The fact is that our society and assuredly business interests in our society, including agri-businesses and heavily Republican, allowed the current situation to occur, somewhat in the bracero tradition. There is no other explanation.
So those workers here illegally are much more accurately called ‘undocumented workers’. If people did not want things to be the way they are, the situation would have changed long ago.
I’m not sure agribusiness people are necessarily Republicans, and I’m not sure it matters if they are. Indisputably, Bush did very little to control illegal immigration, and did less to explain that. One could speculate as to why, but speculation isn’t all that valuable a commodity.
I am not persuaded that most illegals are agricultural workers, either. Perhaps that’s true in some places. It’s most definitely not true here, where most are industrial or construction workers. But, it has been my observation that many, if not most, consider themselves “temporary” anyway, since their presence here is quite often simply a way to raise capital to invest in their home countries.
In that sense, then, it is not dissimilar to the old bracero program.
But some illegals definitely want to stay here indefinitely. The old bracero program had no provision for that, and “braceros” wanting to stay indefinitely had to go through the usual channels for immigrants generally.
But I think the real question is whether illegals presently here are somehow to be given preference over those who would like to immigrate, but are taking the legal route to do it.
When Obama (like McCain) talks about “immigration reform” it is generally taken to mean “amnesty”, or some other preference for illegals over those who want to legally immigrate. If Obama has ever said otherwise in detail, then I have not seen it.
It has seemed to me (and perhaps this was Bush’s thinking) that really massive legal immigration would not allow any kind of “discrimination”. What we have had in the last couple of decades has been a de facto “Hispanic preference” over others. If “immigration reform” did not allow for preferring, say, a Mexican or Guatemalan (fundamentally western and almost always Christian) over, say, Yemenis, Somalis or Iranians, (whose immigration could rightly be concerning for reasons having nothing to do with job competition, etc) and it is hard to see how it could, then it seems likely to me the public will eventually demand that it be shut off altogether, but a lot of water will have passed under the bridge until then.
I think everybody knows Obama’s failure to control the border is aimed at pleasing Hispanic voters and increasing their number. Otherwise, his inaction (and paralyzing of ICE) is inexplicable, given that illegal immigration seems to be a somewhat different problem than before, due to the increasing criminality attendant on it. But does he really want to do away with the “Hispanic preference” on an ongoing basis? Hard to think so. Therefore, one has to wonder whether, after amnesty, there is any follow-on plan that’s seriously intended. Again, if Obama has expressed himself regarding that, I have not seen it. It really seems like “immigration reform” is nothing but a short term gain for the Democrat party (as McCain evidently thought it would be for the Republican party) with chaos to follow. Been there, done that.
So, is “immigration reform” anything more than amnesty and more of same, but with a minor tweak here and there? There is no particular reason to think otherwise. And that, I think, is why so many Americans are leery of it.
Border control will result in the reduction of illegals in the U.S. They all go home a lot. Some never return, some do. One would think, if some kind of “guest worker” program is intended, it would not be the most difficult thing in the world for intended returnees to stop in at a U.S. consulate in Mexico or Guatemala or El Salvador or wherever, for a card update if, indeed, guest workers are needed by the economy at that particular moment in time. If so, it seems to me they should be on the same basis as every other person there who wants to be a guest worker.
But returning to topic, it’s possible there are different views concerning illegal immigration among Republicans. Seems likely there would be at least some, and McCain’s past support of it speaks to that more persuasively than what some functionary of the Southern Baptist Convention might think about it.
But among the public at large, I think things have changed. Until fairly recently, lots of people opposed illegal immigration; perhaps the majority. But most, it seemed, were reasonably content with a sort of benign neglect of the issue. But I think the increasing criminality involved in it has changed that. Even McCain, it seems, has now backed away from his own version of an amnesty program. One can say that was for political expediency, and perhaps it was, since he received a pretty sound political rebuff to his attempt. The lukewarm support for him among many Republicans in the 2008 election, I believe, attested to the likellihood there was very little support for amnesty among Republicans generally.
(continued)