G
I tried a Latin sentence with a known translation from Fr. Z’s blog and got a load of gibberish from Google. I can understand difficulties with conversational translations but Latin prose from religious documents should be relatively simple to translate with reasonable accuracy. I’m not impressed.
Why’s that?Latin prose from religious documents should be relatively simple to translate with reasonable accuracy.
It is stable, predictable, unchanged for centuries and has been translated so often by so many scholars that there are unlimited resources against which to check the Google translation algorithm. In essence, there is no excuse for getting it so wrong, I’m saying I got gibberish not a clause slightly off or a word out of place. Conversation is prone to grammatical errors that could understandably confuse a translator.Why’s that?
“No excuse for getting it wrong,” huh? Sounds like you should ask for your money back and just stick with doing your own translations of such “simple,” “predictable” prose.It is stable, predictable, unchanged for centuries and has been translated so often by so many scholars that there are unlimited resources against which to check the Google translation algorithm. In essence, there is no excuse for getting it so wrong, I’m saying I got gibberish not a clause slightly off or a word out of place. Conversation is prone to grammatical errors that could understandably confuse a translator.
Maybe they see a growing market in it? :dancing:it’s still in alpha, so that should be expected. I’m surprised they made it public.
I don’t know if it’s fair to call Google a translator since it’s more of a search device for possible already-done translations. This is more obvious as letters are typed in and the order changed to fit the dynamic text up to that point.Take a look at Fr. Z’s blog. He compares the Google Translator with some of the old ICEL translations. I find it both funny and sad that the Google translations come out on top. Thank goodness for the new upcoming translation.![]()
Some of the blog comments are rich, as well. For example: “The problem with the ICEL is that half of them don’t know English, and the other half don’t know Latin.”Take a look at Fr. Z’s blog. He compares the Google Translator with some of the old ICEL translations.