God gesture disqualifies team

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joko2599
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The article says that “putting your arms up in the air” is against the rules so pointing at the sky is pretty similar.

There’s no persecution going on here.
I agree, but how did either of those come to be designated “the God gesture”? To me pointing a finger at the sky = “we’re #1”.
 
CaptFun responds in RED
I can agree that this policy seems to go a bit too far, ALLIES! 👍 Even if “a bit” to you is “a lot” to me …

but - uh oh … bracing myself for the qualifier …

again, - and the reemphasis (tension building, cue music …)

“christians” are not being singled out here. :hmmm: Well … let’s HOPE not. I suspect that may be a guess on your part though (barring some inside knowledge of the ruling “judge”).
CaptFun NOW responds below … in black for ease of reading.

I note that you (to your credit) used the PLURAL for Christians above, ringil.

For clarity I must say - THAT is part of my problem with the BIT too far. ONE athlete
“does something” (small in my opinion) and PLURAL people get punished for it!

As it happened to BE a Christian person who “offended” (at least this one-person sports dictator with unreversible punitive powers!) - maybe the “Christianness” of the gesture (CALLED a “God gesture” for some reason)*** was*** the aspect that took the thing from:

– an infraction of a rule (that seems to me at least - to be aimed at a kind of “in your face” taunting). To …

– an inexcusable “death penalty for the WHOLE TEAM” level social crime that must be dealt with in such a way as to insure it never EVER happens again!

When I run my “could this ruling possibly be right in any circumstance?” fairness test - the best I can come up with is the (not very likely scenario) that:

This kid IS a “radical Christian” and DID give this gesture - not merely as some exterior voicing of the Freedom of Religion and expression we all have under the consitiution and most state laws – but as a provocative scofflaw and a triumphalist “Christian”
troublemaker. A “right wing” equivalent of:



THIS moment from the 1968 Olympics.

guardian.co.uk/world/2012/mar/30/black-power-salute-1968-olympics

In the above example Tommie Smith (center) and John Carlos (right) turned their eyes away from the American Flag as it was being raised in victory at the 1968 Mexico Olympics to honor their medal winning performances.

Additionally, showing a bit of pre-meditation some time after having performed - and not in the moment of victory as with the Texas boy here - Smith and Carlos donned black gloves and gave a “black power” salute.

**Similarities with the Texas case: A race. A gesture. Controversy. **

Some cheered them for this and praised their courage. Others thought it ruined the moment and was politically provocative at a time when race riots were plaguing many cities in the US (it was the year Martin Luther King was shot, and Bobby Kennedy, and the Democratic Convention riots, and the Communist North Vietnamese “Tet offensive” invasion of South Vietnam – for a bit of context).

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcThLhOaIWOXEZkLW5LF2BCwQWIEjQ-kxReEHg94RkScGpfpDSy2Fw



The clenched fist symbol (and hence the gesture ?) was a bit close to one of the enemy’s familiar symbols. The Vietnam war … which though not a “war” technically or against the USSR technically but its ally … was quite “hot” at the time. Additionally the symbol of the clenched fist was one favored by the Communist Trotskyites (and Trotsky having been assassinated IN Mexico added another layer of mystery as to what the two athletes precisely or vaguely were saluting and/or shunning on the Olympic platform).

The penalties to Smith and Carlos? None. Save public opinion in some quarters.

And given their seeming anti-American sentiment at the time --*** perhaps*** the two would have welcomed JUST this punishment (per this thread) on THEIR team … the disqualification of the WHOLE US Olympic team and all its athletes’ possible glories, medals etc. – I don’t KNOW that of course - but today’s judge with yesterday’s radicals would have made for a fine bit of political sabotage! Maybe I should pursue fiction writing? :hmmm:

The distinctions between deliberate and accidental should be taken into consideration --even if one decides for the rule over the people (not Jesus’ preference if one examines his counsels to the Pharisees and Sadducees).

Speaking of Jesus, he might call such an action as this “straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel.”

Me? I see the present case as swatting a fly on a window with a hammer. Then perhaps justifying the big unnecessary glass-shattering mess with some “intellectual” dissertation on the “health hazard flies present” - then passing out more, BIGGER hammers to save “the future of the planet”!

http://static.happyplace.com/assets/images/2012/03/4f689ed7f327e.jpeg

:blushing: Entertaining fiction ought to climax with a great crescendo to us exhibitionists.

Anyway thanks ringil for you take and scrutiny of the issue.
 
The penalties to Smith and Carlos? None. Save public opinion in some quarters.
Actually, the IOC banned them from the Olympic Village, suspended them from further competition and threatened to ban the entire US team if they did not enforce the sanction:

MEXICO CITY [Friday]-The United States Olympic Committee suspended Tommie Smith and John Carlos today for having used last Wednesday’s victory ceremony for the 200-meter dash at the Olympic Games as the vehicle for a black power demonstration. The two Negro sprinters were told by Douglas F. Roby, the president of the committee, that they must leave the Olympic Village. Their credentials were also taken away, which made it mandatory for them to leave Mexico within 48 hours.

The decision to dismiss the athletes was made early this morning after the committee had been summoned into a conference by the executive committee of the International Olympic Committee. Members of the United States committee, who were divided on the question of whether action should be taken, emphasized that the dismissals were by edict of the international unit. The I.O.C. indicated, it was said, that it might bar the entire United States team from further participation if the athletes were not disciplined.

nytimes.com/packages/html/sports/year_in_sports/10.16a.html
 
That right.
American must submit to all rules and regulations and by-laws and prickling of sensitivities passed by all the myriad of governmental and NGO’s that rule over the minutiae of all aspects of their lives, and all their expressions.

Such submission is the hallmark of a proud and free people, after all.
\

Indeed. Well said irony.
 
Actually, the IOC banned them from the Olympic Village, suspended them from further competition and threatened to ban the entire US team if they did not enforce the sanction:

MEXICO CITY [Friday]-The United States Olympic Committee suspended Tommie Smith and John Carlos today for having used last Wednesday’s victory ceremony for the 200-meter dash at the Olympic Games as the vehicle for a black power demonstration. The two Negro sprinters were told by Douglas F. Roby, the president of the committee, that they must leave the Olympic Village. Their credentials were also taken away, which made it mandatory for them to leave Mexico within 48 hours.

The decision to dismiss the athletes was made early this morning after the committee had been summoned into a conference by the executive committee of the International Olympic Committee. Members of the United States committee, who were divided on the question of whether action should be taken, emphasized that the dismissals were by edict of the international unit. The I.O.C. indicated, it was said, that it might bar the entire United States team from further participation if the athletes were not disciplined.

nytimes.com/packages/html/sports/year_in_sports/10.16a.html
Thanks for the details Oldcelt. (I’m kind of an Oldcelt myself) 🙂

I stand better informed now. Though per the comparison to the Texas kid (and the way I was thinking about the issue) is still valid in these respects:

— Smith and Carlos were not stripped of their medals.

They had accomplished what they had come for (athletically and politically it looks like).

Their disciplines did not involve MISSING future olympic competitions. As the Texas boy was stripped of his championship and not allowed to go to the next level he’d earned.

Carlos helped San Jose State win an NCAA track championship in 1969 … so his college careers seemed to go on without sanction or suspension. Smith was a member of the National Track & Field Hall of Fame in 1978, and later served on the coaching staff of the 1995 World Indoor Championship team Barcelona, Spain. And yet today he is currently a faculty member at Santa Monica College and the Head Men’s Cross-Country and Track & Field Coach.

as.sjsu.edu/legacy/Smith-Carlos.pdf < This San Jose State site lionizes Smith and Carlos (for both their athletics AND their politics). Similar is probably not in store for the prayer kid at his alma mater. Who was acted UPON not the initiator of the controversy (in MY opinion). :mad:

Smith and Carlos’ USA team was NOT suspended or stripped of anything, though threatened – and the actual “offenders’” BAN from the Olympic Village (when all their events were done) seems like a slap on the hand compared with the severe penalty the Texas boy got.

Smith and Carlos’ action was overt and deliberate (Justified? Some might say yes - for a greater principle. But its easier to say so when their TEAM didn’t end up having to lose their hard earned status because their teammates decided upon a political statement that - however one stands - must be admitted, did co-opt the Olympic stage.

The Texas boy’s - celebration. Or offensive Thanksgiving prayer. Which apparently did not include the two hands in the air (more broad of a gesture) level - being so harshly punished for what seems to be infinitely less of an infraction. Looks even worse when compared to this 1968 gesture that came to my mind.

I’d like the present injustice rectified now. As for the young man and his offense? This COULD make him a cause celebre as likely as it would a “goat”. Not Wheaties box level. But he may make an appearance on a talk show or two soon. And maybe profit from that
in some way.

I’d still like that “ruler’s” name to be published if it hasn’t been. Should he (or she?) reverses this awful decision and have the past week’s uncertainty and pain atone for the infraction – I don’t need to know the name or call for the scalp of someone who seems to be harming innocent young people. < At the VERY least the innocent teammates of “prayer guy”.

digitaljournal.com/article/349487 - Video on the controversy. Doesn’t show the gesture in question. Derrick Hayes is the athlete on the relay team.

Derrick is white. His three teammates are black. A superfluous detail unless one likes conspiracy theories with many angles to get excited over. The video shows a Baptist Church building (Derrick’s church?) as a visual during the report.
 
Rules barring celebration are silly, period. A penalty for pointing up? Ridiculous!
 
Yep. I don’t see how that is “behaving disrespectfully.”
The rules are stupid.

That being said, Christians were not singled out, the rules apply to everyone, and presumably those participating knew the rules and broke them.

The way I see it there are two things here:
  1. A participant chose to break a rule and was punished for it.
  2. The rule is stupid and should be changed.
 
Apparently this boy wasn’t exactly praising God. He was pointing his middle digit, was told about it by the meet referee, and got an attitude. It was then that the team was disqualified.

Even his parents have acknowledged it was not a violation of his religious rights:

khou.com/community/UIL-No-evidence-Columbus-runner-was-disqualified-for-expressing-religious-beliefs-206300381.html
“The UIL has concluded the investigation and has found no evidence to suggest that the disqualification took place as a result of the student-athlete expressing religious beliefs,” the statement said.

Derrick and his parents submitted letters to the UIL confirming that his religious freedoms were not violated.

“In looking back at the conclusion of the 4x100 race, we realize that Derrick could have handled the win in a different manner,” KC and Stacey Hayes said in the letter. “It was not our intention to force the issue that our son’s religious freedom was violated. Nor do we feel that way now. After discussing this with our son, we have come to the conclusion that his religious rights were not violated.”

“Although I am very thankful for all God has given me and blessed me with, on Saturday, April 27, 2013 at the Regional Track Meet in Kingsville, TX, my actions upon winning the 4x100 relay were strictly the thrill of victory,” Derrick Hayes said in his letter. “With this being said, I do not feel my religious rights or freedoms were violated.”
 
Even if it was some sort of a “God gesture” it’s inappropriate. Christians should win with humility since every time you win someone else loses.
 
Even if it was some sort of a “God gesture” it’s inappropriate. Christians should win with humility since every time you win someone else loses.
(The following is NOT personally to J_Peterson - or in opposition to the virtue of humility. But in opposition to its application - in THIS case):

Sooo. … by all means strip him (and his innocent teammates) of a race they won?
  • and send a group that lost by seven yards in their place? Instead of enacting some lesser, more appropriate sanction per the SILLY little non-crime “committed”?
  • Inappropriately applied IMO - by some STILL ANONYMOUS volunteer official per his TASTE?
Why, if this is a “life lesson” for our children to learn - should it not be applied everywhere?
Example: President Obama says he’s Christian. At the end of a speech he gets applauded and waves. Suddenly a shadowy official with powers no one suspected disqualifies him from holding office further - due to:
  • his not being “**sufficiently humble” ** or
  • "perhaps taunting those who don’t believe as he does" all based on one persons’ *impression * and …
according to some obscure line found in an American Law volume somewhere - which by unhappy coincidence falls into the deputized sphere of the shadowy officials’ “job”. And then OUT goes the election results, the power of office etc. and stragely, the media and
most other people who could reverse the nonsense take a “what can you do - its the law I guess” attitude.
Conceding to you (at the limits of my openmindedness) that you might have a point that is valid – one some level, sometime and for the BENEFIT of the person who made the mistake – still my first reaction is “this WAS a track meet – not an etiquette examination – until the absurd results!”

This Universal Interscholastic League’s most recent (that I have) statement about their “ongoing investigation” into the controversy strikes me as one of the most transparent breaches of fairness and exercises in empty self-congratulation I’ve ever seen.

http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSUcpsoALUh_TGi3mYCjaG6J-prX06rjESRZtvwd_8mgOL2UCEstw

They WILL not do the right thing. They WILL spend tax payers’ money on meetings which conclude that the final decision will stand after all - with many a reason why. EVEN though their story changes - as (only coincidentally?) the stories of people who lie do.

Initial story: Offensive prayer. Initial justification: It’s a rule, you can’t pray. He could pray later. Somewhere else. (OUR ruling stands - for the innocent as well as the guilty!)

Later story: NOT offensive prayer - we’re not against prayer and the kid didn’t do it! The press got that wrong (even though the school officials repeated the “error” demonstrating that school officials CAN make errors)! :eek: No, what the athlete did was “disrespectful to the official” at the end of the race! < HIS feelings matter EVER so much. We’re lucky this little nameless volunteer didn’t ban sports in the US altogether given the seemingly unlimited scope of his (absolutely non-challengeable) power to “enforce justice”.

uiltexas.org/press-releases/detail/statement-regarding-investigation-of-region-4-conference-3a-track-decision

Read the above for yourselves. Read the **HUMBLE ** quotes from Derrick Hayes (the student) and his father - who won’t sue the district, league or anyone - though in this (perversely litigious) day and age they might have a pretty good chance to cash in on the deep pockets of a school district.

Compare it to the haughty, self-serving IMO, rendition of ALL the league is doing (except the right thing)! They sign OFF with:
The UIL is committed to protecting student-athletes’ and their rights :rolleyes: and takes matters such as these seriously. :hmmm: In order to reduce the amount of interpretation on the part of track officials in regards to unsporting behavior, the UIL will work with NFHS for a clearer definition of the unsporting behavior rule.
:clapping: Whoopee! NOW they’ve changed their investigation to MORE “about the officials” (poor folks).
  • But why are you investigating if nothing was WRONG?
  • WHY a clearer rule ? Was the muddy rule the excuse for the BAD decision that caused the controversy? Will the new rule still punish the guilty with the innocent?
  • WHY speak of student’s “rights” and taking them seriously - while you strip innocent students (maybe ALL of them!) of their well earned chance to compete.
  • If suspicions of “religious bigotry” (say) are behind a justified sanction – why is not the
    ACTUAL discrimination against the three innocent BLACK members of the relay team not suspicious also? Are investigations into THAT suspicion pending? By an impartial party?
SEND this winning team to state like they’ve EARNED. You little, insignificant, embarrassing (seemingly incapable of doing the obvious right thing) functionaries’ FEELINGS are NOT that important.

And (UIL) if you think “backing up” your officials from the horror of icky feelings of not being respected **enough ** SOLVES even THAT-- maybe you should consider how DISRESPECTED your organizations now are by MANY people (and deservedly so IMO) though you scurry to try to limit the damage with the (false IMO) impression you ARE impartial - and considering reinstatement of at LEAST the innocent parties to the state competition.
 
The rules are stupid.

That being said, Christians were not singled out, the rules apply to everyone, and presumably those participating knew the rules and broke them.

The way I see it there are two things here:
  1. A participant chose to break a rule and was punished for it.
  2. The rule is stupid and should be changed.
Correct, unless it is a matter of how the rule was interpreted. For example, if you have a rule against “excessive celebration” or “taunting,” people can go too far in their zeal to prevent such things.
 
Even if it was some sort of a “God gesture” it’s inappropriate. Christians should win with humility since every time you win someone else loses.
Thanking and/or giving credit to God for your success through a gesture isn’t humble?

As far as “every time you win someone loses,” then you shouldn’t really have competitions. We don’t want anyone to get their feelings hurt. 😛
 
Thanking and/or giving credit to God for your success through a gesture isn’t humble?

As far as “every time you win someone loses,” then you shouldn’t really have competitions. We don’t want anyone to get their feelings hurt. 😛
You may think you are being ironic, but that is fast becoming a prevailing philosophy in education and sports.
 
You may think you are being ironic, but that is fast becoming a prevailing philosophy in education and sports.
Indeed it is. “We are all winners…there are no losers…”

When my oldest played ice hockey, most tournaments had mercy rules where you would stop putting the score up once there was a 8 or 10 point spread. That I get…no need to humiliate. But, playing without keeping score would be pretty ridiculous.

At the end of the game, the winners would cheer and jump on each other briefly…usually mob the goalie. After that, they would line up to bump gloves or shake hands. We taught the kids not to gloat and kept that in check if/when it did happen. That is how to teach sportsmanship.

Now, keeping the parents in line? That is another matter. 😛
 
Even If the rules are unjust, sometimes it just isn’t appropriate to challenge them. Civil disobedience is not always the appropriate course of action. If the kid suspected that his act would have resulted in the disqualification and did so anyway, what he did was wrong.
 
Even If the rules are unjust, sometimes it just isn’t appropriate to challenge them. Civil disobedience is not always the appropriate course of action.** If the kid suspected that his act would have resulted in the disqualification and did so anyway, what he did was wrong**.
There is nothing in the news report that leads me to believe he did so. What is odd, is that the rule is against “excessive celebration,” but that translates to making no gestures whatsoever. It sounds to me like people taking sensible rules to the absurd.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top