Ridgerunner, I wouldn’t condemn you in any way for what you do. Quite frankly there are indeed times to pick up the sword and times that the debate must be engaged. I think Joysong and I both fully recognize this. I think we’re addressing more those who seem to delight in humiliating others.
To me at least, what counts is one’s intent when doing so and the manner in which it is done. One truly intending the good of the one being engaged will usually engage them in a manner that will address the issue without condemning the person, or even seeming to condemn the person.
It is not the debate that is the gnashing of teeth. It is the joy with which so many engage the debate for the person of “winning” and bringing the other side into submission rather than truly lifting them up. There are indeed times when “tough love” is called for, but one has to know that they are called to it AND that they have the credibility with the person being addressed that they will be able to receive it. In some ways it becomes like the requirements for “just war”. There must be a reasonable expectation of success and a minimizing of collateral damage.
Of course all of us have our failures in this. We all have our times when the frustrations lead us to sarcasm and less than fruitful tactics. That is one of the tests I use myself for knowing when my ego has taken over and I need to withdraw, though even then I sometimes overstay my welcome and just can’t turn loose of things, like a dog with the smell of raw meat.
It can be overcome though also, Ridgerunner. I was a very argumentative person for years and the “armchair lawyer” in me loved to debate just for the thrill of making myself look smart and someone else crumble before me. It took some good humiliations of my own to even consider the harm I was doing to others.
The one other test I will often use is to re-read something I’ve written and ask how I would feel if someone said it to my wife or one of my children. It’s amazing how quickly one will alter the tone of something in that context.
Peace be with you!