Gravity of Theft

  • Thread starter Thread starter twf
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you. I really needed to hear this. It is good to know I’m not alone in my sanity.
 
Last edited:
I am inclined to agree with some posters about varying degrees of gravity, but I also caution against having a consequentialist attitude, like “He won’t miss it” or “It won’t hurt anyone very much.” Even if we suppose that consequences determine gravity, this attitude is fallacious because we cannot know the full consequences.

We are scarcely wiser than a child who takes Mommy’s diamond earrings. To the child it seems a small offense, but only because he does not know – cannot even begin to comprehend – the value of those sparkly little things.

Similarly, our petty theft may affect others in ways more serious than we had imagined, and the full effect will likely be unknown to us, at least until all the connections are made clear at the general judgment.
 
Last edited:
Certainly a lot of uncharitable judging going on in your post here, along with a healthy dose of blaming others for your sins. You’re argument holds for any sin at all, “it wasn’t that bad!” “I dom’t deserve eternal punishment for it!” “I refuse to believe in a God who does that!”

Okay? Don’t then.

@twf

All that goes for you too.

Edit: I have a hard time believing that a person who steals a candy bar, is not sorry for it at all because “they’ll never miss it” and refuses to repent is not guilty of mortal sin. If we’re talking about someone who steals a candy bar without thinking, feels horrible about it and then later takes money to the store and admits what they did and apologizes, I would still suggest confession, but I could see that being passed off as a serious venial sin.
 
Last edited:
No one has blamed anyone for their sins. I’m also not aware of anyone on this thread who has admitted to struggling with theft. This is all hypothetical. The argument could apply to any sin? Yes it indeed can. The Church has always taught that while all sin is offensive to God, some sinful actions constitute grave matter and others do not. That’s part of the discernment process (ideally with a confessor). The Church and moral theologians don’t agree with your personal theory that stealing a candy bar is intrinsically grave matter. You’re putting burdens on the faithful that the Church does not.
 
Then on this forum I encountered the idea, from multiple posters, that all theft, no matter how seemingly insignificant, is always grave matter by its very nature.
That understanding is incorrect.
 
Actually, BornInMarch was saying that people telling him stealing was wrong was responsible for him rejecting God. But that’s not really important.

The Church is actually pretty shady on this as far as I can tell. They say some theft may not be mortally sinful, but don’t specify exactly what and when. Many theologians say it ia a matter of how much one steals, and from whom. I think that’s a shaky argument, because to me the attitude of the sinner is more telling.

And I haven’t seen anything from the Church that says theft is not grave matter by it’s nature. I have seen a few theologians. I would agree that all theft does not necessarily constitute mortal sin or even venial sin, I don’t agree that stealing a candy bar from a “rich” store is never mortally sinful.

The Church doesn’t put burdens on anyone, they communicate the burdens God puts on us. God put “thou shall not steal” in the Ten Commandments, impying He feels it is intrinsically grave matter.
 
And I haven’t seen anything from the Church that says theft is not grave matter by it’s nature.
Then what is your reason for being bound to the presupposition that it is? (Since you apparently hold the Church has not dogmatically defined the correct position.)
 
Last edited:
Don’t put words in my mouth. I didn’t want to respond to you, but if you lie about me and about what I say then I will.

I didn’t say that it was for this thing specifically, I said that it was a recurring theme where so-called Catholics on this website say that God will send people to hell for trivial matters. It made God seem like a sadist who hates his children and who tortures them for fun. And I didn’t reject God, I doubted. That’s different because doubting doesn’t go all the way. These doubts were dispelled because I was able to find reasonable Catholics who told me that God was less cruel than people like you think.

In any case, you must be pretty arrogant insist that petty theft is a mortal sin that people go to Hell over even when Priests and Theology Experts say that you are wrong. Do you think you know better than the Church?

Anyway, unless you persist on lying about me I am done talking about this with you.
 
Nobody is suggesting that we go out and steal. Just that the gravity of theft depends at least partially on the value of what was stolen - as opposed to the “all theft is a grave matter” attitude that some so-called Catholics take.

Obviously monetary value isn’t the only factor; there is also sentimental value and principal value as well. To use the $1 trinket example, if the person you stole it from attached a lot of sentimental value to it (say it used to belong to his now-dead son and it’s the only physical reminder he has left) or will become a worse person due to being robbed (say he’s just now learning to trust other people after thinking humans were all garbage for years), then stealing it would be a grave matter because despite it’s low market value there is still a lot of damage done by this theft.
 
I still don’t agree with you, but I do apologize for being harsh in my earlier post.
 
I’m using that term for people who like to present themselves as holy or pious, but who in reality come across as being hard-hearted or as holding views that the Church or the majority of Clergymen says is wrong.

It carries two meanings, saying both “these people aren’t really good catholics” and “these people don’t represent Catholicism at large”. Sometimes I also use “Pharisee” as a synonym for this sort of thing, because the Pharisees in the gospels are often presented as self-righteous hypocrites (Jesus himself at several points tells them that they’re not going to Heaven).
 
I’m using that term for people who like to present themselves as holy or pious, but who in reality come across as being hard-hearted or as holding views that the Church or the majority of Clergymen says is wrong.

It carries two meanings, saying both “these people aren’t really good catholics” and “these people don’t represent Catholicism at large”. Sometimes I also use “Pharisee” as a synonym for this sort of thing, because the Pharisees in the gospels are often presented as self-righteous hypocrites (Jesus himself at several points tells them that they’re not going to Heaven).
That’s harsh. Somebody disagrees with you and you call them all of that? Wow.
 
(This was a double post. Sorry, my mistake.)
 
Last edited:
I know it sounds harsh, and I’m sorry if it comes off as that. It’s just that I get angry whenever I see someone spreads that old lie of “everyone but me is going to Hell!” because I have seen that kind of talk drive people away from God.

I am usually fine with people disagreeing with me on things, but when that disagreement seems to stem from what looks like heartlessness then my patience runs out really quickly. If someone told you that everyone who was ever nice to you was going to Hell, and seemed to think this was a good thing, and you had church documents saying he was wrong, you wouldn’t be so polite either.
 
Last edited:
Could you be reading too much into some of these posts? In my opinion, ChunkMonk and joeybaggz have made good points, offered in charity, and worthy of consideration.

God’s love and mercy are surely great. Nevertheless, we can and should examine how our spiritual health and our relationship with God are affected by a cavalier, unrepentant attitude toward small sins.

Imagine, if you will, that you have a good friend, and everything is great between you and your friend, except that when he comes to visit, he takes small things, things that you would gladly give him, but he takes them without your consent. For example, you meet him one day and he’s wearing a T-shirt of yours. It’s no big deal. You’ve got loads of T-shirts, and you didn’t even notice it was missing. Another time, you visit his home and he’s got one of your dish towels. Over time, it doesn’t get worse. Just little stuff, every now and then. You forgive him, sure, because it’s small stuff and he is your friend. But how do you feel about his taking your stuff? Would you wonder what’s wrong with him, or with your relationship?

With God, we shouldn’t be trying to figure out what we can get away with. We shouldn’t put in just enough effort to pass with a C if we are capable of doing better. Rather we should try to do our best. We are not perfect, but we can try to be the best that we can be, and God will surely be pleased.
 
Try looking at what they said. I asked them if they thought someone would go to Hell and be tortured forever over an act of petty theft, and they both said “Yes, if you steal a 50 cent stamp you will be tortured forever and you deserve to be”. I quoted priests and theologians who said the answer was “no”, and they still both said “yes”.

If a friend kept taking small things from me I’d be annoyed. If a friend almost never paid the bill when we went out for restaurants I’d be annoyed. But I wouldn’t shoot him in the kneecaps and watch him bleed out, and if someone tried deterring my friend by telling him that I would do this then I’d be more upset at that.
It makes my blood boil when I hear people claim that “everybody but me is going to Hell!”. People who claim there are babies in Hell getting tortured and burned and who take joy in the thought of this. I’m sorry, but I’d be lying if I said I could consider such people to be Christian. Matthew 23:13 comes to mind.

Obviously stealing is wrong, but if it’s worse to be Hard of Heart.
 
Last edited:
Well, okay. Your reading is apparently different from mine.
 
Last edited:
I didn’t say the Church never dramatically defined it I said I haven’t seen one.

My reason for believing it is was explained pretty clearly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top