German Church Revenue Reached a Record $7.1 Billion Last Year

  • Thread starter Thread starter TigerLily-1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TigerLily-1

Guest
By Edward Pentin

An investigation by the German Handelsblatt newspaper has revealed the German Catholic Church collected a record €6 billion ($7.1 billion) last year, and that the country’s 27 dioceses are sitting on a fortune of at least €26 billion ($31.2 billion).

Although Church attendance is rapidly falling in the country — 2.2 million have de-registered since 2000 — the newspaper says revenues have been boosted by a “robust domestic economy.”

The report says the Church’s billions are tied up in fixed assets ($24 billion) and financial investments ($18.1 billion). The former are mostly made up of “equities or real estate, particularly in western Germany, donated by former nobility,” according to Handelsblatt.

The newspaper also says the German Church offers “a generous fund for pensions, reserved for higher-ranking ecclesiastical dignitaries, to the tune of €5 billion ($6 billion), but that number could also be higher as several of the bishoprics’ business reports didn’t provide exact information.”

Much of the Church’s wealth derives from the nation’s Church tax. Every baptized German working adult (roughly one third of the country’s Catholics) has to pay a levy of 8 to 9 percent, depending on the state, an arrangement dating back to the 1919 Weimar Constitution, which was transferred verbatim into the current constitution after World War II.

German citizens who formally wish to stop paying the tax cannot receive Holy Communion or other religious services, according to the German Bishops’ Conference. The Church has even been known to look into expats’ home records to determine if they’ve been honest on tax declarations about being baptized or not, Handelsblatt reports.

The Church also benefits from state subsidies, and both the Catholic and Protestant churches receive exclusive tax breaks not bestowed upon other religious groups in Germany.


Also from the above article:

“In 2016, an academic study showed that 54% of German priests go to confession only “once a year or less” (among pastoral assistants, the figure is as high as 91%).”

Link to 2016 news article describing the study: https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/...-fewer-churchgoers-parishes-and-priests-63755

Has anyone read this article? What do you think?

What is going on in Germany is very upsetting and discouraging. If a German citizen doesn’t pay the tax, s/he can’t receive Communion or any other religious service. Here I am, a struggling Catholic with lots of questions about the Church and it’s teachings and here we have Catholic priests that don’t even go to confession!

I pray there’s something Pope Francis can do here. This is a scandal!

Lord, have mercy!
 
Sending this link to a CAF member in Germany for comment. Thanks!
 
Thanks Clare for sending this to me. It’s shocking what wrong stories about the German Church-Tax are brought up and circulate mainly among church-haters. Many read it and pass it on, without informing themselfes first about the full truth.

These articles resp. answers are suitable to create a totally wrong picture.
Yes, the Catholic as well as the Protestant Church of Austria and of Germany is “rich” compared to same Churches in other countries.
But then here a vast percentage of all Kindergarten, schools, hospitals, old-age homes, care-homes, hospices, orphanages and more social fascilities are completely carried and led and financed by the catholic or the Protestant Church, or both together. Of course the figure is in Germany much hiher than in Austria, as Germany is a lot bigger than Austria. Germany’s got 82 Million inhabitants, Austria roughly one tenth of this.

The mentioned 8-9% of the fee, is not of the Income, but of the income-tax, which makes the payment real small!

As to "People who don’t pay get excommunicated - that’s ever so wrong, because all who are member of the Church, do pay, and most of them gladly do!
One can exclude himself of paying only by leaving the Church.
He who leaves the Church, is excommunicatim himself!
Hence the Church does not excommunicate if one doesn’t pay, but this person left the Church and such excommunicated him- or herself out of their own will! Not vice-versa as here as horror-story is read!

As the very many welfare-expenses both Churches have to carry often exceed their ability, lately quite a few hospitals and other social institutions have been taken over by the state. Then the people and the state’s got to pay a lot more. For in state-managed houses and fascilities as mentioned, there are no Catholic Nurses or Protestant Deaconesses who work for nothing. Such the Church-Tax is a blessing for all.

I spend a lot of time today in the local catholic Vincentius-Clinic.

I dare say: These Christian clinics are way better than any other clinic!
Besides cou get a warm home-feeling, when you see crosses in every room.
These day’s I received together with an old lady there, the “Last Rites” including the Eucharist. Such “thing” is self-evident in a Catholic hospitals. I asked a nurse *please call for a priest". No nurse there would look surprised and ask back. They simply do it, for this there is no surprising request, but a fully normal one.

Oh - got to continue hereafter - my answer was a wee bit too long 😃
 
This is the being at home feeling I mentioned, in Christian public houses or fascilities. Oh, how I love paying Church-Tax!

Now this clinc eventually became unable to exist by itself. So they fused or merged with the Karlsruhe Protestand Diaconic-Clinic. For a year now, both clinics of the rather silly name put pogether of Vincentius-Clinik and Diaconal-Clinic VIDIA-Clinic. Ah well…
But please do correct your picture about German/Austrian Church-Tax.

Tomorrow I got an appointment in the city-owned municipal clinic (- 5 minutes to walk from my house) for a radiologic stress Myocardszintygram= heart-exam . No cross anywhere! All much more business-like. No thanks!

Yours
Bruno
Karlsruhe/Germany 🙂
excuse my spelling mistakes: I’m a German Kraut ;-D (or Fritz if you like). In England also Jerry 😉
CU
 
Thanks Bruno! I knew you would have more specific info to clarify this!
May God bless you and bring you many more years of health. God is good!
Clare
 
I am aware that in order to not pay church tax, some German Catholics are willing to stand up and say “I am not a member of the Catholic Church.” It is recorded, sent to the parish where they were baptized and it is entered in their baptismal record.

Think of it, we have martyrs who went to their death unwilling to deny their faith and now we have folks excommunicating themselves by denying they are Catholic in an effort to avoid paying a small amount of money for the upkeep of their Church and its services. Yet in the face of that they feel they should not be denied the sacraments. I don’t understand the mindset that would allow you to proclaim to one and all that you are not Catholic and then say to the Catholic Church, “But you know I don’t mean it so give me Communion and allow me to be married and buried from within your walls.”
 
Thank you @BrunoMaria for your reply !

The National Catholic Register is a reputable and usually reliable Catholic news site and this article isn’t up to their standards. I go to the Register a few times a week and read the latest articles without looking for anything in particular. When I read this article, I was shocked. I vaguely knew that Germany had a Church tax (which as a U.S. citizen I don’t understand 😁) but this article led me to believe the tax was 8% of income separate from the actual income tax. And that the Church is “sitting on” billions of dollars while hospitals and other things are underfunded and suffer. So thank you for clearing that up!

Praying that your test goes well and the results are good!

God Bless you!
 
When I read this article, I was shocked. I vaguely knew that Germany had a Church tax (which as a U.S. citizen I don’t understand)
“Fake news” that where and terribly badly investigated. They shocked me all the same, as they are plain wrong. They should have asked any German Pupil - he had told them 😦

But originally the “Curch Tax” which never was reduced from wages, but 8-9% of the income tax (whilst little incomes rightly neither pay income-tax nor Church tax) was brought up by the diverse German and Austrian governments, after Napoleon. He had dispossessed all Churches and Monasteries of their properties and estates. Napoleon even made Churches into stables for his army’s horses and monasteries to brothels. Such the Churches, Monasteries, Clergy had no income. The secularization was to extinguish Church and belief altogether - make the Church a laugh to anybody.
But the gates of hell will NEVER overcome the Church Jesus founded on St. Peter.

When Napoleon acquired the huge part of Germany left of the River Rhine, the German Kings and Dukes got as a little „reward“ all properties of the Church. The church was even poorer then a single church-mouse in 1803, as the corrupt dukes and kings where quite happy. When Napoleon was defeated (mainly by Field-Marshal Blücher’s ingenious war-fare), the states, kingdoms, countships, princedoms of Germany, agreed to maintaining the Clergy as well as historic Church buildinge Cathedrals etc. Germany was at the time before Bismarck united Germany in 1871 by inaugurating Kaiser Wilhelm I (closely related to British royalty), a rag-rug of little states. The agreement of the late 19th century, after protests and rumors of the people, to maintain Church and cleric, soon became too expensive to aristocracy, so they agreed AGAINST THE WILL OF THE CHURCH on a Church Tax. So, Church-Members of both Churches (Catholic as Protestant) pay 8-9% of their income-tax. The state organized this and get’s from the Church a financial fee for managing and collecting the Church-Tax. In the late 19th century church-tax became law for all members of the Church. In other states such as Great Britain, where the Church was never dispossessed, the Church lives well of their real estates which yield them even better than Church-Tax. Here and in Austria 80% of the Church-expenses, such as maintaining great buildings and Cathedrals are covered by the Church Tax, as well as the main-expense - the wages for schools, Kindergarten, old age homes and many other public facilities as well as great Cathedrals whih are intangible cultural heritage to the whole world.
As said before, it’s voluntary to pay church-tax or not - depending if one is member of the Church or not. But those who leave the Church ’cos of the Church-tax, never where real believers. It’s a real little amount what an individual has to pay. He who refuses even these few dimes, is a poor thing. Poor in understanding. Even the Disciples of Christ had to pay Temple-Tax, and so did Jesus’ family.

I got to be going for todays medical checks of my rotten heart, to see if I’m still alive.

Yours
Bruno
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top