I agree with you about disqualifying the whole team,

YES! THAT was way overkill - unless he was dialing back his temptation to disqualify the whole school’s sports program for a few years …
though I am not sure what the rules are if a team member is disqualified for any reason, is the team allowed to sub someone else, since they aren’t the ones that qualified, I don’t know. - I don’t know that either, but the decision MADE is a much worse (unjust, destructive) option than this one you propose. Should the second place team now go “since they aren’t the ones that qualified”. I say no. Three actual qualifiers and an alternative runner would still be the Columbus High Relay Team that did qualify. The infraction, by all accounts came after the race.
As for the celebration, I think it is a dumb rule that no celebration is allowed, I do too. But WELL administered, (
instead of THIS!) the rule is not so bad.
**In your face taunting **ought to be equivalent to an “unsportsmanlike conduct” flag on the football field - which results in yardage penalties -
not a forfeit of the game, season and playoffs. ZERO tolerance laws should not be administered by people with a
similar level of sensible discrimination. And if they are WRONG or OVER THE TOP in the first place, there ought to be a way to correct the blunders in the second place.
but if you know the rules, you could know this rule and never imagine you are breaking it by “a gesture” not intended to provoke anyone – at the point of an emotional victory at the end of an exhaustive race. (I ran track. If you do it right - you are barely a person for a couple of minutes after the race - you are a “recovering from trauma” person till your breath comes back …
… An angry person appearing in front of a person at that moment, blathering about some rule you didn’t think you broke at all – would seem to you (from my experience) like the wah wah wah of the adults who invaded kid world in the Charlie Brown comic).
I guess at the point of the “post-race warning” this official STILL hadn’t decided to disqualify (or HADN’T actually disqualified) the team yet. So … it was whatever “disrespect” he got THEN that tipped the scales? Or was that additional post-race “warning” insincere? The infraction not serious enough to write up quietly – without a personal confrontation with the minor when he was vulnerable? And THEN SO serious it extends the blame to the innocent? !
Rules Only as GOOD as its Interpreters, Enforcers: In THIS case … :nope:
and especially if you are warned about the rules, then you really have no excuse for breaking them. With an interpreter like this - how many ways might a rule be broken? He broke the tape wrong. He slowed down in a provocative manner. He kept running past the tape too long (a little victory lap?).
If you are participating in something, you are agreeing to participate under the set rules, however, idiotic they may be. I’m conservative myself. Anarchy is a vice. Yet, like you, I agree that some rules can be idiotic.
When these are idiotic - change the idiotic part with all possible dispatch! There is still time. “Ratifying the idiotic” is a kind of litmus test for
“these people should not be running our schools. They can’t get the simplest concept right”. Their POWER is their priority - and challenging even the most idiotic demonstration of that power seems to be their idea of a mortal sin.
The “CURE” Is Worse Than The “Disease” - Mad Doctor Administrating IMO
If there was a crime here, the punishment was worse. The league investigation was a farce and an insult to fair minded peoples’ intelligence. It never considered justice to the students. It appears to be a placebo to those who complained - “look we’re investigating this! Ongoing! Be satisfied.” Meanwhile the state meet is coming up. The athletes remain disqualified (WHEN THEY QUALIFIED!) and all the league does is to reverse itself in meaningless ways (what they say was done, and when, is now different than at first) but the incident is not being examined with the possibility of a different penalty. NO! The rules are being examined! NOT the nameless judge who has caused needless trouble in their name. HIS feelings (and maybe his hidden agenda?) matter more than ***“disqualifying the whole team”? If he’s wrong in THAT (and the LEAGUE doesn’t say THAT - just you and I!) I think he was likely wrong in USING a (possibly good) rule to a bad end.
May his next mistake at work be seized upon with ZERO tolerance and blown all out of proportion - with crazy sanctions and a dash of egregious injustice to his co-workers thrown in!*** <
just kidding, but that felt good to SAY