Global warming slowdown could last another decade

  • Thread starter Thread starter FollowChrist34
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Please provide evidence that global warming is false science. Most scientists agree that global warming is happening.
Please provide evidence that global warming is real science. I just cannot take their models and predictions seriously, especially with the confidence they have about both.

At one time, most scientists agreed that the Sun revolved around the Earth.

Scientific consensus does not automatically make something true.
 
Please provide evidence that global warming is real science. I just cannot take their models and predictions seriously, especially with the confidence they have about both.

At one time, most scientists agreed that the Sun revolved around the Earth.

Scientific consensus does not automatically make something true.
What is it about radiative transfer theory that you do not agree with? The physics is not a model result.
 
What is it about radiative transfer theory that you do not agree with? The physics is not a model result.
I didn’t say I disagreed with the physics. I said I can’t take their model and predictions seriously, especially predictions years down the road.
 
Please provide evidence that global warming is real science. I just cannot take their models and predictions seriously, especially with the confidence they have about both.

At one time, most scientists agreed that the Sun revolved around the Earth.

Scientific consensus does not automatically make something true.
Here is some evidence.
environment.nationalgeographic.com/environment/global-warming/gw-real/

skeptic.com/reading_room/how-we-know-global-warming-is-real/

amazon.com/An-Inconvenient-Truth-Al-Gore/dp/B000ICL3KG :D:D:D

No, but when you have a huge majority climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus/
like 97% it probably means that they are right. In my opinion better safe than sorry. I would be sad if we didn’t at least try to reduce carbon dioxide and green house gases.
 
To think they can make accurate predictions with a model that is trying to model a system as chaotic as the climate is the height of hubris.
But we have- response to volcanoes, freshwater hosing, orbital, etc. The statistics don’t appear chaotic…
 
Here is some evidence.
environment.nationalgeographic.com/environment/global-warming/gw-real/

skeptic.com/reading_room/how-we-know-global-warming-is-real/

amazon.com/An-Inconvenient-Truth-Al-Gore/dp/B000ICL3KG :D:D:D

No, but when you have a huge majority climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus/
like 97% it probably means that they are right. In my opinion better safe than sorry. I would be sad if we didn’t at least try to reduce carbon dioxide and green house gases.
Really? You cite Al Gore as a reputable source?

Again, scientific consensus does not make something automatically true, whether it is 60% or 97%.
 
But we have- response to volcanoes, freshwater hosing, orbital, etc. The statistics don’t appear chaotic…
Climate is a chaotic system, just like weather is a chaotic system. Even the IPCC admits that climate is a chaotic system.
 
Really? You cite Al Gore as a reputable source?

Again, scientific consensus does not make something automatically true, whether it is 60% or 97%.
Sarcasm mate, The three grinning figures next to it should’ve meant I was joking about that one.

I know it is unscientific to say consensus means it’s true. However it shows that the scientific community agrees that global warming is true. Is global warming perfectly true no it isn’t, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t real. Like I said before it’s probably better to reduce carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases than not do anything.
 
However it shows that the scientific community agrees that global warming is true/
Like I said before, at one time, the scientific community though the Sun revolved around the Earth.
Like I said before it’s probably better to reduce carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases than not do anything.
Why? If global warming is not real or if reducing carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases has no effect on it (some scientists say that there is nothing we can do to stop it), then why should we do that?

You are asking people to change their lifestyles. People don’t like doing that. Which is why so many people are hesitant to do anything about global warming.
 
Climate is a chaotic system, just like weather is a chaotic system. Even the IPCC admits that climate is a chaotic system.
I’m skeptical, but that’s not an interesting assertion. The question is whether the sensitivity in trends of decadal statistics to the initial conditions swamps the sensitivity of that metric to the applied forcing of interest in the model. The same type of models from which chaos theory arose indicate that the climate problem is entirely different than the initial condition problem you seem concerned with.
 
I’m skeptical, but that’s not an interesting assertion. The question is whether the sensitivity in trends of decadal statistics to the initial conditions swamps the sensitivity of that metric to the applied forcing of interest in the model. The same type of models from which chaos theory arose indicate that the climate problem is entirely different than the initial condition problem you seem concerned with.
The fact that it is a chaotic system means it is hard to predict, plain and simple. Especially years down the road and especially with the confidence they attach to their models and predictions.

We can’t predict weather more than a few weeks but these people think they can predict climate years down the road? Please.
 
The fact that it is a chaotic system means it is hard to predict, plain and simple. Especially years down the road and especially with the confidence they attach to their models and predictions.

We can’t predict weather more than a few weeks but these people think they can predict climate years down the road? Please.
You don’t seem to know what chaos means. It certainly doesn’t mean the system is completely unpredictable, and the length of time is not really relevant in this context. Start here.
 
You don’t seem to know what chaos means. It certainly doesn’t mean the system is completely unpredictable, and the length of time is not really relevant in this context. Start here.
Don’t presume to know what I do and do not know. I know what chaos is and I have extensive experience with modeling. I model things everyday.
 
Like I said before, at one time, the scientific community though the Sun revolved around the Earth.

Why? If global warming is not real or if reducing carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases has no effect on it (some scientists say that there is nothing we can do to stop it), then why should we do that?

You are asking people to change their lifestyles. People don’t like doing that. Which is why so many people are hesitant to do anything about global warming.
Even if it isn’t real it’s better to not keep polluting the ozone layer.

I’m not saying for everybody to drive smart cars and Toyota Prius’s. But such things like investing in solar power and wind propulsion power can help. Of course it depends on where you live too.
 
I’m not saying for everybody to drive smart cars and Toyota Prius’s. But such things like investing in solar power and wind propulsion power can help. Of course it depends on where you live too.
Investing requires money, money people aren’t too quick to part with. Especially in this economy. Solar power and wind propulsion will replace fossil fuels only when it becomes economically viable to do so, not before. Until then, alternative energy will have to be propped up by government. It is kinda hard to convince people to pay higher taxes for research into alternative energy when we have other short-term things we need to deal with like poverty and healthcare.
 
Don’t presume to know what I do and do not know. I know what chaos is and I have extensive experience with modeling. I model things everyday.
Not an assumption, your comments about climate vs. weather show this. I’m not trying to be mean, but boundary value problems and initial value problems are separate beasts. The linked article makes this clear. What you need to show is that climate statistics over, say, 30 yrs or longer are so sensitive to initial conditions as to swamp the forced component introduced by CO2 or some other perturbation. This is simply not how the real world or complex models behave, at least for most metrics of interest.

Summer is always warmer than winter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top