A
ac_pearse
Guest
Hello forum!
I have a question for y’all.
[Note: I am Catholic. Please forgive me if it seems I’m playing devil’s advocate here…I just want to get my question across clearly!
]
I’ve been studying a lot of biblical apologetics lately, and I’ve stumbled upon something that’s been bugging me. The text in question is Exodus 32:4-6 --the Golden Calf. What my studies have led me to, to quote the footnote in the NAB, “…it is clear that the golden calf was intended as an image, not of a false god, but of the Lord himself, his strength being symbolized by the strength of a young bull. The Israelites, however, had been forbidden to represent the Lord under any visible form.”
So, it seems that they didn’t try to make their own god to worship (which is how I’d always understood the GC story), but rather wanted to worship God through this idol.
If this is correct, then how am I to understand praying to God through an intercessor? Like, say, the Blessed Mother…? The saints? They of course are people, but do we make them idols when we use them in our worship this way?
Also, statues, icons, holy pictures, etc: they are representations of things in heaven, so praying with them…couldn’t that be seen as dangerous territory?
(I know that icons are most integral to the Eastern Orthodox, but it’s a part of the Catholic faith, too.)
Personally, I’ve always seen religious statues and pictures, etc. more as reminders of things I love. When I look at the little St. Claire figure that’s right here on my computer, I don’t imagine that I’m communing with St. Claire, any more than I think the picture of my grandma on the fridge actually puts me in touch with my grandma. I just like to look at it, because I love her! The sacramental view of all of creation is one of the things I love the most about the Church.
In any case…When it comes to graven images, where exactly is the line and do we catholics ever cross it?
I have a question for y’all.
[Note: I am Catholic. Please forgive me if it seems I’m playing devil’s advocate here…I just want to get my question across clearly!
I’ve been studying a lot of biblical apologetics lately, and I’ve stumbled upon something that’s been bugging me. The text in question is Exodus 32:4-6 --the Golden Calf. What my studies have led me to, to quote the footnote in the NAB, “…it is clear that the golden calf was intended as an image, not of a false god, but of the Lord himself, his strength being symbolized by the strength of a young bull. The Israelites, however, had been forbidden to represent the Lord under any visible form.”
So, it seems that they didn’t try to make their own god to worship (which is how I’d always understood the GC story), but rather wanted to worship God through this idol.
If this is correct, then how am I to understand praying to God through an intercessor? Like, say, the Blessed Mother…? The saints? They of course are people, but do we make them idols when we use them in our worship this way?
Also, statues, icons, holy pictures, etc: they are representations of things in heaven, so praying with them…couldn’t that be seen as dangerous territory?
(I know that icons are most integral to the Eastern Orthodox, but it’s a part of the Catholic faith, too.)
Personally, I’ve always seen religious statues and pictures, etc. more as reminders of things I love. When I look at the little St. Claire figure that’s right here on my computer, I don’t imagine that I’m communing with St. Claire, any more than I think the picture of my grandma on the fridge actually puts me in touch with my grandma. I just like to look at it, because I love her! The sacramental view of all of creation is one of the things I love the most about the Church.
In any case…When it comes to graven images, where exactly is the line and do we catholics ever cross it?