CaptFun responds in RED
I can agree that this policy seems to go a bit too far, ALLIES!

Even if “a bit” to you is “a lot” to me …
but - uh oh … bracing myself for the qualifier …
again, - and the reemphasis (tension building, cue music …)
“christians” are not being singled out here.

Well … let’s HOPE not. I suspect that may be a guess on your part though (barring some inside knowledge of the ruling “judge”).
CaptFun NOW responds below … in black for ease of reading.
I note that you (to your credit) used the PLURAL for Christians above, ringil.
For clarity I must say - THAT is part of my problem with the BIT too far. ONE athlete
“does something” (small in my opinion) and PLURAL people get punished for it!
As it happened to BE a Christian person who “offended” (at least this one-person sports dictator with unreversible punitive powers!) - maybe the “Christianness” of the gesture (CALLED a “God gesture” for some reason)*** was*** the aspect that took the thing from:
– an infraction of a
rule (that seems to me at least - to be aimed at a kind of “in your face” taunting). To …
– an
inexcusable “death penalty for the WHOLE TEAM” level social crime that must be dealt with in such a way as to insure it never EVER happens again!
When I run my “could this ruling possibly be right in any circumstance?” fairness test - the best I can come up with is the (not very likely scenario) that:
This kid IS a “radical Christian” and DID give this gesture - not merely as some exterior voicing of the Freedom of Religion and expression we all have under the consitiution and most state laws – but as a provocative scofflaw and a triumphalist “Christian”
troublemaker. A “right wing” equivalent of:
THIS moment from the 1968 Olympics.
guardian.co.uk/world/2012/mar/30/black-power-salute-1968-olympics
In the above example Tommie Smith (center) and John Carlos (right) turned their eyes away from the American Flag as it was being raised in victory at the 1968 Mexico Olympics to honor their medal winning performances.
Additionally, showing a bit of pre-meditation some time after having performed - and not in the moment of victory as with the Texas boy here - Smith and Carlos donned black gloves and gave a “black power” salute.
**Similarities with the Texas case: A race. A gesture. Controversy. **
Some cheered them for this and praised their courage. Others thought it ruined the moment and was politically provocative at a time when race riots were plaguing many cities in the US (it was the year Martin Luther King was shot, and Bobby Kennedy, and the Democratic Convention riots, and the Communist North Vietnamese “Tet offensive” invasion of South Vietnam – for a bit of context).
http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcThLhOaIWOXEZkLW5LF2BCwQWIEjQ-kxReEHg94RkScGpfpDSy2Fw
The clenched fist symbol (and hence the gesture ?) was a bit close to one of the enemy’s familiar symbols. The Vietnam war … which though not a “war” technically or against the USSR technically but its ally … was quite “hot” at the time. Additionally the symbol of the clenched fist was one favored by the Communist Trotskyites (and Trotsky having been assassinated IN Mexico added another layer of mystery as to what the two athletes precisely or vaguely were saluting and/or shunning on the Olympic platform).
The penalties to Smith and Carlos? None. Save public opinion in some quarters.
And given their seeming anti-American sentiment at the time --*** perhaps*** the two would have welcomed JUST this punishment (per this thread) on THEIR team … the disqualification of the WHOLE US Olympic team and all its athletes’ possible glories, medals etc.
– I don’t KNOW that of course - but today’s judge with yesterday’s radicals would have made for a fine bit of political sabotage! Maybe I should pursue fiction writing?
The distinctions between deliberate and accidental should be taken into consideration --even if one decides for the rule over the people (not Jesus’ preference if one examines his counsels to the Pharisees and Sadducees).
Speaking of Jesus, he might call such an action as this “straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel.”
Me? I see the present case as swatting a fly on a window with a hammer. Then perhaps justifying the big unnecessary glass-shattering mess with some “intellectual” dissertation on the “health hazard flies present” - then passing out more, BIGGER hammers to save “the future of the planet”!
http://static.happyplace.com/assets/images/2012/03/4f689ed7f327e.jpeg
:blushing: Entertaining fiction ought to climax with a great crescendo to us exhibitionists.
Anyway thanks ringil for you take and scrutiny of the issue.