media and others tend to think they are accurate. The only way to make them accurate is to show a signal in multiple studies and events.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top