Global warming slowdown could last another decade

  • Thread starter Thread starter FollowChrist34
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote:
You have to understand first off, a 1000 years for a mortal man is like a blink of God’s (or a geologist’s) eye. And that is why climate scientists are quite alarmed at this current warming…bec it is exceedingly rapid, magnitudes of order more rapid than in the past warmings when large chunks of life died out. Actually there is no analog from the past for this. However, they do know that extremely slow warmings, such as during the Eocene optimum over many millions of years, not much harm was done. However, during the PETM and end-Permian over 10,000s to 200,000 of years a tremendous loss of species and life occurred. Now we’re doing the same but over several 100s of years – by extracting fossil fuels and burning them lickity-split (in geological timeframe terms).

More fear mongering on your part.
Sorry but those are the facts re paleoclimatology. There have been some great extinctions in earth’s history, some caused by great warming episodes (climate hysteresis). Please do consult a geologist, if you have doubts about that.

I’m also not making it up that we could be pushing the climate system into such a climate hysteresis that could trigger natural carbon releases and lead to 6C warming or more, and last for 100,000 to 200,000 years. I’m not making it us. They used to say if we reach 450 ppm on CO2 that would lead to the tipping point into much greater warming – by melting permafrost and ocean hydrates (and remember the oceans are warming faster at deeper levels than heretofore thought) and releasing carbon (mainly CH4 which degrades in about 10 yrs to CO2).

Now they are saying that 350 ppm could lead to this tipping point. I know, we are now at about 399 ppm now (see co2now.org/current-co2/co2-now/ ). However, since there is a good lag time, and the earth system also draws down CO2 naturally, there is still time to reduce our GHG emissions and allow plant-life to drawn down CO2 to a safe level (at least I think and hope there is).

It is the laggards that are causing alarm and raising real fears by tempting fate on this, not people like myself who are suggesting prudence by doing what is feasible and sensible to reduce our emissions.
Climate scientists are ascribing more and more of the warming to natural variation. Also, we really don’t know it is unprecedented, that’s speculation based on projections from very limited data.
Where did you hear that? I’m hearing just the opposite…unless some scientists are saying that the initial warming we humans have been causing is now releasing massive amounts of carbon and we’re already at or past the tipping point. However, the real experts on this are not making such a claim…at this point.
I’m 100% behind increased inefficiencies, I even drive a Prius.
I would stop wasting the millions of tax dollars on solar panel installation and put it to universities for real R&D on energy solutions. Did you know we’ve had molten salt nuclear plants in development for 60 years? It’s significantly safer than any nuclear plant in production.
Great to hear you are into mitigation – if not AGW then the concomitant problems from burning fossil fuels, etc.

RE solar, I saw a program where a 12 year old girl heart-broken over the birds affected by the BP oil spill, in talking about the need for alt energy, said, “Have you ever heard of a solar panel spill?” I think solar is great and it is just about cost-competitive with fossil fuels now. The price has taken a nose drive in the past 5 years. It’s actually crazy for people with south sloping roofs (ours is S by SE) not to install solar panels – they are missing a great savings.

But you are also right – we need many other solutions as well.
 
Communists show up at all sorts of protest marches for various movements. This is opportunism of their part. They certainly aren’t “the movement”, nor do they speak for the whole movement, which has adherents from all political persuasions.
However, in order to combat global warming you almost have to have a Socialistic or Communistic economic system because it stopping global warming requires the subjection of private property to the state or the community, in the name of the common good.
 
I already have … with real climate scientist, not amateur armchair “scientists.”
You’re making the assumption that “real” climate scientists understand statistics. From what I have seen, they obviously do not.

If you want to find someone who properly understands statistics, data analysis, and measuring the effects of variables on other variables, then talk to an economist.
 
However, in order to combat global warming you almost have to have a Socialistic or Communistic economic system because it stopping global warming requires the subjection of private property to the state or the community, in the name of the common good.
The catechism speaks quite a lot about the “common good”. It is not the same thing as communism. So talking about the common good in general is not necessarily a bad thing. And there is no reason why any remediation measures have to subjugate private property.
 
Communists show up at all sorts of protest marches for various movements. This is opportunism of their part. They certainly aren’t “the movement”, nor do they speak for the whole movement, which has adherents from all political persuasions.
It’s a great big left wing agenda. The advantage I have in knowing that is that my grandfather was a communist. A hater of the Catholic Church despised capitalism and supported the hidden agenda of the green movement . And of course we see right around the world people from the left side of politics supporting the green agenda e.g. Al Gore. These days it’s just what left wing political parties do and now as we have seen with our own eyes and heard from these red ragging communists they can’t help themselves the truth has a way of surfacing , and it will. Try as you might be assured that the truth will always be there for everyone to see. That’s the nature of truth any GOOD Catholic knows that.
 
Communists show up at all sorts of protest marches for various movements. This is opportunism of their part. They certainly aren’t “the movement”, nor do they speak for the whole movement, which has adherents from all political persuasions.
It is interesting that during the anti-racism or Black Pride movement, they were also accused of being communists.

The point is there are many types of environmentalism, just as there are many types of feminism and minority movements.

There is:
  • Mainstream Environmentalism (probably 90% of environmentalists) – concerned about a healthy environment for the children – clean air, water, non-toxic foods and products, etc.
  • Free Market Environmentalism – the free markets would solve environmental problems; the triple bottom line - profits, people, & planet
  • Deep Ecology - holistic, ecological view of humans and the environment, ecocentric, spiritual aspects of environmentalism
  • Steady State Economics - societies must shift away from endless growth & consumption, toward environmental sustainability
  • Environmental Justice - minorities, poor, and women bear a disproportionate burden of environmental harms, while they benefit least from the system
  • Anarchists - against big gov and big corps, into forming ecological, sustainable communities that are much more democratic and participatory than current situation, getting off the grid, etc (sort of like the Tea-Partiers)
  • Eco-Feminism - blame the men for environmental problems & think women know better 🙂
  • Marxism - blame capitalism for environmental problems and think a more equal distribution of goods & services will solve the problems.
There are more strands, as well…
 
CO2 is less than 0.004% of the Atmosphere

It is so low because plant life strains CO2 from the atmosphere.

If this was not true, life couldn’t exist here.

These so called scientist are paid to study global warming and only post there negative findings. This is not science!

Scientists who have already dis proven this theory are called everything for Evil Capitalists to Racists.

If the climate is warming or cooling it is in the hands of God or its just solar cycles.

If we did stop burning fossil fuels, these corrupt politicians would be taxing us so they can cap Volcanoes. This push for Energy Taxes is no different than the push for Red light Cameras. REVENUE.

Global Warming: Humbug I say.
 
Global Warming: Humbug I say.
as is every communist agenda. They have to keep lying and getting more ridiculous to keep the hype going. As we know with lying, the more you speak it the deeper in the mire you get. The communists are going to have to find a new strategy to push their agenda because they are starting to lose the gay marriage debate as well. I wonder what they will come up with next.
 
The catechism speaks quite a lot about the “common good”. It is not the same thing as communism. So talking about the common good in general is not necessarily a bad thing.
Some of the most heinous atrocities in history where committed in the name of the “common good”. It’s an “end justifies the means” philosophy and I’m pretty sure the Church does not support that kind of thinking.
And there is no reason why any remediation measures have to subjugate private property.
But they invariably do require subjugation of private property.
 
The catechism speaks quite a lot about the “common good”. It is not the same thing as communism. So talking about the common good in general is not necessarily a bad thing. And there is no reason why any remediation measures have to subjugate private property.
It is mentioned 67 times and never in the context being used here.In fact here is how the Church defines"common good"

1925 The common good consists of three essential elements: respect for and promotion of the fundamental rights of the person; prosperity, or the development of the spiritual and temporal goods of society; the peace and security of the group and of its members.
 
It is mentioned 67 times and never in the context being used here.In fact here is how the Church defines"common good"

1925 The common good consists of three essential elements: respect for and promotion of the fundamental rights of the person; prosperity, or the development of the spiritual and temporal goods of society; the peace and security of the group and of its members.
It certainly seems to me that having an environment in which people can live is both a temporal good of society and a factor in the peace and security of the group and it’s members.
 
Some of the most heinous atrocities in history where committed in the name of the “common good”…
Some of the most heinous atrocities in history (like 9/11) where committed in the name of “religion”. Does that mean we must denigrate all religion? But that is what you are suggesting - to denigrate a belief because it claims to be directed toward the common good.
 
It certainly seems to me that having an environment in which people can live is both a temporal good of society and a factor in the peace and security of the group and it’s members.
Wasting resources too mitigate a myth Is for the good of only the mythmakers
 
Wasting resources too mitigate a myth Is for the good of only the mythmakers
So, this question boils down to the only real question - whether or not AGW is a myth. Talking about common good efforts all being communistic is just an empty distraction - which all I was trying establish at this time.
 
Some of the most heinous atrocities in history (like 9/11) where committed in the name of “religion”. Does that mean we must denigrate all religion? But that is what you are suggesting - to denigrate a belief because it claims to be directed toward the common good.
I wasn’t suggesting anything. I was merely pointing out that the Church does not support “means justifying the end” thinking.
 
So, this question boils down to the only real question - whether or not AGW is a myth. Talking about common good efforts all being communistic is just an empty distraction - which all I was trying establish at this time.
Whether AGW is a myth or not isn’t the important part. What is important is if we can do anything to stop it and if it is worth imposing harsh economic burdens in the hopes that we might be able to mitigate the damage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top